Could the next pope be from Africa or Asia? Experts weigh in
Pope Francis marked multiple firsts for the papacy, becoming the first Latin American pope and the first from the Southern Hemisphere when elected in 2013.
He was also the first head of the Roman Catholic Church born outside of Europe in over a millennium.
Following his death on Monday at the age of 88, the selection process to elect the 267th pontiff will soon begin.Ahead of the secretive gathering of eligible cardinals for the vote, questions swirl over whether the next pope will similarly come from outside Europe, such as Asia or Africa, and potentially be another history-making leader.
"I do think it's fair to say that election of an archbishop from Asia or Africa is certainly a real probability now. That is not unthinkable at all," Bruce Morrill, the Edward A. Malloy chair in Roman Catholic studies and distinguished professor of theology at Vanderbilt University, told ABC News. "That's very different from when, let's say, someone like John Paul II was elected. It was a big deal back in 1978 because he wasn't Italian."
"To move a couple papacies later to a man from Argentina -- clearly, it's reflecting more than ever a global church," he added.
The election of someone from the Global South would be a "move in that direction of how to be a global church," Jaisy A. Joseph, an assistant professor of theology and religious studies at Villanova University, told ABC News.
"That move from a Eurocentric church to a truly global church -- I think that's what Francis really inaugurated," she said.
MORE: Who are the top contenders to be the next pope? Experts weigh in
Pope Francis' successor could be someone who continues his progressive legacy and mirrors his pastoral approach, or someone who counters it with a more conservative approach, experts say.
"Is he going to be someone who really strongly continues the primary emphases of the Francis papacy, or do they want to go with someone that they would see as bringing a balance or a certain pendulum swing, to use that language, in counter or contrast of priorities from the Francis papacy?" Morrill said.
Such a swing occurred when Pope Francis was elected, succeeding Pope Benedict XVI, Morrill noted.
For Morrill and Joseph, one man who is a natural successor to Pope Francis is a man known as the "Asian Francis" -- Cardinal Luis Antonio Gokim Tagle, 67, of the Philippines.
"Really being with people, listening to people, encountering people where they are and not being afraid of difference -- I think those are traits that Tagle really exemplifies," Joseph said. "That could possibly be a point of continuity if he were to be elected pope."
Morrill said Tagle is a "strongly viable candidate" and someone who would continue the priorities of Pope Francis, who appointed Tagle to an office in the Vatican that focuses on evangelization.
"If the electors are going to turn to someone and discern the way to go is to continue, strongly, the priorities of the late Pope Francis, Tagle fits the bill," Morrill said.
"He's likewise someone who smiles readily and has this warm pastoral way," he added. "That's what makes him the figure that we would think of as providing the most continuity."
If elected, Tagle would be the first Asian pope.
MORE: Pope Francis live updates
Should the voting cardinals move in a more conservative direction, a potential pope could be found in Sub-Saharan Africa, Morrill said. Such a move would make for the first Black pope in modern history.
"There would be archbishops, cardinal archbishops in Sub-Saharan Africa that are much more focused on preservation or guarding of the strict traditional practices and teachings of the church," Morrill said.
One name that comes to mind for Morrill is Cardinal Fridolin Ambongo Besungu, 65, of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Other conservative candidates from Africa that could gain recognition include Ghanaian Cardinal Peter Turkson, 76, and Guinean Cardinal Robert Sarah, 79, according to Miles Pattenden, historian of the Catholic Church at Oxford University.
Cardinals under the age of 80 are eligible to participate in the secret conclave inside the Sistine Chapel to choose the next pontiff, a gathering that typically commences between 15 to 20 days after the pope's death.
A two-thirds majority is required to elect a pontiff.
MORE: Electing a new pope: What happens next and what is a papal conclave?
Francis appointed roughly 80% of the cardinals who are eligible to vote for his successor, which could impact the selection of the next pope, Morrill said.
"He was advancing and choosing more and more people from Asia and Africa, and so that does all feed these distinct probabilities or possibilities," Morrill said. "But there really is no way to make any solid prediction."
The Pew Research Center found that under Francis, voting-age cardinals from the Asia-Pacific region increased 10%, and those from Sub-Saharan Africa went up 8%, while those from Europe decreased 51%.
In all, there are 53 cardinal electors from Europe, 23 from Asia, 18 from Africa, 17 from South America, 16 from North America, four from Central America and four from Oceania, according to the Vatican.
For Phyllis Zagano, the senior research associate-in-residence in Hofstra University's Department of Religion, it's unclear at the moment how that shift in makeup will impact the election of the next pope.
"The College of Cardinals has expanded significantly under Pope Francis, who has included cardinals from the farthest reaches of the world," Zagano told ABC News. "Whether that will make any difference in the election of his successor remains to be seen."
Could the next pope be from Africa or Asia? Experts weigh in originally appeared on abcnews.go.com
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Panama Canal boss says MSC ports deal threatens neutrality, FT reports
(Reuters) -The sale of two ports near the Panama Canal to a global consortium led by Mediterranean Shipping Company (MSC) threatens the canal's principle of neutrality, the canal's head Ricaurte Vasquez told the Financial Times. "There is a potential risk of capacity concentration if the deal comes the way it is structured as we understand right now,' Vasquez told the FT in a report published on Tuesday. "If there is a significant level of concentration on terminal operators belonging to an integrated or one single shipping company, it will be at the expense of Panama's competitiveness in the market and inconsistent with neutrality." MSC is one of the world's top container shipping groups. MSC and the Panama Canal Authority did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. CK Hutchison confirmed last month that MSC, run by the family of Italian billionaire Gianluigi Aponte, was the main investor in a group seeking to buy 43 ports, including the two ports in Panama, for $22.8 billion. The clarification follows weeks of scrutiny and criticism in China over CK Hutchison's plan to sell the ports to a consortium, which was previously led by U.S. investment firm BlackRock. BlackRock remains part of the group. The proposed sale has also drawn the attention of U.S. President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly expressed his desire to reduce Chinese influence around the Panama Canal and termed the deal a "reclaiming" of the waterway after it was first announced. In April, China's top market regulator said it was paying close attention to CK Hutchison's planned sale and that parties to the deal should not try to avoid an antitrust review. Vasquez added that the canal should use the ports deal as an opportunity to become a terminal operator itself by reactivating a project to build a terminal in the Port of Corozal at the Pacific end of the canal, according to the FT. Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Rachel Maddow Says the ‘Interesting Question' About Trump Is ‘What the Country Lets Him Get Away With'
Rachel Maddow belittled Donald Trump on Monday night whilechatting with her MSNBC colleague Lawrence O'Donnell, declaring that Trump's latest 'dictator' actions have made him 'very boring.' Not that she argued the current situation isn't serious, only that Trump is acting like, as she joked, a blonde copy of the extremely corrupt former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi. But Maddow also clarified that the 'really interesting question' about all of this is 'what the country lets him get away with. The comment came up at the start of 'The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell,' as the duo discussed how Trump's current actions — calling in the national guard over the objections of California Gov. Gavin Newsom to quell lawful protests — are the exact opposite of what he said he could legally do in 2020 during the George Floyd protests. At that time, Trump said it would be unlawful for him to do so without a request of a state governor. 'I mean the difference,' Maddow said, is that 'he's decided that he's throwing it all out. You know, 'dictator on day from day one,' and you know, going to terminate parts of the Constitution. And he's decided that he doesn't matter what Congress does, and it doesn't matter what the courts do, that he's just the strong man he's going to be.' 'He's decided to throw out all the rules,' Maddow continued. 'The thing that that has done, as far as I'm concerned, is make him very boring, because it's like it's all on the table. We know exactly what he's doing. We know exactly what his intentions are. He's blonde Berlusconi. This is, I mean, he's just trying to do the same thing all the other strongmen and would be dictators do all over the country. I think the really interesting question is, what the country lets him get away with, and we're seeing a really interesting test of that right now, all over the country, especially this week.' Later in the discussion, Maddow argued that the issue isn't that Trump has changed his mind over what he can and cannot legally do, it's that 'we can probably intuit that what he's being told is, 'yeah, it's illegal, therefore, go do it.' I think that the more laws he breaks, the more blatantly unconstitutional things he both proposes and tries, I think the more they think power accrues to him, because he's less constrained by things that don't actually stop him.' 'And so ultimately, I mean, the courts are pushing him back. Congress, to a certain extent, is pushing him back a little bit, although I think a little bit more than they're giving credit for, but mostly it's people pushing him back. He's deeply, deeply, deeply unpopular and underwater on every issue, and he is absolutely panicked by the protests against him, to the point where he's already playing the biggest cards that he's gotten. He's not even six months into this term. I just think, I think we're getting the test really early, and I think that he's failing.' Maddow later noted that Trump's rhetoric and response to the protests is vastly out of proportion with the scope of them, but 'even if these protests were 100 times the size that they are, there still wouldn't be an operational reason to bring in active duty troops or federalized National Guard. I mean, it's just, it's not, it's not that sort of thing. This is obviously not operationally necessitated, right, in terms of the security of the city. He's doing this because he's panicking and thinks that he looks weak, and therefore he has to do something that seems strong.' 'And so we will have tanks destroying the streets of Washington this Saturday, and we will have National Guardsmen and active duty US Marines standing around Los Angeles, wondering what their what this has to do with their military careers. And it's all because he has no freaking idea how to deal with this politically. And he's absolutely panicking about the, I think, trenchant and joyful and sustainable opposition against him.' Maddow added. Watch the whole conversation below: The post Rachel Maddow Says the 'Interesting Question' About Trump Is 'What the Country Lets Him Get Away With'| Video appeared first on TheWrap.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
ABC News staffers ‘pissed' at Terry Moran over ‘stupid' verbal assault on Trump aide Stephen Miller: ‘He should be fired'
ABC News staffers are 'pissed' at Terry Moran and some are calling for his head after he blasted Trump aide Stephen Miller as a 'world class hater,' The Post has learned. Moran's diatribe on social media over the weekend, which he has since deleted, was condemned by ABC News executives for lacking 'objectivity and impartiality.' The veteran newsman was suspended 'pending further evaluation' Sunday, but some colleagues felt the punishment did not go far enough. 'He should be fired,' one ABC News insider told The Post on Monday. 'People inside are pissed at Terry for screwing things up for the network.' 'Everything that Trump has said about the media — that they are haters and they are biased — Moran proved it true,' the source explained, adding that journalists are supposed to 'check your biases at the door and only deal with the facts.' Firing Moran may serve Debra OConnell, President of ABC News Group and Networks, Disney Entertainment, who is in the throes of trimming the budget amid larger cuts at Disney. A source with knowledge said a journalist with Moran's level of experience — namely a senior-level correspondent who has covered the White House and co-anchored 'Nightline' — likely makes between $600,000 and $900,000 a year. 'That could save the network a lot of money, and she would demonstrate to the White House that ABC takes the issue seriously,' the person said. ABC News declined to comment. Moran did not respond to requests seeking comment. His early-morning screed Sunday tore into Trump's Deputy Chief of Staff. 'The thing about Stephen Miller is not that he is the brains behind Trumpism. Yes, he is one of the people who conceptualizes the impulses of the Trumpist movement and translates them into policy. But that's not what's interesting about Miller,' Moran railed on X. 'It's not brains. It's bile. Miller is a man who is richly endowed with the capacity for hatred. He's a world-class hater,' the ABC News reporter added. 'You can see this just by looking at him because you can see that his hatreds are his spiritual nourishment. He eats his hate.' The verbal onslaught came after Moran landed an interview with Trump in April as controversy over the administration's tariff policies swirled. Sources said Moran has close ties to ABC News vice president and Washington DC bureau chief Rick Klein. Moran had ingratiated himself with Klein by expressing that he had some Trump-friendly views, such as the importance of networks providing unbiased coverage geared toward the entire country, which has been a White House criticism of left-leaning networks, one of the sources said. But the interview quickly turned testy, with Trump telling Moran that he agreed sit down with the correspondent because he 'never heard' of him. A source with knowledge said it wasn't that cut-and- dry and that Trump officials held conversations with the network about possible interviewers and that they agreed on Moran because of his national reporting and White House experience. According to reports, the president did not want to be interviewed by Stephanopoulos or star anchor David Muir, whom he previously criticized for wrongly fact-checking him during a September presidential debate. 'I was shocked that Trump picked him,' said a second source, who had previously worked with Moran. 'Terry is a little pompous. He would weigh in on things he had nothing to do with. He always wanted to voice his opinion — even in emails that he was cc'd on.' The source called the attack on Miller 'stupid.' 'Terry has always had a high opinion of his opinions,' the person said. ABC News said it suspended Moran over concerns about him violating the outlet's standards on impartiality and objectivity. 'ABC News stands for objectivity and impartiality in its news coverage and does not condone subjective personal attacks on others. The post does not reflect the views of ABC News and violated our standards — as a result, Terry Moran has been suspended pending further evaluation,' a spokesperson previously told The Post. Staffers lamented that Moran's outburst undermined the inroads OConnell had been making with the administration in recent months. OConnell and other network execs have taken trips to West Palm Beach, Fla. and held meetings with Trump officials, a source with knowledge said. One such meeting took place in December, shortly after ABC parent Disney paid $16 million to settle a defamation lawsuit against the network over 'This Week' anchor George Stephanopoulos for saying Trump was found guilty of raping E. Jean Carroll. A New York court had found Trump guilty of sexual assault — not rape, a key legal difference — in the civil case. Trump has denied wrongdoing in that case.