Differing reactions from farming and tourism bosses as Galloway National park Plans scrapped
Farming and tourism bosses have offered different reactions to the decision not to make Galloway Scotland's third national park.
A report on NatureScot's consultation revealed there was great support among the environment, recreation and tourism industries, with landowners and managers as well as the farming, forestry and the renewable energy sectors having the greatest concerns.
NFU Scotland president, Andrew Cannon, said: 'Farmers, crofters and land managers raised legitimate concerns around the clarity, cost and purpose of the designation.
'The Scottish Government has clearly recognised that there was not enough local backing for such a significant change in land management structure.
'We thank NatureScot for engaging closely with us during the process and for recognising, as we have repeatedly called for, that existing arrangements should be strengthened rather than overhauled.
'Going forward, we urge the Scottish Government to work in partnership with NFU Scotland and our members on practical projects that support biodiversity, climate action and thriving rural communities without additional regulatory burdens.'
Scottish Land and Estates also welcomed the move.
The South of Scotland Destination Alliance were left disappointed by Rurual Affairs Secretary Mairi Gougeon's announcement.
Chief executive, David Hope-Jones, said: 'We feel this is a missed opportunity to attract sustained investment in visitor management, visitor experience and visitor infrastructure.
We represent 750+ local businesses and when consulted in the autumn of 2023, the majority of SSDA members (66 per cent) supported the idea.
'Now that the Galloway National Park has been rejected by the Scottish Government, we feel it is crucial that there is some other form of investment in the south of Scotland to support sustainable tourism and economic prosperity.
'Together, we have an ambitious South of Scotland Responsible Tourism Strategy, developed and delivered by hundreds of local businesses and communities, with all public agencies committed. The results from this have been hugely positive and yet there has been a significant decrease in funding to support sustainable destination management and marketing.
'In deciding not to back the Galloway National Park, we call on the Scottish Government to outline how, through new investment, the same sustainable economic results can be achieved.'
Other organisations unhappy at the move included Ramblers Scotland, Protect Rural Scotland, the Scottish Campaign for National Parks, RSPB Scotland and the Scottish Rewilding Alliance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
7 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Councils blame SNP government for high school leadership crisis
The organisation has also raised concerns that attempts to reduce class contact time for teachers will force cuts to other key services if the change is not fully funded by the Scottish Government. Last week The Herald reported that many of Scotland's secondary school leaders feel a mixture of 'helplessness and frustration' due to 'unrealistic expectations' overwhelming workload pressures. School Leaders Scotland (SLS), which represents promoted secondary school staff, has warned that despite the many positives of their jobs, members 'overwhelmingly feel their wellbeing is overlooked, with unrealistic expectations and inadequate support systems in place.' A survey of SLS members has uncovered an average working week of more than 53 hours, with some reporting having to work between 70 and 80 hours in a week – well beyond the terms of their contracts. Nearly 90 percent reported being unable to take an uninterrupted break of 20 minutes. Responses also highlighted a wide range of problems and concerns, including a lack of business managers in some areas, the use of centralised recruitment systems by certain councils, the impact of cuts to council support teams, and the provision of 'inadequate' financial tools. READ MORE As a result of the increasing pressures being experienced by school leaders, 61% of those surveyed said that have considered leaving the profession early. Schools Leaders Scotland describe this as a 'depressing statistic' which shows 'how unhappy school leaders are in their posts.' In response to The Herald's reporting on the SLS survey findings, a spokesperson for COSLA, which represents all of Scotland's councils, blamed the Scottish Government's funding cuts and drew attention to current demands around teacher numbers. Their spokesperson said: 'Local authorities have had to prioritise frontline services and in particular teachers - but greater demands on budget have meant central support functions that used to be available to schools have had to be reduced or cut in many cases. This has been necessary given the budget pressures on councils, including years of cuts to council funding in real terms.' Almost all council funding is controlled either directly or indirectly by the Scottish Government. The spokesperson continued: 'COSLA shares the concerns of SLS regarding children and young people who are distressed, or who have additional support needs. 'We will continue to engage closely with the Scottish Government and Trade Unions on reducing class contact time, but we are clear that this commitment must be fully funded by the Scottish Government, otherwise we risk Councils being forced to cut to other key services that support the wellbeing of pupils with additional support needs.' The Scottish Government has been approached for comment.
The Herald Scotland
9 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
For Women Scotland slam SNP sex motion for 'lack of basics'
The judgement was widely interpreted as asserting that trans women should not be granted access to women's single-sex spaces. Bodies such as the Scottish Parliament and Police Scotland have already rewritten policies in an effort to comply with the law. But last week FWS announced it is suing SNP ministers again after accusing them of refusing to abide by the ruling. READ MORE: The group said it had been left with 'little choice' but to take the Scottish Government to court again after SNP ministers refused to abandon gender self-ID policies, which it argues are now clearly in breach of the law. It has now emerged that SNP members have drawn up a resolution to their party's annual conference in October which while accepting the court's judgement, argues that it poses risks to trans people . It urges the party to seek "accurate legal advice" on "how services can continue to include trans people in line with their lived genders within the bounds of the UKSC ruling". The motion, first reported on by The National states: "By defining 'sex' strictly as 'biological', the decision affects how transgender people are recognised under the EA 2010 [Equality Act 2010], as organisations and businesses are now using this ruling to limit access to single sex spaces and services." It adds: "Conference acknowledges the legal capacity the UK Supreme Court has, however is concerned around the unprecedented risks posed by the UK Supreme Court rulings such as the reductionist definition of women, which rolls back progress for all women, including transgender, non-binary, intersex people and people with VSCs. "Conference expresses concern that the ruling has allowed for horrific practices such as the now legalised strip-searches of transgender women by male police officers and the medical exclusion of transgender people in certain healthcare practices." It goes on to argue that in light of these considerations, conference calls for the SNP to: "Push for the Scottish Government to seek accurate legal advice regarding how services can continue to include trans people in line with their lived genders within the bounds of the UKSC ruling." It also calls for a number of other measures including the setting up of a Scottish Government working group "focused on the inclusion and protection of those with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment", and a firm "commitment to a trans-inclusive conversion practices ban within the next Scottish parliamentary term". Susan Smith, director of For Women Scotland, told The Herald: "We cannot help but be amused by the generous acknowledgement that the apex court has legal capacity. "The rest of the motion is tiresome rather than funny and suggests that those proposing it lack basic comprehension skills. "Far from being excluded from healthcare, the ruling ensures trans-identified people are entitled to provisions appropriate to their sex - we argued, for example, that the Scottish Government were wrong to say that pregnant women with a GRC [gender recognition certificate] were not covered by maternity rights. "The Scottish Government has all the 'accurate' legal advice they require in the form of the ruling and should, by now, have learnt the danger of trying to change equality law by stealth. "We are also unimpressed by the cynical attempt to use people with medical conditions (different sex development) as a wedge. The Supreme Court ruling made no change to their rights. "If the SNP has any sense, they will stop trying to fight a rearguard which is doomed to failure and will only serve to waste resources and further alienate the public." The SNP was approached for comment.
Scotsman
12 hours ago
- Scotsman
Kids back to school, Greens back to improving education
Scottish Green Party co-leader Lorna Slater As schools across Edinburgh and the rest of Scotland return for a new academic year, families are once again adjusting to early mornings, packed lunches and the excitement that comes with new classrooms and new challenges. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... For children, the return to school is an opportunity to learn, grow and make friends. For us in politics, it is a reminder of our responsibility to ensure that every child in Scotland has access to the best possible education, no matter their background. That is why the Scottish Greens are working hard in Parliament to transform education, making it fairer, greener and more supportive for every pupil. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad One of the most significant changes we are delivering is the replacement of the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA). For too long, the SQA has been associated with a system that did not always put learners first. We have listened to the voices of young people, parents and teachers and now the Scottish Government must create a new independent qualifications body. This reform is about creating a system that is transparent, accountable and above all, centred on the needs of young people. Heading back to school. Making the school day greener is another key priority. Schools are not just places of learning, they are also part of our communities. By investing in renewable energy, improving insulation and cutting waste, we can make schools healthier environments for pupils while also tackling the climate crisis. Greener schools also provide valuable opportunities for children to learn about sustainability in practice, reinforcing lessons that will be vital for their futures. I am also incredibly proud of the expansion of free school meals. Good nutrition is essential for learning, yet too many families still struggle with food costs. By extending free meals to more pupils, we are reducing the stigma around school dining and making sure that no child is forced to go through the school day hungry. This is an investment not only in children's health but also in their education and wellbeing. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Affordability does not stop at food. The cost of school uniforms can be a huge burden on families. The Scottish Greens have been campaigning to make uniforms more affordable, working with local authorities and schools to promote more flexible and inclusive approaches. No pupil should feel left out or disadvantaged because their family cannot afford a particular blazer or logo. Education is about giving every child the tools to thrive. By reforming qualifications, making school buildings sustainable, expanding free meals and tackling the cost of uniforms, we are taking steps that will help build a fairer Scotland where every child has the chance to succeed.
