Misinformation-laden website almost convinces Alberta town to abandon climate program
Patrick Wilson, a councillor in Cochrane, Alta., let a website he'd found do the talking for him.
"This website I'm quoting from, I don't know a whole lot about," he told council on Monday night. "But I just thought their words were better than mine."
Wilson used those borrowed words to introduce a motion that would make Cochrane the first Alberta municipality to withdraw from Partners for Climate Protection, a national net-zero framework the town had been part of for over two decades.
The website Wilson was quoting is part of a troubling trend in local politics. It belongs to KICLEI (Kicking International Council out of Local Environmental Initiatives) – a group using an AI chatbot to craft talking points aimed at persuading local politicians to abandon net-zero programs. The chatbot is instructed to emphasize 'local decision-making' and 'non-partisan civic engagement,' while downplaying emissions targets and international cooperation.
KICLEI is not a reliable source of climate information, according to scientists at NASA, the US National Centre for Atmospheric Research and the University of Melbourne, who told Canada's National Observer that the group has spread misinformation about their research.
Yet its messaging came within a whisker of spurring policy change in Cochrane. Only a last minute intervention by Mayor Genung halted the town's exit from the PCP program until a review by an environmental task force.
KICLEI was founded in 2023 by former Freedom Convoy activist Maggie Hope Braun. Its campaign in Cochrane began in February 2025, when local resident Ron Voss presented a letter from KICLEI to the council that described Alberta as a "net carbon sink" and warned that the Partners for Climate Protection program imposes "unnecessary costs and external controls."
'This website I'm quoting from, I don't know a whole lot about… but I just thought their words were better than mine.'— Alberta councillor, citing a wedsite with an AI chatbot pushing towns to quit net-zero programs
These arguments are not new. They echo conspiracy theories popularized by the US Tea Party that claim that the climate crisis was invented by the UN to establish a "one world government" and erode private property rights. In 2010, dozens of US municipalities left the international sustainability network ICLEI because it promoted UN agendas.
The same network ICLEI now administers the Partners for Climate Protection program with the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, making it a natural target for a Canadian revival of the US movement.
Canada's National Observer 's recent investigation found that KICLEI is explicitly importing US Tea Party tactics into Canada. In August 2023, its founder Maggie Hope Braun told councillors in Douro-Dummer, Ontario that they were enabling "an act of treason" by allowing the creation of "UN city states." However, the group has since moderated its language, with the help of its AI chatbot.
When Wilson brought forward his motion, he acknowledged receiving an email warning councillors not to 'abandon their net-zero commitments to carefully crafted conspiracy theories" – quoting our investigation. But Wilson pushed back, arguing that the council should take a role in approving any "externally-driven" initiatives. He expressed his 'shock and surprise' that Cochrane had been a member of the climate protection program since 2004.
Wilson's reasoning resonated widely. At least three other councillors supported the motion to leave the program, with Councillor Marni Fedeyko reassured by staff that they could always rejoin later, after a pending local election, if needed.
The motion seemed certain to succeed until, at the last minute, Mayor Genung raised concerns about potential 'ripple effects' on environmental progress in other municipalities. He also warned that Cochrane could lose access to grants from the Federation of Municipalities' Green Municipal Fund, which are available to members of the program.
The final decision was postponed until September, when the town's environmental task force will report back on Genung's concerns.
As Genung suspects, the stakes of this decision may ripple far beyond Cochrane. So far, Thorold, Ontario is the only municipality that KICLEI has convinced to leave the Partners for Climate Protection program and it is frequently used as an example to legitimize the campaign.
KICLEI is a "very small group, trying to make a case that it is a national movement," said Fenwick McKelvey, an expert in Information and Communication Technology Policy at Carleton University.
McKelvey is skeptical that many elected officials will be persuaded by KICLEI's AI-powered campaign. 'It's going to come across as bullshit,' he said.
Yet, at least one man disagrees. In a recent council meeting, Councillor Wilson waxed poetic, saying that KICLEI expresses his concerns 'much better and more eloquently than I could.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
39 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
Spy agency says it doesn't just go after extremists' computers. It also goes after their online reputation
In one case late last year, the agency detected a ransomware group targeting Canadians working in a critical infrastructure sector. Within 48 hours, the report reads, CSE's teams identified and notified victims and ran a cyber operation to disrupt the criminal group's activity. The spy agency also said that it helped identify legitimate businesses that were covertly supporting foreign governments' military, political and commercial activities meant to undermine the Canadian Armed Forces. Walshe declined to say if the businesses were Canadian or had a connection to Canada but noted that CSE's mandate does not allow it to act against Canadians. 'Our mandate in this sphere is foreign,' she said. Over the last fiscal year, CSE says it responded to 2,561 cyber security incidents affecting either the government of Canada or critical infrastructure providers. That's a 16 per cent increase compared to the previous year as hostile actors increasingly target Canada's critical infrastructure sectors such as energy, finance, food, water and manufacturing. CSE also says in the report that between 2020 and 2023, it improperly shared information about Canadians with international partners that had been acquired 'incidentally' while targeting foreigners. 'Corrective actions included placing strict limits on information sharing and seeking assurances from CSE's trusted partners that the shared information was deleted,' the agency said, adding that it also notified the minister of defence. The report does not detail how many Canadians were impacted or what information was improperly disclosed. Once again, CSE says the People's Republic of China is by far the most prominent threat to Canada's national security, engaging in activities ranging from espionage to intellectual property theft and transnational repression. China's targets are also vast and include government, civil society, media, the defence industry and the R&D sector. 'The People's Republic of China (PRC) operates, and continues to expand, one of the world's most extensive and dynamic security and intelligence systems,' reads the report. 'The PRC cyber program's scale, tradecraft and ambitions in cyberspace are second to none.' Russia is also a key threat actor and continues to conduct espionage, spread disinformation and run influence operations against Canadians. Unlike previous years, the 2024-2025 annual report does not mention North Korea and barely notes the cyber threat posed by Iran, though Walshe said both regimes remain problematic for Canada. 'They are both capable threat actors,' she said. 'We absolutely do see that those two states posing a continued threat to Canada, just not highlighted in this report.' Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our politics newsletter, First Reading, here.
Edmonton Journal
40 minutes ago
- Edmonton Journal
Spy agency says it doesn't just go after extremists' computers. It also goes after their online reputation
Article content OTTAWA — Canada's cyberintelligence agency doesn't just go after violent extremist group leaders' computers and networks, it also attacks their reputation, credibility and trustworthiness to undermine them, according to a new report. In its latest annual report published Friday, the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) offered new detail about what it does during an 'active cyber operation'. Article content In other words, how CSE leads its minister of defence-approved campaigns meant to disrupt, influence or interfere with online threats posed by hostile actors like foreign states, organized crime or extremist groups. The activities go well beyond the clichéd image of tech wizards in hoodies hacking into foreign threat actors' computers and wreaking havoc on their IT systems (though that also happens). In cases last year where CSE ran operations against violent extremist organizations, for example, the cyber-spy agency targeted the adversaries' online presence and reputation on top of their IT infrastructure. 'Using a multi-faceted approach that targeted VEOs' technical infrastructure and online presence, CSE conducted active cyber operations to damage the credibility and influence of key group leaders, reducing their ability to inspire and lead,' reads the report. Article content The operations also aimed to 'weaken trust and reduce cohesion between leaders and followers, undermining the unity and strength of these organizations,' the report continues. Asked in an interview if CSE leads online disparagement campaigns against leaders of violent extremist organizations, Cyber Centre deputy head Bridget Walshe declined to go into detail. 'It's difficult for me to get into details about the actual techniques that are being used, because if we share those techniques, then that impacts them and the effectiveness decreases,' Walshe said. 'Violent extremism is a big one, because there is an immediate threat to Canada. So, what we've tried to do is highlight what the impact is' of CSE's cyber operations, she said of the latest report. In total, CSE says it was authorized to run four active or defensive cyber operations last fiscal year, including another that targeted the 10 biggest ransomware groups impacting Canada. Article content In one case late last year, the agency detected a ransomware group targeting Canadians working in a critical infrastructure sector. Within 48 hours, the report reads, CSE's teams identified and notified victims and ran a cyber operation to disrupt the criminal group's activity. The spy agency also said that it helped identify legitimate businesses that were covertly supporting foreign governments' military, political and commercial activities meant to undermine the Canadian Armed Forces. Walshe declined to say if the businesses were Canadian or had a connection to Canada but noted that CSE's mandate does not allow it to act against Canadians. 'Our mandate in this sphere is foreign,' she said. Over the last fiscal year, CSE says it responded to 2,561 cyber security incidents affecting either the government of Canada or critical infrastructure providers. Article content That's a 16 per cent increase compared to the previous year as hostile actors increasingly target Canada's critical infrastructure sectors such as energy, finance, food, water and manufacturing. CSE also says in the report that between 2020 and 2023, it improperly shared information about Canadians with international partners that had been acquired 'incidentally' while targeting foreigners. 'Corrective actions included placing strict limits on information sharing and seeking assurances from CSE's trusted partners that the shared information was deleted,' the agency said, adding that it also notified the minister of defence. The report does not detail how many Canadians were impacted or what information was improperly disclosed. Once again, CSE says the People's Republic of China is by far the most prominent threat to Canada's national security, engaging in activities ranging from espionage to intellectual property theft and transnational repression. Latest National Stories
Calgary Herald
an hour ago
- Calgary Herald
Americans living near the Canada-U.S. border to hold 'Elbows Up for Canada' rally
Article content In an act of solidarity toward their northern neighbours, some Upstate New York residents are organizing an 'Elbows Up for Canada' rally. Article content Residents who live near the Canada-U.S. border have organized this movement in an attempt to strengthen ties with Canadians. The event will take place on July 5. Article content Article content Dubbed the 'Friendship Flotilla,' it will see the Americans taking part boating along the St. Lawrence River with Canadian and American flags, as well as signs showing their support for Canada. Article content Article content 'Every day we look across the St. Lawrence River and we see friends, family members, and business partners,' said Eileen Jarrett, one of the organizers of the rally. 'We hope this rally will remind everyone of our friendship.' Article content Article content Rally-goers will then head to Morrisette Park – those with boats will take the Friendship Flotilla across the St. Lawrence River from the Ogdensburg Marina to Fort Wellington in Prescott, and those without boats will stay at the park and wave across. Article content The boaters will then split and head to both Brockville and Morrisburg to bring the flotilla to the other major Canadian border towns in the area. Article content Organizers of the event are encouraging residents of Prescott to gather on the Heritage River Trail walking path at 2 p.m. to see the flotilla and greet the rally-goers. Article content Article content This movement aims to show Canadians that not all Americans agree with President Donald Trump's threats against Canada's sovereignty, and many want to extend an olive branch to their neighbours across the river. Article content 'Our countries share family ties, with many dual citizens and cross-border families, along with shared values of democracy, diversity, and human rights,' said Jarrett. 'Organizers emphasize that the movement is positive, focused on celebrating what unites rather than protesting what divides. The rallies aim to demonstrate the grassroots support for continued U.S.-Canada co-operation across economic, environmental, and security issues.' Article content Jarrett hopes that a number of North Country residents will come and join the movement, although she is unsure of the number of people who will take part in the rally.
