Lawyers in Brazil submit final statement for Bolsonaro in coup trial
In a statement submitted on Wednesday evening, Bolsonaro's legal representatives denied the charges against him and said that prosecutors had presented no convincing evidence.
'There is no way to convict Jair Bolsonaro based on the evidence presented in the case, which largely demonstrated that he ordered the transition … and assured his voters that the world would not end on December 31st,' the document states.
The right-wing former president faces up to 12 years in prison if convicted of attempting to mount a coup after losing a presidential election to left-wing rival and current President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.
Bolsonaro, who raised alarm in the months leading up to the election by casting doubt on the voting process, has denied involvement in the plot, which allegedly included plans for Lula's assassination.
The former leader's legal representatives say the fact that he authorised the transition contradicts the coup allegations.
'This is evidence that eliminates the most essential of the accusatory premises,' they said.
Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet submitted final arguments in July, citing handwritten notes, digital files, message exchanges, and spreadsheets that he said show details of a conspiracy to suppress democracy.
Following Bolsonaro's election loss, crowds of his supporters gathered outside of military bases, calling on the armed forces to intervene and prevent Lula from taking office. A group of Bolsonaro's supporters also stormed federal buildings in the capital of Brasilia on January 8, 2023. Some drew parallels to a military coup in the 1960s that marked the beginning of a decades-long period of dictatorship, for which Bolsonaro himself has long expressed fondness.
Bolsonaro and his allies, including United States President Donald Trump, have depicted the trial as a politically motivated 'witch hunt'.
A recent survey conducted by Datafolha, a Brazilian polling institute, found that more than 50 percent of Brazilians agree with the court's decision to place Bolsonaro under house arrest in August. The survey also found that a majority believe that Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, a frequent target of right-wing ire and central figure in the trial, is following the law.
Respondents also largely disagreed with the claim that Bolsonaro was being persecuted for political reasons, with 39 percent in agreement and 53 percent in disagreement.
Speaking from the White House on Thursday, Trump said Bolsonaro was an 'honest man' and the victim of an attempted 'political execution'.
The Trump administration has mounted a pressure campaign to push the court to drop Bolsonaro's case, sanctioning De Moraes and announcing severe sanctions on Brazilian exports to the US. That move has met anger in Brazil and been depicted as an attack on Brazilian sovereignty.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
13 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
Verdict, sentencing in coup trial for Brazil's Bolsonaro set for September
Brazil's Supreme Court says it will hand down a verdict and sentence in former President Jair Bolsonaro's coup trial early next month, in a case that has polarised the country and drawn in the ex-leader's ally, United States President Donald Trump. The court announced on Friday that the five-justice panel overseeing the proceedings will deliver decisions on the five charges between September 2 and 12. A coup conviction carries a sentence of up to 12 years. Bolsonaro, under house arrest since August 4, is accused of orchestrating a plot to cling to power after losing the 2022 presidential election to Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. He denies the allegations. Prosecutors allege Bolsonaro led a criminal organisation that sought to overturn the election results. The case includes accusations that the plot involved plans to kill Lula and Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who is presiding over the trial. They have presented messages, handwritten notes and other material they say document the conspiracy. Defence lawyers counter that no coup attempt was carried out and that Bolsonaro allowed the presidential handover to take place, undermining claims he tried to block it. The five charges against Bolsonaro include attempting a coup, participation in an armed criminal organisation, attempted violent abolition of the democratic order, and two counts linked to destruction of state property. Two separate five-justice panels operate within Brazil's top court. Justice de Moraes, a frequent target of Bolsonaro's supporters, sits on the panel hearing the case. Although Bolsonaro appointed two justices during his 2019–2022 presidency, both serve on the other panel. The Supreme Court headquarters in Brasilia was one of the targets of a rioting mob of supporters known as 'Bolsonaristas', who raided government buildings in January 2023 as they urged the military to depose Lula, an insurrection attempt that evoked Trump supporters on January 6, 2021. The rioting also prompted comparisons to Brazil's 1964 military coup, a dark era that Bolsonaro has openly praised. The trial has captivated Brazil's divided public. Tensions deepened when Trump linked a 50 percent tariff on Brazilian imports to his ally's legal battle, calling the proceedings a 'witch hunt' and describing Bolsonaro as an 'honest man' facing 'political execution'. The Trump administration has also sanctioned Justice de Moraes and imposed further trade restrictions on Brazil, a move widely criticised in the country as an assault on national sovereignty. A recent Datafolha poll found more than half of Brazilians support the decision to place Bolsonaro under house arrest, while 53 percent reject the idea that he is being politically persecuted.
Al Jazeera
17 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
A political shift ahead? What to know about Bolivia's presidential election
For the first time in nearly two decades, Bolivia is on the precipice of a rightward shift. Voters in the South American nation will go to the polls on August 17 to choose the next president, as well as members of Congress. But schisms within Bolivia's long-dominant left have opened the door to a possible right-wing victory, with candidates like businessman Samuel Doria Medina and former President Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga leading the race. Bolivia has been unsettled by political and economic turmoil in recent years, including high inflation and dwindling currency reserves. That, in turn, has fuelled public dissatisfaction with the ruling Movement for Socialism (MAS) party, which has been in power almost continuously since 2006. Candidates like Medina and Quiroga are hoping to capitalise on that disillusionment to oust MAS from the presidency. But tensions in the country remain high, and polls show a close race that may not produce a clear winner in the first round of voting. Who are the figures shaping the race, what issues are top of mind for voters, and how could this election shape Bolivia? We answer those questions and more in this explainer. When is the election? The first round of voting will take place on Sunday, August 17. Will there be a second round of voting? Possibly. To avoid a run-off, the top presidential candidate must either earn more than 50 percent of the vote or garner 40 percent of the vote and have a 10-point lead over the second-place contender. But that scenario is unlikely, given the tight race between candidates like Medina and Quiroga. The presidential race is expected to proceed to a second round of voting on October 19. Are there other races on the ballot? Yes. In addition to voting for a president and vice president, Bolivians will cast ballots for 36 Senate seats and 130 positions in the Chamber of Deputies. Bolivia has a population of approximately 12 million, of which more than seven million are eligible voters. Who are the main presidential candidates? A total of 10 presidential candidates registered to race in Sunday's election, but so far, no single contender has decisively broken into the lead. 'This is the first national election in two decades without a dominant party or a clear frontrunner,' said Glaeldys Gonzalez Calanche, an analyst with the International Crisis Group, a research nonprofit. Two closely watched candidates, however, are both conservatives who struggled to make an impression in past elections. They now appear to have a shot at success, a development that underscores the implosion of the once-formidable Bolivian left. One of the candidates is a politician and businessman named Samuel Doria Medina. An entrepreneur who made his fortune in cement, Medina now owns hotels and Burger King restaurant franchises in Bolivia. In the 1990s, he also served as a minister of planning under President Jaime Paz Zamora. The founder of the right-of-centre National Unity Front, Medina previously made three failed attempts to run for president: in 2005, 2009 and 2014. He likely faces his stiffest competition from fellow also-ran, the right-wing Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga. Like Medina, Quiroga has been a presidential candidate three times before: in 2005, 2014 and 2020. But he briefly ascended to the presidency himself after being elected as the country's youngest vice president in 1997. He shared a ticket at the time with the country's former military dictator Hugo Banzer, whose government in the 1970s was associated with abuses such as torture and enforced disappearances. As president, Banzer decided to leave office in 2001 after he was diagnosed with lung cancer, and Quiroga served the final year of Banzer's term. Are there any contenders on the left? Yes, but they have not been polling as strongly as their conservative counterparts. Andronico Rodriguez is the leading left-wing candidate, running as an independent. The president of the Senate, Rodriguez boasts roots in Bolivia's rural coca-growing regions, which tend to be strongholds for the governing MAS party. Rodriguez, however, split from the MAS party this year as Bolivia's leftist coalition fractured. Outgoing president and MAS member Luis Arce has been blamed for Bolivia's slumping economy, and MAS founder Evo Morales has been locked in a feud with both Arce and Rodriguez as he seeks to regain the presidency himself. The official MAS candidate in the 2025 election, former minister Eduardo del Castillo, has barely made a ripple in the polls. What do the polls say? A poll aggregator compiled by the Americas Society/Council of the Americas shows conservatives Samuel Doria Medina and Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga vying for the lead. But the polls note that a significant number of voters are either undecided or intent upon casting null votes, adding a wild-card element to Sunday's race. Three polls taken between early June and late July show Medina in the lead, with between 19.6 and 24.5 percent support. Quiroga, meanwhile, garnered between 16.6 percent and 22.9 percent in the polls. And Andronico Rodriguez, the left-wing candidate, earned between 6 percent and 13.7 percent support among the survey respondents. What issues are top of mind for voters? The country's economic turbulence and cost of living crisis are among the highest-profile issues for voters this election cycle. 'Bolivia is experiencing its worst economic crisis in a generation,' said Gonzalez Calanche, the analyst with the International Crisis Group. She pointed out that the national currency has lost more than half of its value. While Bolivia has vast stores of natural gas and oil, its production has tumbled, leading to an economic shortfall. The country has been forced to import fuel rather than exporting it amid shortages. A survey in May found that voters identified rising prices as their top concern, followed by other economic issues such as fuel shortages, shrinking dollar reserves and unemployment. Why isn't the current president running? President Luis Arce announced in May that he would not seek re-election, as the country's economic crisis and a feud with former mentor Evo Morales sent his popularity plummeting. The final months of Arce's five-year term have been defined largely by tumult. In 2023 and 2024, the country saw its currency reserves shrink, and its natural gas industry suffered. Morales, meanwhile, began to position himself as a critic of Arce's government. Under Arce's leadership, Bolivia's judicial system barred Morales from seeking a fourth term as president, and an arrest warrant was issued against Morales for statutory rape. Tensions rose in June 2024, when a general stormed the presidential palace and appeared to attempt a coup d'etat. Arce blamed Morales's supporters, and Morales claimed Arce had staged the coup to rescue his popularity. What role is Evo Morales playing? Bolivia's election is notable for the absence of one of the country's most influential figures: MAS founder Evo Morales. As a three-term president from 2006 until 2019, Morales oversaw a period of substantial economic growth that made him popular in Bolivia and across the Latin American left. But in 2019, Morales sought a controversial fourth term in office. Though official results showed he won, protests, threats and claims of vote tampering forced Morales to leave the country. Some have described his exile as a coup, driven by the military and the political right. When Arce, his former finance minister, was elected president in 2020, Morales was able to return to Bolivia. But the two leaders have fallen out, in part as a result of their rivalry for the presidency, and Morales has rallied his supporters to his side in a split that has fractured the Bolivian left. In May, a constitutional court upheld a ruling that Morales could not run again, due to term limits imposed since he left office. But Morales has continued to press for a fourth term in office, and he has urged his supporters to cast null ballots to protest Sunday's election. Polls estimate the combined number of undecided voters and protest votes could amount to between 25 and 34 percent of voters. Morales's supporters have also led demonstrations in protest of the former president's exclusion from the election. Some have blocked roads. Others have erupted into clashes that left police and protesters dead. How long is a presidential term? Presidents are elected in Bolivia for a term of five years. In recent years, the country's courts have limited presidents to two consecutive terms in office. This has been a source of consternation for Morales, who served three consecutive terms and hopes to gain a fourth. Why is this election important? Bolivia's left is likely on track for its first defeat in a presidential race in nearly two decades. That would send shockwaves throughout Latin America, where Bolivia has been a left-wing stronghold for much of the 21st century. 'The left has been weakened by schisms and personal disputes between Morales and Arce,' analyst Gonzalez Calanche said. She explained that those schisms will be reflected in the ballot box, as trade unions and other left-leaning organisations struggle to unite behind a candidate. With tensions high, economic conditions deteriorating, and no consensus candidate to lead the country, Gonzalez Calanche fears Bolivia could be heading into a period of uncertainty as it approaches a possible second round of voting. 'There's a very dire economic situation, made worse by social and political unrest,' she said. 'It's a cycle that continues to feed itself.'
Al Jazeera
a day ago
- Al Jazeera
Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai's trial delayed over health concerns
Hong Kong judges have postponed the trial of media tycoon Jimmy Lai until he is provided with a heart monitoring device and related medication. Friday's decision marked the second delay to the case this week after his lawyer said he had suffered heart palpitations. The 77-year-old founder of the Apple Daily newspaper is charged with foreign collusion under Hong Kong's national security law, which Beijing imposed following widespread pro-democracy protests in 2019. Closing arguments in the long-running trial were originally expected to begin on Thursday, but all court sessions were suspended due to bad weather. As the court resumed on Friday, defence lawyer Robert Pang said that Lai had heart 'palpitations' and had experienced the feeling of 'collapsing', but added that the tycoon did not want attention to be concentrated on his health. Lai has been kept behind bars since December 2020, reportedly in solitary confinement, and concerns have previously been raised over the septuagenarian's welfare. 'The world is watching' The three-judge panel adjourned the case to Monday to allow time for prison authorities to outfit Lai with a wearable heart monitor and provide medication. The sprawling trial, which began in December 2023, is entering its final stages as Western nations and rights groups continue to call for Lai's release. Aside from the collusion charge – which could land him in prison for life – Lai is also charged with 'seditious publication' related to 161 op-eds carrying his byline. The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) said on Thursday that 'the world is watching how Hong Kong treats its journalists'. 'The prolonged detention of Jimmy Lai not only destroys Hong Kong's historic reputation as a free and open society, but also as a trusted hub for business,' said CPJ regional director Beh Lih Yi. Trump comments US President Donald Trump told a Fox News radio programme on Thursday that he had previously brought up the Lai case with Chinese President Xi Jinping. 'I'm going to do everything I can to save him … you could also understand President Xi would not be exactly thrilled,' the outlet quoted Trump as saying. The Hong Kong government said on Wednesday it 'strongly disapproved and rejected the slanderous remarks made by external forces' regarding Lai's case. Lai is a British citizen and his son Sebastien reiterated in March calls for the Keir Starmer administration to do more, saying: 'I don't want my father to die in jail.' Two prosecution witnesses, Chan Tsz-wah and Andy Li, also accused Lai of financially backing an advocacy group that ran overseas newspaper advertisements supporting the 2019 protests. Lai has denied calling for sanctions against China and Hong Kong and said he never advocated separatism. Apple Daily was forced to close in 2021 after police raids and the arrests of its senior editors.
