logo
What is a 'sanctuary jurisdiction' and how was the US list of them made?

What is a 'sanctuary jurisdiction' and how was the US list of them made?

Independent30-05-2025
The U.S. government's list of 'sanctuary jurisdictions' that includes hundreds of communities, both red and blue, is confounding critics. They have noticed the list included misspellings, communities with small immigrant populations, and those with strong support for cooperation with federal authorities.
Jessica Vaughan is director of policy studies at the Center for Immigration Studies, which favors anti-sanctuary policies and started publishing a list of sanctuary jurisdictions 10 years ago. The center's list is different from the government's. Vaughan noted that the center discloses its methodology and frequently updates its list.
'That's one thing that I feel is missing from the (government's) list is some documentation as to why they're appearing on the list,' she said.
A message was left Friday seeking comment from DHS.
The list is part of the Trump administration's efforts to target communities, states and jurisdiction s that it says aren't doing enough to help its immigration enforcement agenda and the promises the president made to deport more than 11 million people living in the U.S. without legal authorization.
What are the stakes?
The Department of Homeland Security and the U.S. attorney general will send them official notice to the 500 jurisdictions on the list 'regarding its defiance of Federal immigration law enforcement and any potential violations of Federal criminal law,' according to an executive order from President Donald Trump.
The list could be updated when the administration receives new information, but those that remain on the list could face serious financial consequences, including suspended or terminated federal grants and contracts by the Office of Management and Budget.
It is not clear what legal actions the government will pursue.
How was the list made?
DHS said it used several factors to make the list, including whether the cities or localities identified themselves as sanctuary jurisdictions, how much they complied with federal officials enforcing immigration laws, if they had restrictions on sharing information with immigration enforcement or had any legal protections for people illegally in the country.
But experts noted that the list is too broad and it is difficult to understand the criteria used to make it.
'It seems quite arbitrary because not all of these states or specific jurisdictions have a policy that limits cooperation with ICE,' said Nithya Nathan-Pineau, an attorney with the Immigrant Legal Resource Center.
How did communities that support Trump's policies end up on the list?
That's unclear.
Several communities said they have been outspoken supporters of the president and his stringent immigration policies and do not understand why they have been included. Among them: Shawano County, Wisconsin; Alexandria, Virginia; and Huntington Beach, California.
Jim Davel, administrator for Shawano County, thinks the administration may have confused the county's vote in 2021 to become a 'Second Amendment Sanctuary County' that prohibits gun control measures with it being a safe haven for immigrants. He said the county has approved no immigration sanctuary policies.
What is a sanctuary city?
There is no clear definition of a sanctuary jurisdiction, but it is generally understood to apply to state and local governments that limit cooperation with federal immigration authorities. DHS said it took into account 'factors like compliance with federal law enforcement, information restrictions, and legal protections for illegal aliens.'
The notion of sanctuary dates back to Medieval Europe, when civil law enforcement entities were not allowed to enter churches, Cesar Garcia Hernandez, a professor at Ohio State University's College of Law, explained Friday.
The term evolved into the 'sanctuary movement' among U.S. churches and other religious institutions that would house Central Americans fleeing civil war in the 1980s.
'There there was no legal guarantee of immunity for people who were who were spending their time inside church buildings, but there was policy' that prohibited immigration arrests, Garcia Hernandez said. That changed under the current Trump administration.
The Immigrant Legal Resource Center, a nongovernmental organization, said that when compiling its own list of sanctuary jurisdictions, it considers how they limit interactions with ICE and federal law enforcement, and how they protect information.
___
Associated Press writers Amy Taxin in Santa Ana, California, and Scott Bauer in Madison, Wisconsin, also contributed.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Newsom warns Trump he's 'playing with fire' on redistricting
Newsom warns Trump he's 'playing with fire' on redistricting

Daily Mail​

time11 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Newsom warns Trump he's 'playing with fire' on redistricting

By Gavin Newsom sent a stern warning to President Donald Trump that he is 'playing with fire' over efforts to rewrite the congressional map in Texas. In a letter penned to the president on Monday, Newsom vowed to not 'stand idly by' as Texas along with other GOP-dominated states attempt to add more Republican seats to protect and enlarge their majority in the U.S. House. Democrats only need to flip three House seats to regain control of the chamber in the upcoming 2026 midterms . 'If you will not stand down, I will be forced to lead an effort to redraw the maps in California to offset the rigging of maps in red states,' Newsom wrote. The White House did not immediately respond to the Daily Mail's request for comment. Newsom goes on to address Trump directly by claiming the president is 'playing with fire' that will lead to the 'destabilization of our democracy.' 'You are playing with fire, risking the destabilization of our democracy, while knowing that California can neutralize any gains you hope to make,' Newsom added. 'This attempt to rig congressional maps to hold onto power before a single vote is cast in the 2026 election is an affront to American democracy.' Newsom, who many believe has aspirations for a presidential run in 2028, made similar comments last week after claiming he will 'fight fire with fire' against Gov. Greg Abbott's redistricting plan. 'The proposal that we're advancing with the legislature has a trigger only if they move forward, to dismantling the protocols that are well-established,' Newsom told the press. 'Would the state of California move forward in kind? Fighting? Yes, fire with fire.' Newsom's new letter to Trump is the most outspoken example of Democrats planning to counter the GOP redistricting in Texas. Democratic state lawmakers fled from Texas to deny the GOP the quorum necessary to vote on legislation in the state capital.

Trump signs order extending China tariff truce by 90 days, White House says
Trump signs order extending China tariff truce by 90 days, White House says

Reuters

time11 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Trump signs order extending China tariff truce by 90 days, White House says

WASHINGTON, Aug 11 (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump has signed an executive order extending a tariff truce with China by another 90 days, a White House official said on Monday with only hours to go before U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods were due to snap back to triple-digit rates. The order followed a noncommittal answer by Trump to reporters as to whether he would extend the lower tariff rates a day after he urged Beijing to quadruple its purchases of U.S. soybeans. A tariff truce between Beijing and Washington was set to expire on Tuesday at 00:01 ET (04:01 GMT). The order prevents U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods from shooting up to 145%, with Chinese tariffs on U.S. goods set to hit 125%, rates that would have resulted in a virtual trade embargo. "We'll see what happens," Trump told a press conference, when asked how he planned to extend the deadline. "They've been dealing quite nicely. The relationship is very good with President Xi (Jinping) and myself." Imports from China are currently subject to 30% tariffs, including a 10% base rate and 20% in fentanyl-related tariffs imposed by Washington in February and March. China had matched the de-escalation, lowering its rate on U.S. imports to 10%. The two sides in May announced a truce in their trade dispute after talks in Geneva, Switzerland, agreeing to a 90-day period to allow further talks. They met again in Stockholm, Sweden in late July, but did not announce an agreement to further extend the deadline. Kelly Ann Shaw, a senior White House trade official during Trump's first term and now with Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld, said she expected Trump to extend the 90-day "tariff détente" for another 90 days later on Monday. "It wouldn't be a Trump-style negotiation if it didn't go right down to the wire," she said, adding Trump could also announce progress in other aspects of the economic relationship as a backdrop for granting the extension. "The whole reason for the 90-day pause in the first place was to lay the groundwork for broader negotiations and there's been a lot of noise about everything from soybeans to export controls to excess capacity over the weekend," she said. Ryan Majerus, a former U.S. trade official now with the King & Spalding law firm, welcomed the news. 'This will undoubtedly lower anxiety on both sides as talks continue, and as the U.S. and China work toward a framework deal in the fall. I'm certain investment commitments will factor into any potential deal, and the extension gives them more time to try and work through some of the longstanding trade concerns," he said. The White House declined to comment beyond Trump's remarks. The Treasury Department and U.S. Trade Representative's Office did not respond to requests for comment. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has said Washington has the makings of a deal with China and he was "optimistic" about the path forward. Trump pushed for additional concessions on Sunday, urging China to quadruple its soybean purchases, although analysts questioned the feasibility of any such deal. Trump did not repeat the demand on Monday. But Washington has also been pressing Beijing to stop buying Russian oil, with Trump threatening to impose secondary tariffs on China.

Boyfriend from hell abducted woman he was dating and kept her trapped in his home for six months, cops say
Boyfriend from hell abducted woman he was dating and kept her trapped in his home for six months, cops say

Daily Mail​

time13 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Boyfriend from hell abducted woman he was dating and kept her trapped in his home for six months, cops say

A Texas man has been arrested after allegedly abducting a woman he was dating and keeping her locked inside his home for at least six months. Kenneth Leon Wright, 41, held the victim in a home with windows nailed-shut and doors locked from the outside so she couldn't escape, ABC13 reported. Wright has now been been charged with aggravated kidnapping and assault family violence. According to court documents, Wright hid the woman and subjected her to abuse for at least 6 months. The victim's alleged sister, Shenita Carter, said she had no idea where her sibling was living and that Wright would only occasionally bring her to visit family earlier this month. 'He would not give us the address,' Carter told the outlet. 'He would only bring her to my mom's house.' Kenneth Leon Wright, 41, held the victim in a home with windows nailed-shut and doors locked from the outside so she couldn't escape Her sister then called her, claiming she was being abused, Carter revealed. Their mother managed to track down the address and called the police for a welfare check. When Carter arrived, she said she was shocked by the conditions of the home. Carter recalled the front door locking from the outside, no key for her sister and windows nailed shut. '(It's) disgusting, sad the fact that this is how she had been living,' Carter said. 'The windows have nails on them,' she added. Another woman who answered the door at the apartment listed in Wright's court documents identified herself as Wright's current girlfriend and insisted he was 'taking care' of the alleged victim and not holding her against her will.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store