Post Office compensation happening far too slowly, damning report finds
A report by the cross-party Public Accounts Committee (PAC) found victims of the Horizon IT scandal are still not getting the payouts they deserve with the Government taking 'insufficient' action
Compensation for Post Office scandal victims is still moving "too slowly", a damning report has found.
Cross-party MPs found not enough is being done to make sure those affected by the Horizon IT failings are applying for payouts. One scheme for wrongly convicted postmasters has not had a single full claim, the Public Accounts Committee found.
It says the Government has taken "insufficient action" to make sure those who are entitled to compensation actually receive it. Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, who chairs the committee, said: "Thousands of people were failed deeply by the system.
"This Committee would have hoped to have found government laser-focused on ensuring all those eligible were fully and fairly compensated for what happened. It is deeply dissatisfactory to find these schemes still moving far too slowly, with no government plans to track down the majority of potential claimants who may not yet be aware of their proper entitlements."
By March the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) had written to 18,500 people making them aware of the Horizon Shortfall Scheme. But just one in five letters received a response - and there are no plans to follow up, the committee report said.
MPs found that 25 of 111 eligible victims had not applied to another scheme relating to convictions in the most complex cases. Sir Geoffrey said: "It is entirely unacceptable that those affected by this scandal, some of whom have had to go through the courts to clear their names, are being forced to relitigate their cases a second time."
More than 700 postmasters were wrongly convicted, and many more suffered after dodgy computer systems made it look like money was missing from their branches.
Elsewhere the committee found the department had been "dangerously flatfooted" in trying to recoup nearly £2billion in Covid-related fraud.
It found DBT had recovered just £130million in payouts from lenders, while the National Investigation Service (NATIS) had got back a "minimal" £8.6million from Bounce Back loan fraud. Business owners inflated their turnover to secure more cash to stay afloat during the crisis, costing the taxpayer huge sums.
Sir Geoffrey said: "DBT were unable to tell us if even the tiny fraction of that sum recovered was in fact even related to fraud. Indeed, relying on government-backed lenders to recover losses, who thus lack any incentive to pursue lost funds, has been a dangerously flatfooted approach.
"Now that the Insolvency Service has taken over responsibility for viable cases, we look forward to hearing how it fares where others have failed."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
26 minutes ago
- Reuters
New Zealand draft infrastructure plan outlines need for more hospitals, electricity
WELLINGTON, June 25 (Reuters) - New Zealand on Wednesday released a draft 30-year national infrastructure plan, which highlighted a need for the country to invest more in hospitals and electricity production and to prepare to spend more on responding to national disasters. The plan aims to improve infrastructure preparations and introduce a less politically driven approach to infrastructure investment, which critics say has been impacted by electoral cycles with the stop-start results being costly for large projects. 'We want the National Infrastructure Plan to help build common ground about our areas of need and what is affordable for Kiwis, giving the Government of the day guidance for making decisions about infrastructure,' said Geoff Cooper, chief executive of the New Zealand Infrastructure Commission. The draft plan said the country needed to establish affordable and sustainable funding, make it easier to build new infrastructure, prioritise maintaining current infrastructure and assess the readiness of projects before they are funded. While New Zealand was in the top 10% of the OECD in its infrastructure spend as a percentage of gross domestic product, it was not getting the returns it should, it added. To meet demand, annual capital investment would need to increase from around NZ$20 billion ($12 billion) today to slightly more than NZ$30 billion by the 2050s, according to the plan. The New Zealand government has outlined plans to boost the infrastructure build in the country, and earlier this year hosted an infrastructure investment summit to promote foreign investment in the country's infrastructure. 'The Government is determined to improve New Zealand's infrastructure system and to work alongside the industry and other political parties to establish a broad consensus about what needs to change,' said Chris Bishop, Minister for Infrastructure. The finalised plan is expected to be released at the end of the year and will be discussed by parliament in early 2026. ($1 = 1.6565 New Zealand dollars)
Sky News
28 minutes ago
- Sky News
Post Office scandal: Govt has not done enough to ensure compensation for victims, committee of MPs finds
The government has not done enough to ensure all victims entitled to compensation from the Post Office scandal have applied for it, a report has found. Many current and former postmasters affected by Horizon IT failings and associated miscarriages of justice are not yet receiving fair and timely compensation, according to the report by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC). Only 21% of the 18,500 letters the Post Office sent to postmasters to make them aware of the Horizon Shortfall Scheme had been responded to, figures provided by the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) show. About 5,000 further letters are expected to be sent in 2025. Under the scheme, current and former postmasters who were financially affected by the Horizon IT system, but who were either not convicted or did not take the Post Office to the High Court, can either settle their claim for a final fixed sum of £75,000 or have it fully assessed. There is also the Horizon Convictions Redress Scheme (HCRS), which is for sub-postmasters who had their convictions quashed after the passing of the Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Act last year. The 800 or so sub-postmasters who are eligible to claim under the HCRS are entitled to a £600,000 full and final settlement, or the option to pursue a full claim assessment. By the end of March, 339 had accepted the settlement sum, the report by the PAC, which is made up of MPs from all sides of the House of Commons, found. But the PAC report states that the government has no plans to follow up with people who are, or may be, eligible to claim but are yet to apply. 3:09 The committee recommends that the DBT should outline what more it will do to ensure every affected postmaster is fully aware of their options for claiming. A third scheme provides compensation to sub-postmasters who were wrongly convicted of fraud, theft and false accounting. Of the 111 sub-postmasters eligible to claim for the Overturned Convictions Scheme and who are either entitled to a £600,000 full and final settlement, or to pursue a full claim assessment, 25 have not yet submitted a claim, some of whom represent the most complex cases. The DBT has taken over the management of the scheme from the Post Office, and the PAC report recommends that the department should outline how it plans to handle the remaining cases under the scheme. Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP, chair of the PAC, said thousands of people were "deeply failed" by the system during "one of the UK's worst ever miscarriages of justice". He added: "This committee would have hoped to have found government laser-focused on ensuring all those eligible were fully and fairly compensated for what happened. "It is deeply dissatisfactory to find these schemes still moving far too slowly, with no government plans to track down the majority of potential claimants who may not yet be aware of their proper entitlements. "It is entirely unacceptable that those affected by this scandal, some of whom have had to go through the courts to clear their names, are being forced to relitigate their cases a second time."
Scotsman
35 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Planning bill will boost development but not without investment in skills
UK Government action is welcome, but additional pieces of the construction jigsaw must be put in place, writes Richard Whitehead Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The introduction of the UK Government's new Planning & Infrastructure Bill into parliament earlier this year came just days after figures showed British construction output has followed other areas of the economy in slowing down since the turn of the year. The bill itself – part of a broad package of measures designed by Labour to get Britain building and deliver growth through much-needed new infrastructure – aims to halve approval times for new roads, railways, and renewable energy installations to less than two years. The revamped National Planning Policy Framework that complements it will also enforce higher housing targets for local councils and make it easier for them to acquire land to help meet them. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad This is of course only the first reading of the bill, and while the Government in Westminster should be commended for its leadership in attempting to reform a broken system, it will be some time before we begin to see its impact. If central government is serious about seeing meaningful progress within this parliament – and to support the ten-year infrastructure strategy currently in development – then additional pieces of the jigsaw need to be put in place while the bill progresses. Conntractors report that finding suitably skilled staff is a significant challenge (Picture: Chief among them is investment in planning departments to help progress the approval of new schemes at pace. It is no secret that the capacity of local teams has been a major block on development activity. Official statistics from the Scottish Government showed the number of local development applications – smaller applications for changes to homes and developments with up to 50 houses – was the lowest for five years last year. Meanwhile, the average decision time just to set out planning schedules between developers and the planning authority increased again to more than 11 weeks. Ultimately, these are the numbers that reduce confidence among private investors that the projects they are funding will get off the ground. With interest rates falling and funders generally more active than they have been in recent years, now is the opportune time to build that confidence – adding people power to make the most of the reduction in red tape. Of course, that remains easier said than done given the current state of the public purse. With the UK Government's Spending Review due in June, the IFS's view is that Scottish funding will grow annually at around 0.5 per cent in real terms – less than half the speed projected by Holyrood. Rachel Reeves' Spring Statement, and the scale of any cuts implemented, will give a good indication of whether all this will be possible. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Outside of planning departments, the other major inhibitor of future developments coming forward at pace is Britain's ability to build them. The Construction Industry Training Board has outlined that around 250,000 extra construction workers will be required by 2028 to meet the development pipeline. Recruitment in the sector is generally fast-moving but almost a third (31 per cent) of contractors report finding suitably skilled staff as their most significant challenge. In particular, there is an issue around older workers retiring and not being replaced, as well as the long-standing void created by the end of Freedom of Movement. Richard Whitehead, chief executive (Europe and India) at global infrastructure leader AECOM The introduction of Skills England and the inception of regional Homebuilding Skills Hubs since last year's general election shows positive intent. Further initiatives like this, part of a complementary skills strategy that includes planning professionals, will be key if we are to get Britain building again.
