Harris accuses Israel of genocide in Dáil clash over Gaza
Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris has insisted Government is doing all it can to help ordinary people in Palestine - describing what is happening as "the genocidal activity of the Netanyahu government" and that there is "an act of evil going on".
Mr Harris was speaking during a heated Dáil exchange in which Independent TD Catherine Connolly said in her view Israel has become "a rogue state" and that the coalition is "standing over a narrative that is utterly false".
Speaking during a Dáil Leaders Questions debate, Ms Connolly said 54,000 Palestinians have been killed since the Hamas attack on Israel on 7 October 2023, including 15,630 children.
Ms Connolly said during this same period 630,000 people have been displaced, and that "at least 28 aid workers have been killed since 1 May, an average of one worker per day".
While saying there have been calls for an immediate ceasefire, the Independent TD said that Israel has said it "intends to establish 22 new settlements".
She asked, "how have we allowed this to happen?", before saying:
"We've let it happens because we've bought into a narrative that has been pushed more than 100 years, 140 at this time, that Jewish people without a land and Palestine was a country without a people.
"And arising from that then the narrative took hold that they were entitled to that land notwithstanding the Nakba in 1948, a new Nakba happening under our very eyes and noses, with the narrative that Israel is the only democracy, the bulwark against Islamic religions and Muslims, and we have all bought into that to a certain extent.
"The Hamas attack happened on 7 October, which we are on record as condemning, I also said history did not start on that day.
"It is time for us to reflect, to stop the cognitive dissonance and ask why an independent republic is standing over a narrative that is utterly false."
In response, Mr Harris said the Government is "not standing over" anything, before adding that what is taking place is the "genocidal activity of the Netanyahu government" in Israel.
The Tánaiste said he wanted to make it clear he "differentiates between the government of Israel and the people of Israel", but said what is happening is "despicable" and that there is "an act of evil going on here, this is evil".
Mr Harris said the measures the Government is taking include progress on the Occupied Territories Bill, saying Ireland "is the first country in Europe" to take this step and that other countries may be looking at us to ask, "why can't we do it in other countries as well".
He continued that "I don't buy into the narrative that Opposition is good and Government is bad", repeating that "we're all appalled by the genocide we're witnessing".
However, Ms Connolly responded, saying Government can be "appalled and sickened" but is still "refusing to recognise the elephant in the room".
She said that in her view there is an "umbilical cord" between Israel and the US, which she described as the "biggest supplier" of weapons to Israel.
She said the US is followed by the EU, which she said is "morally corrupt and inept" on the issue, saying "let's call a spade a spade".
Ms Connolly said this is happening while Shannon Airport is being used by the US air force, and while in her view "the Occupied Territories Bill is going nowhere".
She added: "It's time we led. Call out the narrative for what it is. Israel is a rogue state; it is not a democratic state. Stand up, stand up and account for what you're going to do."
Mr Harris again responded, saying Deputy Connolly has "such vitriol and dislike for Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil" that in his view progress is not being acknowledged.
He criticised Ms Connolly's remarks, saying "while you're standing here throwing brickbats at me", Government is being praised by other countries for the steps it is taking.
Mr Harris added that he is "disgusted and sickened" by what is happening in Gaza and that "we were the first country to say what Israel is doing is genocide".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
MPs vote to continue parliamentary ping-pong over AI ‘theft' crackdown
Conservative shadow science minister Dr Ben Spencer, who described himself as a 'Bill Murray fan', called on the Government to 'bring an end to this Groundhog Day'. Peers agreed on Monday to amend the Government's Data (Use and Access) Bill. Their proposal would force the Government to prepare fresh legislation which would open up AI model databases, so that copyright owners could see whether their works have been used as 'data inputs'. But MPs voted 317 to 185, majority 132, on Tuesday to reject the amendment and continue the battle at Westminster, known as parliamentary ping-pong. Rocket Man singer Sir Elton John is among the stars who have urged the Government to strengthen copyright protections, when he said last month that ministers are 'absolute losers' and that he felt 'incredibly betrayed'. Dr Spencer told the Commons: 'Copyright law is a toothless instrument if the lack of transparency about the use of create content in AI models continues. 'The lack of transparency renders rights enforcement elusive, and the Government is apparently happy for this to persist on an open-ended basis.' At the despatch box, he added: 'Creatives continue to lose out when their work is exploited without payment, the AI industry, especially smaller firms, can't get out of the starting blocks let alone play their part in turbocharging our tech economy, and the Government continues to risk the confidence of both key industries with the chilling effect on investment that this entails.' On the stand-off, Dr Spencer told the Commons: 'We're stuck in Groundhog Day in this Bill until the Government realises that the Lords' amendments are not a nuisance but an opportunity, and that they need to listen to the concerns and change course.' There is no time commitment from the Government benches whatsoever on bringing back a Bill to this House to address the current theft of property that is raining down on the UK creative industries Conservative former minister Sir Julian Smith Conservative former minister Sir Julian Smith later said: 'There is no time commitment from the Government benches whatsoever on bringing back a Bill to this House to address the current theft of property that is raining down on the UK creative industries.' ADVERTISEMENT Learn more Technology minister Sir Chris Bryant had earlier spoken against the amendment, which was put forward by Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason director Baroness Kidron. 'One could argue that introducing a draft Bill which would then be considered in various different places, followed presumably by a Bill, would actually delay things rather than speed things up,' Sir Chris told the Commons. He said that he 'cannot think of any Bill in our history that has included such a clause', to compel the Government to bring forward new draft legislation within three months of the publication of a report into the use of copyrighted works in the development of AI systems. Sir Chris told MPs: 'A central plank of parliamentary sovereignty is no parliament can bind its successor. 'That doesn't just mean from one parliament to another, but it means one session can't bind a future session.' Commons culture, media and sport committee chairwoman Dame Caroline Dinenage, the Conservative MP for Gosport, accused Sir Chris of 'dancing on the head of a pin' and added: 'The fact is that all legislation somehow binds those that are coming down the track.' The Bill will now return to the House of Lords.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
OECD warns Irish Government to keep lid on ‘surging public spending'
"Looming risks warrant greater fiscal prudence," the report says in relation to Ireland. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has 38 member states, including Ireland, and acts as a think tank to promote international trade and prosperity. The report stops well short of calling for a return to austerity, but says Ireland needs to prioritise spending and focus on investment that delivers for the economy long term – including housing – and better target spending in general. Figures earlier this year from the Department of Finance showed that Government spending in 2025 was up 50pc on pre-Covid-19 levels thanks to increases under the previous Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil-dominated coalition. The two parties have since returned to power. 'Higher investment in housing, transport and energy infrastructure is essential to maintain foreign investor confidence and preserve living standards,' the report says. That investment should be scheduled to avoid causing a surge in prices, it says. 'Additionally, greater emphasis should be placed on improving spending efficiency – supported by comprehensive spending reviews, stricter domestic fiscal guard-rails, and better-targeted income support where needed,' it says. Windfall corporation taxes should continue to be allocated to the long-term savings funds, it says. Given the nature of the economy, Ireland is especially exposed to the threat from a US trade war, the report warns. The OECD is forecasting a significant slow down in economic growth here; with modified domestic demand predicted to slow to 2.2pc this year and 2.1pc in 2026 – both well below the long-term average. The budget surplus is expected to narrow, though not close. Tariff-related concerns are expected to weigh on consumers, even with strong jobs and wage data, while the export sector and multinationals are heavily exposed to any hit to US trade. Gross domestic product (GDP) growth is projected to be 3.7pc in 2025, slowing to 2.3pc next year as trade fragmentation weighs on export-oriented sectors. Uncertainty will encourage households to save more and spend less. While the Government is expected to have less money at its disposal than in recent years, the report calls for higher investment in housing, transport and energy infrastructure. With labour shortages in many sectors it suggests boosting incentives in the tax and benefit system, alongside improving the supply of quality vocational pathways into skilled work. Meanwhile, the OECD is forecasting that the US economy will see growth slow further to just 1.5pc in 2026. Donald Trump's policies have raised average US tariff rates from around 2.5pc when he returned to the White House to 15.4pc, the highest since 1938, according to the report. World economic growth will slow to 2.9pc this year and stay there in 2026, according to the forecast. That is well down on global growth of 3.3pc last year and 3.4pc in 2023. Without mentioning Mr Trump by name, OECD chief economist Alvaro Pereira wrote in a commentary accompanying the forecast: "We have seen a significant increase in trade barriers as well as in economic and trade policy uncertainty. This sharp rise in uncertainty has negatively impacted business and consumer confidence and is set to hold back trade and investment.'' China – the world's second-biggest economy – is forecast to see growth slow from 5pc last year to 4.7pc in 2025 and 4.3pc in 2026. Euro area growth is tipped to accelerate, however, up from 0.8pc last year to 1pc in 2025 and 1.2pc next year, in part thanks to rate cuts from the European Central Bank.
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Calls for suspension of EU-Israel Association Agreement
The head of a leading Palestinian human rights organisation has urged the European Union to suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement in light of Israel's deepening military campaign in Gaza and the planned expansion of illegal Jewish settlements in the West Bank. Issam Younis, managing director of the Al Mezan Centre for Human Rights, was addressing a meeting in Brussels on the situation in Gaza and the West Bank hosted by the European Endowment for Democracy (EED), an EU-funded organisation supporting democracy in the Middle East. "If not now, when? Shall they wait until how many Palestinians are killed - more than 54,000," asked Mr Younis. "We have no need to prove that Israel is violating the basic principles of international law and international humanitarian law. "It's well documented." Last month a majority of EU member states, including Ireland, signed up to a Dutch proposal for a review of the Association Agreement, on the basis that Israel may be in breach of its binding human rights and international humanitarian law clauses. On foot of that shift in member state opinion, the EU's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas has begun the review process, with the possibility that it may be completed in time for a meeting of EU foreign ministers in Luxembourg on 23 June. Mr Younis said the advisory opinion last July of the International Court of Justice was clear and the EU had a moral, legal and political obligation to abide by the court's finding. "First, the occupation is illegal. It should be ended," he said. "Palestinians have full rights for self-determination. "What is really important [regarding] the advisory opinion is that it has obligations on third party states, and here we're talking about act not to prolong the occupation and to cease any cooperation with the state of Israel that would prolong the occupation. Mr Younis said the statements by religious right ministers in the Israeli coalition amounted to the ethnic cleansing of Gaza and that the time was ripe for the EU to apply concrete measures which would help bring about a two-state solution. "If Europe is still advocating the two-state solution, then they should say clearly that settlements are illegal and genocide [has] be stopped, and that Gaza is for Gazans," he said. Mr Younis accused Israel of deliberately frustrating the two-state solution by expanding illegal settlements in the West Bank and by creating irreversible facts on the ground. The Al Mezan Center for Human Rights is an independent, non-partisan, organisation based in Gaza.
