Limbs in the Loch killer in bid for freedom after being denied parole
A lawyer has urged a judge to throw out a legal challenge brought by 'limbs in the loch' killer William Beggs as he seeks to be freed from prison.
Mark Lindsay KC told Judge Lady Drummond on Monday that parole board officials acted lawfully in a decision made by the organisation in February 2024.
The Court of Session heard how staff refused to release Beggs on license from the life sentence given to him in October 2001 for murdering Barry Wallace.
Lawyers for Beggs claim that the parole board's decision to deny their client's release from custody was incorrect – this has prompted them to raise a judicial review at Scotland's highest civil court.
His legal team wants Lady Drummond to quash the February 2024 decision. They also want the parole board to convene a tribunal of new members to reconsider Beggs's bid for freedom.
However, on Monday, Mr Lindsay said the decision made by the parole board was lawful.
He told Lady Drummond: 'There's no merit in the grounds of appeal advanced on behalf of the petitioner.
'I invite your lady to dismiss the petition.'
Beggs was jailed for life in 2001 after murdering and dismembering 18-year-old Mr Wallace after luring him back to his flat in Kilmarnock, in Ayrshire. He disposed of the limbs and torso in Loch Lomond and the head at sea.
He was ordered to serve a minimum term of 20 years in jail before he could seek to apply for release on parole, but he completed that period in December 2019.
Legal papers lodged in the case state that the petitioner is now 'five years over his punishment part.'
A hearing in the action was due to begin at the Court of Session in Edinburgh in the absence of Beggs earlier this year. However, Lady Drummond agreed to discharge it so the murderer could either be brought into court or observe proceedings virtually via a video conferencing app called Webex.
On that occasion, Lady Drummond was told that Beggs, 62, wanted to be able to respond to what was said in the judicial review as he was present at the Parole Board hearing.
The court heard that Beggs had made a complaint to the prison authorities over a refusal to bring him to court and has had no response.
Beggs's lawyer Simon Crabb said: 'He wishes to be able to fully participate in the hearing by attending to hear the arguments, to observe any judicial interventions, and to be able to see justice is done in his case.'
Mr Crabb said Beggs felt he had been treated unfairly and added: 'He thinks it is important he should be present either in person or by Webex. This is a case that obviously involves his fundamental right to liberty.'
On Thursday, Beggs observed proceedings from prison. He could be seen wearing a navy suit, a light blue shirt, and a royal blue tie. He sat beside a prison officer and had what appeared to be a number of legal files beside him.
Lawyers acting for Beggs claim parole board officials made their decision partly on the basis of an 'irrelevant factor'.
They claim that parole board officials considered his conviction for murdering student Gary Oldham, 28, in England in 1987. However, Beggs successfully appealed the conviction.
Beggs's legal team claims that in their February 2024 decision, parole board officials considered the death of Mr Oldham in their deliberations. They believe the parole board had no lawful basis to do this.
On Monday, Mr Lindsay said this wasn't the case and considered evidence that related to the level of risk posed by Beggs to the public.
He added: 'They looked at the lack of insight and they looked at the lack of insight, focused work on the part of the petitioner.
'They looked at the lack of a supportive network for the petitioner.
'They were entitled to conclude that the level of risk posed by the petitioner cannot be, at this time, managed within the community.'
Mr Lindsay also told the hearing that Beggs will have another chance to apply for parole at another hearing in August 2025.
Lady Drummond told the lawyers that she'd issue her findings at some time in the near future.
She added: 'I will take this to Avizandum.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
13 minutes ago
- ITV News
Michael Steele, triple killer convicted of 'Essex Boys' gangland murders, released from prison
A triple killer convicted of the "Essex Boys" gangland murders has been released from prison, the Ministry of Justice confirmed. Michael Steele was jailed for life in 1998 for the killings of Tony Tucker, Pat Tate and Craig Rolfe, which he and his co-defendant Jack Whomes denied. The three men were found shot dead in a Range Rover in Rettendon, near Chelmsford, Essex, in 1995. In February, a Parole Board panel decided to free Steele, now in his 80s, because his imprisonment was 'no longer necessary for the protection of the public'. But Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood had challenged the decision and asked for his case to be reviewed again on the grounds the decision was legally irrational. The MoJ confirmed Steele was released in May. A spokesperson for the government department said: 'Our thoughts remain with the family and friends of Craig Rolfe, Tony Tucker and Pat Tate. 'This decision was made by the independent Parole Board after a thorough risk assessment. 'Michael Steele will be on licence for the rest of his life, with strict conditions and intensive probation supervision. He faces an immediate return to prison if he breaks the rules.' The Parole Board decided Whomes, then aged 59, could be released in 2021. The killings took place after a row over a drug deal, prosecutors said, and the case later inspired the 2000 film Essex Boys, starring Sean Bean. The decision in February to release Steele came in the second review by the Parole Board following the end of his initial minimum term of 23 years' imprisonment. He had not been assessed as suitable for formal risk-reduction interventions while in prison, 'partly through lack of need and partly because he had maintained his innocence of involvement in the murders', the Parole Board's summary said. It added that risk factors for Steele at the time of his offending included his 'criminal lifestyle, involvement with drugs and association with the wrong people'. But the Parole Board also found that Steele's behaviour in prison had shown 'marked improvement' and none of the witnesses considered risks would be imminent if he was released into the community. Strict licence conditions were set out for Steele, including to live at a designated address, be of good behaviour, provide financial and business details, give up his passport, and be subject to electronic tagging and a specified curfew. There were additional restrictions relating to the use of electronic technology, contact with the media or other publications, and not to own a boat, plane or firearm.
Belfast Telegraph
5 hours ago
- Belfast Telegraph
‘Essex Boys' triple killer Michael Steele released from prison
Michael Steele was jailed for life in 1998 for the killings of Tony Tucker, Pat Tate and Craig Rolfe, which he denied, alongside co-defendant Jack Whomes. The three men were found shot dead in a Range Rover in Rettendon, near Chelmsford, Essex, in 1995. A Parole Board panel decided in February to free Steele, now in his 80s, because his imprisonment was 'no longer necessary for the protection of the public' but Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood challenged the decision and asked for his case to be reviewed again on the grounds the decision was legally irrational. Steele was released from prison in May, the MoJ confirmed. A spokesperson for the government department said: 'Our thoughts remain with the family and friends of Craig Rolfe, Tony Tucker and Pat Tate. 'This decision was made by the independent Parole Board after a thorough risk assessment. 'Michael Steele will be on licence for the rest of his life, with strict conditions and intensive probation supervision. He faces an immediate return to prison if he breaks the rules.' The killings took place after a row over a drug deal, prosecutors said, and the case later inspired the 2000 film Essex Boys, starring Sean Bean. The decision in February to release Steele came in the second review by the Parole Board following the end of his initial minimum term of 23 years' imprisonment. He had not been assessed as suitable for formal risk-reduction interventions while in prison, 'partly through lack of need and partly because he had maintained his innocence of involvement in the murders', the Parole Board's summary said. It added that risk factors for Steele at the time of his offending included his 'criminal lifestyle, involvement with drugs and association with the wrong people'. But the Parole Board also found that Steele's behaviour in prison had shown 'marked improvement' and none of the witnesses considered risks would be imminent if he was released into the community. Strict licence conditions were set out for Steele, including to live at a designated address, be of good behaviour, provide financial and business details, give up his passport, and be subject to electronic tagging and a specified curfew. There were additional restrictions relating to the use of electronic technology, contact with the media or other publications, and not to own a boat, plane or firearm. The Parole Board decided Whomes, then aged 59, could be released in 2021.
Daily Mirror
7 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Notorious ‘Essex Boys' triple killer released from jail after 29 years
Michael Steele was convicted of the murders of Tony Tucker, Pat Tate and Craig Rolfe, who were found shot dead in a Range Rover in Rettendon, near Chelmsford, Essex, in 1995 Michael Steele, a triple murderer convicted of the infamous "Essex Boys" gangland killings, has been released from prison, as confirmed by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ). Steele was sentenced to life imprisonment in 1998 for the murders of Tony Tucker, Pat Tate and Craig Rolfe, crimes he denied, alongside co-defendant Jack Whomes. The victims were discovered shot dead in a Range Rover in Rettendon, near Chelmsford, Essex, in 1995. A Parole Board panel decided in February to release Steele, now in his 80s, stating that his continued incarceration was "no longer necessary for the protection of the public". However, Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood challenged this decision, requesting a review of his case on the grounds that the decision was legally irrational. Despite this, Steele was released from prison in May, as confirmed by the MoJ. A spokesperson for the government department stated: "Our thoughts remain with the family and friends of Craig Rolfe, Tony Tucker and Pat Tate. This decision was made by the independent Parole Board after a thorough risk assessment. Michael Steele will be on licence for the rest of his life, with strict conditions and intensive probation supervision. He faces an immediate return to prison if he breaks the rules." Prosecutors said the murders occurred following a dispute over a drug deal, and the case later inspired the 2000 film Essex Boys, starring Sean Bean. The decision to release Steele in February came during the second review by the Parole Board, following the end of his initial minimum term of 23 years' imprisonment. The Parole Board has disclosed that while in prison, Steele wasn't deemed apt for formal risk-reduction measures as he professed innocence for the murders and had no apparent need. The report highlighted past risk factors including his "criminal lifestyle, involvement with drugs and association with the wrong people". Despite this, they noted Steele's "marked improvement" in behaviour behind bars, convincing them he doesn't pose immediate risks after release. Parole Board documents uncovered by the Mirror lays bare Steele's life behind bars, in which he is said to have been an "exemplary" inmate, except for on one occasion when he was caught with a kettle. A 2021 report stated: "He has only ever had two proven adjudications on this sentence, the most recent one being in January 2021 for having an unauthorised item in his possession, a kettle for which he was given a caution. Despite his impeccable behaviour, the prison authorities have refused to downgrade his status and he has spent his entire sentence in maximum security conditions. Strict release conditions for Steele entail living at an approved address, abiding by good behaviour, revealing financial dealings, surrendering his passport, and complying with electronic tagging and a curfew. He's also barred from high-tech gadgetry, speaking to media, and owning any boat, plane or firearm. Meanwhile, Whomes, aged 59, was greenlit for release in 2021.
