Birmingham mayor, city council file lawsuit against state over water utility board changes
The skyline of Birmingham, Alabama. Birmingham officials have filed a lawsuit against a new state law that would reduce the number of appointments from the city to the Birmingham Water Works Board. (John Coletti/The Image Bank)
The Alabama Legislature's 2025 session is over, and the lawsuits have begun.
After state lawmakers passed a bill reducing Birmingham's appointments to the Birmingham Water Works Board (BWWB), Birmingham officials filed a federal lawsuit to try to protect their controlling interest in the utility.
The city government currently appoints six of the nine directors on the board; SB 330, sponsored by Sen. Dan Roberts, R-Mountain Brook, converts BWWB into a regional authority with seven members and a single appointment from the city.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
A hearing on the lawsuit, filed before Gov. Kay Ivey signed the bill on May 7, was scheduled for Thursday but postponed. The law does not explicitly mention BWWB but its provisions reflect the make-up of the water utility. Currently, two directors are appointed by the mayor while the Birmingham City Council appoints four members.
A message was left with Gov. Kay Ivey's office Thursday seeking comment.
Proponents of the legislation said it was necessary to impose changes. In the past, the water utility has been beset with issues with billing, oversight and concerns over public trust. Customers reported concerns with unread meters and inaccurate water bills.
Under Roberts' bill, the governor, lieutenant governor and counties that own a major reservoir would each get an appointment. Birmingham's mayor and the president of the Jefferson County Commission also get an appointment. The governor's appointment must come from one of the counties served by the utility.
Another county located outside the area where the utility is based gets to also appoint a board member. The governing body of the municipality where the regional water utility is located appoints a director. Finally, that law states that a resident where the water utility is located may also be a member of the Board.
The remaining members are selected, respectively, by the Jefferson County Mayors Association, the Shelby County Commission and Blount County Commission.
The lawsuit alleges the bill the equal rights and due process protections in the U.S. and Alabama constitutions. The lawsuit says that lawmakers in the Legislature, most of whom are white, reduced the power of officials in Birmingham whose population is 67% Black and forms 41% of the utility's customer base.
The lawsuit also notes that other areas with representation are mostly white. In Blount County, it says, only about 2% of the residents are Black, and in Walker County, only 6% are Black.
'SB330 violates the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution,' the lawsuit states.
Plaintiffs listed in the lawsuit also stated that the law violates their right to due process because any changes to the board require changes to the Certificate of Incorporation, which is not part of the legislation, that must be approved by Birmingham City Council. The law changes the Certificate of Incorporation by reducing the number of members that the city council may appoint, which members of the Council did not approve.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey speaks to future leaders during University of Alabama visit
Over 400 rising high school seniors gathered at the University of Alabama for the 83rd session of the American Legion Auxiliary Alabama Girls State program. Throughout the week of June 1-6, delegates gained hands-on experience in a model state government. Participants wrote bills, debated them on the House and Senate floor, participated in party caucuses and ran for office. They also heard from a variety of speakers including Gov. Kay Ivey, a former Girls State lieutenant governor, and U.S. Sen. Katie Britt, who was elected Girls State governor in 1999. The session was scheduled to culminate with a trip to Montgomery to visit with elected officials, hold lawmaking sessions at the State House and tour the Capitol, the Alabama Supreme Court and Governor's Mansion. Organizers say the Girls State program provides delegates with a better understanding of how government works and a sense of patriotism while building self-confidence and lasting friendships. More: Boys State at University of Alabama aims to create good citizens "Alabama Girls State is a fun-filled, hands-on learning opportunity in good citizenship training for some of the best and brightest young women in the State of Alabama. Sponsored by the American Legion Auxiliary, Alabama Girls State is a premier youth leadership program which offers a one-of-a-kind experience to its delegates," said Lee Sellers, program director, in news release. This year featured the largest delegation of girls to have ever attended Alabama Girls State, with the more than 400 rising seniors representing high schools throughout Alabama. UA also hosted the Boys State program May 25-31. This year marks the first time UA has hosted Boys and Girls State since 2021. Ivey spoke to delegates June 5 at Moody Music Building on the University of Alabama campus. During her remarks, Ivey shared her personal experiences at Girls State and how the program has influenced her political career. "My time here at Girls State has allowed me to mentor and to be mentored by women across every corner of the state of Alabama, forming friendships that are not just good and strong, but long-lasting," Ivey said. After graduating from Auburn University in 1967, worked as a high school teacher and a bank officer. She served as reading clerk for the Alabama House of Representatives under then-Speaker Joseph C. McCorquodale and she served as assistant director at the Alabama Development Office In 2002, Ivey was elected to the first of two terms as Alabama's treasurer and in 2010, she was elected to the first of two terms as lieutenant governor. On April 10, 2017, Ivey was sworn in as Alabama's 54th governor after the resignation of Robert Bentley. She filled out the rest of Bentley's term before winning the gubernatorial election in 2018 and she was re-elected in 2022. She is the first Republican woman to serve as Alabama's governor but she's the second woman to hold the state's top executive office. Tuscaloosa County native Lurleen B. Wallace, a Democrat, became Alabama's first female governor in 1966. Ivey emphasized the importance of citizenship, the constitution and the military during her Girls State speech. Ivey said she doesn't let being a female in a male-dominated field discourage her and she encouraged delegates to pursue their goals. Ivey said she believes that success should be measured by a person's qualifications and not their gender. "I strongly believe that whoever is the most-qualified person should be the one to get the job. And as I like to say, sometimes the best man for a job is a woman," Ivey said. Ivey concluded her speech by inspiring the delegates to carry the values of Girls State into their future endeavors. More: Accessing local journalism is even easier with the News app "Girls State is not just a week. It's a state of mind, an attitude and a way of thinking that has stuck with me my entire life," said Ivey, who grew up in the town of Camden in Wilcox County. ".... (You should) leave Girls State this week with an understanding of the beauty of our democracy is that all people, even a girl, from a little town in Wilcox County can make a difference if we try," she said. Reach Jasmine Hollie at JHollie@ This article originally appeared on The Tuscaloosa News: Gov. Kay Ivey says Girls State offers opportunity for future leaders
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Biden book author reveals how White House staff truly felt about Karine Jean-Pierre as press secretary
CHICAGO - One of the authors of the new bombshell Joe Biden book pulled back the curtain Thursday on how White House staffers truly felt about former White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre. During their book tour in Chicago, "Original Sin" authors Alex Thompson and Jake Tapper were asked about the announcement of Jean-Pierre's new book promising to shed light on the "broken White House" she worked in and that she left the Democratic Party to become an independent. "Someone just texted me before I got on stage, a former Biden person, which is, 'It is quite the ballet move to say that you're leaving the Democratic Party because they were disloyal to Joe Biden.' But that is what she's saying," Thompson told the Windy City audience Thursday at The Vic Theatre. Biden-era White House Reporters Express Disbelief On Karine Jean-pierre's Sudden Party Switch Thompson noted that despite "mass bad reviews" within the Biden administration of Jean-Pierre's job performance as White House press secretary, she was seen as "untouchable" due to her allyship with top Jill Biden aide Anthony Bernal. "I think what's really provoking anger from former Biden people… there was mass frustration on how she went about the job, felt that she was not good at it, was not aware she was not good at it, she did not try hard to get better at it. And there's more focus on elevating her own profile than not," Thompson said. Read On The Fox News App "And now for her to then go out after the Democratic Party elevated her to the top spokesperson job in the country and then for her to then try to sell books by leaving the party, they say that simmering resentment just exploded instantly," the Axios reporter added. Tapper speculated that there would have been less "scorn" aimed at Jean-Pierre if she didn't announce she had become an independent, something the CNN anchor made little sense to him. Credibility Crisis: Karine Jean-pierre's Defense Of Biden's Mental Fitness Over The Years The event moderator, NPR media correspondent David Folkenflik, asked Tapper and Thompson why former Biden staffers by and large "aren't using their names" as they criticize Jean-Pierre. "I totally wonder that too," Tapper reacted. "Because, like, what are you afraid of?" Click Here For The Latest Media And Culture News Thompson responded by insisting many of them don't want to speak publicly because they have since landed new jobs and don't want their employers to be associated with the mudslinging. "I'd also say that the Biden culture was to punish and try to destroy people who spoke out," Thompson said. "And yes, they don't have power anymore, but they are watching very closely. I think some people still fear retaliation." Tapper added that since Jean-Pierre was a trailblazer" as the first Black woman and LGBTQ press secretary, that was another reason why her former colleagues aren't speaking out. Both authors took turns scrutinizing Jean-Pierre's credibility following her loyal defense of Biden before and after his disastrous debate performance. Tapper recalled a 2023 private fundraiser Biden attended in which he didn't have a teleprompter and how he told donors his canned remarks about how the events of Charlottesville inspired his presidential run in 2020 twice in the span of a few minutes, and how at the following press briefing, Jean-Pierre told reporters, "Well, that's how strongly he feels about that moment." "In her defense, she rarely saw him," Tapper article source: Biden book author reveals how White House staff truly felt about Karine Jean-Pierre as press secretary
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
He was 20 when he was sentenced to death. Now he hopes US Supreme Court will hear his case
A man on Mississippi's death row is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to take a look at his case while he continues seeking other federal relief. Terry Pitchford, 39, was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death in 2006 for the death of a man in a Grenada County grocery store during an armed robbery in 2004. In 2023, Terry Pitchford's conviction and death sentence were set aside and a new trial was ordered by a federal district court judge. The state appealed and the conviction and sentence were reinstated after a ruling in favor of the state by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Mississippi: Man whose death sentence was overturned in 2023 is now facing death again. Here's why Now Pitchford is hoping the nation's highest court will review his case while he also continues to work on other aspects of the case in the Mississippi Northern District of U.S. District Court. The state has until July 3 to file a brief opposing Pitchford's petition. The Supreme Court may consider Pitchford's petition at the opening conference of the October term. Pitchford is asking the Supreme Court to review his Batson claim, which refers to jury selection in which race, ethnicity or gender played a role in excluding potential jurors. During jury selection at Pitchford's trial, then-District Attorney Doug Evans "used four of his allotted 12 peremptory strikes to remove four of the five Black venirepersons provisionally seated in the jury's empaneling," court records show. Evans was accused of doing the same during the prosecution of Curtis Flowers, who stood trial six times for the murders of four people at a furniture store in Winona. The U.S. Supreme Court in 2019 overturned Flowers' conviction for the last time, with Justice Brett Kavanaugh "citing a 'relentless, determined effort to rid the jury of Black individuals,'" according to an earlier story. In Pitchford's case, during his appeal, the Mississippi Supreme Court said Pitchford should have raised objections at his initial trial if he wanted to contest the jury selection. The court's decision in favor of the state was not unanimous. Two justices disagreed with the ruling, saying "the record showed that D.A. Evans used peremptory strikes in an intentionally racially discriminatory manner," according to court documents. The federal court agreed with the dissenters and set aside Pitchford's conviction and ordered a new trial. The federal appellate court looked at the case and determined the Mississippi Supreme Court did not err when it considered the Batson claim and reinstated Pitchford's conviction and sentence. Now it will be up to the U.S. Supreme Court to weigh in, if it decides to review the case. Lici Beveridge is a reporter for the Hattiesburg American and Clarion Ledger. Contact her at lbeveridge@ Follow her on X @licibev or Facebook at This article originally appeared on Mississippi Clarion Ledger: Mississippi death row inmate asks SCOTUS for help
