logo
Vancouver Canucks mailbag, part 1: Strategic paths to contender status tiers

Vancouver Canucks mailbag, part 1: Strategic paths to contender status tiers

New York Times8 hours ago
The meat of the NHL offseason is in the books.
That doesn't mean it's the dog days of summer yet, however. There are still some interesting unrestricted free agents who are just beginning to fall through the cracks and drop their respective prices. The Canucks have signed a value free agent midsummer in consecutive years — Pius Suter in 2023, Daniel Sprong in 2024 — and are scouring the market for such options again. We could see a move like that occur in the next three to five weeks.
Advertisement
Meanwhile, there is some industry expectation that, as the logic of the cap growth era really sets in, we may see more late summer trade activity than we're used to. That must be music to the ears of Canucks hockey operations leadership, especially given the unfinished feeling of this roster at the moment.
As we wait to see what comes next, we wanted to open up the offseason reaction mailbag. We got nearly 150 submissions over the weekend, and we'll pick through the most interesting of those questions to deliver you some answers to your pressing Canucks questions in our two part, post-July 1 edition of the VIP only mailbag.
Note: Submitted questions may be edited for clarity and style.
Can you provide a tiered list of the strategic paths management could take to turn the Canucks into a contender? — Patrick F.
Thanks for the question, Patrick, and kudos for framing it so irresistibly. As you well know, I can't resist a tiered list!
OK, here goes nothing …
The most likely to deliver the next great Canucks team tier
The rebuild over a multiyear time horizon plan
In my view, the Canucks' most likely path to bringing a Stanley Cup to Vancouver in the not-too-distant future is going to require a more dramatic reset than anything they seem to be prepared to even consider.
It's unfortunate because the Canucks mined some super elite top-end talent from their last, fitful, quasi-intentional rebuilding phase from 2014 through 2019, but poor cap allocation, organizational ineptitude, pandemic-related budgetary tightfistedness, poor contractual decisions and, ultimately, interpersonal conflicts in the dressing room have submarined the potential of the Elias Pettersson, Quinn Hughes era.
Now that's not to say that whatever remains of this era is hopeless. The team, as currently constructed, could congeal under Adam Foote, Pettersson could bounce back, Thatcher Demko could stay healthy and they could very plausibly make the playoffs this year and next. They could maybe even find a solid level as a playoff-calibre team, with a shot to go deep, provided they get a near-perfect run out and make a couple of savvy in-season swings.
Advertisement
If we're being ruthlessly honest about the true talent level of this team, however, and compare it to what we see out of Florida, Edmonton, Carolina, Vegas and Dallas, there's probably just too much distance to travel.
The Canucks are probably shy of what those top-five contender tier teams have by at least an additional elite player, and an additional top-line calibre player beyond that. And, of course, there are levels to this. Just entering that discussion doesn't put you on par with a Panthers team that seems to have eight bona fide top-line calibre forwards, is keeping the band back together and ran roughshod over four of the top-10 true talent teams on their way to a second consecutive Stanley Cup.
If the goal is to win a championship, the Canucks shouldn't be fearful of rebuilding, though I'll acknowledge that the timing to begin at the moment is completely suboptimal given the handful of recent extensions and the Hughes contract timeline.
Nonetheless, being willing to take a step back on paper and chase more volatile profiles to accumulate value, amassing draft picks, being disciplined about pouncing on sell windows when players 'pop' (as, for example, Brock Boeser did during his 40-goal performance in the 2023-24 campaign) and even trying to maximize your lottery odds with Gavin McKenna and Landon DuPont in mind, would all be worthwhile steps to take given how stubbornly the Canucks appear to be stuck in the mushy middle.
Obviously it's a painful step to have to take, and you'd face a tall task attempting to sell the vision to Hughes (much less Canucks ownership). I simply don't know how Vancouver gets to the top of the ladder without trying to use the natural gravity of the NHL system — even if the weight of that gravity is about to be restrained by the cap growth era — to slingshot back up the standings, in the fashion that the Montreal Canadiens have managed.
Advertisement
The maybe it could work, but it's on a knife's edge tier
The get Quinn Hughes extended and get lucky plan
This is the plan that the Canucks are more or less attempting to execute, and if they can execute it, it's a credible one, even if it's not as likely — in my opinion — to succeed.
It calls for the Canucks pushing at least some chips into the centre of the table to remain competitive in the short term. The goal is to win enough to remain an appealing destination for their captain so as to minimize the risk of his departure, either as an unrestricted free agent in 2027 or as a pre-agent willing to use his leverage in 2026.
Even if that plan is successful, however, and I wouldn't necessarily say the Canucks executed on it this summer given that they were unable to move their draft picks or trade their second tier prospects for win-now difference-makers that could upgrade the middle of their forward group, it's a difficult one to pull off because it's still going to require them to be supremely efficient in one volatile area or another.
As great as Hughes is, the Canucks will still require more talent beyond the most impactful two-way defender in the sport. So, whether it's by nailing a draft class in the transformative style of the Dallas Stars in 2019 (the Stars won the draft lottery and selected Miro Heiskanen at No. 3, then added Jake Oettinger and Jason Robertson in the same draft class). Or by seizing on multiple unique opportunities in which star-level players shake loose and you're able to hit on a run of hugely valuable trades in bulk (like the Panthers did in landing Eetu Luostarinen, Matthew Tkachuk, Sam Bennett, Sam Reinhart, Evan Rodrigues, Seth Jones and Brad Marchand), Vancouver will still need something extra to occur to more fundamentally change its trajectory in order to join the ranks of the NHL elite.
The one I fear we're seeing
The just get in and anything can happen plan
My concern when I look at this Canucks offseason so far is that they're attempting to build a team that can punch above its weight in the Stanley Cup playoffs.
Advertisement
Obviously, we know that the game changes in the postseason, but attempting to reverse-engineer a Cinderella playoff run is the path that the Canadiens were on under Marc Bergevin. And it's a path that regularly made the Canadiens a reasonably difficult out come playoff time and helped them reach the 2021 Stanley Cup Final, where they were overmatched and summarily dispatched in five games by the Tampa Bay Lightning.
The problem for the Bergevin era Habs, of course, was that they didn't have a championship ceiling. So while they were tough to eliminate once they made it to the playoffs, they only had a high enough level to even make it there about half the time.
When I think about what Evander Kane brings to the Canucks, and when he's at his most impactful (when the games are heaviest come playoff time), or when I consider why this team would be willing to invest $13 million in goal beyond this upcoming season, my greatest concern is that the organization is attempting to build a plucky playoff team, as opposed to constructing a team with a greater level of ambition in mind.
Doing so in an NHL era in which parity is virtually non-existent feels like a very unlikely path to a Stanley Cup victory.
Marco Rossi? It just makes so much sense. Wild don't want to pay him. Canucks have surplus on wings and need at C. What's a realistic trade offer, and are the Canucks still in on it? Is there a 'Ballard, Raymond and a second' type offer that isn't a joke? — Joel T.
Yeah, I can't shake the thought that this is a hypothetical deal that we'll be talking about long into the dog days of summer.
Whether or not it actually happens, however, is another matter entirely. Rossi wouldn't be the first restricted free agent to undergo contentious second-contract negotiations with their team, only to re-sign and ultimately remain in place until a much later date (Martin Necas and Cole Perfetti are a couple of similar situations that come to mind).
Clearly, the Wild have a bit of a problem on their hands with Rossi, and it's one of their own making. This isn't just a dollars-and-cents issue, either. Rossi was upset about his playoff usage and said as much.
Advertisement
The Canucks, of course, have an even more significant problem on their hands. The Wild's issue is repairing a relationship with a promising young player who felt underutilized and untrusted in the playoffs; Vancouver's issue is that it doesn't have a promising young centre who's a candidate to fill a hole on the second line who is nearly on Rossi's level.
Which brings us to the reason that we'll keep monitoring this one. The Wild have a problem, and the Canucks have a problem. The two organizations are very closely linked, not solely because Wild general manager Bill Guerin was Jim Rutherford's assistant general manager in Pittsburgh, but also because Canucks general manager Patrik Allvin and Guerin are very close personal friends with an exceptional working relationship. Guerin, in fact, attempted to hire Allvin when he departed the Penguins organization for Minnesota, and was rebuffed.
When it comes to creative cooperative problem solving, it's usually easiest to pull it off with someone you like, trust and respect. The Wild and the Canucks have that going for them at the hockey operations leadership level.
We'll see if that matters. At this point in the offseason, I'd expect a short-term agreement that keeps Rossi in Minnesota for the time being to be the most likely outcome here.
As for what a realistic trade package might look like, it's likely going to be difficult to pull off in the wake of Vancouver's offseason moves, less because the Canucks no longer have their 2025 first-rounder to sell and more because of the cap space they've already committed. In order to add Rossi and extend him long-term, Vancouver would have to shed a fair bit of salary either directly in the trade or prior to executing it. Even trading both Dakota Joshua and Teddy Blueger (which would give the Canucks about $5.5 million in total cap space with 20 men on the roster) probably wouldn't be enough to get it done cap-wise.
Maybe it gets you close enough if you front-load the bonus structure sufficiently and amped up the trade protections involved on a max-term second contract, but it would be a very tricky balance to strike.
Even so, if the Canucks are going to land Rossi, I still suspect that Vancouver would be looking at trade packages in which either Tom Willander or their 2026 first-round pick would have to be included. And I have a hard time seeing the Canucks be willing to do that.
Advertisement
What does a reasonable trade deal for Artūrs Šilovs look like? — Andy L.
The Daniil Tarasov deal that the Panthers completed with the Columbus Blue Jackets is probably the high water mark of what the Canucks can realistically expect in an offseason deal involving Artūrs Šilovs.
However, based on how both goaltenders appear to be viewed in the industry and that Tarasov is the more NHL-tested goaltender of the two, he probably carries modestly more value, even if Šilovs has the better AHL statistics and is coming off an incredible run as the MVP of the Calder Cup playoffs.
You're most likely talking about a late-round pick, with the value diminishing further the closer you get to Canadian Thanksgiving.
Of course, the Canucks don't necessarily have to trade Šilovs and shouldn't rush into doing so. They could also elect to place him on waivers early, as Vancouver did years ago with Jacob Markstrom, in an attempt to get him through while teams have a large number of players on their training camp roster and are less likely to put in a claim. Vancouver can also hold Šilovs and wait to see what shakes loose during training camp, in terms of goaltender injuries and the like. Remember, after all, Vancouver didn't bring in Kevin Lankinen until after training camp concluded last September, and he carried the team through the first half of the season!
Things change quickly in the crease, and there are currently no obvious goaltending jobs around the NHL. As such, Vancouver's best play is likely to wait and see what changes. Failing that, the club can always try to sneak him through waivers early on during camp, or find a team willing to pay modestly to jump the waiver queue (like the Panthers did for Olli Juolevi, in sending Noah Juulsen and Juho Lammikko to Vancouver; or as Vancouver did for Vitali Kravtsov). That's the dynamic that Vancouver is most likely locked into here.
(Photo of Thatcher Demko and Quinn Hughes: Mike Stobe / NHLI via Getty Images)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Skydive Into the Record Books on World Skydiving Day
Skydive Into the Record Books on World Skydiving Day

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Skydive Into the Record Books on World Skydiving Day

Leading global skydiving organizations encourage jumpers to be part of history on July 12 for 2nd annual #WorldSkydivingDay FREDERICKSBURG, Va., July 07, 2025--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Together, the U.S. Parachute Association (USPA), Australian Parachute Federation, British Skydiving and Canadian Sport Parachuting Association announce the second annual World Skydiving Day, taking place on Saturday, July 12, 2025. This global celebration invites first-time jumpers and experienced skydivers alike to celebrate the thrill of the sport while aiming to break the world record for the most skydives completed on this day worldwide. In 2024, skydivers around the globe set the inaugural record with 30,351 jumps across 51 countries in just one day. As skydivers around the world aim to break the record, some will also create group formations in the shape of the number two (2) in the sky, acknowledging this second annual event. "Last year, skydivers from around the world came together to make history, and this year, we're aiming even higher," said USPA Executive Director Albert Berchtold. "World Skydiving Day is becoming a global tradition that brings people together through a shared spirit of adventure. Whether it's your first jump or your thousandth, this is your chance to be part of something bigger than yourself – a worldwide celebration of the sport of skydiving." To be counted, anyone who skydives on July 12 must submit proof of their jump at Those who take part can also order a personalized certificate commemorating their role in this once-in-a-lifetime event. Those who are ready to be a part of skydiving history can click here to find a nearby skydiving center and book a jump for World Skydiving Day. Hundreds of drop zones will be participating across the country, with notable locations including: Boston Skydive Center – Smithfield, R.I. Chicagoland Skydiving Center – Rochelle, Ill. Music City Skydiving – Waverly, Tenn. Skydive Arizona – Eloy, Ariz. Skydive Atlanta – Thomaston, Ga. Skydive Chicago – Ottawa, Ill. Skydive Cincinnati, Waynesville, Ohio Skydive Coastal Carolinas – Oak Island, N.C. Skydive DeLand – DeLand, Fla. Skydive Midwest – Sturtevant, Wis. Skydive Paraclete XP – Raeford, N.C. Skydive Perris – Perris, Calif. Skydive Raleigh – Franklinton, N.C. Skydive Sebastian – Sebastian, Fla. Skydive Spaceland-Dallas – Whitewright, Texas Skydive STL – Sullivan, Mo. Skydive Twin Cities – Baldwin, Wis. To stay up to date with the latest news and announcements, visit View source version on Contacts Media Contact: Ali Westergren, ali@ Sign in to access your portfolio

After Cam York contract, are the Flyers done for the offseason?
After Cam York contract, are the Flyers done for the offseason?

New York Times

time2 hours ago

  • New York Times

After Cam York contract, are the Flyers done for the offseason?

After inking restricted free agent defenseman Cam York to a five-year, $25.75 million deal on Monday ($5.15 AAV), Philadelphia Flyers general manager Daniel Briere has nimbly taken care of what was the only obvious bit of pending business. As reported here previously, it was a drawn-out process with York. After his breakout 2023-24 season, there were talks toward the beginning of last season that broke down fairly quickly. When the club agreed to extensions with pending RFAs Tyson Foerster on May 29 and Noah Cates on June 11 — and York was left unsigned — it fueled speculation that York, who had an up-and-down 2024-25 for a few reasons, might be dangled as trade bait for a roster upgrade elsewhere. Advertisement Instead, the door still remains wide open for the 24-year-old to establish himself as key part of the future. There are no guarantees that will happen. The Flyers left themselves some flexibility here, as the deal doesn't include any trade protection (per a team source) despite them buying two seasons of what would have been unrestricted free agency for York. But there may not be a player on the Flyers' roster that is more looking forward to the coaching change to Rick Tocchet than York, who never really seemed to see eye-to-eye with John Tortorella and whose heated argument with the coach during a game in Toronto hastened Tortorella's firing two days later on March 27. As York said on getaway day after last season, once Brad Shaw took over on an interim basis, 'I able to play with a bit more freedom. Maybe not gripping the stick as tight. As a player, that's everything, in a way. It felt good to kind of get back to that, and have that mindset.' It stands to reason that a new five-year deal should help that mindset, too. If Briere is done for the summer, he's seemingly accomplished what he consistently said he set out to do — improve the team for the immediate future, while maintaining flexibility for the 2026 offseason. Yes, it's quite possible that the Flyers have already hit 'rock bottom' in their rebuild, as Briere said he was hopeful was the case in his comments immediately after Tortorella was let go. There are reasons for optimism they could start to turn a corner. The dreadful power play, 30th in the NHL last season and last for the previous two, will get some fresh eyes with Tocchet and assistant coach Yogi Svejkovsky. Tocchet, especially, has had success coaching power plays in the past. Unlike with Tortorella and former assistant coach Rocky Thompson, there should be more of a teaching element on the power play from the new staff. Advertisement The center depth is improved. No doubt that Christian Dvorak's one-year, $5.4 million deal is an overpay, but it was a necessary one considering how desperate the Flyers were for another pivot. To clarify: the Flyers didn't sign Dvorak with the idea of flipping him at the trade deadline. While that can always happen if the team ends up being terrible, Briere has made it clear in some of his comments that he owes it to the players who have been on the team for a few years now (think Travis Sanheim, Travis Konecny) to try and make a run at the playoffs. Both the Flyers and Dvorak agreed to this deal under the assumption that he will be around for the duration (and Dvorak, according to a source close to the player, is looking forward to playing for Tocchet again, too). There is more elite skill. That's in the form of Trevor Zegras, of course, whose YouTube highlight reel is as dazzling as anyone's in the league. Briere was universally praised for the deal, as he didn't have to surrender that much to acquire Zegras, who may simply need a change in scenery to resume a career that looked to be on the cusp of stardom. Even a return to Zegras' previous career high of 65 points would be a home run, especially if it comes with him skating in the middle of one of the top two lines, as is his and the team's preference. The league-worst goaltending has nowhere to go but up. Dan Vladar probably isn't going to be in the running for the Vezina Trophy anytime soon, with a career save percentage of .895, but he's an experienced goalie and, at age, 27, that he could still conceivably get better. If Vladar puts up just league-average numbers, allowing Sam Ersson to regain his form as a solid tandem guy before Carter Hart's departure midway through the 2023-24 season, that alone would be worth a double-digit improvement in points in the standings. Young players are arriving. A fifth-round pick in 2022, Alex Bump has emerged as a winger who, at this point, should probably considered likely to make the opening-night lineup. He may even be joined by this year's No. 6 overall draft pick Porter Martone and/or 2024 first-round pick Jett Luchanko, both of whom will come to camp in September with an eye on making the roster. And the Flyers expect their other young players already here to get better, too. Matvei Michkov, in particular, could be ready to break out after an outstanding rookie season. There remains the possibility for another notable move, particularly after Briere said he might be willing to go the offer-sheet route. That could be a way to upgrade the center position. Or, perhaps there could be trade talks involving Sabres defenseman Bowen Byram, who is still without a deal in Buffalo. Advertisement But that feels increasingly unlikely. The Flyers are now up against the salary cap for next season (they may even have to make a more or two before the season begins to get cap compliant), yet still have plenty of cap space to play with in less than a year, as they finally reach the end of a three-year process of carrying dead money in the name of resetting the team culture and acquiring future assets. Briere has been patient and methodical in his approach in getting here. There's not much reason to believe that's going to change between now and the start of camp in a little more than two months.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store