'Non-fatal strangulation offence will give survivors justice they deserve'
The mother of a student who took her life after being subject to abuse, including non-fatal strangulation, is urging MSPs to make it a new, stand-alone offence.
Fiona Drouet is campaigning to change the law following the death of her daughter Emily in 2016.
The 18-year-old law student was subjected to abuse and violence by her boyfriend before being found dead in her halls of residence in 2016.
Emily's former boyfriend Angus Milligan was later convicted of physically and verbally abusing the teenager and was subsequently expelled from the university.
He admitted to choking and slapping Emily as well as assaulting and threatening her during a campaign of abuse.
Fiona Drouet is now urging ministers to make non-fatal strangulation a stand-alone offence to help deter offenders in the future.
'We are looking at an exceptionally serious crime that merits a law in itself, to be recognised as exceptionally high risk,' she told MSPs on Wednesday.
'It is very different to other forms of abuse.'
Non-fatal strangulation is currently dealt with under the common law of assault in Scotland or under the Domestic Abuse Scotland Act.
Ms Drouet said creating a new offence could help educate people about the crime and also deter offenders.
She told MSPs that when a person has the oxygen supply to their brain restricted, 'they are going to have an automatic response of fighting, literally fighting for their life, something that is hugely traumatic'.
She described it as being 'like a near-death experience'.
The mum stood in front of Holyrood's Criminal Justice Committee and read text messages her daughter had sent to friends before her death.
In the messages, Emily said about her abuse: 'I was so scared, I thought I was going to die'.
In another message, she said: 'I am so scared that I think I want to die.'
'If we have a stand-alone crime saying that was non-fatal strangulation, I think potentially it acts as a strong deterrent, a stronger message,' Fiona said.
'I'm worried any other approach minimises the severity and risk of the crime and doesn't give victims, survivors the justice that they absolutely deserve.'
Non-fatal strangulation has already been made a stand-alone offence in the other nations of the UK, with detective superintendent Lindsay Fisher of the Police Service of Northern Ireland telling the committee about the impact there when new laws came in in June 2023.
'The improvements that having a stand-alone offence have been immense,' she told MSPs
'Within three days of the legislation going live, we had not only used the new stand-alone offence, but we had somebody appearing in court having been charged for it.'
Dr Emma Forbes, national lead for domestic abuse in the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) said they are 'worried' by anecdotal evidence about the 'increased prevalence' of non-fatal strangulation particularly amongst young people.
She told the committee that almost two-fifths of the 136 cases COPFS received from Police Scotland in March, which are being prosecuted under the Domestic Abuse Scotland Act, involved non-fatal strangulation.
However, Dr Forbes insisted Scotland has 'effective legislation at the moment'.
She accepted there are compelling reasons to create a specific offence of non-fatal strangulation saying that this would raise public awareness, which urgently needs to be done, and would also provide improved data on the number of such crimes.
But she added: 'We have a very strong foundation in our law in Scotland and I would worry about the unintended consequences of a specific offence, not least because it would be more difficult evidentially to prove.'
At the moment, Holyrood's Criminal Justice Committee is considering a petition from Ms Drouet to make non-fatal strangulation a standalone criminal offence in Scotland.
MSPs on the committee will listen to evidence from a variety of sources.
If they decide that it should be a stand-alone offence, they can invite the Scottish Government to reflect on the evidence and ask if they have any plans to make non-fatal strangulation a standalone offence in Scotland.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
an hour ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Justice Minister voices concern over time taken to find Tina Satchwell's body
Jim O'Callaghan also said it would be preferable if An Garda Siochana had its own cadaver dog to help find human remains. He said there is currently just one cadaver dog on the island of Ireland which belongs to the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI). It was announced last week that both the investigation into the murder of Mrs Satchwell, and of Co Kerry farmer Michael Gaine, will be reviewed. A report is to be compiled and given to Mr O'Callaghan on Mrs Satchwell's disappearance while the case of Mr Gaine is undergoing a peer review. Speaking on RTE Radio One's This Week programme, Mr O'Callaghan said he had his quarterly meeting with Garda Commissioner Drew Harris last week and brought up the murder of Mrs Satchwell. 'I think from the outset it has to be said that gardai deserve to be commended for getting justice in this case,' he said. 'The person responsible for her murder, Richard Satchwell, is now serving a life sentence. 'However I did raise with the commissioner concern about the fact it had taken a considerable period of time to find her body and he said he is going to prepare a report on that.' It took six years before Mrs Satchwell's body was found. Mr O'Callaghan pointed out there are 'very devious people out there who go to very great lengths to hide their crimes'. 'That was the case with Richard Satchwell, and it is also the case with the person responsible for the murder of Mike Gaine who hasn't yet been apprehended,' he said. Asked whether a cadaver dog should have been brought into the Satchwell home in 2017 during the investigation, Mr O'Callaghan said 'probably, it should have happened'. He said he also spoke to Mr Harris about the effectiveness of cadaver dogs. 'They're a very specialised dog in terms of trying to train them, there is one on the island of Ireland, the PSNI has one,' he said. 'That dog is sought by many police forces in Britain as well. We got the use of the dog here and he was of much assistance. 'It obviously would be preferable if we had a cadaver dog. They have a very limited work life, cadaver dogs, they're only operational for a period of about three years, they have to go through a very difficult training process. 'It would be preferable if the cadaver dog available on the island had been used earlier.'
The Courier
2 days ago
- The Courier
Daughter's tribute to Dundee mum who suddenly died in front of family on Perthshire holiday
A Dundee woman has paid tribute to her 'superwoman' mum after she suddenly died on a family holiday. Louise Beattie tragically passed away in front of her two youngest kids and partner Steven Milne at Tummel Valley Holiday Park, in Perthshire, on Tuesday afternoon. The 45-year-old leaves behind three children: Euan Shaw, 13, Eliana Shaw, 14 and 24-year-old Emily Mather. The family was celebrating Steven's upcoming birthday at the Parkdean resort near Pitlochry when the tragedy unfolded. It is understood that Louise had a seizure in the pool at the holiday park. She was pronounced dead at the scene, and the exact cause of her death is unknown. Police say there are no suspicious circumstances. Emily, who is from Dundee but now lives in Manchester, told The Courier: 'She was always caring and had so much time for those around her. 'My mum was always a giver, and never a taker, and would go out of her way for anyone. 'Many people will remember my mum as the 'stamp lady' outside Deja Vu nightclub. 'She was a real superwoman of a mum, she had a heart of gold and was some character.' Former Baldragon Academy pupil Emily previously told of how pole fishing saved her life after she lost her gran in 2021. She added: 'We're not sure what caused her death yet, but it was a medical incident. 'A biopsy will take place at the beginning of next week. 'It's been a difficult few days, but I just want to make sure I'm there for the kids. We're all pulling together.' Family friend Hollie has set up a GoFundMe page to help the family give Louise the 'send-off she deserves'. It's already raised thousands of pounds. Speaking to The Courier, Hollie said: 'Louise laughed her way through life, everything was funny to her and she was a very good friend to have. 'She was always the first person at your door when something was up. 'It's been a really challenging time for the family, and the fundraiser will help them all out. 'She was the best mum and she deserves the best send-off ever, for the kids too. 'Sleep tight Louise, we will miss you forever.' Emily added: 'Every donation means a lot and is very much appreciated.' A spokesperson for Tummel Valley Holiday Park said: 'Our thoughts are with the deceased, and we would like to send our deepest sympathies and condolences to their family and friends during this difficult time.' A Police Scotland spokesperson said: 'Around 3.40pm on Tuesday we were called to Main Road, Tummel Bridge, Pitlochry, following a report of concern for a woman. 'Emergency services attended and the 45-year-old was pronounced dead at the scene. 'There are no suspicious circumstances and her family are aware. 'A report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.' A spokesperson for the Scottish Ambulance Service said: 'We received a call at 3:30pm on Tuesday to attend an incident at Tummel Bridge, Pitlochry. 'We dispatched one ambulance, a paramedic response unit (PRU), a BASICS Scotland doctor and an air ambulance to the scene.'
Daily Record
2 days ago
- Daily Record
Drugs mule caught with £1m cannabis haul 'stuffed in suitcases' at Cairnryan port
Chace Cappellie tried to traffick the class B drug via his vehicle from a Stena Line ferry from Belfast to Cairnryan. A drugs mule was snared with over £1m worth of cannabis stuffed in suitcases, after a routine search of his car by two Scottish port security officers. Chace Cappellie, 33, was found with a huge stash of the class B drug in his vehicle at Cairnryan in Dumfries and Galloway. He had been attempting to ship the haul from Northern Ireland into Scotland via a Stena Line ferry. But his operation was unravelled by two port security officers who were working in connection with the Border Force, after they conducted a routine check. During the search, the officers found a single suitcase containing the drugs. After the discovery, a more thorough search was conducted. This lead to the discovery of five more suitcases, containing 92 vacuum-sealed plastic bags, which gave off a strong smell of cannabis. A further 110 bags were then found hidden within the other bags, containing a massive 108kg worth of cannabis. The total value of the seized drugs was estimated to have a street value of up to £1,085,160. Cappellie, of Halesowen in the West Midlands, was convicted at the High Court in Glasgow after he admitted to being concerned in the supply of a controlled drug. He was jailed for three years and two months on Friday. Moira Orr, who leads on major crime for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), said: 'This individual failed in his attempt to bring significant quantities of illegal and harmful drugs through Scotland. 'Chace Cappellie has now been held accountable thanks to an extensive Border Force operation, working with COPFS, to disrupt a network of drug supply. 'These drugs would have inflicted serious harm on communities, but with each case of this kind we are reducing that risk. 'We are targeting all people who threaten communities across Scotland, not only drug couriers but also those who direct their movements.' It comes after another Scottish drugs trafficker who flooded the UK with millions of pounds worth of heroin was ordered to pay back just £42,000 earlier this week. Christopher Heaney, from Anstruther in Fife, was jailed for nine years in February 2024 after profiting £120,000 from the £7m cross-border heroin conspiracy. The 48-year-old, alongside four others, were busted by cops following the arrest of a bent police officer in May 2022. Steven Creasey, an ex-police officer who had also worked for the Royal Navy, was stopped while driving his vehicle to Fife having already travelled from his home in Cardiff to Liverpool the same day. A drugs dog sniffed out a professionally installed hide under the passenger seat of his car, which was found to contain a 5kg stash of heroin and one kilogram of adulterant. A burner phone also found in his possession revealed that the former cop had been operating as a professional drugs courier engaged by the heads of a gang based in Liverpool. Their drugs were then distributed for onward supply across the UK by Heaney and three others. A Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA) hearing was held at Cardiff Crown Court on Thursday. It heard how despite profiting around tens of thousands of pounds as part of the operation, Heaney was ordered to pay back a fraction of £42,000 Judge Lucy Crowther ordered him to pay the sum within three months. If he fails to do so, he will face an additional 18 months in jail.
