logo
‘I was naive in being hopeful': Labour voters feel let down after first year

‘I was naive in being hopeful': Labour voters feel let down after first year

The Guardiana day ago
Labour supporters have told the Guardian of their dissatisfaction with the party's first year in government, as Keir Starmer marks 12 months since becoming the first Labour prime minister since Gordon Brown.
Members and voters said initial optimism had given away to unhappiness about the government's record, although many were keen to state the positives they felt had been forgotten under the weight of recent events.
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/1.Jan_from_manc_summary_of_disappointment.mp3
Jan, a former Labour member from Manchester said she was 'disillusioned, disappointed and despairing' with Starmer's tenure so far.
She recalled the strategy often attributed to the Labour leader in the run-up to the election last year, and said: 'I kept telling myself that really, Keir Starmer was a man with a Ming vase on a polished floor, and that somehow after they were in power that things would really start to change and we would have an alternative to the Tory government that left the complete mess we're in at the moment.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/4.Jan_from_manc_feeling_let_down_and_betrayed.mp3
She said she had resigned her membership over the last year as a result of her unhappiness with the party's policies on the war in Gaza, and wider changes to welfare.
She said: 'I'm more sad than I am angry, and that's [a] very difficult place to be, to feel so let down, betrayed and disappointed.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/7.Desanka_housing_and_background.mp3
In south London, Desanka, a social housing tenant and worker, said Labour's housing policy would not sufficiently cut local authority housing waiting lists. 'What we need is genuinely affordable housing. Without housing, without good safe housing, you can't have healthy people, and you can't get an education,' she said.
'I think until they address that, if they were to do that, and to have a genuine response to allow councils to build more, and put money in it, and bring back affordable housing grants that used to be. I know times are hard, but you have to make choices.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/8.Desanka_some_positives_and_why_not_voting_labour.mp3
While she was keen to credit the government for attempting to rebalance the country, she said she wouldn't back the party again at the ballot box. She cited disagreement with the party's policy on asylum seekers on small boats not being able to apply for citizenship.
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/10.Kennedy_some_of_the_positives_and_govt_is_listening.mp3
Kennedy was another who believed Labour was not getting recognition for the positives so far. Giving the party a B grade for its first year, he said he was a supporter of the family farms tax policy and introducing VAT on private school fees.
He said Starmer and his cabinet had stabilised the country, but disputed how stereotypically Labour the government's policies had been.
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/11.Kennedy_how_he_would_rate_labour.mp3
'They need to be hitting the rich more than hitting the poor,' Kennedy said. 'So again, the welfare bill, again, that was another political suicide. Where do they think they're going? And why are they hitting the most vulnerable sectors in society? They need to be hitting the super-wealthy, the super-rich, big business, big corporations, people who really can't defend themselves.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/12.Laura.mp3
Laura, a lifelong member, said she was 'overwhelmingly disappointed' with the party's performance. She said she was unhappy with policies she thought had targeted the poorest in society.
She said: 'I remember driving to work and feeling a sense of optimism and hope for the future for the first time in a very long time. That hope and optimism has now vanished and I feel despair, disappointment and quite often guilt and regret at having voted for this government.'
The NHS worker continued: 'I've lost trust in these politicians in whom I initially had so much hope.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/13.Hazel_Lamb_beginning_on_Labour_dealing_with_the_situation.mp3
Sympathy was the overarching feeling for Hazel Lamb, who said the government was dealing with a 'much worse situation than they anticipated'.
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/14.Hazel_Lamb_loving_govt_honesty.mp3
'What I love is the fact that the government is honest,' Lamb said. 'I think that people have integrity and are trying their best. I don't have a sense that there's self-interest going on here, I have a sense that people are actually trying to do something about all the difficult situations that we've got.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/16.Lily_Raper_disappointed_about_palestine_and_trans_rights.mp3
Lily Raper, who has spent most of her life under Conservative-led governments, said her excitement was replaced with dismay at Labour's foreign policy, and its policies on trans rights.
She said: 'I hoped for a solid stance from the Labour government in halting the arms sales to Israel, in preventing the genocide occurring in Palestine. Obviously we've not seen that, and I've seen Labour effectively throwing trans women under the bus. Disappointment is too light a word.'
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/17.Barney_Duff_talks_positives_but_disappointed.mp3
Barney Duff said the initial successes of Labour's first 100 days had been forgotten. He referred to the creation of Great British Railways, and changes to renters' rights that are still going through parliament, but said things had since gone awry.
Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $https://uploads.guim.co.uk/2025/07/04/18.Barney_Duff_summary_of_feeling_negative.mp3
'It's just been a bit of a train wreck,' Duff said.
He added: 'I thought they were going to pivot when they got in charge. I was hopeful that they'd return to their manifesto that won the leadership, but I was quite naive in being hopeful.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

King Charles sends unity message on 7/7 attacks anniversary
King Charles sends unity message on 7/7 attacks anniversary

Leader Live

time26 minutes ago

  • Leader Live

King Charles sends unity message on 7/7 attacks anniversary

The head of state said comfort can be taken from the 'spirit of unity' across the UK, which has allowed the nation to heal. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer also said that 'those who tried to divide us failed," adding: 'We stood together then, and we stand together now'. The King has called on the country to continue its spirit of unity (Image: PA/Aaron Chown) The King said: 'Today, as we mark 20 years since the tragic events of 7th July 2005, my heartfelt thoughts and special prayers remain with all those whose lives were forever changed on that terrible summer's day. 'We remember with profound sadness the 52 innocent people who were killed in senseless acts of evil – and the enduring grief of their loved ones. 'We recall, too, the hundreds more who carry physical and psychological scars, and pray that their suffering may ease as the years pass. 'In doing so, we should also remember the countless stories of extraordinary courage and compassion that emerged from the darkness of that day. 'The selfless bravery of our emergency services, transport workers, and fellow citizens who rushed towards danger to help strangers reminds us of the very best of humanity in the face of the very worst.' Other members of the Royal Family are taking part in memorials today, including The Duke and Duchess of Edinburgh, who will appear at the National Service of Commemoration at St Paul's Cathedral from 11.30am on Monday. Sir Keir Starmer said that 'those who tried to divide us failed' (Image: PA) The King also stressed the importance of communities coming together in times of adversity. He said: 'While the horrors will never be forgotten, we may take comfort from the way such events rally communities together in solidarity, solace and determination. 'It is this spirit of unity that has helped London, and our nation, to heal. 'As we remember those we lost, let us therefore use this 20th anniversary to reaffirm our commitment to building a society where people of all faiths and backgrounds can live together with mutual respect and understanding, always standing firm against those who would seek to divide us.' The Duke and Duchess of Edinburgh are to attend a memorial today (Image: PA) The 7/7 attacks were a series of attacks across London's transport network on July 7, 2005. The attacks saw bombs detonated on three underground trains and a double-decker bus. This caused severe casualties during rush hour, seeing 52 people killed and more than 700 injured. These were carried out by Islamist terrorists using improvised explosive devices made from concentrated hydrogen peroxide and pepper, packed into backpacks.

Post Office victims ‘to wait three more years for payouts'
Post Office victims ‘to wait three more years for payouts'

Telegraph

time31 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Post Office victims ‘to wait three more years for payouts'

Victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal could wait another three years for compensation, lawyers have warned. Many victims of the scandal are still awaiting full redress, as one of the final reports from the long-running inquiry – looking at the impact on those who had their lives destroyed and compensation – is set to be published on Tuesday. More than 900 sub-postmasters were wrongfully prosecuted by the Post Office between 1999 and 2015 after faulty Horizon software made it look as though money was missing from the business accounts. The previous Conservative government said those who had their convictions quashed were eligible for £600,000 payouts – with victims such as Amanda and Norman Barber accepting the fixed offer. Despite losing their business and home, the couple, from Warrington, said they found it 'almost impossible' to provide the details required to have their case individually assessed so did not want to risk 'getting less'. Unexplained shortfalls in their accounts at Thelwall Post Office eventually led to them being prosecuted over a deficit of £5,600 – despite using around £200,000 of their own money to attempt to balance the books. Both received a community order of 12 months and 100 hours' community service. Missing evidence Speaking about the redress process, Mrs Barber, 55, said: 'We were being asked to produce evidence we simply couldn't get our hands on with regards to our losses as we are talking going back 15 years. 'We found it almost impossible to provide the details needed to go down the route of having our case individually assessed. 'It just didn't seem worth it. I think sub-postmasters are still being left in an impossible situation when it comes to seeking true and full redress. 'Given the time it would take we simply couldn't risk a full assessment and getting less, particularly because the lack of documents we had. 'It got to the stage where, when the £600,000 was offered, it seemed the best way to bring years of torture to an end.' Redress has been a key issue for sub-postmasters since the scandal came to light, with many finding the various compensation schemes difficult to navigate. Lead campaigner Sir Alan Bates previously described the various processes as 'quasi-kangaroo courts', telling The Sunday Times that the Department for Business and Trade 'sits in judgment of the claims and alters the goal posts as and when it chooses'. The chairman of the Horizon IT inquiry, Sir Wyn Williams, is due to publish his findings on redress on Tuesday. Mrs Barber, who will join other sub-postmasters in attending the report's publication event, said: 'We feel we just need to be there to hear what is said. 'Lives were ruined and compensation has been made too hard to get, and too little by far.' One law firm involved in securing redress for victims, Hudgell Solicitors, said it still had more than 700 compensation cases to resolve. Solicitor Neil Hudgell said the firm had agreed damages for more than 300 people, totalling £170 million, but said the redress process had 'far too much red tape to get through'. He said: 'We have seen inconsistencies between the various compensation schemes, which remain over-engineered and over-legalistic, with far too much red tape to get through. 'There has also been a repeated failure to give the benefit of the doubt to sub-postmasters in appropriate circumstances. 'It's made it far too long a process for so many people who have been through so much, and are now in the latter stages of their lives. 'It has been re-traumatising for many, and increasing numbers are sadly passing away without seeing redress.' Addressing how long it could take for all claims to be settled, the solicitor added: 'At the current speed, we are looking at another two to three years.' Mr Hudgell said one client who was initially offered £50,000 has seen their offer rise to £500,000. He added: 'It is not a one-off glitch, but a stark illustration of a very common issue. 'It has been a painful process for all, and ended with a new appeals process being confirmed earlier this year, in recognition that many people had been under-compensated.' In a statement, the Department for Business and Trade said: 'We are grateful for the Inquiry's work, which has revealed the immeasurable suffering that victims of the scandal have endured. 'This Government has quadrupled the total amount paid to affected postmasters to provide them with full and fair redress, with more than £1 billion having now been paid to over 7,300 claimants.'

Trump calls for Gaza hostages release ahead of Netanyahu meeting at the White House – Middle East crisis live
Trump calls for Gaza hostages release ahead of Netanyahu meeting at the White House – Middle East crisis live

The Guardian

time32 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

Trump calls for Gaza hostages release ahead of Netanyahu meeting at the White House – Middle East crisis live

Update: Date: 2025-07-07T06:45:58.000Z Title: Content: A Russian Foreign Ministry statement said its minister Sergei Lavrov had issued a new denunciation of Israeli and US strikes on Iran last month, 'including the bombing of nuclear energy infrastructure under safeguards of the International Atomic Energy Agency.' It came during Lavrov's talks in Rio de Janeiro with Abbas Araqchi, his Iranian counterpart, who he met at the BRICS summit. The Foreign Minister restated Moscow's offer to help resolve disputes around Tehran's nuclear programme, the Russian Foreign Ministry said. Update: Date: 2025-07-07T06:45:58.000Z Title: Content: In a joint statement from the opening of the BRICS summit in Rio de Janeiro, the leaders of the BRICS group of developing nations called attacks against Iran's 'civilian infrastructure and peaceful nuclear facilities' a 'violation of international law.' The group expressed 'grave concern' for the Palestinian people over Israeli attacks on Gaza, and condemned what the joint statement called a 'terrorist attack' in India-administered Kashmir. The group voiced its support for Ethiopia and Iran to join the World Trade Organization, while calling to urgently restore its ability to resolve trade disputes. Update: Date: 2025-07-07T06:45:58.000Z Title: Read our full analysis here: Content: Benjamin Netanyahu returns to the White House holding all the cards in the Gaza talks in Washington. Joint attack on Iran have put the Israeli PM in a powerful position as he dangles the prospect of a Trump-brokered ceasefire deal. Netanyahu and Donald Trump have a complex personal relationship – and Trump openly vented frustration at him last month during efforts to negotiate a truce with Iran – but the two have appeared in lockstep since the US launched a bombing run against Iran's nuclear programme, fulfilling a key goal for Israeli war planners. Netanyahu arrives in Washington in a strong political position, observers have said, potentially giving him the diplomatic cover he would need to end the war in Gaza without facing a revolt from his rightwing supporters that could lead to the collapse of his government. Update: Date: 2025-07-07T06:45:58.000Z Title: Welcome and summary Content: Hello and welcome to the Guardian's continuing coverage of the crisis in the Middle East. Donald Trump has said there is a good chance a Gaza hostage release and ceasefire deal could be reached with the Hamas this week, as he prepares to meet with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday at the White House. Trump told reporters before departing for Washington on Sunday that such a deal meant 'quite a few hostages' could be released. Here is what has happened so far: Donald Trump will host Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington DC on Monday as the US president seeks again to broker a peace deal in Gaza and the Israeli prime minister takes a victory lap through the Oval Office after a joint military campaign against Iran and a series of successful strikes against Tehran and its proxies in the Middle East. The first session of indirect Hamas-Israel ceasefire talks in Qatar ended inconclusively, two Palestinian sources familiar with the matter said early on Monday, adding that the Israeli delegation didn't have a sufficient mandate to reach an agreement with Hamas. The talks resumed on Sunday, ahead of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's third visit to the White House. Israeli warplanes launched a wave of strikes in Gaza on Sunday, killing at least 38 Palestinians, according to hospital officials, as talks over a ceasefire in the devastated territory reached a critical point. Officials at Nasser hospital in the southern city of Khan Younis said 18 people were killed by strikes in al-Mawasi, a nearby coastal area that is crowded with tented encampments of those displaced by fighting elsewhere. Israel has continued to launch waves of airstrikes in Gaza, hours after Hamas said it was ready to start talks 'immediately' on a US-sponsored proposal for a 60-day ceasefire. The announcement by the militant Islamist organisation increased hopes that a deal may be done within days to pause the killing in Gaza and possibly end the near 21-month conflict. Israel has attacked Houthi targets in three Yemeni ports and a power plant, the Israeli military said early on Monday, marking the first Israeli attack on Yemen in almost a month. The strikes on Hodeidah, Ras Isa and Salif ports, and Ras Qantib power plant were due to repeated Houthi attacks on Israel, the military added.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store