BBC bosses accused of ‘throwing people out to the wolves' by axing River City
Lynda Rooke, who also starred in dramas Casualty and The Bill, told MSPs that shutting down the BBC soap could result in Scotland losing talent from the sector.
Rooke, who is the president of actors' union Equity, told MSPs on Holyrood's Culture Committee about the security soaps can provide.
She said: 'Sometimes when I was doing the soaps I breathed a sigh of relief that I could pay off the overdraft and get myself back on the straight and narrow, and that is so important.
'You take that away and you really are throwing people out to the wolves, basically.
'It is the long-term view and the security that so rarely happens in this industry, River City offers this to those performers and crew and technicians.'
With that 'at risk', she said it is possible actors and others working behind the scenes in the TV sector could end up leaving Scotland.
Rooke warned: 'You are going to lose talent again, we have known it happen in the past, many people have gone down to London because they couldn't make a living.'
She appeared before the committe alongside River City star Frank Gallagher, who plays Lenny Murdoch.
He told MSPs: 'There should be a place for people who want to work in our own country instead of waiting for some dramas that are probably brought up from the BBC production in London.'
BBC Scotland announced back in March that River City, which is based in the fictional area of Shieldinch, is to end next year. It has been on air since 2002.
At the time the broadcaster said the decision reflects a change in viewing patterns as audiences move away from long-running series, instead opting for shorter shows.
At the same time as it axed the soap, BBC Scotland announced three new dramas.
Speaking about these planned new shows, Rooke said: 'I can almost guarantee they will not replace the jobs or the infrastructure, I doubt that will be the case.'
She told the MSPs how soaps can help develop talent in the TV sector, saying they 'allow people who normally don't have easy access into the film and television industry to actually get in there'.
She added: 'They become a training ground both on screen and off screen and it allows people from marginalised communities in particular to enter into the industry, which can be a very closed shop, with lots of barriers, especially outside London and the South East.'
Meanwhile, Equity general secretary Paul Fleming told the committee that 'River City is the rubicon we're not prepared to cross'.
He insisted the Scottish soap 'has got a fanbase, it has got a clear dedicated viewership', and said both it and other long-running productions 'provide stable, high-quality employment'.
Contrasting that with the planned new programmes, he said: 'Nine million pounds for three dramas is not really that sort of deep intellectual commitment.'
Mr Fleming also questioned the value of the hit programme Traitors to Scotland.
The show is filmed in the Highlands, but Mr Fleming said: 'Traitors does not employ actors as professional actors, that is not the role of it, and if you look at the economic value it creates, it is a small, contained production brought up from London, a bit of a flash in the pan.'
A BBC Scotland spokesperson said: 'The decision to end River City is a creative one driven by changing audience habits and declining viewing figures, which have dropped to an average of 200,000 per episode, considerably lower than other BBC dramas.
'Audience patterns have shifted away from long-running serials to short-run dramas, so that is where we will be moving our drama investment.
'This is about value for money for the audience. We are not cutting our drama spend in Scotland – in fact, we will increase it to around £95 million over the next three years.'
The spokesperson continued: 'The BBC remains committed to reflecting Scottish culture and voices in dramas across the UK.
'River City training opportunities will remain active for another year until we cease production in April 2026.
'We are actively working with BBC colleagues, the independent companies making our newly announced dramas and others in the industry on future training opportunities.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
4 hours ago
- STV News
Scottish film talent 'bypassed' in big-screen boom, industry figures warn
From city streets to sweeping landscapes, Scotland has long been a star of the big and small screen. In recent years, global productions have transformed familiar locations into backdrops for hits like Indiana Jones, Tetris and Batman – with Spider-Man the latest to swing into Glasgow. Last year alone, the city hosted 140 productions – from Shetland and The Buccaneers to The Running Man – bringing in an estimated £33m to the economy. But behind the blockbuster buzz, some in the industry say Scotland's own film talent is stuck on the sidelines. STV News Filming for Marvel's upcoming blockbuster Spider-Man 4 kicks off, as sets and film production vehicles are spotted in Glasgow. 'It's amazing that big movies like Spider-Man are filmed here, but more needs to be done to promote Scottish films by Scottish talent,' senior producer and director Peter Strachan said. 'Just because it's filmed in Scotland, doesn't make it a Scottish production. 'A lot of work has gone into attracting movies to be filmed in Scotland, but more has to be done to support directing, producing and writing talent to flourish and actually make movies.' Screen Scotland say they're committed to supporting Scotland-based film and TV talent, with most of its production funding going to Scotland-based projects. Recent examples include Only Child and Mayflies for BBC Scotland, The Rig for Amazon Prime and feature films such as Aftersun and The Outrun. STV News Producer and director Peter Strachan The agency last month doubled its investment in new film talent from Scotland to £1.2m with the creation of new programme Talent Builder. This sits alongside a £4m annual film development and production fund that directly invests in films from Scotland-based producers, directors and writers, and the £2.5m Broadcast Content Fund for television projects from Scottish production companies. Yet even productions that look Scottish on screen, like hit reality TV show The Traitors, can have surprisingly few Scots working behind the camera. Season three of the show, which filmed in the Highlands, had 13 Scotland-based people working on it, according to Mr Strachan's data – equivalent to 5.94% of the total staff. 'It's considered by London that Scottish screen talent doesn't have the requisite skills or experience. That's just nonsense. 'The question we should be asking is not about Scottish qualification – it's about origination. Are the TV shows and movies we're getting to watch on our screens made in Scotland, by Scottish talent? Research shows that's not to the extent it ought to be.' STV News Karan Bhopal has been involved in extra work for 35 years Karan Bhopal has worked as an extra on everything from Batman to Indiana Jones – but says too often visiting productions use London-based casting companies. 'I enjoy it – you get to meet people and see things behind the scenes,' he said. 'Being part of motion pictures is such a buzz, but there's many people on the books that want to be a part of productions. We sometimes don't get a bite of that apple. 'Some of the bigger production companies coming from America use London-based casting companies. Sometimes the doors are closed to us – I find that quite unfair.' Talent agency manager David Bell agreed, saying Scottish professionals are too often overlooked for key jobs. 'Scotland has a wealth of talent, but when the big productions come to film they come up with English staff and generally we're drafted in to plug gaps at the last minute. 'They're not using assistant directors, makeup artists, costume people that have worked in the industry for years. They're bypassing using local talent.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
The Lost Boys get loose: Jack Holden on rebooting Peter Pan and The Line of Beauty
The room is hot, sticky and covered in trampled confetti. A mashup of noughties bangers impels our bodies to move. As Club Nvrlnd draws to a close, the audience doesn't want to get off the stage, our throats scratchy from screaming along. 'I'm singing along to every word, every night,' grins the show's writer, Jack Holden, bounding over after having just had a boogie on the platform. We are all glistening with sweat and nostalgia, this show's giddy delirium impossible to resist. Over the next few months, the spotlight is sticking to Holden. A powerhouse of a performer and a deft, emotive writer, the 35-year-old's jukebox-nightclub musical already has audiences at the Edinburgh fringe lining up in the street. His adaptation of Alan Hollinghurst's queer classic novel The Line of Beauty, meanwhile, is soon to be staged at the Almeida in London, and the true-crime thriller Kenrex, that he co-wrote and stars in, is returning for a London run. 'I'm an optimist,' he says, smiling bashfully over coffee earlier in the day. 'I say yes to things then work out how to do them.' Proving his muscle as an actor in War Horse and comedy series Ten Percent, Holden showed his strength as a writer with Cruise, an electronically scored story of a survivor of the Aids crisis blended with his time volunteering at LGBTQ+ listening service Switchboard. Seeing the Olivier-nominated show, producer David Adkin and director Steve Kunis approached Holden with another challenge: to write the book for a musical transposing the familiar story of Peter Pan into a noughties nightclub. 'I'm a Peter Pan myself,' Holden admits. 'Afraid of growing up, trying to create musical, euphoric, hedonistic neverlands of my own. With Club Nvrlnd, I've been able to realise it in my purest, most silly, unashamed way.' In this hazy, fairy-dust-fuelled world we, the lost boys, join Peter (a petulant Thomas Grant) on the eve of his 30th birthday. Having peaked in high school, he's now refusing to grow up. RuPaul's Drag Race's Le Fil shines as our compere Tiger Lily while a rival club owner, a glimmering, bare-chested Hook (Matthew Gent), tries to sabotage Nvrlnd. 'It's absolute chaos,' Holden grins. 'I think we found our audience last night. They are young and ready to dance.' Music pulsates through all of Holden's work. For Kenrex, his thriller co-written with Ed Stamboulian, he has continued his collaboration with The Little Unsaid's John Patrick Elliot, who scored Cruise. The show has been seven years in the making. 'We've cooked it low and slow,' Holden says. 'It's not a cost-effective process.' But it has given them time to find the right form for what began as an experiment, asking whether it was possible to stage a true-crime podcast. They had workshopped the show with a cast of 10 when lockdown hit. 'We realised, in true-crime radio, you hear voices in sequence,' he reasons, 'so it could be coming from one voice.' Holden now plays every part. To watch his performance over the course of Kenrex is to see a shapeshifter in action. With Elliot's music and clever tech, Holden rolls through the roster of distinct characters who, in 1981, finally decide to take justice into their own hands. Holden found inspiration in Andrew Scott's one-man show Vanya, which revealed the power in taking time to transition between characters. 'Kenrex is an exercise in stillness,' he says. 'It's a tightrope walk every night.' Holden's theatrical exploration of the 80s continues with The Line of Beauty, which he is adapting for Rupert Goold's last season at the Almeida. His version streamlines the text to focus on the four young men as they navigate the decade's societal shifts with varying levels of privilege. 'It's about how much has changed,' says Holden, 'but also how much of that entrenched class structure and snobbery is absolutely the same.' The story also returns his focus to the Aids crisis. 'I have fictional arguments in my head about why I'm doing another play about [this topic],' he says. 'But then I argue back and go: how many war movies have been made?' Born in 1990, Holden questions his place to write about the 80s, but he sees its long shadow snaking through his life, with the homophobic legislation Section 28 only repealed when he was a teenager. 'Older gay friends who remember before the Aids crisis say everyone was just having a wild time,' he says ruefully. 'Then Aids came along and instilled so much terror.' Now, with the ready availability of the drug PrEP, Holden hopes the debilitating weight of that fear is finally lifting. 'It's a bit of a sexual renaissance,' he laughs. Freedom is starting to unfurl again. The looseness of bodies. The embrace of a wild night out. The unadulterated fun that Club Nvrlnd encourages. Holden smiles. 'The best drama always happens on the dancefloor.' Club Nvrlnd is at Assembly Checkpoint, Edinburgh, until 24 August; The Line of Beauty is at the Almeida, London, 21 October-29 November; Kenrex is at the Other Palace, London, from 3 December-1 February.
The Guardian
6 hours ago
- The Guardian
James Trickey: Don't Count on Me review – accountant takes calculated risk in fringe debut
There's a bait-and-switch to begin newcomer James Trickey's show, which starts with our host in sunglasses raving to techno music. The music stops, the shades are removed and then, in deadpan: 'I'm a chartered accountant.' It's a fun pivot, from suave to schmuck. It's also a misdirection, because Trickey then re-ascends to high status for the rest of the show, delivering his debut set in unusually imperious style at a time when, for fringe wannabes at least, self-deprecation is the norm. You've got to admire the chutzpah; high status is harder for a rookie to pull off. It comes at the expense of warmth, though: I found Trickey's maiden fringe set reminiscent of Jack Whitehall's way back when. He's technically excellent, plenty of good jokes, sometimes a bit facile, his mannerisms occasionally feeling borrowed. His is an expertly constructed example of the genus 'debut fringe show', deploying his day job and field of expertise (accountancy and mathematics) as a lens through which to explore who he is, where he's come from – and where he's going. That's a lot to get through, and Trickey packs plenty into the hour, ranging across his parentage – old white dad, Cambodian mum – his passion for tomato puree, and the kids' trust fund he's establishing based on Subway loyalty points. The latter prompts a section on probability and expectation, consisting of a weak rap/rhyme set-piece and reflections on the gamble he's taking by quitting accountancy for standup. Earlier, we get some material making hay with our host's dual heritage ('Am I being racially excluded from the racist banter?'). One or two of those jokes are funnier in principle than in practice. The tenuous idea is apparent behind a routine justifying racism based on the GDP of the country being abused, but it raises a wan smile at best. The joke about how seedy it looks when ageing white dad takes young Asian son to school is not a pleasant one. Technique may be running ahead of judicious selection of material, then, but Trickey has certainly got it, and his gamble in taking up comedy looks odds-on to pay off. At Pleasance Courtyard, Edinburgh, until 24 August All our Edinburgh festival reviews
