Plans for new Bradford home rejected over tree felling row
Applicant Mohammed Tayyab said the new building, erected on a different footprint to the former care home, would help improve the area.He said the trees had been felled before they bought the site in 2021, but planners told Bradford Council's planning panel that as the landowners it was still their responsibility to replace them.
'Not a good look'
Labour councillor Safina Kauser spoke in favour of the plans and said the site had been derelict for eight years before the applicants bought it."It is almost like planning officers don't want to bring this property back into life," she said."Why are they making it so difficult?"She said the site was on the "doorstep" of Lister Park, the site of many City of Culture events, and asked: "Do you want people to drive by and see this eyesore? It is not a good look for Bradford."Kauser said the applicants were being penalised for something they had not done.However, officers said whoever felled the trees, it was done without consent, and approving a large house on the site would essentially reward that illegal act.Planning committee chair Labour's Sinead Engel, said the fact the site was an eyesore was not something in favour of the applicant."It is their responsibility to keep the site safe."I can't bring myself to sanction a plan that rewards criminal activity."Regardless of who committed the crimes – the person who did it has benefitted if it has increased the value of the land."Seven members voted to refuse the plans, and three voted against the officer's recommendation.
Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Reform UK councillor Ed Hill expelled from party
A Reform UK councillor who was elected to Devon County Council in May has been expelled from the UK said it had expelled Ed Hill for publishing a letter about free school meals in the name of all Reform Devon councillors without their June it emerged Hill had reported two fellow Reform councillors to police over election the member for Pinhoe and Mincinglake, said there had been a misunderstanding which led him to believe he could add his colleagues' names as signatories. 'Unacceptable' A Reform UK spokesman said Hill's actions "damaged the interests of the party".The spokesman said: "We will not tolerate any councillor using their colleagues' names without their consent."Hill sent the letter to all of Devon's MPs and to the media asking them to support automatic enrolment for free school Fife Cook is leader of the Reform group on Devon County Council, which now has 17 said: "Irrespective of something being a good cause, attaching councillors' names to a letter without their consent is totally unacceptable behaviour."That Cllr Hill not only did this, but then made the letter public - including sending it to the media and MPs - meant disciplinary action was inevitable." Hill said he genuinely believed he had secured the permission of colleagues via one of the Reform councillors."I think it feels like an overreaction and I'm still committed to the Reform cause," he said."Nobody from Reform contacted me about the suspension before it happened."Hill was previously removed from his role as chairman of the Exeter branch of Reform after reporting colleagues to police over concerns relating to overspending on election said: "Had I been able to communicate directly with my fellow councillors through formal party channels - instead of being excluded from all internal communications - this confusion could have been easily avoided."Reform UK said it would not be taking any action against Neil Stevens, member for Alphington and Cowick, regarding his election expense and Cornwall Police said there had been no arrests or charges at this point, but enquiries remain ongoing.
Telegraph
10 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Crumbling water industry is damaging Britain's economy, MPs warn
Britain's crumbling water industry is hitting housebuilding and slowing the country's economic growth, MPs have warned. On Friday, MPs on the public accounts committee (Pac) said the sector's failure to build new reservoirs had delayed the construction of thousands of new homes and offices that were urgently needed to boost the UK economy. This includes 7,000 new houses being built in Oxford as well as 50,000 new homes in Cambridge which have been delayed because of a major shortfall in the water supply, the MPs said. Crucially, they added that neither the Government or the Environment Agency (EA) were able to say how many homes had been denied planning permission because of a lack of water pipes and that customers were footing the bill for the failures. Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the Pac chairman, said: 'The monumental scale of work required to reverse the fortunes of failing water companies is rivalled only in difficulty by the efforts needed to repair customers' faith in the sector. 'Customers are being expected to shoulder the burden of water companies' failings, without being told why or on what their money will be spent.' Water companies are under intense scrutiny after the debt crisis at Thames Water put renewed focus on how much companies are spending on fixing creaking water infrastructure. According to the Pac, 10 out of Britain's 16 water companies failed to generate enough income last year to cover the interest payments on their debts – leaving them unable to invest more. In two cases over the past two decades, water companies paid out dividends worth more than 100pc of the entire value of company assets, according to the MPs. Ofwat is also blamed for failing to prevent water companies from taking excessive dividends – even as it has flagged concerns about the payouts. The regulator signalled concerns about 10 water companies last year. The water industry must spend nearly £300bn on new infrastructure to avoid looming water shortages – including building 10 new reservoirs – and boost UK economic growth. The investment is urgently required because the UK has failed to build a single new reservoir since the Carsington Water reservoir in Derbyshire – which was opened more than 30 years ago in 1992. The report placed a portion of the blame on the Environment Department's failure to ensure water companies had been building and maintaining the infrastructure needed to avoid looming shortfalls, which are expected to hit 5bn litres a day by 2050. By the end of the year, the MPs recommended that the EA should publish a list of all housing and commercial developments being delayed or blocked. The report comes as Southern Water announced it had doubled the pay of chief executive Lawrence Gosden to £1.4m at the same time as announcing a hosepipe ban for 1m customers. Southern Water, which servers 4.7m customers across Kent, Sussex, Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, is now the fourth water company to announce a hosepipe ban, alongside Thames Water, Yorkshire Water and South East Water.
BBC News
41 minutes ago
- BBC News
Brackley housing estate development to go to planning inspector
A decision to build 700 homes on the outskirts of a market town will be made by the Planning Inspectorate following opposition from a local council. The plans for the homes, on 86 acres of greenfield in Brackley, Northamptonshire, were submitted by developers Ashfield Land and Vulpes Land. Ashfield Land said the housing estate would include public open spaces, allotments, an extension of Brackley Rugby Club, and access from Halse Road and the A422 Brackley Northamptonshire Council is opposed to the application. Councillors have not been able to agree the level of financial contributions the developer should make, known as a Section 106 agreement. The decision was referred to the Planning Inspectorate after the authority failed to issue a decision on the plans for four years, the Local Democracy Reporting Service council received more than 100 letters opposing the plans. Local people cited a lack of dentists, doctors and schools in the area, a loss of farmland and biodiversity and increased traffic. 'Enough is enough' Farthinghoe Parish Council, the Wildlife Trust and the Campaign to Protect Rural England also objected. Conservative councillor Fiona Baker said adding more houses would be "detrimental to the quality of life of the residents already in the town"."There's a mention of allotments and a rugby pitch. This is in no way compensation for the increase of a minimum of 1,400 people joining the area," she in the morning was already "like a mass exodus from the town"."I ask you to refuse this application, not because it's 'not in my backyard', but because enough is enough," she said they would work with the developers to secure appropriate Section 106 conditions, ahead of the appeal, due at the end of October. Follow Northamptonshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
