70 recommendations made in Medicine Hat inspection
The city asked for the inspection in September 2024 after months of disagreements between the mayor, council and chief administrator. It was then ordered by the minister of Alberta Municipal Affairs.
The final 207-page report was presented during a council meeting on Monday.
'The bottom line seems to be that the decision was that they contravene the Municipal Governance Act, and as a result, they have to have some consequences for that,' said Jim Groom, a political scientist based in Medicine Hat.
Along with 70 recommendations, the report also included three directives from the minister of municipal affairs that must be followed.
These include council and the Chief Administrative Officer (CAO) reviewing the recommendations and reporting to the minister, as well as making the report publicly available.
Council, the CAO and other designated officers must also complete respectful workplace training.
'There's less than 100 days left in this council, and I would not expect this to make any drastic changes in any way, shape or form, and it was evident by the council meeting last night that there's still a lot of animosity, still a lot of personality clashes,' said Groom.
The report says council has been operating in a somewhat hostile environment since early on in its terms.
That was highlighted by an exchange between Mayor Linnsie Clark and the city manager Ann Mitchell that led to council moving to sanction the mayor and cut her pay in half.
A Calgary judge later reversed that decision.
Council and others in city hall are working to repair those relationships.
'There's still some ambiguity about how do we get to the to the right area of correcting this? Whose fault it is isn't the right thing, but what was the precipice? How do we get past that? What's the crux?' said Medicine Hat city councillor Shila Sharps.
The report says the residents of Medicine Hat did not lose out on programs or services because of council infighting, but it also called governance function of the city ineffective and noted that distrust made it difficult to make effective decisions.
A new council will be elected this fall, and the hope is to start the new term on the right foot.
'We are making sure that we have a very robust orientation for the new council coming in in October,' said Mitchell. 'I've been a city manager for 20 years, so I've gone through a few orientations and so has our clerk, so knowing best practices is really important.'
CTV news reached out to Clark and will update this article if and when a response is received.
The full report can be read on the City of Medicine Hat's website.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
15 minutes ago
- CBC
B.C. court rejects First Nation's challenge to increase in Mount Polley tailings dam level
Social Sharing The B.C. Supreme Court has dismissed a First Nation's bid to stop the level of a tailings dam from being increased at the Mount Polley mine site, which suffered a catastrophic dam collapse that spilled millions of litres of waste and water 11 years ago. The Xatsull First Nation claimed the province's approval of the plan to raise the level of the dam in B.C.'s Interior by four metres was improper and done without "meaningful" consultation with the nation. But Justice Michael Tammen ruled Wednesday that the provincial government's consultation with the Xatsull was proper. "I view the consultation here as deep and, importantly, the process employed by the province provided Xatsull with ample opportunity to present their perspective," Tammen said. The First Nation said in a statement it was disappointed in the ruling. "This is the same facility that breached and devastated Xatsull's territory in 2014 — the worst mining disaster on record. Its impacts are still harming our Nation's rights, culture and way of life today," it said. "We will be reviewing the decision as well as exploring our options to determine next steps." Mount Polley is an open-pit copper and gold mine located in British Columbia's Cariboo region, 56 kilometres northeast of Williams Lake. The mining company says the size of the tailings pond needs to be increased to ensure Mount Polley can continue to operate. "As ore is processed, the resulting ground rock (tailings) is stored in the TSF (tailings storage facility.) To safely accommodate ongoing tailings deposition, the height of the TSF must be gradually increased over time." Tammen said Mount Polley Mining Corp.'s plan to raise the tailings storage level was "comparatively modest," and the rationale for provincial approval "readily apparent." The court had been expected to rule on an application for an injunction on Tuesday, with a decision on the nation's judicial review to follow, but Tammen dismissed the Xatsull's legal challenge outright and found no basis to grant an injunction to stop the plan moving ahead. Tammen said raising the dam as proposed "does not increase the scope of operations at the mine, nor does it increase the ecological footprint of ongoing mining operations." He said the tailings dam failed "catastrophically" in 2014, which "has in turn caused widespread and long-lasting environmental damage and corresponding impacts to Xatsull's Aboriginal title, rights, culture, and way of life." "Xatsull is obviously and understandably extremely concerned with the potential for a further failure and thus has a corresponding interest in ensuring that the mine is being operated in an environmentally responsible and safe manner," he said. He said he didn't want to dismiss, diminish or minimize the "deleterious" effects of the tailings dam failure, which is still the subject of civil litigation and Fisheries Act charges against the company. Chief Rhonda Phillips said earlier this year that the province was allowing the work to proceed without a valid environmental assessment certificate at the site of the spill that sent millions of tonnes of water and tailings into the environment on the nation's territory. Phillips had said "meaningful" reform is needed in the aftermath of the 2014 spill because the provincial government is still approving "risky storage methods" while failing to adequately consult the nation.
CTV News
44 minutes ago
- CTV News
Ontario, Saskatchewan at odds over Canada's response to Trump tariffs
Ontario Premier Doug Ford warns Donald Trump could end CUSMA 'tomorrow, with one signature,' and that all Canadian leaders are on the same page. Ontario and Saskatchewan remained at odds over Canada's response to U.S. President Donald Trump's escalating trade war Wednesday as the premiers prepared to meet with the prime minister to talk trade. Prime Minister Mark Carney was holding virtual meetings in private with his cabinet and the premiers Wednesday afternoon, less than a week after Trump ramped up his trade assault on Canada with a baseline 35 per cent tariff. The new tariff applies only to goods not covered by the Canada-United States-Mexico agreement on free trade, better known as CUSMA. The latest levy took effect on Friday after the two countries failed to hit an Aug. 1 deadline to secure a new trade agreement. Before meeting with Carney, Ontario Premier Doug Ford said he was frustrated by the impacts of high U.S. tariffs on his province's economy and called again for retaliatory tariffs. 'You can't have tariffs on one side and not the other. I still stand by what I say — dollar for dollar, tariff for tariff,' Ford told reporters at a news conference Wednesday in Thornhill, Ont. 'They understand strength, not weakness, and we should never, ever roll over and be weak.' Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe, meanwhile, said Wednesday Canada should dial down its retaliatory tariffs. 'Maybe it's time for Canada even to at least not add additional counter-tariffs in this space, but to even consider removing some of the counter-tariffs that are harmful to Canadian businesses and Saskatchewan businesses today,' Moe said during a radio interview, adding that Canada is largely 'protected' by the CUSMA trade pact. Moe said his province is working to protect industries that are being hit hard by tariffs, including the steel sector. 'What we've done is pull forward a significant amount — 10 years, actually — of Crown procurement to support the steel industries here in Saskatchewan,' he said. Moe gave credit to Carney for his government's efforts to strengthen trade ties with other countries, including Mexico, particularly while Canada remains subject to China's canola oil and meal tariffs. When asked to explain why his government ended up putting American liquor back on the shelves and returning to its standard procurement processes, Moe said the government already prioritizes Saskatchewan companies. 'We need to get to that space in a more solid form with our largest trading partner, the United States of America, and someone is going to have to take the early steps,' he said, noting Alberta has also shifted its policies. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's office said she would not be issuing any statements ahead of the meeting. Ford said he wants to see more done to stimulate the economy. He called on Ottawa to cut taxes and said the Bank of Canada should drop its interest rate. 'We have to get the governor of the Bank of Canada to lower those damn interest rates from 2.75,' he said. 'Knock 'em down. Build confidence. 'Let's work together on getting rid of the HST on homebuyers, and not just first (time) ones. Let's stimulate the market and we'll follow suit if the federal government does that.' Ford said Wednesday he had a 'good conversation' with U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Tuesday that was 'positive,' and he believes the 'prime minister is doing everything in his power to get a fair trade deal with the U.S.' Carney told a press conference in B.C. on Tuesday that he has not talked to Trump in recent days, but will speak with him 'when it makes sense.' The prime minister added that about 85 per cent of trade with the U.S. remains tariff-free because of CUSMA. Sector-specific tariffs, like the 50 per cent duty on steel, aluminum and copper, remain in place. Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand and Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne were in Mexico City on Wednesday, part of a two-day mission to meet with Mexican officials and businesses on trade. With files from Lisa Johnson in Edmonton, Alta. and Allison Jones in Thornhill, Ont. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 6, 2025 David Baxter and Kyle Duggan, The Canadian Press
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Mexico seeks more trade with Canada in face of Trump tariffs
Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum, left, speaks before a meeting with Prime Minister Mark Carney at the G7 Summit in Kananaskis, Alta., on Tuesday, June 17, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck Mexico's president said Wednesday her country will seek to expand trade with Canada amid U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff offensive, which threatens a three-way free trade deal between the North American neighbors. Trump has imposed additional duties on both countries despite the existence of the USMCA treaty, which he has said he wants to renegotiate. He raised tariffs on isolated Canadian imports from 25 to 35 percent from August 1, but has agreed to delay a 30 percent general tariff on imported Mexican goods for 90 days until October. Both countries are affected by global U.S. tariffs on automotive, aluminum and steel exports. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum has been hosting senior Canadian officials to discuss strategy in the face of the tariff torrent. 'We have the treaty, obviously, but we also want Canadian companies to continue investing... to expand direct trade between Canada and Mexico,' Sheinbaum said Thursday after meeting Canada's Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne and Foreign Minister Anita Anand. Canada has said the Mexico talks would focus on economic growth, security and trade. The meetings also serve to prepare for a visit by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, for which no date has been announced. Trump has justified the tariffs by accusing the United States' neighbors of not doing enough to stem the flow of undocumented migrants and fentanyl across their borders.
