SC closes contempt proceedings against DDA for felling trees in ridge land
Passing orders on a contempt petition filed by Delhi resident Bindu Kapurea seeking contempt action against then DDA vice chairman Subhashish Panda, a bench of justices Surya Kant and N Kotiswar Singh noted that 'clearly DDA was in contempt for keeping the court in the dark about the trees already being felled when its application for tree felling was taken up by the court'.
'The overarching public interest weighs heavily on this court,' the bench noted as it found that the action of tree cutting was not malafide but for constructing a road to serve the larger good of operationalising the hospital, whose construction is complete and is awaiting inauguration.
The DDA VC informed the court that he was on leave at the time of tree felling and had since then moved out of the department, considering which the court closed contempt proceedings against him.
Three officials who were found guilty after an internal inquiry held by DDA, were directed by the court to pay ₹25,000 each as a fine towards environmental damage.
Also Read: Tree felling near Sector 43 sparks outcry, audit demand
The court censured the three officials and clarified that this order will be in addition to any disciplinary action sought to be taken by the DDA.
As part of restorative steps to be undertaken for the 1,000 trees chopped in the ridge area, the bench considered the DDA proposal to undertake compensatory afforestation on a plot of 185 acres.
The bench directed a committee of three court-nominated experts to inspect the area along with officials of DDA and government of national capital territory (NCT) of Delhi.
The notice on the contempt petition was issued by the court in May last year when Kapurea through her lawyers – senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan and advocate Manan Verma, pointed out how DDA misled the court by not informing it that even before its application seeking permission to fell trees could be heard by the top court on March 4 last year, the trees had been felled in February 2024.
The court had taken strict view of the matter and sought explanation from the DDA VC, its officials, the Delhi government and the Delhi lieutenant governor (LG) VK Saxena in his capacity as chairman of DDA.
DDA, which had accepted its mistake, told the top court on Tuesday to purge the contempt. The court took a serious view of the matter as Delhi ridge area constitutes the 'green lung' of Delhi and by an order passed by the top court on May 9, 1996, trees within ridge cannot be felled without court's prior permission.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
9 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
PM Modi should announce restoration of statehood to J&K on I-Day, says minister
Jammu and Kashmir minister Satish Sharma on Thursday demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi announce restoration of statehood to the Union Territory during his Independence Day speech at the Red Fort. The J&K said PM Modi should make the announcement on August 15 itself as it is something that the UT could get after 8 weeks. (DD Grab) Sharma was responding to questions from reporters about the Supreme Court on Thursday giving the Centre eight weeks to file a response on a plea seeking the restoration of statehood to J-K. "The PM should make an announcement tomorrow only for something that we may get after eight weeks," he said. The minister, however, said the Supreme Court should consider every aspect and return the dignity of the people of J-K. In a related development, the ruling National Conference (NC) said it was disappointed by the SC giving the Centre eight weeks. "It is disappointing. People of J-K were eagerly waiting for some good news, but today's decision to wait for the Centre's response for another eight weeks is disappointing," NC state spokesperson Imran Nabi Dar said. He, however, said the party is hopeful that the people of J-K will hear "good news" in the next hearing or the coming days. A bench comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) B R Gavai and Justice K Vinod Chandran also took note of the submissions of Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, that there are "several considerations which go into the decision-making process". It listed the plea, filed by academician Zahoor Ahmad Bhat and socio-political activist Ahmad Malik, for a hearing after eight weeks. "You cannot ignore what happened in Pahalgam... It is for Parliament and the executive to take a decision," the CJI said when senior lawyer Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for Bhat, sought an early hearing.
The Hindu
9 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Truth of triumph, says Bihar Congress on Supreme Court's SIR order
Ahead of Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's 16-day vote adhikar yatra (right to vote march) in Bihar from August 17, the State's party president Rajesh Kumar 'Ram' on Thursday (August 14, 2025) hailed as a 'triumph of truth and defeat of conspiracy' the Supreme Court's interim order on the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar. The court on Thursday directed the Election Commission to publish the names of voters deleted from the draft roll published on August 1 with reasons. 'This [order] is our first victory,' Mr. Kumar said. 'This is not only an order of the court but a big step taken to protect the democratic values of the country. Since the beginning, we have been saying that deletion of names from the voters' list is a murder of democracy. Today, the Supreme Court has protected democratic rights of people of Bihar and now there will not be any ploy to steal votes,' he added. Mr. Gandhi will start his march from Sasaram and will be joined by Opposition leaders, the party said. The yatra will culminate in a public meeting in Patna's Gandhi Maidan on September 1. The Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha will cover 1,300 km, visiting Rohtas, Aurangabad, Gaya, Nawada, Jamui, Nalanda, Sheikhpura, Munger, Katihar, Purnia, Supaul, Darbhanga, Sitamarhi, West Champaran and Saran districts, said party spokesperson Rajesh Rathore. 'The State unit of the party will organise the nationwide 'save democracy torch procession' in all district headquarters on Thursday,' said party spokesperson Asit Nath Tiwari. Asked how the party will benefit from Mr. Gandhi's 16-day visit in the upcoming Assembly elections, senior Congress leader Kishore Kumar Jha said, 'It will make the desired difference like the party had earlier got after the Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra.' In the 2024 Lok Sabha election, Congress candidate Manoj Kumar had won the Sasaram parliamentary seat defeating BJP's Shivesh Kumar. From the neighbouring Lok Sabha seat Aurangabad, the Rashtriya Janata Dal candidate Abhay Kushwaha beat Sushil Kumar Singh of the BJP. Party general secretary (organisation) K. C. Venugopal and other leaders visited Sasaram on Wednesday to review preparations for Mr. Gandhi's visit.
The Hindu
9 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Thrissur's voters' list row boils over as parties arm themselves for legal battle
The political temperature in Thrissur shows no signs of cooling as allegations of large-scale voters' list tampering and bogus voting escalated into a multi-party legal and political confrontation. All the three major parties - the Communist Party of India (CPI), Communist Party of India (Marxist) [CPI(M)], and the Congress - are preparing to move the Election Commission and the courts with what they claim is hard evidence of fraud. CPI leader and former Minister V.S. Sunilkumar set the pace on Wednesday by submitting documents to the State Chief Electoral Officer. CPI State secretary Binoy Viswam has gone further, demanding a Supreme Court-monitored judicial probe into what he calls a 'large-scale desecration of the voters' list' in Thrissur, allegedly carried out under the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) influence. On Suresh Gopi Addressing the media in Thrissur on Thursday, Mr. Viswam accused Union Minister Suresh Gopi of playing a 'central role' in the manipulation. 'His stone-like silence speaks volumes. Earlier, he would rush to comment on every issue. Now, even in the face of this grave matter, he remains mute,' Mr. Viswam said. Drawing parallels with Bihar, where he claimed voters were removed on religious grounds, Mr. Viswam said Thrissur's case was different: 'Christian voters were not deleted , fake voters were added. Mr. Gopi must explain who brought them, where they are now, and who funded this operation.' He also took a swipe at sections of the Christian clergy. 'Those dazzled by gold crowns and sweet cake must read Vicharadhara carefully, especially the parts about recognising your enemies.' Fresh allegations came from Mr. Sunilkumar, the CPI's 2024 Lok Sabha candidate from Thrissur, who claimed ten votes were registered under the address and number of the BJP Thrissur district committee office. 'In booth number 42, at 'Deendayal Mandiram,' votes were added without even a house number. None of these individuals live there,' he said. He further alleged that BJP State vice-president V. Unnikrishnan, a Malappuram native, who voted in Thrissur, played a direct role in the voter roll manipulation. CPI(M) district secretary K.V. Abdul Khader said the malpractice extended beyond Thrissur city, citing 17 fake votes allegedly added at a BJP leader's house in Avinissery panchayat. These voters, he said, cast ballots at booth number 69 in Nattika, where 79 non-residents were on the rolls. Last-minute inclusion Kerala Pradesh Congress Committee political affairs committee member T.N. Prathapan accused the BJP's central leadership of manipulating Kerala's 2023–24 voters' list update by influencing a private software company engaged by the Election Commission, enabling the last-minute inclusion of over 30,000 fake voters in Thrissur. He called for judicial investigation into the irregularities. The BJP has fired back with State vice-president K.K. Aneesh Kumar accusing the CPI(M) and the Congress of committing the same malpractice in Punkunnam area. Meanwhile, Thrissur District Congress Committee president Joseph Tajet warned that the new voter registration software provided by the Election Commission lacks safeguards to detect duplicate votes, a change he said will 'open the floodgates' for double voting in Kerala's upcoming local body polls. With the CPI planning a mass protest in Thrissur on Saturday, the voters' list controversy is set to dominate the district's political landscape well into the coming weeks.
