Calls for police to maintain bin strike presence
Roger Harmer, Lib Dem leader on the city council, urged police not to wait until the city reached crisis point before stepping in.
His comments came after the number of officers sent to police the picket lines were cut and amid reports of bin lorries being blocked by striking workers at depots.
On Monday lorries were seen driving up to depot gates in Tyseley but parking up inside as striking workers stood outside. West Midlands Police said it would continue to assess the situation and ensure its presence is in line with its core policing responsibilities.
Why are Birmingham's bin workers on strike?
Bin strike exposes divide between rich and poor
I haven't had my recycling collected since January
Harmer urged West Midlands Police to have a "consistent presence" at picket lines and not to wait "until the city reaches crisis point again".
"Human-height mounds of black bags" became commonplace in the city and Harmer described it as "a national embarrassment and terrible for the city's reputation".
"The police have powers to stop strikers from obstructing working crews – they should not wait for the city to reach crisis point again before acting," he added.
However some people in the city said a crisis point had already been reached for them.
Judith Whalley told BBC Radio WM that the strike was starting to affect her ability to leave her home in Hockley.
"As it's not been collected, people are just putting more rubbish and more rubbish out," she said.
"Once again, I'm about to be trapped because it's spreading across the pavement but I can't get down the pavement on my mobility scooter.
"With the weather the way it is, [it is] really getting smelly."
However, Ms Whalley said she sympathised with those on strike: "Nobody could afford to lose that sort of money."
Lorraine Boyce, from West Heath, said her hallway was full of recycling but some people had stopped separating it.
"Probably they've got sheds or halls, full of recycling," she said.
"They've started putting that in bags so a lot more black bags have appeared.
"It's very, very depressing."
Police patrols had previously helped secure the smooth exit of trucks from depots in recent weeks by using powers under Section 14 of the Public Order Act, a law used around public gatherings.
But a force spokesperson confirmed those powers were no longer in place as the issue "does not currently meet the threshold".
It came after waste collections were disrupted on Thursday when bin lorries were blocked from leaving two depots by striking refuse workers, leading to reports of rubbish piling up in parts of the city again.
Police were parked nearby and were seen getting out of their patrol cars but they remained a distance away.
The council said it was not safe for their trucks to leave the depot due to the police no longer using their Section 14 powers.
"The gates had been locked for safety reasons, and we had already attempted to get lorries out of the depot. The gates were reopened at 8 am," it said.
Union Unite, which organised the strike, has been approached for a comment on Monday's picket lines.
The all-out strike began on 11 March in a dispute with the council over plans to downgrade the roles of drivers, which the union said would see pay cuts of up to £8,000.
This news was gathered by the Local Democracy Reporting Service which covers councils and other public service organisations.
Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Why are Birmingham bin workers on strike?
PM living in 'la-la land', striking bin worker says
Bin strike policing cut as waste builds up again
Striking bin workers block depot lorries again
Bin collections not back to normal - politicians
Birmingham City Council
Unite
West Midlands Police
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
02-08-2025
- Yahoo
Nine arrests as protesters clash outside Islington asylum hotel
Nine people have been arrested after protests erupted outside a hotel in north London as rival groups faced off over its continued use to accommodate asylum seekers. Police were forced to intervene after brief clashes broke out between both groups outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in Islington. A large group of masked protesters dressed in black and chanting 'we are anti-fascist' marched from a side street towards the main demonstration, prompting officers to rush in and separate the two sides. Meanwhile, people believed to be migrants were seen watching from hotel windows as chants and drumming continued in the street below. The Met Police said there had been nine arrests, including seven on suspicion of breaching Public Order Act conditions. The force said a 33-year-old man who was part of the anti-immigration demonstration was also arrested for a racially aggravated public order offence. A further eight counter-protesters were also arrested. A 22-year-old woman was arrested for expressing support for Palestine Action. A further three men, aged 30, 21 and 28, and three women, aged 43, 33 and 21, were arrested for breaching the Public Order Act conditions in place. A 21-year-old man was arrested for breaching the Public Order Act conditions in place, as well as two cases of assaulting an emergency worker. The Met Police had earlier imposed strict conditions on both the protest and counter-demonstration and increased their presence. The force said the protest against the use of the Islington hotel was organised by local residents under the banner 'Thistle Barbican needs to go – locals say no'. A counter protest, organised by Stand Up To Racism and supported by former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, as well as other groups including Finsbury Park Mosque and Islington Labour Party, also took place. Claire Ogley was one of the many Islington residents who joined the Stand Up to Racism protest outside the Thistle City Barbican hotel. The 31-year-old told the Standard: 'I live in Islington. I wanted to show support as a local resident. 'It's really important to stand up to the far right when they come out. We have a message that migrants are not a problem, they are not a threat to us. 'They are welcome. It's not an issue to have migration. I wanted to stand up for that locally.' The protester added: 'We saw the riots on the street a year ago. It is really frightening to see. 'There is a really worrying trend of increasing populism, trying to divide people and stoke up hatred.' Joel, who was also part of the same protest, also told the Standard: 'Islington is a multicultural area of London. The fascists want to intimidate people and they want to come down and say asylum seekers are the root cause of all the problems of the world, but it's not the case.' The 77-year-old added: "We want to show that the racists [and] the fascists are out there to intimidate people. We have to stand together. "We always need more people [to protest], we have to give confidence to people that we are a multicultural city. 'Without the input of people from all over the world, the fashion industry, the food - all the elements of London would be nothing without people from all parts of the world." He added: "I'm proud to live in London, we want to see more people [who] will be welcome. It's not about attacking the fascists, it's about standing together.' Protesters against asylum seekers being placed in the Thistle City Barbican hotel had waved St George's flag and chanted across the street from the building. Susie Luke, who has lived in the Clerkenwell area her whole life, told the Standard: 'Our communities are struggling. 'People are living in the block of flats opposite on food stamps, watching people live over there for free.' Ms Luke also raised concerns about crime in the area increasing, claiming that her friend was followed home and a young man had a chain ripped from around his neck outside the hotel. A large group of masked protesters dressed in black, chanting 'we are anti-fascist' had appeared from a side street and marched towards the rival group outside the hotel during the protests. There were brief clashes before police rushed in to separate the two groups. Online groups that have voiced support for the protest include 'Patriots of Britain' and 'Together for the Children'. The Metropolitan Police said on Friday that plans were in place to 'respond to any protest activity in the vicinity of other hotels in London being used to accommodate asylum seekers'. There were also posts online advertising a 'for our children, for our future' protest in Newcastle on Saturday outside The New Bridge Hotel. A 'stop the far right and fascists in Newcastle' counter-protest had been organised by Stand Up To Racism at the nearby Laing Art Gallery. In a statement, the organisers of the counter protest said: 'Yet again far-right and fascist thugs are intent on bringing their message of hate to Newcastle. They aim to build on years of Islamophobia, anti-migrant sentiment and scapegoating. 'In Epping and elsewhere recently we have already seen intimidation and violence aimed at refugees, migrants and asylum seekers. 'Newcastle, like the rest of the North East, has a well-earned reputation for unity in the face of those who seek to divide us. Whatever problems we face, racism and division are not the answer.' On Saturday evening, a spokesperson for Northumbria Police said: 'The safety of the public is our utmost priority and when we became aware of a protest planned in Newcastle today, we ensured we had an increased presence in the city to deliver a proportionate policing response. 'While the activity mainly passed without incident, disappointingly, four people were arrested in connection with public order offences. 'All four remain in police custody. 'The right to lawful protest is a key part of any democracy, which the police uphold. 'However, we will not accept people using them as a means to commit crime or disorder.' About 100 people attended a protest outside the Stanwell Hotel in Spelthorne, Surrey, on Friday evening, during which a packet of lit firelighters was thrown at police, Surrey Police said. A man was arrested on suspicion of attempted arson and inquiries are ongoing to trace another suspect, the force said. Officers also arrested a man on suspicion of conspiracy to commit violent disorder and aggravated trespass following a protest at the same location on Thursday evening.
Yahoo
28-07-2025
- Yahoo
How much do UK bank holidays cost? Calls grow for celebration after Lionesses' Euros win
The last time the government announced an extra bank holiday was for Queen Elizabeth's Platinum Jubilee. The government is facing calls to promise an extra bank holiday to commemorate the Lionesses defending their Euros title after their victory over Spain on Sunday. During the tense final in Basel, Chloe Kelly managed to bring it home for England for the second time in a row after she scored the trophy-winning penalty. The Football Association and the government have announced an open-top parade down The Mall in central London on Tuesday, 29 July, to mark the occasion. But many want to see the government go further and give the nation an extra day off to celebrate. Lib Dem leader Sir Ed Davey said an additional day off would be a great way of honouring the "stunning achievement". In a post on X, he said: "Back-to-back champions! The Lionesses have done it again and made us proud. How about it, Keir Starmer? Time for that bank holiday?" Sir Keir Starmer also called for a bank holiday when England were the runners-up in the 2023 women's World Cup, when he was leader of the opposition. Will there be a bank holiday? Although there's been no official work on it yet, it is unlikely. When speaking to BBC Breakfast on Monday, business secretary Jonathan Reynolds said there should be a "celebration." But he added: "I can't, I'm afraid, promise a bank holiday." Several news organisations, including the Telegraph, have also reported that Downing Street has said there will not be one. There was no bank holiday following their victory in the 2022 tournament, nor was there one when the men's team won the 1966 World Cup. How much does a bank holiday cost? In 2022, the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport published an assessment on how much the additional bank holiday to mark Queen Elizabeth II's Platinum Jubilee in June 2022 cost the UK economy. The study factored in the loss of economic output, weighed against the increased activity in the hospitality and tourism sector. The assessment also considered any 'bouncing back' that may have happened due to increased productivity later in the week, as businesses tried to catch up with what they had lost. Overall, they said the extra bank holiday cost the British economy £2.4bn in terms of lost GDP. The UK's annual GDP in recent years has been over £2.5 trillion, so an extra bank holiday costs the economy less than 0.01% per year. Considering the Platinum Jubilee was also a celebration, it would likely cost a similar amount for a bank holiday celebrating a major sporting win. Although the extra bank holiday for the Jubilee was announced months in advance, giving businesses much more time to prepare and it would be unlikely that the government would promise a day off with just a few days' notice.
Yahoo
25-07-2025
- Yahoo
Birmingham depot where lorries delayed again by striking bin workers
Continued strike action by bin workers in Birmingham in a pay dispute with the council has led to lorries being delayed from leaving one depot. The refuse collectors have been on the picket line at the Atlas Depot in Tyseley on Thursday (July 24) morning affecting the number of dustcarts which have been able to get out. Birmingham City Council has said this may affect the number of bin collections it can make in the centre and east of the city. Read more: Costs of the bin strike exposed Areas served by the Atlas depot include the city centre, the Jewellery Quarter and Soho, Newtown and Nechells, Moseley, down to Hall Green, up to Ward End, Bromford and Hodge Hill and across to Sheldon, and Shard End. In a post on X, the city council said: 'Due to actions on the picket line there are delays in waste wagons leaving our Atlas depot this AM. 'This may affect the number of collections we are able to make from this depot. 'If today is your collection day, leave bins out we will collect them asap.' An injunction had been in place which appeared to have stopped striking bin workers delay bin trucks from leaving depots. But the council confirmed delays had started again last week and have continued this week. West Midlands Police had been intervening to stop the blockades of bin depots but has now eased back on that intervention following a Court of Appeal decision in May found police powers to restrict protests were 'unlawful'. The decision set a higher threshold to what amounts to 'serious public disorder, serious damage to property or serious disruption to the life of the community' under the Public Order Act. A West Midlands Police spokesperson asked why it was not stopping lorries being delayed said: 'We continue to have a policing presence at sites across Birmingham as and when required as a result of the current industrial action. 'We attend to deal with any breach of the peace and to ensure any crimes are investigated accordingly. 'We continue to assess the situation and ensure our presence at the sites is in line with our core policing responsibilities.' And a Unite spokesperson said: 'Our members, as always, are engaged in peaceful and lawful picketing.' The long-running bin strike began in January and went to an all out strike in March with Unite the Union members striking over the council's plans to remove 170 Waste Recycling and Collections Officer roles. This week the total cost of agency workers who are carrying out bin collections while Unite members strike, has been almost £8 million. Get the latest BirminghamLive news direct to your inbox The council is looking to limit the number of higher paid roles to stave off multi-million-pound equal pay claims if those roles continue. Unite say their members are being asked to forfeit £8,000 in wages – and they are therefore striking. In April some 200 drivers, mainly men, were told they too faced pay cuts as part of the equal-pay review, with drivers set to be downgraded from the Grade 4 paygrade to Grade 3 – a lower level. And earlier this month the council announced some 130 workers – all senior drivers – are now at risk of redundancy. The strike shows no signs of abating with residents facing continuing missed collections, no green collections service all year and no recycling either.
