HPD vacancy task force under Council scrutiny
The Honolulu City Council is set to vote Wednesday on a proposed task force to reduce the Honolulu Police Department's dire staffing shortage of 456 uniformed officer vacancies—which despite mitigation efforts has grown 32 % in some four years.
Council member Andria Tupola, who introduced Resolution 160 to form a task force, says HPD's staffing shortage is an ongoing crisis that puts the public at risk.
'We can't be burning days. This is a big issue, ' said Tupola during the Council's Public Safety Committee meeting Thursday. 'By the end of this year, we don't want to hit 500 ' police officer vacancies.
The Council's Public Safety Committee has recommended that the City Council adopt Resolution 160 to fill vacancies and promote officer retention at HPD.
Tupola's resolution states HPD 'is currently experiencing a severe staffing shortage, with 456 uniformed officer vacancies as of February 2025, compared to 345 vacancies in February 2021, despite ongoing efforts to reduce the shortage.'
'This staffing shortage has resulted in inadequate police coverage across Oahu, increased emergency response times, unmanageable caseloads for police detectives, and increased safety risks for both officers and the public, ' the legislation says.
Resolution 160 highlights that in 2024, HPD conducted an internal 'Commander Performance Survey ' in which survey responses noted 'high vacancy rates, increased workloads, insufficient resources, and overall safety risks.'
Tupola's resolution alleges that HPD's inability to resolve its officer vacancies rests with its leadership, in this case Police Chief Arthur 'Joe ' Logan.
'The City Council finds it necessary to hold the Chief of Police accountable for the failure to adequately address vacancies in a timely and effective manner, which has directly contributed to the current crisis, and to take swift action to resolve this issue, ' Resolution 160 states. 'Council believes it is critical to establish a task force to develop actionable strategies for reducing vacancies, improving retention, and ensuring that the HPD can effectively serve and protect Oahu communities.'
Logan did not immediately respond to the Honolulu Star-Advertiser's request for comment.
Tupola's resolution also noted that part of HPD's challenge is that the department is not using all of its annual appropriations. In fiscal year 2024, HPD's patrol division let approximately $15 million in funding lapse—the largest lapsed amount of any city department, according to the Status of the City's Finances 2025 report issued by the Office of Council Services.
The report also noted that HPD let $50 million of its overall fiscal year 2024 appropriation lapse. To put that into perspective, in March, HPD submitted a fiscal year 2026 operating budget request of nearly $400 million to fight crime.
Resolution 160 also requests that the task force 'remain in effect to monitor progress on its recommendations and may be dissolved by the Council once (HPD ) demonstrates sustained improvement in recruitment, retention, and staff levels.'
Tupola announced at Thursday's meeting that she had taken part in a recent meeting to discuss the task force proposal with Logan, Council Public Safety Committee Chair Val Okimoto and Police Commission Chair Kenneth Silva.
She said the group 'all agreed that a written plan about addressing the vacancies, and not just recruitment (but ) also retention ' was needed and that budget-line items needed to delineate how to 'fund each of the things that we think will help the department move forward.'
Tupola thanked city Managing Director Mike Formby for his assistance.
'He's been participating in a lot of these discussions, so he's included as well in the list of nine people ' on the task force, she added.
Tupola noted that the State of Hawaii Organization of Police Officers and the Hawaii Government Employees Association could 'also play a role ' in advising Logan on how to retain positions or recruit to fill vacancies.
The task force, Tupola said, also should have a representative from an outside police department.
HPD Maj. Parker Bode, assigned to the department's Human Resources Division, told the committee that he favored Resolution 160.
'We support the intent of the task force, ' he said.
Eddie Fujioka, a retired city Emergency Medical Services district chief, was among others who testified in support of forming a task force. Fujioka said he was pleased that a focus of Tupola's resolution is shoring up police dispatchers.
'I've noticed that the Police Department has always been short of dispatchers, ' he said. 'They're the primary answering point for the County of Honolulu, which means every 911 call must go to the Police Department, and it's routed to either EMS or Ocean Safety.'
He added that HPD's dispatchers 'are the only dispatchers who are nonuniformed personnel, which means they make the lowest wages of any dispatcher in the county, yet they do the most amount of work, answer the most amount of calls.'
'And I've seen times when they're on skeleton crew and when a dispatcher who's on the radio has to go on a break, another dispatcher has to manage two districts, which is very dangerous and stressful for the dispatchers, ' Fujioka said.
Council member Esther Kia 'aina suggested increasing the task force's 90-day timeline to produce a written report to 180 days.
'People who are going to be part of this task force will have their own opinions, and you don't rush something, ' Kia 'aina said. 'You discuss it and ensure that out of the collective voices you will hopefully have a unified front to wean out what should be actionable items.'
Tupola said she was agreeable to a verbal amendment to increase the timeline to 180 days, but said, 'It does not prohibit us from finishing it faster.'
Waianae Coast Neighborhood Board Chair Philip Ganaban told the Star-Advertiser after the meeting that his board supports Tupola's Resolution 160.
A lifelong Waianae resident, Ganaban said increasing police presence in the area is a good thing, but it won't solve all crimes that occur there, particularly gun-related violence involving youth and families.
'We need to really find ways to make things positive for these kids, ' he said, adding that the cost of living and a lack of youth-oriented programs along the Waianae Coast increase the challenges. 'So these kids can fall into the wrong crowd, and can get them things that they can't do the legal way—which comes with the guns.'
'Don't get me wrong, I would love to have more police, ' he added, 'but I think it's not going to prevent anything.'
To promote prevention and education, Ganaban said he favors restarting Drug Abuse Resistance Education, or D.A.R.E., or the Scared Straight program where at-risk youth are exposed to jail or prison life.
'Those are good programs that are not in the schools anymore, and I don't know why, ' he said. 'That's one of those HPD things that they did have that actually really made a difference when it started at a young age with the kids.'
Jeff Merz, the Waikiki Neighborhood Board's Subdistrict 1 vice chair, said he favored improvements to HPD's staffing but also recognized that crime in the island's prime tourist zone will still occur.
'Again, anything we can do to shed light on the issue is good, but I'd like to see some absolutes, or some things that come out of this that are actionable and that would need to be required to be taken by the city, ' Merz, a 23-year Waikiki resident, said of the proposed task force. 'If those are the recommendations that they have to implement, or try to make them so we can solve this issue, as opposed to coming up with a report and putting it on the shelf.'
'So I think if it's got some teeth to it, and the City Council and the mayor agree to implement the recommendations, then I think we have something to stand on there, ' he added.
However, Merz noted recruiting for police officers in high-priced Oahu is difficult.
'We're not the only city suffering from a lack of police officers ; it's nationwide, ' he said. 'Possibly, we're not going to be able to fill all of those positions ; it's expensive in Hawaii, and it's just not an occupation that a lot of people want to pursue.'
Merz said employing new technologies—including ground-based surveillance cameras and aerial drones—may be alternate ways for law enforcement to reduce crime in Waikiki and elsewhere on the island.
TASK FORCE REQUIREMENTS The HPD staffing and retention task force, formed by Resolution 160, will be composed of the following nine members :—The Council chair, or the chair's designee—A representative from the mayor's office—The chief of police, or the chief's designee—A Honolulu Police Commission representative—A city Department of Human Resources representative—A State of Hawaii Organization of Police Officers representative—A Hawaii Government Employees Association representative—A current HPD officer, to be appointed by the Council—A representative from another police department with success in reducing officer vacancies, also to be appointed by the Council.
Once formed, Resolution 160 says the new task force should study the following issues :—Analyze HPD recruitment and retention challenges and identify the primary causes of vacancies.—Review and evaluate existing hiring and retention initiatives, including financial incentives.—Assess HPD's hiring standards to determine whether they are unnecessarily restrictive and preventing qualified applicants from being hired.—Develop a strategic plan with short-and long-term recommendations to reduce vacancies and improve officer retention.—Evaluate HPD's budget to ensure funding is directed toward staffing priorities.—Submit a report to the Council within 180 days of the adoption of the resolution, which provides the task force's analysis and recommendations, and provide a copy of the report to the Honolulu Police Commission to support its evaluation of the chief of police.
Source : Resolution 160
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Honolulu City Council adopts $5.19B budget package
Two late votes by the Hono lulu City Council Wednesday evening finalized approval of a $5.19 billion budget package for the city's 2026 fiscal year, which begins July 1. The Council unanimously adopted a $3.91 billion executive operating budget, which in general will fund city salaries, police and fire services and street and parks maintenance. The panel also fully passed a $1.28 billion capital improvement program budget meant to pay for infrastructure improvements. The Council-approved budget is a 10.4 % increase over Honolulu's current $4.7 billion budget, which expires June 30. Mayor Rick Blangiardi has within 10 days to sign the budget bills into law. The latest budget includes $1.5 million toward new ambulances and six full-time equivalent positions to improve emergency response times on Oahu, particularly in Maunawili, Ko Olina, and Koolaupoko. Council additions also include $500, 000 in traffic safety upgrades near school zones, and $400, 000 in community policing support for all eight Honolulu Police Department districts, among other funding. And under the finalized CIP budget, Council member Andria Tupola successfully added $1.7 million to pay for the long-awaited improvements to an unfinished Waianae Police Station at 85-939 Farrington Highway. 'So we can finish the project, ' she added. But of note on the Council's latest budget vote was the hours-long delay toward its approval. Following back-and-forth discussions inside Honolulu Hale's Council Chambers Wednesday, the panel took a meeting recess after 5 p.m. The Council's final votes cast came after 9 p.m., in a meeting that began over 12 hours earlier. 'The extended recesses were required to carefully review and reconcile the Council member's changes in the draft legislation on the floor, ' a Council spokesperson told the Honolulu Star-Advertiser Thursday. On Wednesday, changes arose after Council Chair Tommy Waters' introduced a new floor draft of Bill 22—the executive operating budget—that morning. In that bill, Waters looked to redirect up to $19.1 million in previously appropriated but unused, or 'lapsed, ' city departmental funds to bolster the city's sewer fund, as a way to defray the cost of anticipated multiyear sewer fee rate increases expected to start July 1. 'We have established a provisional account with the general fund to allow the sewer fund to access it as a contingency when needed, ' Waters said. 'If the funds go unused for sewer activities they will lapse back into the general fund.' But city staff balked. 'We were kind of confused and surprised this morning when we saw the posted (floor draft ) by yourself, Chair Waters, ' city Department of Budget and Fiscal Services Director Andy Kawano said at the meeting. He added, 'It doesn't make sense to take funding out of departments for salaries and current expenses and set aside in a provisional for sewer activities when we, in fact, should not use it.' Kawano stated such an action could harm the city's AA + bond rating—the city's creditworthiness that impacts its ability to do bond financing—as the city tackles federally mandated, multibillion-dollar upgrades to its sewer treatment infrastructure and related utilities. Waters' floor draft—opposed by city staffers and questioned by Council members—later evaporated. Waters' attempt to add general funds mirrored his introduction of Bill 43 last month—a measure which was ultimately postponed during a recent meeting of the Council's Executive Management committee. On May 5, Waters advanced Bill 43, meant to redirect a portion of the 3 % visitor-generated Oahu transient accommodations tax, which in part is earmarked for Honolulu's rail project, to the city's sewer fund. But the chief critic of Waters' measure—BFS Director Kawano—asserted such an action was not a feasible option for the city to pursue. 'This measure will negatively impact the city's general fund and deviate from the intended purpose of the TAT, which is to provide general fund capacity to fund city services ; mitigate the strain visitors place on public facilities, emergency serv ices, and natural resources ; and provide additional funding for rail (i.e., 'Skyline') construction, ' Kawano wrote in a May 12 letter to Council. In related business Wednesday, the Council on a split vote adopted its version of city-initiated Bill 60, which deals with anticipated increases to the city's sewer fee rates. As part of the budget process, the Blangiardi administration proposed a 10-year, 115 % sewer fee rate increase that's expected to begin this summer. City officials say sewer fee hikes are necessary to support the city Department of Environmental Services' ongoing wastewater operations and maintenance efforts, as well as a $10.1 billion capital improvement program for Oahu's wastewater collection and treatment system that's planned through 2040. And they assert the work includes a $2.5 billion upgrade to the Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant as required under a 2010 federal consent decree. On Wednesday, the Council voted 5-4—with Esther Kia 'aina, Scott Nishimoto, Tupola and Waters dissenting—on Budget Committee Chair Tyler Dos Santos-Tam's draft of Bill 60, which shaves the city's decade-long span for increased rates down to about six years. That plan would start Jan. 1, 2026, and run through 2031. As approved, Bill 60's sewer fee increases for a household that uses about 6, 000 gallons of water per month—deemed 50 % of all single-family households in Honolulu—equates to a 6 % increase in sewer fees in fiscal year 2026, 7.5 % in fiscal year 2027, 8.5 % in fiscal year 2028, followed by 9 % over the remaining three fiscal years. After the year 2031, sewer rates would increase 3 % annually. As proposed, a household that uses 6, 000 gallons a month is currently charged $99.77 on average. By year 2031, that average bill would rise to $160.85, a more than 61 % increase, ENV data indicates. Under Dos Santos-Tam's Bill 60, ENV will have authority to set up a program called Customer Assistance for Residential Environmental Services, or CARES, to help with 'affordability and equity ' of increased sewer fee rates. Sewer customers who qualify based on household income of less than 80 % area median income will be eligible for a $20 to $25 credit on their monthly base fee. The program will be funded at $10 million per year. Customers will have to apply for the program to prove eligibility and then be re-verified every six months, ENV states. Still, not all were happy with Bill 60's approval. 'Really listen to your constituents because we're going to feel the effects, ' Oahu resident Tara Rojas said with disappointment, during remote public testimony to the Council. 'And this is only sewer (fees ), not even including anything else.'
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cuomo vows ‘top to bottom review' of key NYC housing agency, stirring mixed responses
Andrew Cuomo is pledging he would as mayor 'cut out the bureaucracy' from New York City's Department of Housing Presevation and Development, arguing it's riddled with 'red tape' — a proposal welcomed by real estate industry players but that is raising alarm bells among tenant advocates. The issue emerged in Wednesday night's first Democratic mayoral primary debate, when Cuomo said he would 'blow up' the department in order to address the city's housing crisis. The agency — which is tasked with helping finance affordable housing construction, enforce tenant protections and administer certain rental assistance programs — has become an 'obstacle' to the mission of building more apartments across the city, Cuomo added. Asked Thursday to elaborate on what Cuomo meanty, his spokesman Rich Azzopardi said the ex-governor 'believes HPD is too slow and too inefficient in fulfilling its core functions.' 'If elected mayor, among his first duties would be to order a top to bottom review of the agency and then implement a plan to cut out the bureaucracy, cut the red tape and make it functional in a reasonable manner,' Azzopardi told the Daily News. Azzopardi said the ex-governor's critical view of HPD applies to all its sectors — affordable housing financing, tenant protection enforcement and rental assistance administration. Cuomo's housing plan released last month didn't include the proposal to overhaul HPD, which has an annual budget of more than $1.5 billion. The plan includes the production of 500,000 new housing units in the city over 10 years, but did not spell out how many of those apartments would be affordable. The plan also said Cuomo would as mayor oppose most up-zoning efforts in outer-borough neighborhoods, a stance at odds with HPD's focus under Mayor Adams to facilitate more affordable housing construction in pockets of the city that have historically produced little of it. Housing has emerged as a key issue in this year's mayoral race as the city reels from skyrocketing rents and a dearth of vacant apartments, and there's widespread agreement more units must be built. However, there are disagreements over what sort of affordability requirements should be placed on developers, with moderate politicians like Cuomo championing looser restrictions while more left-leaning stakeholders want most new apartments reserved for low-income New Yorkers. Cuomo, who's polling as the favorite to win the June 24 Democratic mayoral primary, floated the push for restructuring HPD as his mayoral run has taken in millions of dollars in donations from real estate industry executives and landlord lobby groups, who often air concerns about the need to reform the agency. As first reported by Politico Thursday, Housing for All, a super PAC funded by one of the city's largest landlord lobbies, is plunking down $2.5 million on airing ads boosting Cuomo's run. The lobby group, the New York Apartment Association, which mostly represents landlords of rent-stabilized buildings, vehemently opposes efforts to freeze rent for the city's stabilized tenants, a proposal several of Cuomo's mayoral race opponents, including runner-up candidate Zohran Mamdani, have embraced. Kenny Burgos, the New York Apartment Association's CEO, lauded Cuomo for promising to 'blow up' the HPD, saying the agency is 'choking the market' from producing more housing. 'It is bringing on layers upon layers of violations to owners, where there are scenarios where owners can't even clear the violations because of HPD mismanagement,' Burgos said. 'So, you know, any candidate talking about completely reforming the agency that has really huge overarching powers on regulated housing, I'd say is a good approach.' But Brooklyn Councilman Lincoln Restler, a progressive Democrat who used to be a senior adviser to ex-Mayor Bill de Blasio, including on housing and tenant issues, said Cuomo's proposal is 'dangerous' and voiced concern his comments signal he's open to the real estate industry's push to roll back tenant protections and rent regulations. 'Cuomo is going to do the bidding of wealthy real estate interests who had paid for his campaign, not meet the needs of the people of New York City,' Restler said. Mamdani, who's consistently polling in second place in the mayor's race, told The News: 'HPD doesn't need to be 'blown up' — it needs to be fully staffed so it can protect tenants and get affordable housing built.' A city government official involved in the Adams administration's affordable housing efforts argued HPD has undergone various reforms in recent years to streamline the agency's operations. In the last fiscal year, HPD financed 14,706 newly-constructed affordable homes. 'HPD is already blowing up the status quo, making it easier to build new apartments and easier to get into affordable housing,' said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity. Cea Weaver, director of the left-leaning Housing Justice for All group, acknowledged there are many roadblocks to affordable housing production, but also argued HPD isn't one of them. 'A top to bottom review, that sounds like a hell of a lot bureaucracy,' she said. 'What needs to happen is to actually just let HPD operate.'
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
El Rancho water tower bowl now in place
A new landmark can now be seen in Duncan after the bowl for the El Rancho water tower was raised into place this week. Crews began work at 8 a.m. Monday, June 2 and spent most of the day raising the bowl, according to Loisdawn Jones, director of communications for the City of Duncan. She said workers 'hoisted the bowl more than 80 feet and affixed it to the tower, a process that took several hours.' 'Completing the eye-catching step of raising the bowl on the new El Rancho Water Tower is a significant milestone in City of Duncan's continuing efforts to update city water infrastructure,' a release from Jones' office states. Construction began on the water tower project in summer 2024. The first step in the project was establishing the foundation and tower pedestal. 'The full tower stands almost 100 feet tall, and the bowl is 40 feet tall and about 70 feet in diameter,' according to City of Duncan. The El Rancho water tower, which sits on the city's north end, 'holds 1 million gallons of water and replaces an aging water tower that is adjacent to the site,' according to the City of Duncan. While the bowl is now in place, the water tower will become fully functional later on in the year and provide water to 'almost 30,0000 residents across approximately 40 square miles with improved water supply, quality, and pressure.' City Manager Chris Deal said the raising of the bowl was a significant mile stone for the Duncan community. 'It is a proud day for Duncan and its citizens, as this is another piece of the overall efforts by Mayor Armstrong and Council to provide the best quality water for our community,' Deal said. City paperwork shows the El Rancho water tower funds come from a loan under the Oklahoma Water Resources Board Financial Assistance Program.
