US newspaper recommends books that don't exist through AI-generated reading list
An AI-generated reading list in the Sun-Times and Inquirer featured fake titles by real authors; both have apologised. – LYNDON FRENCH/The New York Times
The summer reading list tucked into a special section of the Chicago Sun-Times and The Philadelphia Inquirer seemed innocuous enough.
There were books by beloved authors such as Isabel Allende and Min Jin Lee; novels by bestsellers including Delia Owens, Taylor Jenkins Reid and Brit Bennett; and a novel by Percival Everett, a recent Pulitzer Prize winner.
There was just one issue: none of the book titles attributed to the above authors were real. They had been created by generative artificial intelligence.
It's the latest case of bad AI making its way into the news. While generative AI has improved, there is still no way to ensure the systems produce accurate information. AI chatbots cannot distinguish between what is true and what is false, and they often make things up. The chatbots can spit out information and expert names with an air of authority.
Most of the book descriptions were fairly believable. It didn't seem out of reach that Bennett would 'explore family bonds tested by natural disasters,' or that Allende would pen another 'multigenerational saga.'
The technology publication 404 Media reported earlier on the reading list. In addition to nonexistent book titles, the section included quotes from unidentifiable experts.
Both the Sun-Times and the Inquirer issued statements condemning the use of AI and in part blamed King Features, a Hearst syndicate that licenses content nationally. The syndicate produced the 56-page supplement to the newspaper called 'Heat Index: Your Guide To The Best Of Summer', which also included things like summer food trends and activity recommendations.
While the list did not have a byline, a freelancer named Marco Buscaglia took responsibility for the piece. He confirmed that the list was partially generated by artificial intelligence, most likely Claude.
'It was just a really bad error on my part and I feel bad that it has affected the Sun-Times and King Features, and that they are taking the shrapnel for it,' Buscaglia said in an interview.
It's fairly common for media organisations, especially resource-strapped local newsrooms, to rely on syndicates to supplement coverage.
Just two months ago, 20% of staff at the Sun-Times resigned as part of a buyout offer.
On the newspaper's homepage on Wednesday, there were two banners atop the website. One linked to the statement on the May 18 special section, and the other linked to a piece on how federal cuts threaten local journalism.
Felix M. Simon, a research fellow in AI and digital news at the Reuters Institute at Oxford University, said the technology was not entirely at fault. There are responsible and irresponsible ways to use AI for news gathering, he said.
'We need better education for everyone from the freelancer level to the executive level,' said Simon, calling on people to look 'at the structures that ultimately allowed this factually false article to appear in a reputable news outlet.'
The special section was removed from the Inquirer's website when it was discovered, according to Lisa Hughes, the publisher and CEO of the paper. The section was also removed from the Sun-Times' e-paper version, according to a statement, and subscribers would not be charged for the premium edition.
King Features did not respond to requests for comment, but in a statement provided to the Sun-Times said it had 'a strict policy with our staff, cartoonists, columnists, and freelance writers against the use of AI to create content.'
In their statement, the Sun-Times said that the incident should be a 'learning moment.'
'Our work is valued — and valuable — because of the humanity behind it,' the statement read. – By TALYA MINSBERG/ ©2025 The New York Times Company
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
a day ago
- The Star
Man jumps into display of China's Terracotta Army: officials
China's famous terracotta warriors pictured in the northern Chinese city of X'ian. Photo: AFP A domestic tourist climbed over a fence and jumped into a section of the world-famous display of China's Terracotta Army, damaging two ancient clay warriors, authorities said on Saturday. The 30-year-old was visiting the museum housing the Terracotta Army in the city of Xi'an on Friday when he "climbed over the guardrail and the protective net and jumped", public security officials said in a statement. The man surnamed Sun was found to "suffer from mental illness" and the case is under investigation. He "pushed and pulled" the clay warriors and two were "damaged to varying degrees", the statement said. He was "controlled" by security personnel. The pit he jumped into is up to 5.4m (18 feet) deep, according to the museum's website. Built around 209 BC to stand guard over the tomb of the first emperor, the 8,000-strong Terracotta Army is one of China's most important archaeological discoveries and considered a symbol of ancient Chinese artistic and military sophistication. A major tourist attraction in Xi'an, capital of the northern province of Shaanxi, it has been a Unesco world heritage site since 1987. A worker at the museum told AFP on Saturday that the display was open as usual. - AFP
The Star
4 days ago
- The Star
Tony Award nominee Marjan Neshat makes history in Broadway play 'English'
Marjan Neshat is a veteran of stage and screen who teaches fledgling actors. Like so many of us, she sometimes has bouts of self-doubt. 'I think on the first day of class, I still always have imposter syndrome, but I've grown to live with it,' she says. 'I never thought that I had the gravitas to be like, 'I'm going to teach you acting.'' This semester, her students at The New School got to witness self-doubt kicked to the curb when Neshat became a first-time Tony Award nominee. 'I'm sure they're all a bit more smitten with me now,' she says, laughing. Neshat earned the nod for her work – appropriately enough – playing a teacher in Sanaz Toossi's Pulitzer Prize-winning and Tony Award-nominated play English , which premiered on Broadway in the fall. 'There's something about this play that feels so bottomless,' she adds. 'It kind of felt like winning the lottery because it was, to me, everything as an actress that I care about – it was artistic, and it was subtle and it was nuanced.' The play has made history by making Neshat and co-star Tala Ashe (left) the first female actors of Iranian descent to be Tony-nominated. English explores the ways in which language shapes identity, can help people feel understood or misunderstood and the push and pull of culture. It's set in a storefront school near Tehran, where four Iranian students are preparing over several weeks for an English language exam. Neshat plays their teacher, a woman who loves rom-coms and English but who is unmoored, a foot in Iran and one in England, where she lived for many years but never completely felt at home. 'We don't always belong to what we're born to,' says Neshat. 'She understands the potential of language and the potential of reaching beyond yourself. And yet she's at a point in her life where she's also losing a lot of that.' The play is packed with cultural references – like Christiane Amanpour, Hugh Grant and Whenever, Wherever by Shakira. One character admires Julia Roberts' teeth, saying 'They could rip through wire. In a good way.' 'I feel like so often, when you're telling stories about a different culture, especially in the Middle East, it's like, 'Well, we wanna see them behind the veil' and 'We want to see our idea of them.' And I feel like, especially with my character, I feel it defies all of that. I feel she is romantic and flawed and complicated.' The play has made history by making Neshat and co-star Tala Ashe the first female actors of Iranian descent to be Tony-nominated. (The first Iranian-born actor to receive a Tony acting nomination was Arian Moayed.) The two face off at the Tonys on June 8 in the category of best performance by an actress in a featured role in a play alongside Jessica Hecht, Fina Strazza and Kara Young. Neshat's family fled post revolutionary Iran in 1984, when Neshat was eight, and she hasn't been back since. She decided early on she wanted to act, despite her mother's fear that her daughter might share the same fate as Marilyn Monroe. She adores the plays of Anton Chekhov and watching movies on the Criterion Channel, and she's obsessed with the novel Anne Of Green Gables . 'I'm not like super-showy. I'm interior and deep,' she says. When English ended its run, she and the cast wept in their dressing rooms. 'She (Neshat) thrives in mystery and yearning and I think I've always strived to capture a feeling that goes beyond language. She's after that, too,' says Toossi. 'I think she holds contradictions and leaves space for the audience. She operates in a register must of us can't quite reach.' Neshat's credits range from the movies Sex In The City 2 and Rockaway to an off-Broadway production of The Seagull with Dianne Wiest and Alan Cumming, and to roles on TV in New Amsterdam , Quantico , Elementary and Blue Bloods . 'I've sort of been saved by art in so many ways,' she says. 'It's been sometimes like a really bad boyfriend, and it's brought out all my middle school rejection and angst, but truly, in the best of ways, I have, I think, become more myself or understood who I am.' English – written in the wake of President Donald Trump's ban on travellers from several predominantly Muslim countries during his first term – premiered off-Broadway at Atlantic Theater Company in 2022 with Neshat in the teacher's role. 'There is something very emotional about the fact that she wrote this as like a cry into the void when the Muslim ban happened and the fact we were like opening shortly after Trump became president,' says Neshat. 'Just the culmination of all these things, it felt like an event.' She has a tight bond with Toossi, nurturing her English and also appearing in the playwright's Wish You Were Here . The playwright once saw Neshat at a play reading before they ever met and soon gave the teacher in English the name Marjan. Neshat jokes that 'she wrote me into being.' 'Her writing has given me some of the richest roles of my life,' says Neshat. For her part, Toossi says getting Neshat and Ashe to be Tony-nominated is her proudest achievement. On the opening night for English on Broadway, Neshat was joined by her mother and her 12-year-old son, Wilder, and they marvelled at the journey life takes you. Neshat's grandmother was married at 13 in Iran and never learned to read or write, though she dictated poems and letters. Just two generations later, their family has star on Broadway. 'The little girl I was in Iran would never have imagined that I would be sitting with my mom and nominated for a Tony,' she says. 'It just truly is a ride.' – AP
The Star
25-05-2025
- The Star
US newspaper recommends books that don't exist through AI-generated reading list
An AI-generated reading list in the Sun-Times and Inquirer featured fake titles by real authors; both have apologised. – LYNDON FRENCH/The New York Times The summer reading list tucked into a special section of the Chicago Sun-Times and The Philadelphia Inquirer seemed innocuous enough. There were books by beloved authors such as Isabel Allende and Min Jin Lee; novels by bestsellers including Delia Owens, Taylor Jenkins Reid and Brit Bennett; and a novel by Percival Everett, a recent Pulitzer Prize winner. There was just one issue: none of the book titles attributed to the above authors were real. They had been created by generative artificial intelligence. It's the latest case of bad AI making its way into the news. While generative AI has improved, there is still no way to ensure the systems produce accurate information. AI chatbots cannot distinguish between what is true and what is false, and they often make things up. The chatbots can spit out information and expert names with an air of authority. Most of the book descriptions were fairly believable. It didn't seem out of reach that Bennett would 'explore family bonds tested by natural disasters,' or that Allende would pen another 'multigenerational saga.' The technology publication 404 Media reported earlier on the reading list. In addition to nonexistent book titles, the section included quotes from unidentifiable experts. Both the Sun-Times and the Inquirer issued statements condemning the use of AI and in part blamed King Features, a Hearst syndicate that licenses content nationally. The syndicate produced the 56-page supplement to the newspaper called 'Heat Index: Your Guide To The Best Of Summer', which also included things like summer food trends and activity recommendations. While the list did not have a byline, a freelancer named Marco Buscaglia took responsibility for the piece. He confirmed that the list was partially generated by artificial intelligence, most likely Claude. 'It was just a really bad error on my part and I feel bad that it has affected the Sun-Times and King Features, and that they are taking the shrapnel for it,' Buscaglia said in an interview. It's fairly common for media organisations, especially resource-strapped local newsrooms, to rely on syndicates to supplement coverage. Just two months ago, 20% of staff at the Sun-Times resigned as part of a buyout offer. On the newspaper's homepage on Wednesday, there were two banners atop the website. One linked to the statement on the May 18 special section, and the other linked to a piece on how federal cuts threaten local journalism. Felix M. Simon, a research fellow in AI and digital news at the Reuters Institute at Oxford University, said the technology was not entirely at fault. There are responsible and irresponsible ways to use AI for news gathering, he said. 'We need better education for everyone from the freelancer level to the executive level,' said Simon, calling on people to look 'at the structures that ultimately allowed this factually false article to appear in a reputable news outlet.' The special section was removed from the Inquirer's website when it was discovered, according to Lisa Hughes, the publisher and CEO of the paper. The section was also removed from the Sun-Times' e-paper version, according to a statement, and subscribers would not be charged for the premium edition. King Features did not respond to requests for comment, but in a statement provided to the Sun-Times said it had 'a strict policy with our staff, cartoonists, columnists, and freelance writers against the use of AI to create content.' In their statement, the Sun-Times said that the incident should be a 'learning moment.' 'Our work is valued — and valuable — because of the humanity behind it,' the statement read. – By TALYA MINSBERG/ ©2025 The New York Times Company
