logo
EXCLUSIVE Care home SLAMS Martha's Vineyard millionaire for 'stopping seniors from enjoying the beach'

EXCLUSIVE Care home SLAMS Martha's Vineyard millionaire for 'stopping seniors from enjoying the beach'

Daily Mail​01-06-2025
A care home on Martha's Vineyard has slammed a millionaire homeowner for allegedly gatekeeping a beach from its elderly and disabled residents.
Melinda Loberg, a longtime resident of the famed Massachusetts island, filed a lawsuit against Havenside - a non-profit corporation affiliated with the Island's Episcopal Churches and the Diocese of Boston - on May 12.
Havenside is a senior living facility that sits just behind Loberg's $5 million waterfront home - but a fierce legal war was launched after elderly residents were allegedly crossing into the homeowner's land to get to Vineyard Haven Harbor.
The care home, however, argues that they have always had a right to use the 13-foot corridor on the north side of her land to gain access to the beach.
Now, Lucinda Kirk, the property manager of Havenside Corporation, told DailyMail.com that Loberg's lawsuit is just 'a land grab against island seniors.'
The majority of Havenside's residents are disabled and elderly - and they deserve to 'enjoy the many health benefits of salt air and serenity,' she said.
In the suit, Loberg claimed that when she bought the home in 1992 she was never told about the easement access that the seniors allegedly have - triggering the neighborhood dispute last month.
Fighting back, Kirk told DailyMail.com: 'The lawsuit that our neighbors filed should be seen for what it is: A land grab against Island Seniors.
She has lived at her $5 million idyllic home on Crocker Avenue with her husband since July 1992. Havenside has since told Loberg its residents have a right to use a small path on her property to get to the water. (her property is circled in red on the left, and the senior home is circled on the right)
'The Lobergs want to incorporate our easement into their beach-front property, apparently without any care how that will affect Havenside's 36 Residents.
'Our neighbors are attempting to outspend us in legal proceedings to grab our land with bogus legal claims.'
Many of Havenside's residents don't just live in the apartments for affordable housing, but also 'have mobility disabilities and/or chronic health conditions,' the spokeswoman added.
Kirk added: 'The land of Havenside has an appurtenant easement which provides beach access for our Seniors. It is the safest and easiest way for our Residents to enjoy the many health benefits of salt air and serenity.
'The issue at stake for Havenside is not about money, but preserving safe and equal access to the beach for our senior Residents.'
The legal filing went on to state that any access rights were taken away before Havenside took over its property. Loberg also emphasized that she has been using the land for 30 years which voids the corporation's past claims to it.
Havenside said that information is false and that it has had an easement there since 1890, the Vineyard Gazette reported.
The specific area that the senior center is claiming to control is a space that the Loberg's 'cleared the existing vegetation' from, along with 'removed tires, bottles, car mats, and large chunks of macadam and then planted Parcel 2A with grass,' the documents read.
Following the cleanup, the couple decided to install a 170-foot fence along the area in question - cutting off access for more than two decades, the lawsuit stated.
Havenside said they planned to gain access to the beach by cutting the grass between the fence and garden beds to construct an entry gate, the filing continued.
After informing Loberg of its plans, the corporation sent a tenant by the name of Frank Rapoza over to the property, 'carrying tools,' so he could 'install' the fence, per the lawsuit.
Tensions quickly rose when Loberg saw him standing in her driveway ready to get to work, so much so that she threatened to call the police if he attempted to install the gate.
With that, Rapoza fled the property, but soon after Loberg received a phone call from him 'threatening to return and install the gate,' the lawsuit detailed.
'In response to this phone call, Plaintiff installed a "No Trespass" sign on the Property line near the Havenside Property,' it added.
A manager with Havenside then reached out to Loberg and stated that Rapoza 'was not an agent of Havenside or its Board. Any representation otherwise has never been authorized.'
Loberg, a former Tisbury select board member, chose to sit down with Havenside on July 14, 2024 to talk about the issue, but 'representatives were not inclined to discuss alternative solutions and instead insisted upon the existence of the purported access easement,' her lawsuit read.
Later that month, the corporation offered to 'remove' the easement in exchange for 'a cash payment,' but Loberg denied the 'extortive offer.'
By October of that year, Havenside filed a Wetlands Protection Act Notice of Intent (NOI) with the local Conservation Commission 'seeking approval to make improvements on Plaintiff's Property within the alleged Access Easement,' the lawsuit said.
In that filing, 'Havenside falsely claimed to be the owner of the Property, failing to accurately fill out Section 3 requiring them to list the Property Owner if different from the applicant,' it went on.
In February, the Loberg's said they 'discovered a group from Havenside, including Mr. Rapoza, trespassing on Plaintiff's Property and in the process of cutting Plaintiff's Fence in order to install a gate.'
Loberg then called the police who asked the group to vacate, but 'declined' to forcibly remove them, noting that it was a 'civil matter.'
The lawsuit also included an image of Rapoza, an alleged 'manager of Havenside,' and unknown person 'destroying a section of Plaintiff's Fence and installing the gate.'
A police report was also filed in relation to the incident.
'Mr. Rapoza subsequently returned and finished installing the Gate,' the lawsuit said, adding that Havenside has since added signage to the entrance of Loberg's property stating that residents are allowed to use that as an access point to the beach.
Loberg 'feels harassed and threatened by the conduct of Havenside's tenants and does not feel safe on her Property as a result of their conduct,' the filing concluded.
She has demanded that 'Havenside, its guests, tenants and invitees' are not allowed to access her property and that it does not benefit from any easement over the Plaintiff's Property for the purpose of accessing Vineyard Haven Harbor.'
An initial hearing was held on May 20 and the next is set for June 16, according to documents.
Kirk said Havenside is working on obtaining a pro bono lawyer to fight for residents to gain access to the waterfront.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Republicans propose bill to rename the Kennedy Center to the Donald J. Trump Center for the Performing Arts
Republicans propose bill to rename the Kennedy Center to the Donald J. Trump Center for the Performing Arts

The Independent

time11 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Republicans propose bill to rename the Kennedy Center to the Donald J. Trump Center for the Performing Arts

Republican Representative Bob Onder has proposed a bill to rename the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, D.C., after President Donald Trump. The proposed legislation, titled the 'Make Entertainment Great Again Act,' cites President Trump as a significant cultural icon and patron of the arts. This bill follows a separate amendment, introduced by Republican Representative Mike Simpson, to rename the Kennedy Center's Opera House after First Lady Melania Trump, which passed the House Appropriations Committee 33-25. President Trump recently replaced members of the Kennedy Center's board and became its chairman, stating his intention to ensure the institution was 'not going to be woke.' John F. Kennedy's grandson, Jack Schlossberg, has criticized these renaming efforts, suggesting President Trump is 'obsessed with being bigger than JFK.'

Ashlee Simpson and Evan Ross' burglary alarm sparks police visit to A-lister's LA home
Ashlee Simpson and Evan Ross' burglary alarm sparks police visit to A-lister's LA home

Daily Mail​

time12 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Ashlee Simpson and Evan Ross' burglary alarm sparks police visit to A-lister's LA home

The police were called to Ashlee Simpson and Evan Ross ' home after a burglary alarm was set off at their Los Angeles residence on Monday morning, according to a new report. Law enforcement sources told TMZ that cops responded to a possible burglary at the residence after receiving a call from someone connected to the couple regarding the alarm. It's unclear if Ashlee, 40, and her spouse, 36, were at home at the time of the incident, but neither contacted authorities themselves, insiders further told the site. A sweep of the home was reportedly conducted by police, however they found no clear indications of burglary or forced entry. It was determined by the authorities that either the alleged trespassers had left the scene or a false alarm had occurred, the site adds. has contacted representatives for the couple for comment but have yet to hear back. Ashlee and Evan have been married since 2014 and have daughter Jagger Snow, nine, and son Ziggy Blu, four, together. Ashlee also has 16-year-old son Bronx Mowgli with her ex-husband Pete Wentz. The possible burglary scare isn't the only one to make headlines this past month, with other big names in the Los Angeles area also targeted by alleged burglars. American Idol boss Robin Kaye and her husband Thomas DeLuca, both 70, were both shot to death at their home after walking in on an alleged burglar at their Los Angeles home. They were gunned down by the callous intruder who used the victims' own weapon that they had for self-defense. Raymond Boodarian, an Encino resident, was later arrested. Investigators believe Raymond was burglarizing the residence July 10 while the couple was away and shot them when they suddenly returned. The 22-year-old has been charged with two counts of murder and other offenses in relation to the deaths. Raymond is yet to enter a plea. His next court appearance is scheduled for August 20. He is currently being held without bail at the Twin Towers Correction Facility in downtown LA. An alleged attempted burglary also occurred at Teddi Mellencamp's Encino home earlier this month. Three individuals attempted to enter the Encino, CA property she shares with Arroyave but were foiled by her state-of-the-art home security system, which frightened them away and summoned law enforcement to the scene. She posted a video showing three figures - all dressed in black - jumping the main gate at the front of her estate before stalking across the driveway towards the house at 10:11pm. She then posted footage from another security camera in which the home invaders slipped through a small wooden side gate, venturing deeper into the property. One of the figures gingerly opened the side gate and ushered the other two in, whereupon the three of them crept along the side of the house. The one in front could be seen opening a backpack and pulling out a curved object that was not clearly identifiable on video. They all slowly made their way forward - only to suddenly wheel around and scurry back out the gate as they apparently realized the burglar alarm had caught wind of them. 'We are grateful that everyone is unharmed,' Mellencamp wrote in the caption of the post. 'While we are shaken, we are fortunate to have the latest in home security systems which scared off the intruders.' She added: 'Authorities were alerted and swiftly responded. We appreciate everyone's heightened concern in light of recent criminal activities in our area, but we are safe.' Law enforcement sources previously told TMZ that police responded to a burglary call and rushed to the scene. By the time officers arrived, the suspects had already fled. Authorities believe the individuals had just burglarized a neighboring home before attempting to break into Teddi's property.

At least three victims shot in mid-Manhattan skyscraper; suspect 'neutralized'
At least three victims shot in mid-Manhattan skyscraper; suspect 'neutralized'

Reuters

time39 minutes ago

  • Reuters

At least three victims shot in mid-Manhattan skyscraper; suspect 'neutralized'

NEW YORK, July 28 (Reuters) - A person who opened fire inside a midtown Manhattan skyscraper housing the National Football League headquarters and offices of several major financial institutions, including hedge fund giant Blackstone, has been "neutralized," the New York city police commissioner said. Police did not immediately make details of the shooting public, but a law enforcement source told Reuters at least one New York Police Department officer and two civilians were struck by gunfire and that the suspect was believed to be dead. The source said the information was preliminary, and the condition or extent of injuries sustained by the police officer and two others was not immediately known. The New York Post newspaper, citing unnamed police sources, reported that a gunman wearing a bullet-resistant vest and carrying an AR-style rifle had opened fire inside the Park Avenue skyscraper, wounding a police officer and a bystander. The Post reported they were in critical condition. The gunman, the Post reported, had barricaded himself inside the office tower, possibly on the 32nd floor of the building. A short time later, New York Police Commissioner Jessica Disch said on X: "At this time, the scene has been contained and the lone shooter has been neutralized." The skyscraper at 345 Park Avenue houses a number of financial firms, including Blackstone, the world's largest hedge fund, as well as KPMG and Deutsche Bank, along with the NFL headquarters and the Consulate General of Ireland. News media footage showed a large police presence in the area around the office tower. "There is an active shooter investigation taking place in Midtown right now," New York Mayor Eric Adams said in a statement on social media platform X as news of the shooting first surfaced. The FBI said agents from its New York field office were also responding to provide support at the scene.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store