From Pakistans Flop To Irans Front Line: Why Chinas HQ-9B Air Defense System Is Under Scrutiny?
The HQ-9B is a long-range air defense system designed in China. It takes inspiration from Russia's S-300 and includes some American and Israeli technologies. The system is built to intercept aerial threats, including enemy aircraft, drones, cruise missiles, and some ballistic missiles. It uses radar to locate targets and then launches its own missiles to destroy them mid-air. The HQ-9B can engage 8 to 10 targets at once within a range of 250 to 300 km.
Pakistan's Troubled Experience With HQ-9B
Pakistan integrated the HQ-9B into its military in 2021, promoting it as a strong tool against India's increasing air power, which includes Rafale jets and BrahMos missiles. However, the system has performed poorly on several occasions, most notably during India's "Operation Sindoor" in May 2025.
During "Operation Sindoor," India carried out precision strikes on terrorist targets in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK). These strikes involved advanced weaponry, including BrahMos missiles, French SCALP cruise missiles, and Israeli Harop drones. Despite the HQ-9B's presence, it reportedly failed to intercept any of these threats. Reports indicated that the Indian attacks were so precise that they also destroyed an HQ-9B battery near Lahore.
The system's failures extended beyond "Operation Sindoor." In 2024, when Iran targeted Pakistan's Balochistan with missile and drone strikes, the HQ-9B again showed no response.
Several reasons are put forward for the HQ-9B's failures in Pakistan:
Lack Of Training: Pakistani military personnel may not have received sufficient training to operate the complex system.
Jamming And Stealth Technology: India's use of electronic warfare and stealth missiles might have evaded or confused the HQ-9B's radar.
Technical Limitations: Some experts believed the HQ-9B may not be fully capable of intercepting high-velocity missiles, like the BrahMos.
Maintenance Issues: The system's high maintenance costs and possible shortages of spare parts in Pakistan could have hurt its operational readiness.
These repeated failures led to significant criticism in Pakistan and even on Chinese social media, where the Pakistani military was described as "mute spectators," and the reliability of the HQ-9B was questioned.
China's Strategic Transfer To Iran
The news of China transferring the HQ-9B system to Iran came out in July 2025. This deal seems to be an exchange for oil, as US sanctions prevent Iran from making cash payments.
Why Iran Needs Air Defense: Iran faces serious geopolitical challenges and threats from powerful adversaries, such as Israel and the United States. Recent Israeli airstrikes on Iranian sites have highlighted the need for Iran to improve its air defense systems. The HQ-9B could offer vital long-range aerial defense.
Benefits For China:
Secure Oil Supply: The deal gives China a steady and potentially discounted supply of oil, which is essential for its economy.
Expanding Arms Market: China aims to increase its market presence in the arms trade. Providing the HQ-9B to Iran helps establish a foothold in the unstable Middle East.
Reputation Management: The HQ-9B's poor performance in Pakistan damaged China's credibility in defense technology. Deploying it in Iran allows Beijing to showcase the system's effectiveness, particularly against sophisticated Western military technology.
Israeli Concerns: Israel has expressed worries about this deal, as the HQ-9B could significantly boost Iran's ability to counter aerial threats.
Prospects For HQ-9B In Iran And India's Position
It remains uncertain whether the HQ-9B will perform better in Iran. Its past failures in Pakistan do not necessarily indicate that it is ineffective overall. Its success in Iran will depend on several factors:
Training And Maintenance: Iran will need to ensure thorough training for its personnel and may rely on China for maintenance and spare parts.
Adversary Technology: Both Israel and the U.S. have stealth aircraft and advanced missiles that might evade the HQ-9B's radar systems.
Operational Integration: Iran's ability to effectively integrate and use the system within its existing defense framework will be essential.
For India, this development could raise concerns, especially given the complex nature of India-Iran relations. If Iran successfully deploys the HQ-9B, it could shift the balance of power in the Middle East. However, India's own strong air defense systems, including the S-400 and Akash missile systems, are designed to counter a wide range of aerial threats, positioning it to handle any potential implications.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
16 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Parliament Monsoon Session: Opposition demands two-day discussion on Pahalgam, Operation Sindoor in Rajya Sabha
The Opposition on Wednesday (July 23, 2025) put forth their demand for holding a debate on the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor in the Rajya Sabha from next week and Prime Minister Narendra Modi's presence be ensured. The demand was put forth during the first meeting of the Business Advisory Committee (BAC) of the Rajya Sabha during the Monsoon Session of Parliament. The meeting was attended by leaders of various parties and Leader of the House J.P. Nadda, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju. The BAC meeting was chaired by Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman Harivansh. This is the first time that the meeting of BAC is being held, after the same was rescheduled since Monday (July 21, 2025). On Monday (July 21, 2025) evening, the first day of the Monsoon Session, Jagdeep Dhankhar resigned from the post of Vice-President, leading to further postponement of the meeting. "The Business Advisory Committee meeting of the Rajya Sabha was held today under the chairmanship of Deputy Chairman Harivansh. The entire opposition demanded that the discussion on the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor be taken up starting next week. 'The two-day discussion for 16 hours should be taken up a day after the same started in Lok Sabha,' Congress's deputy leader in Rajya Sabha Pramod Tiwari told reporters after the meeting. He also said the Opposition wanted no resolution should be brought up during the debate on Operation Sindoor/Pahalgam attack and a normal discussion spanning two days should be held. Govt Agrees to Debate on Operation Sindoor & Pahalgam Terror Attack "We have demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi should be present during the discussion, and we have been assured that by the government," he also claimed. "I am hopeful that the prime minister will be present during the debate on Operation Sindoor," Mr. Tiwari said. Both Houses of Parliament have witnessed repeated adjournments amid uproar by Opposition members over the issue of the Pahalgam attack, Bihar's Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls and other issues.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
16 minutes ago
- First Post
‘Stay strong': Trump aide meets Imran Khan's sons, takes a jibe at Pakistani establishment
Richard Grenell, a key ally of US President Donald Trump, posted a photo with the sons of jailed former prime minister of Pakistan Imran Khan and declared: 'You are not alone' read more Richard Grenell, a close aide of US President Donald Trump, met with the sons of jailed Pakistani leader Imran Khan in California Richard Grenell, a key ally of US President Donald Trump, on Tuesday (July 22) met with the sons of jailed former prime minister of Pakistan Imran Khan in California. Grenell, who served as Trump's special envoy and US ambassador to Germany, posted a photo with the brothers, Sulaiman Isa Khan and Kasim Khan, on social media. Grenell wrote on X: 'Welcome to California, my friends. I loved hanging out with you today. Sulaiman and @Kasim_Khan1999, you must stay strong. There are millions of people around the world who are sick of political prosecutions. You are not alone.' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Welcome to California, my friends. I loved hanging out with you today. Sulaiman and @Kasim_Khan_1999, you must stay strong. There are millions of people around the world who are sick of political prosecutions. You are not alone. #freeimrankhan — Richard Grenell (@RichardGrenell) July 22, 2025 The meeting has spotlighted Khan's ongoing imprisonment, who has been detained since August 2023. Human rights groups and Khan's party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), claim his detention is politically driven. Concerns about Khan's conditions in Adiala Jail, Rawalpindi, are growing globally. Reports indicate he is held in solitary confinement, cut off from newspapers, books, and television. This isn't Grenell's first show of support for Khan. Grenell previously backed Khan during Trump's 2024 campaign. On Newsmax, he praised Khan's leadership and criticised Pakistan's current government, saying, 'We had a much better relationship with Pakistan during the Trump administration when a guy named Imran Khan was the leader.' He called Khan a 'political outsider with common-sense views.' Grenell also compared Khan's legal battles in Pakistan to Trump's in the US, stating, 'He's currently in prison, facing many of the same allegations as President Trump,' and called for the former cricketer's release. The meeting with Khan's sons is viewed as another clear sign of support from Trump's inner circle. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
16 minutes ago
- First Post
To protect the Chinese, Pakistan plans to train its police with 'military standards'
Sharif announced a slew of new security measures that his government will take to make Pakistan a business-friendly nation for Chinese nationals read more Chinese Premier Li Qiang and Pakistan's Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif react after unveiling a plaque to mark the completion of the New Gwadar International Airport, during a ceremony at the Prime Minister's House in Islamabad, Pakistan October 14, 2024. (Photo: Reuters)/Representational image. Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday said that the police force will be given military-level training in order to protect Chinese nationals residing in the country for business purposes. Sharif announced a slew of new security measures that his government will take to make Pakistan a business-friendly nation for Chinese nationals. 'The confidence of Chinese companies in the Pakistani economy is extremely important for our economic future.' The prime minister's comments came as both countries expand the scope of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). In recent days, several Chinese citizens living in various parts of the country have come under attack. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD What other measures will be taken? Sharif said that since 'China is our friendly country', it is a priority of the government to take care of any Chinese national residing in Pakistan. He emphasised that with the progress of CPEC, ensuring the safety of Chinese nationals in Pakistan had become even more critical. He directed that priority measures be implemented at all airports to ease their arrival and departure. Interior Minister Syed Mohsin Raza Naqvi said that the entire country is working towards providing safety to Chinese nationals, as different states are constructing, what the government has called, a 'safe city'. Chinese nationals are also being provided with security escort facilities for travel, according to a report by Dawn. Chinese nationals attacked in Pak Thousands of Chinese nationals are employed at China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) sites and major infrastructure projects across regions including Sindh, Balochistan, and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where they have frequently been targeted in attacks reportedly carried out by militants, including the BLA and the Pakistani Taliban. According to official figures from Pakistan's National Counter Terrorism Authority (NACTA), at least 20 Chinese citizens have been killed and 34 injured in 14 terrorist attacks across the country since 2021.
