The Irish Times view on rules for immigration: a case of more haste meaning less speed
has put the Government on notice
that parts of its flagship immigration legislation breach fundamental rights and may well end up being challenged in the Irish and European Courts.
The International Protection Bill 2025 will give effect to the EU Migration and Asylum Pact which seeks to align asylum practices across the EU by next June.
The process by which applicants for international protection are assessed and adjudicated and, if necessary, removed from the State will be simplified with the objective of giving a decision – including appeal – within two to six months, depending on an applicant's circumstances. The procedure currently averages 18 months.
The dysfunctional nature of the current system – and the opportunity provided to reset it by the EU Migration and Asylum Pact – is acknowledged by the IHREC. But it is equally clear that many of the proposed measures may not comply with the EU Charter on Fundamental Rights.
READ MORE
It has identified several issues of concern in the proposed legislation, in particular the right of applicants to free legal advice, which will now only be available at the appeal stage. It has also flagged a lack of clarity in relation to how the age of minors will be determined if this is disputed. It has also raised concerns about the rights of applicants with no identification who are covered by the UN Refugee Convention to which Ireland is a signatory, but which is not yet incorporated into national law.
The common theme to these and the other issues raised by the IHREC is that the Government's rush to get the International Protection Bill enacted in time to meet the deadline for the introduction of the EU pact may be counterproductive if it leaves it open to numerous legal challenges, either from the commission or others.
It notes that effective scrutiny of legislation by the Oireachtas – which appears difficult under the current timelines – could go a long way to heading off challenges . A case of the more haste the less speed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
26 minutes ago
- The Journal
British special forces and MI6 spies among more than 100 Britons included in Afghan data leak
THE DETAILS OF more than 100 Britons, including spies and special forces, were included in a massive data leak that resulted in thousands of Afghans being secretly relocated to the UK. Defence sources have said that details of MI6 spies, SAS and special forces personnel were included in the spreadsheet, after they had endorsed Afghans who had applied to be brought to the UK. The dataset, containing the personal information of nearly 19,000 people who applied for the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (Arap), was released 'in error' in February 2022 by a defence official. The Ministry of Defence (MoD) became aware of the breach more than a year later, when excerpts of the spreadsheet were anonymously posted in a Facebook group in August 2023. Other details leaked included the names and contact details of the Arap applicants and names of their family members. In a statement on Tuesday, after an unprecedented superinjunction was lifted by a UK High Court judge, British Defence Secretary John Healey offered a 'sincere apology' on behalf of the Government for the data breach. He later told the Commons the spreadsheet contained 'names and contact details of applicants and, in some instances, information relating to applicants' family members, and in a small number of cases the names of members of Parliament, senior military officers and Government officials were noted as supporting the application'. 'This was a serious departmental error,' he added. Shadow defence secretary James Cartlidge also apologised on behalf of the former Conservative government, which was in power when the leak happened and when it was discovered more than a year later. Cartlidge later asked Healey about reports that someone other than the original person who leaked the data had been engaged in blackmail. Arap was responsible for relocating Afghan nationals who had worked for or with the UK Government and were therefore at risk of reprisals once the Taliban returned to power in Kabul in 2021. Between 80,000 and 100,000 people, including the estimated number of family members of the Arap applicants, were affected by the breach and could be at risk of harassment, torture or death if the Taliban obtained their data, judges said in June 2024. However, an independent review, commissioned by the UK Government in January 2025, concluded last month that the dataset is 'unlikely to significantly shift Taliban understanding of individuals who may be of interest to them'. Advertisement The breach resulted in the creation of a secret Afghan relocation scheme – the Afghanistan Response Route – by the previous government in April 2024. The scheme is understood to have cost around £400 million (€463m) so far, with a projected cost once completed of around £850 million (€983m). Millions more are expected to be paid in legal costs and compensation. Around 4,500 people, made up of 900 Arap applicants and approximately 3,600 family members, have been brought to the UK or are in transit so far through the Afghanistan Response Route. A further estimated 600 people and their relatives are expected to be relocated before the scheme closes, with a total of around 6,900 people expected to be relocated by the end of the scheme. Projected costs of the scheme may include relocation costs, transitional accommodation, legal costs and local authority tariffs. The case returned to the High Court in London today, sitting in a closed session in the morning where journalists and their lawyers were excluded. While private hearings exclude the public and press but allow the parties in the case to remain, closed hearings require specific lawyers who can deal with sensitive issues, including national security. During the public part of the hearing, Mr Justice Chamberlain said that while he needed to give lawyers for the Ministry of Defence an 'opportunity' to argue why a closed hearing was needed, 'I will be scrutinising very carefully any justification for holding any part of this hearing in private, let alone in closed'. The judge later said he would not be 'kicking the ball down the road'. He added: 'The superinjunction has now been lifted and if there are other matters that are capable of being reported in public, that needs to be able to happen straight away.' Also on Thursday, Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) requested a number of documents used in the superinjunction proceedings be provided to it 'immediately'. This includes intelligence assessments from the MoD and the Joint Intelligence Organisation, as well as the unredacted report of retired civil servant Paul Rimmer. The ISC has also asked for the reasons why barristers for the UK Government previously told the Court of Appeal that information about the breach could not be shared with it.
Irish Times
36 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Traveller and Roma culture to be included in school curriculum, says Department of Education
The Department of Education is working on a plan to promote better understanding of Traveller and Roma identity in schools, an Oireachtas committee has heard. The committee also heard 15 link workers will be employed in areas with high enrolment of Travellers and Roma children to encourage better communication between schools, children and their parents. These link workers will be 'very much rooted in the community' and will act as culturally sensitive mediators, said Grainne Cullen, principal officer at the Department of Education and Youth. Two national co-ordinators have already been appointed, the Joint Committee on Key Issues affecting the Traveller Community heard. This policy is modelled on the Supporting Travellers and Roma (STAR) programme, piloted in schools between 2019 and 2024. [ Greater Traveller representation needed in Irish politics, says UN committee Opens in new window ] Latest figures from the department say 31.4 per cent of Traveller children sit the Leaving Certificate, compared to the national average of 91.7 per cent. Traveller and Roma children are also much more likely than non-Travellers to be on a reduced school hours programme. Social Democrat TD Jen Cummins said that in her experience from a recent visit to the Ballyfermot Traveller Action Project, motivating children on reduced hours to go to school is difficult. 'There is nothing less motivating for a child than to get up, get ready and go to school for only an hour,' she said. 'We must try harder.' The department said it was changing the way schools report reduced school hours and was engaging with the Traveller and Roma community to develop a national campaign to tackle issues of attendance. Among the other policies contained in the strategy is a three-strand approach to respecting and promoting understanding of Traveller identity in schools. Ms Cullen spoke about educating student teachers about Traveller history and culture, providing opportunities and resources for professional learning, and including Traveller histories in the school curriculum. [ 'I had to hide my identity': Traveller students on their experiences in higher education Opens in new window ] The department drew particular attention to their new video resource for teachers produced by education specialist Dr Hannagh McGinley. Cliodhna O'Neill, assistant secretary general at the Department of Education, said the 'work is essential to promoting understanding, respect and pride in Traveller culture among all students'. Ms O'Neill said the department understood how important it was for young people to have a visual representation of their culture. This decision received positive feedback from the committee, with Sinn Féin TD Dessie Ellis saying this was 'very worthwhile'. Members of the committee agreed the department should maintain a focus on eliminating intergenerational barriers to education, such as through adult literacy initiatives.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Disability groups challenge Government to 'show me the money' in budget
Will this year's budget translate general election promises on disability services into cold hard cash? Disability groups have essentially said 'show me the money' to Government in a series of pre-budget submissions this week. Inclusion Ireland represents people with intellectual disabilities and their families. Its data shows social welfare supports do not match the needs of 66% of adults with an intellectual disability, so it wants core disability payments raised above the poverty threshold. One in four families said their child received no early intervention therapies. This needs investment in children's disability network teams (CDNTs), the submission recommended. CEO Derval McDonagh said: 'Our community is not looking for short-term fixes; we demand long-term thinking and ambition from our leaders.' Its survey of 1,000 people identified 'significant gaps' between people's lived experiences and what the State is obliged to provide under the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The Disability Federation of Ireland referred back to the programme for government promise of 'a step change in the supports and services required by people with disabilities". The federation's campaign call is 'deliver the step change'. It also argued for an increase in core social protection rates to reflect the true cost of living with a disability. The Disability Federation of Ireland said councils should be funded to make sure 7.5% of all new housing is suitable for wheelchair users. The CDNTs need at least 75 extra full-time therapists and staff, it said. It also called for more assessment of need funding. Councils should be funded to make sure 7.5% of all new housing is suitable for wheelchair users. The federation pointed out the voluntary charity sector delivers over 70% of disability services here. This needs sustainable, multi-annual funding it said. As I Am, Ireland's autism charity, focused on strategies and policies already in existence but in need of funding to roll-out fully. It called for resourcing of the Autism Innovation Strategy. It echoed calls for a weekly cost of disability payment, and also recommended a 10% increase in disability, carers, and domiciliary care allowances. CEO Adam Harris, brother to Tánaiste Simon Harris, said: 'Budget 2026 must confront the uncomfortable reality that our systems are failing autistic people, from year-long waits for services to social exclusion and financial strain." Norma Foley, minister for children, disability and equality and Hildegarde Naughton, junior minister for disability will soon be sitting in on heated budget discussions. They now have a shopping list prepared by people directly impacted by the reality of disability. Can they deliver the money is the question. Read More Letters to the Editor: System fails people with disabilities
