GAA chief admits lesson learned from scoreboard error with change implemented for All-Ireland hurling final
Stoppage time between Tipperary and Kilkenny was effected by
Advertisement
4
On 70 minutes a wide by Noel McGrath was incorrectly marked down as a point by the scoreboard operators
4
Eoin Cody clearly eschewed an easy point thinking that he had to go for goal
4
A goal-line block by Robert Doyle was critical in securing Tipp's two-point win
4
Smyth, far left, was speaking at the launch of GAA Refwell, a new wellness and support programme for Gaelic games referees
Despite referee James Owens correctly maintaining the correct scoreline in his handbook, it was plain to see that Kilkenny and Tipperary players were working off the scoreboard at GAA headquarters.
It marred the ending of a brilliant game and
If John Donnelly's last-gasp shot had found the net and the full-time whistle had then been blown, it would've slowly dawned on everyone that the Cats had in fact won by a point rather than only levelling things and sending the contest to extra-time.
Speaking to
Advertisement
Read More On GAA
He reflected: "It was a mixture of stuff. The time of the game probably didn't help.
"So at 69 minutes we had a Kilkenny sub, at 70 minutes the ball went wide, we had a Tipperary sub at the same time.
"We didn't notice the scoreboard had changed in relation to that (Noel McGrath's wide which was recorded as a point).
"Then the difficulty is we didn't get a break in play to stop the game to check the thing. We've changed our processes last week and our protocols around that, so it's something we just have to work on."
Advertisement
Most read in GAA Hurling
The confusion appeared to arise from one of the two umpires reaching up to catch the sliotar as it drifted wide whilst his peer signalled it was a wide ball.
When quizzed on how such a misunderstanding can be avoided, Smyth emphasized that stricter procedures shall prevent such potentially game-changing errors from cropping up again.
'Easiest interview I've ever had' jokes RTE GAA host after pundits go back and forth before Meath vs Donegal
He added: "You prevent it by tightening up your procedures.
"And, as I say, we're on the sideline there, how we communicate to the scoreboard and then what we do afterwards, how do we communicate out?
Advertisement
"So there's lots of things when we looked at it afterwards that we just have to tighten up.
"Look, we're talking about refereeing here but we could be talking about anything, we could be talking about players - if we get the basics right, the other things will follow.
"When you're playing in goals, for example, you have to catch the ball, you have to kick the ball, you have to hold the ball.
Advertisement
"With refereeing, you make decisions, you apply the rules, you have to re-emphasise the basics. Look, there were mistakes made on that day so we just have to ensure that our protocols are working."
Liam Gordon
Meanwhile Premier boss Liam Cahill has
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
35 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Jim McGuinness' mum hails Donegal boss' ‘drive to do better' in rare TV interview ahead of All-Ireland final vs Kerry
JIM McGUINNESS' mum gave a rare interview to RTE to speak of her pride in her son on the eve of the All-Ireland football final. The 52-year-old will look to lead the Tir Chonaill to Sam Maguire once again 2 Jim McGuinness, right, will look to lead Donegal to victory in the All-Ireland final against Kerry Credit: Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile 2 His mum was interviewed by RTE He was at the helm when they last won it in 2012 and can toast his second tenure in style by doing it again at the expense of the Kingdom. With anticipation reaching a fever pitch in his hometown of Glenties, film a segment for Friday's Six One News . This included going to Jim's Cafe which is run by the McGuinness family , including his mum Maureen. And speaking to RTE, she said: "He had a great passion always for the Gaelic and then he went to soccer for a while as well. Read More on GAA "I would say he always say he had a bit of drive in him always and to do better always." Jim McGuinness made his sensational return to the football championship for his efforts. However, it Paddy McBrearty admitted: 'We didn't know what to expect. We knew Jim would either welcome us or there would be another response. Most read in GAA Football 'When you door-step someone . . . if it was me, I probably would have told him to clear it. 'We hadn't seen each other in a long time but we had a good chat about where Donegal football was. Daniel O'Donnell and Daithi O Se have hilarious argument 'But he never said no, which kept the thing alive. If he said no, that would have been fine. 'There wasn't just one conversation. There were a few conversations and it kept the pressure on. 'Thankfully he came back because god knows where it would be if he didn't.' That 2014 All-Ireland final defeat to Kerry remains a They had just produced a blistering surprise win over reigning champions That seismic result was Jim Gavin's sole Championship defeat in charge of the Sky Blues as the greatest team the game has seen went on to win the next six on the bounce. But that year's title was not won by McGuinness' Donegal either — they were all set to finish the job against McGuinness went to the banquet that night at the CityWest Hotel with no idea what happened and would quit as boss. He said: 'I would say until I got back involved, there wasn't a day I didn't think about it. 'I can remember walking about the hotel after we lost, in a daze. 'I didn't know what happened, didn't know where I was, didn't know what actually had gone wrong there, and taking a step back from that and trying to work that out . . . it's very, very painful. "You're in a banquet and there's 1,200 people and you don't want to see anybody. That's not a nice place to be. 'All of that factors into it but I think when you get back on the horse, then you're not thinking about the past, you're thinking about what you need to do. 'You're thinking about moving forward and we have moved forward and we've created this opportunity. 'If everything works well and everything goes to plan, the only thing that it guarantees you is to be competitive. That's the only thing that it guarantees you. 'But if we're competitive in this All-Ireland, I'll be happy. I'll be really, really happy. That's all we're looking for, is to go in, show our true colours and be competitive. The focus has to be there.'
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Joe Brolly makes bold ‘spectacle' comparison between gaelic football and hurling ‘you wouldn't have imagined saying'
JOE BROLLY believes gaelic football is now a "better spectacle" than hurling with the new rules presenting "endless possibilities". And he reckons the new landscape has set the stage for football final. 2 Joe Brolly believes gaelic football has become a better spectacle than hurling Credit: Harry Murphy/Sportsfile 2 He revealed how the new rules will affect Donegal's plan for David Clifford Credit: Seb Daly/Sportsfile The 2025 football season has seen the debut of a set of new rules devised by Review Committee. The changes - including a new 40m scoring arc outside of which two-points can be recorded - has seen a more entertaining product on the pitch. And former Speaking on the Free State podcast, he argued: "It's a thing you wouldn't have imagined saying nine months ago. Read More on GAA "It's (football) now a better spectacle than hurling. 'Gaelic football now, the whole emphasis is on speed, skill. All the traditional skills are coming back. "The high catch, which had disappeared under the (Jim) McGuinness formula, and so you can go along and revel in the game." The culmination of the new-look season will come on Sunday when Most read in GAA Football The Kingdom will be out to lift Sam Maguire for the first time since 2022, while the Tir Chonaill will be trying to win it for the first time since 2012. Central to Kerry's chances will be the mercurial David Clifford, and Brolly reckons the new rules will grant the Fossa man freedom. Daniel O'Donnell and Daithi O Se have hilarious argument He added: "The endless possibilities that the new rules present, I think it's going to be a brilliant, brilliant occasion. "Before, Jimmy (McGuinness) changed all of the rules and really came up with the antidote to 'This is how we can offset the traditional game. "This is how we can nullify it. You can't do that now because the new game is all about scoring rate. "Total application to attack and very clean defending.' 'This is the first All-Ireland final where David Clifford will be free to play where he is not going to be in the middle of a spider's web of defence - where there are 14 men back. "Where he's being double or triple marked. 'That's one of the fascinations. How will Donegal cope with him? "I suspect they will put a flying machine like Ciaran Moore on him who is tall and simply limit him, because that's all you can do with David.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
All-Ireland final: Rivalry reignited between the greens and golds of Donegal and Kerry
Stories of grown men swapping land, farm animals and even holidays abroad for the golden passes to the All-Ireland final were rife in coffee shops and bars from Ballybunion to Ballybofey. It's eleven years since Donegal appeared in a senior football final and the county last won in 2012. But Kerry will be very slow to relinquish any designs on Sam Maguire, having last lifted the trophy in 2022 and remain all-time record-holders. The two sides met in 2014 and there's massive demand for tickets from the north to the south of the country. READ MORE [ Donegal v Kerry: Throw-in time, TV details and team news about All-Ireland football final Opens in new window ] A ticket allocation of a little more than 13,000 was never going to come even close to satisfying the demand of GAA-mad county Donegal. A decade plus another year without a triumphant homecoming to The Diamond in Donegal Town has been too long for most to take. Cue the return of manager Jim McGuinness last year and the ramping up of expectations of every man, woman and child who has ever hung a Donegal flag from their sitting room window or uttered the name of Michael Murphy . The best of times: Murphy and Jim McGuinness celebrating after winning the All-Ireland in 2012. Photograph: Dara Mac Donaill/The Irish Times After falling at the penultimate hurdle against Galway last year, expectations of the messiah and his men are even higher. In their first capture of Sam Maguire back in 1992, flocks of painted sheep were a novelty matched only by the respraying of cars in gold and green in the build-up to the county's shock defeat of a fancied Dublin side. This time around it's the abundance of colour which has captured the imagination with every corner, lamppost and gable wall in most towns and villages getting a touch. Street vendors at makeshift stalls dealing in hats, flags and headbands have popped up in most larger towns across the county this week. Not surprisingly, Glenties, the hometown of manager Jim McGuinness, claims the award for best decorated with life-size cardboard cut-outs of the team battling for space with giant good luck placards along the town's main street. Meanwhile, in Killarney locals were dressing in green and gold all weekend, including those at the MACademy performing arts school where groups of four to 16 year olds each picked their heroes and stressed that 'Kerry is on fire'. Colour had been slow to go up in the tourist town, but by Friday it more than matched Tralee. Traditionally, it is Killarney volunteers who put up the street bunting, but health and safety rules from working at heights, the chamber of commerce and tourism said in a statement. Health and safety rules prevented volunteers from putting up bunting File photograph: Bryan O Brien / The Irish Times But Killarney Vintners combined with the local chamber of commerce and hired contractors to bedeck the town with bunting. Tralee meanwhile, from the Austin Stacks to the Kerins O'Rahillys is decked in the green and gold. Just like 2014, both teams in this year's All-Ireland have the same colours. A 'raid' by supporters saw the Donegal flags planted at the iconic GAA sites Dr Croke's in Killarney. Monday's lark included an overnight drive from Donegal as far as the Kerry county GAA centre of excellence in Currans where further flags were placed. 'The Kingdom's Green and Gold' by Garry McMahon has been belting out from Flathery's Pub in Dingle, all week and along all three peninsulas. Son of 'The Master' the writer Bryan McMahon, the late Garry, was a keen hurler and footballer in his youth, and is widely felt to have penned the greatest of Kerry anthems. Still everyone will be hoping it's a 'victory' this weekend, and not 'a salute to the gallant foe to pack the bags and go', as the song suggests. The shrines of Kerry football have all been visited, not least the statue of the great Paidi O'Shea, footballer and manager in Ventry; and the great Mikey Sheehy has been pictured with his son, now a county councillor on Tralee's Rock Street. Back in up Buncrana, a huge banner on the corner of the An Tuath Nua bar on main street cheekily proclaims 'Donegal for Sam, Kerry for butter.' 'Donegal for Sam, Kerry for butter' sign on roadside Once drab Garda stations have also been decorated in support of Donegal goalkeeper Shaun Patton, a community Garda based out of Buncrana. Spare a thought for Sergeant Maurice Doyle, a GAA loving Kerryman who will have a lot to listen to in Letterkenny Garda Station if Donegal triumph. Those left behind when Jim's cavalcade leaves for the capital can still soak up the atmosphere of the big game with countless outdoor screens being erected in villages and towns across Donegal. The most optimistic ticketless fans will still travel to Croke Park in the hope of meeting a friend, long-lost cousin or neighbour who may just have a 'spare.' When Jimmy's winning matches, anything is possible.
