Garbage offenders up, Laxmi Nagar tops NMC's shame list
2
Nagpur: Days after Nagpur slipped to 27th rank among million-plus cities in Swachh Survekshan 2024 rankings announced on Thursday, fresh data from Nagpur Municipal Corporation's nuisance detection squad (NDS) has laid bare the city's entrenched problem of civic indiscipline and ineffective enforcement.
From January 1 to June 30, 2025, the NDS team led by Virsen Tambe penalised 4,487 violators and collected Rs25.43 lakh in fines for garbage dumping in open, improper waste disposal by hotels and vendors, and other hygiene violations. Despite the decline in absolute numbers from previous years, the mid-year total already exceeds 40% of last year's annual count, suggesting another dismal year ahead for Nagpur's sanitation record.
At the heart of this problem lies Laxmi Nagar, which has consistently emerged as the worst-performing zone in terms of civic discipline. In just six months this year, the zone recorded 1,141 cases and Rs5.43 lakh in penalties — far ahead of any other zone. Over the past three years, Laxmi Nagar logged 4,310 cases in 2022, 3,692 in 2023, and 2,675 in 2024, topping NMC's shame list.
Other zones with significant offences this year include Mangalwari (917 cases, Rs4.67 lakh), Gandhibagh (491 cases, Rs3.02 lakh), and Hanuman Nagar (480 cases, Rs2.38 lakh).
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Buy the Dip: Top 5 Dividend Stocks with Growth Potential
Seeking Alpha
Read More
Undo
Meanwhile, Satranjipura zone, with only 70 violations and Rs8,800 in fines, appears to be the most compliant — or perhaps the least monitored.
The offenders are a mix of citizens throwing household waste in open spaces, shopkeepers not segregating garbage, and vendors — particularly meat, chicken, and vegetable sellers — who litter streets near markets. Despite routine inspections, civic officials admit that many repeat violators treat the fines as a negligible cost of doing business.
A year-wise comparison shows a steady decline in enforcement. NMC penalised 13,634 offenders in 2022 (Rs80.5 lakh), 14,011 in 2023 (Rs71.6 lakh), and 10,681 in 2024 (Rs54.4 lakh). The first half of 2025 alone has seen over Rs25 lakh in fines, raising questions about both citizen apathy and the administration's ability to drive behavioural change.
A senior health officer remarked, "We're trying our best with the limited manpower. But unless there's public ownership of cleanliness, Nagpur cannot improve." The consistent non-compliance in key zones, especially those with higher income and education levels, points to a deeper failure of civic responsibility rather than mere ignorance.
As monsoon aggravates hygiene risks and festivals approach, NMC faces a fresh challenge: enforcing discipline in a city where awareness drives have failed, and penalties are proving to be no deterrent.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Fazilpuria link or unpaid loan? All theories under scanner in Gurgaon murder
Gurgaon: Days after a gangster claimed responsibility for shooting dead a property dealer linked to rapper Fazilpuria, police are investigating another angle involving an unpaid loan. Delhi-based property dealer Rohit Shokeen's friend, a witness in the case, has told cops that the 39-year-old was asked to come to Gurgaon to collect Rs 30 lakh that he had lent years ago to a friend, Deepak Nandal. Sources said on Wednesday the witness told police that Nandal had borrowed the money from Shokeen in 2023 and hadn't returned it despite repeated requests. You Can Also Check: Gurgaon AQI | Weather in Gurgaon | Bank Holidays in Gurgaon | Public Holidays in Gurgaon Shokeen had even insulted Nandal over the debt to their common friends, and he was humiliated because of it, they said. The friendship between the two deteriorated after Shokeen's father last year filed a complaint with the Delhi commissioner's office, alleging that Nandal and his family were threatening them with consequences. Nandal, he said, had borrowed money from Shokeen to make a music video. On Aug 4, Shokeen was standing near his car near Palm Hills society in Sector 77 when two motorcyclists with their faces covered struck him with around a dozen bullets. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Doctors Shocked: New Weight Loss Trick Burns Fat Quickly Her Life & Health Learn More Undo Shokeen's Delhi-based friend survived the attack unhurt as he had just crossed the road to buy cigarettes. "The friend who accompanied Shokeen to Gurgaon but survived the attack told us that Nandal, who lives abroad, had asked him to collect the loaned money from his aides here. But we are still verifying the same," a police officer said. So far, investigators have not concluded any motive for the attack. After the Aug 4 murder, gangster Sunil Sardhania on social media claimed responsibility for killing Shokeen. "I, Sunil Sardhania, got Rohit Shokeen murdered at SPR Road in Gurgaon. Fazilpuria will have to pay our money or else many people will die in this fight," the post declared, mentioning even Deepak Nandal. The police officer told TOI cops are working to authenticate Sardhania's claim made online. TOI reported earlier this week that the murder could be the result of a bitter fallout between Fazilpuria and Nandal, who had previously produced the rapper's songs. Sardhania, a member of the Himanshu Bhai gang, purportedly warned the singer to return Rs 5 crore to Nandal, who had invested in building the rapper's career. Fazilpuria, however, consistently denied any loan arrangements and said that only music labels invested in his career. Cops had briefly detained a food delivery executive who witnessed the murder but was not linked to the shooting. The police officer said they have not found any evidence that indicates the involvement of Shokeen's friend who survived the attack in the murder plan. "We are investigating all possible angles and theories," the officer said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
‘Speed up decision on database of fake rape complaints'
New Delhi: Delhi High Court on Wednesday asked Delhi Police and state govt to expeditiously decide a plea that wants a database of those who file multiple fake complaints of sexual offences, much along the lines of a sex offenders registry. A bench comprising Chief Justice DK Upadhyaya and Justice Tushar Rao Gedela was hearing a PIL that sought its intervention in the form of directions to the police to make people aware of women who repeatedly file fake rape cases. Though declining to issue any directions, the court pointed out that the petitioner had already raised the issue by making a representation to Delhi Police and other authorities and the same should be decided by the authorities in a time bound manner. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi Without expressing any opinion on the merit of the plea, HC disposed of the plea by asking the police to decide the representation. On the petitioner's request to pass a direction to the authorities concerned to maintain the database, the court said, it was the authorities' domain and "they know better how the policing is to be done" refusing to pass specific directions. "Without expressing any merit on the issues raised, the petition is disposed of with the direction to the authorities to take an informed decision on the petitioner's representation with expedition. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Magnesium Deficiency Causes Heart Attacks! Never Ignore These 32 Symptoms Undo The petition stands disposed of accordingly," the court said. It was hearing a PIL by one Shonee Kapoor seeking a direction to the govt and Delhi Police to maintain a database at each police district headquarter "regarding the complainants who have registered more than one complaint of allegation of rape or sexual offences and mandatorily take the identity card—preferably Aadhaar card—from the complainants." The plea alleged a rampant misuse of the rape laws at the instance of a few complainants and highlighted that even courts have been forced to express concern about such fake cases.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Fake ED officers rob trader of Rs 70 lakh, gold
1 2 Vijayawada: In a shocking case of impersonation and organised robbery, four individuals — two of them dressed in police uniform — allegedly posed as Enforcement Directorate (ED) officials and fled with Rs 70 lakh in cash and some quantity of raw gold from a jeweller near Medikonduru on Sunday. The incident came to light after the trader lodged a formal complaint with the local police. According to Medikonduru circle inspector Nagul Meera, the complainant, Mani Jagadeesh, is a resident of Guntupalli in Ibrahimpatnam mandal. He is a recent entrepreneur, who opened a gold and silver testing shop named Sri Swami Samartha Gold & Silver Testing Centre in Vijayawada last month. Prior to this, Jagadeesh worked at a similar shop in Rajamahendravaram, where he came in contact with a person named Ranjith Maruthi Peta. Around 15 days ago, Ranjith contacted Jagadeesh and informed him about the availability of raw gold at Rs 5,000 per gram. Acting on the offer, Jagadeesh purchased five grams of raw gold through an unidentified person, paying Rs 25,000. Satisfied with the initial transaction, Jagadeesh later decided to procure two kilograms of raw gold at Rs 58 lakh per kilogram. For this larger deal, Jagadeesh, along with his friend Praveen from Kakinada, travelled to Rajamahendravaram. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Jolie-Pitt Family Shows Support For Shiloh's Change Drivepedia Undo There, they agreed to pay Rs 70 lakh initially and finalise the remaining payment later. On Sunday, Jagadeesh, Praveen, Ranjith, and a few others began their journey from Palnadu district's Sattenapalli in two vehicles after holding discussions about the gold trade. Jagadeesh's car was intercepted on the outskirts of Medikonduru by people in another vehicle. Four individuals, including two dressed as police officers, confronted the group. Claiming to be ED officials, the impersonators threatened the victims and forcibly took away Rs 70 lakh in cash along with the raw gold that was in Jagadeesh's possession. Following the incident, Jagadeesh approached the local police on Monday and filed a formal complaint. He also reported that Ranjith Maruthi Peta, who facilitated the deal, since went missing and was untraceable. Medikonduru police have registered a case based on Jagadeesh's complaint and have launched a manhunt for the suspects. Efforts are underway to track down the culprits using surveillance footage and mobile data records.
