MPs vote to continue parliamentary ping-pong over AI ‘theft' crackdown
Conservative shadow science minister Dr Ben Spencer, who described himself as a 'Bill Murray fan', called on the Government to 'bring an end to this Groundhog Day'.
Peers agreed on Monday to amend the Government's Data (Use and Access) Bill.
Their proposal would force the Government to prepare fresh legislation which would open up AI model databases, so that copyright owners could see whether their works have been used as 'data inputs'.
But MPs voted 317 to 185, majority 132, on Tuesday to reject the amendment and continue the battle at Westminster, known as parliamentary ping-pong.
Rocket Man singer Sir Elton John is among the stars who have urged the Government to strengthen copyright protections, when he said last month that ministers are 'absolute losers' and that he felt 'incredibly betrayed'.
Dr Spencer told the Commons: 'Copyright law is a toothless instrument if the lack of transparency about the use of create content in AI models continues.
'The lack of transparency renders rights enforcement elusive, and the Government is apparently happy for this to persist on an open-ended basis.'
At the despatch box, he added: 'Creatives continue to lose out when their work is exploited without payment, the AI industry, especially smaller firms, can't get out of the starting blocks let alone play their part in turbocharging our tech economy, and the Government continues to risk the confidence of both key industries with the chilling effect on investment that this entails.'
On the stand-off, Dr Spencer told the Commons: 'We're stuck in Groundhog Day in this Bill until the Government realises that the Lords' amendments are not a nuisance but an opportunity, and that they need to listen to the concerns and change course.'
There is no time commitment from the Government benches whatsoever on bringing back a Bill to this House to address the current theft of property that is raining down on the UK creative industries
Conservative former minister Sir Julian Smith
Conservative former minister Sir Julian Smith later said: 'There is no time commitment from the Government benches whatsoever on bringing back a Bill to this House to address the current theft of property that is raining down on the UK creative industries.'
ADVERTISEMENT
Learn more
Technology minister Sir Chris Bryant had earlier spoken against the amendment, which was put forward by Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason director Baroness Kidron.
'One could argue that introducing a draft Bill which would then be considered in various different places, followed presumably by a Bill, would actually delay things rather than speed things up,' Sir Chris told the Commons.
He said that he 'cannot think of any Bill in our history that has included such a clause', to compel the Government to bring forward new draft legislation within three months of the publication of a report into the use of copyrighted works in the development of AI systems.
Sir Chris told MPs: 'A central plank of parliamentary sovereignty is no parliament can bind its successor.
'That doesn't just mean from one parliament to another, but it means one session can't bind a future session.'
Commons culture, media and sport committee chairwoman Dame Caroline Dinenage, the Conservative MP for Gosport, accused Sir Chris of 'dancing on the head of a pin' and added: 'The fact is that all legislation somehow binds those that are coming down the track.'
The Bill will now return to the House of Lords.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
2 hours ago
- Irish Post
British Government must ‘honour its commitments' on Casement Park
FIRST Minister Michelle O'Neill has called on the British Government to honour its commitments on funding the redevelopment of Casement Park stadium. Out of action since 2013, the GAA grounds in Belfast are in need of a costly rebuild in order to make them fit for purpose once again. There were hopes that the site could be rebuilt in time to host matches within the upcoming Euro 2028 tournament, which is due to take place at venues across Britain and Ireland, but these were dashed last year when the British Government pulled its funding for the project, claiming there was 'significant risk' that the project would not be completed in time for the event. Despite being unable to take part in the Euro 2028 event, plans to rebuild the site are still on the table. The project has an estimated cost of £250m, just under half of which is already in place, with the Irish government pledging around £43m, the Northern Ireland Executive committing to £62.5m and the GAA lined up to provide £15m. The British Government has yet to commit to a funding sum for the project, although Chancellor Rachel Reeves is due to announce a comprehensive spending review next week which is expected to include the stadium development plans. Ms O'Neill met with the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland Hilary Benn yesterday afternoon where they discussed the project. 'Casement Park must be built,' Ms O'Neill said following the meeting. 'We've just me with the Secretary of State and we have let them know in no uncertain terms, and have done at every turn, how important Casement Park is,' she explained. 'The British Government must find a way to honour its political commitment and put their money on the table and back a project that will bring enormous benefits to everybody.' Ms O'Neill explained the importance of the stadium to the people of Northern Ireland, claiming 'the GAA is something to be celebrated, it's something that really celebrates diversity, it's something that is really at the heart of our community'. She added: 'This is a flagship project for the Executive, there is a political commitment to make this happen and to deliver upon Casement Park and I want to work with all ministers around the Executive table, with both the British government, the Irish Government and the GAA. 'Lets get this done. Let's deliver on Casement Park.' SDLP Leader Claire Hanna believes the Northern Ireland Executive should also increase the funding commitment it has made to project. Ms Hanna claims the Executive's long-standing offer of £62.5m is out of step with the growth in its own budget in the years that have passed since the offer was first made. 'The idea that a £62.5m offer still stands, unchanged, despite a dramatically increased budget, simply doesn't add up,' she said. 'This isn't about whether the money exists—it's about whether there's the will to use it,' she added. 'Let's be clear: the delay in getting Casement Park built is unacceptable. If the Executive shows its commitment through real funding, it will strengthen the case for UK investment. "But both sides need to stop passing the buck.'
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
A main road that endangers the lives of drivers every day must be urgently upgraded says Sligo business group
Sligo Chamber of Commerce has called on the Government to scrap a limited plan to redevelop just two sections of the N17 and commit to a previous promise to transform the entire 40km stretch of road from Collooney to Ireland West Airport Knock into a modern, safe, dual carriageway. The call is backed by Joe Gilmore, Managing Director of Ireland West Airport Knock and other regional businesses, who have urged the Government to revisit plans for full redevelopment of the road as originally outlined in the National Planning Framework. The Chamber and Ireland West Airport Knock believe the current situation in which heavy goods vehicles are travelling alongside cars, buses, and agricultural vehicles in winding single lanes of traffic is proving a barrier to economic growth in the region. The N17 is the primary road linking the West and North West and forms part of the national network connecting the cities along the western seaboard – Cork, Limerick, Galway and Derry. It is also a key part of the Atlantic Economic Corridor, a government initiative to encourage investment in the West of Ireland. A provision for the full redevelopment of the N17 from Collooney to Ireland West Airport was established in the National Planning Framework in 2018. However, in 2023, the previous Minister for Transport, Eamon Ryan, placed a ministerial condition on the planned redevelopment which limited the works to the construction of a bypass at Tubbercurry and another at Charlestown. Sligo Chamber of Commerce CEO Aidan Doyle believes the ministerial condition is an 'arbitrary' measure and must be scrapped in favour of full redevelopment. He added: 'The existing road connecting Ireland West Airport Knock and Collooney is unsafe and unfit for purpose. Drivers and residents of communities along the N17 are sadly familiar with the unsafe conditions created by the heavy flow of traffic along the route. To kick-start economic growth and protect the lives of road users, it's vital that the Government scraps the arbitrary ministerial condition inserted by the previous Minister for Transport and delivers on original commitments in the National Planning Framework, which is a high-standard dual carriageway linking the 40km section of road linking Collooney and Ireland West Airport Knock.' Data from the Northern and Western Regional Assembly (NWRA) shows that northern and western region is lagging far behind its European counterparts in terms of infrastructure provision. Indeed, according to a 2024 report from the NWRA, the Northern and Western Region ranks 218th out 234 NUTS2 regions for transport infrastructure and has a regional competitiveness rating on par with regions in the former Soviet states of Romania, Hungary, Slovakia, and Poland. Managing Director of Ireland West Airport Knock Joe Gilmore said: 'The existing N17 is a barrier to growth in the North West and West of Ireland. The delivery of a modern dual carriageway from Ireland West Airport Knock to Collooney, and south of the airport to Tuam, as outlined in the National Planning Framework, will be necessary to fulfil our region's economic potential and address the eastern imbalance in the national economy. A safe and free-flowing connection to Ireland West Airport can go a long way to remedying this imbalance and setting the region, and the country, on the path to a more prosperous future.' Also urging the Government to invest in a larger-scale capital project are Daithi Feehily, CEO of Sligo Travel, and Ann Butler of Higgins Pharmacy in Sligo. Learn more As a regular user of the N17, Mr Feehily says there are unsafe conditions created by heavy traffic flows along the narrow and winding route. Indeed, Mr Feehily reported that his fleet of vehicles regularly sustain damage when passing other buses or HGVs on the road. Ms Butler, who lives along the N17, has criticised the government's failure to commit to the full redevelopment of the route, adding that the current condition of the road endangers lives of motorists and residents of communities along the N17 and deepens regional inequality. Sligo Travel CEO Daithi Feehily said: 'Our drivers regularly travel along the N17. The narrow and winding nature of the road is such that our vehicles have sustained damage from passing HGVs and public transport. While this damage has so far been limited to broken wing mirrors and glazing, the effect on a small business like ours is not insignificant. We have considerable concerns for the safety of drivers and passengers on the N17 and fear that there could be much more serious consequences from these incidents if the road is not redeveloped in the future.' Managing Director of Higgins Pharmacy Ann Butler said: 'The N17 between Ireland West Airport Knock and Collooney is not just a bottleneck to economic growth – it's a daily hazard to public safety. The government's failure to deliver on its commitment to fully redevelop this vital route endangers lives and deepens regional inequality. We call for immediate investment to transform the N17 into a safe, modern dual carriageway that supports both prosperity and protection for the North West.'
RTÉ News
5 hours ago
- RTÉ News
North west businesses call for full N17 upgrade
Sligo Chamber of Commerce has called on the Government to scrap a plan to redevelop some sections of the N17 and to commit to a full redevelopment of the route between Knock and Collooney, describing it as "unsafe and unfit for purpose". The Chamber, representing more than 200 businesses in the north west, wants the Government to "commit to a previous promise to transform the entire 40km stretch of road from Collooney to Ireland West Airport Knock into a modern, safe, dual carriageway". The call is backed by the Managing Director of Ireland West Airport Knock, Joe Gilmore, and other regional businesses, who have urged the Government to revisit plans for a full redevelopment of the road. The N17 is the primary road connecting the west and north west regions. It forms part of the Atlantic Economic Corridor connecting Cork, Limerick, Galway and Derry. Sligo Chamber of Commerce said a provision for the full redevelopment of the N17 from Collooney to Ireland West Airport was established in the National Planning Framework in 2018. However, it said a ministerial condition issued two years ago has limited the planned works to the construction of bypasses of Tubbercurry and Charlestown. The Chamber's CEO, Aidan Doyle, believes the ministerial condition is an "arbitrary" measure and must be scrapped in favour of full redevelopment. Mr Doyle says the existing road connecting Ireland West Airport Knock and Collooney is unsafe and unfit for purpose. The Chamber's call is backed by the Managing Director of Ireland West Airport Knock, Joe Gilmore, who said the existing N17 is a barrier to regional growth. Mr Gilmore said the delivery of a dual carriageway from Ireland West Airport Knock between Collooney and Tuam will be necessary to fulfil the region's economic potential and to address regional imbalance in the national economy. "Daily hazard to public safety" A previous TII report found the Knock to Collooney route has a collision rating twice the national average and traffic volumes exceed efficient operating capacity. CEO of Sligo Travel, Dáithí Feehily, said his company's vehicles have sustained damage from passing HGVs and public transport because of the road's narrowness at certain locations. Mr Feehily said that while this damage has so far been limited to broken wing mirrors and glazing, its effect on business is not insignificant. "We have considerable concerns for the safety of drivers and passengers on the N17 and fear that there could be much more serious consequences from these incidents if the road is not redeveloped in the future," Mr Feehily said. Ann Butler of Higgins Pharmacy in Sligo, who lives along the N17, has criticised the Government's failure to commit to the full redevelopment of the route. "The N17 between Ireland West Airport Knock and Collooney is not just a bottleneck to economic growth – it's a daily hazard to public safety," she said. Ms Butler said the Government's "failure to deliver on its commitment to fully redevelop this vital route endangers lives and deepens regional inequality". "We call for immediate investment to transform the N17 into a safe, modern dual carriageway that supports both prosperity and protection for the north west," she added. A spokesperson for the Department of Transport said the N17 Knock to Collooney project is listed for progression in the current National Development Plan. The spokesperson said the Government is "committed to the development of this project, as demonstrated by the allocation of €1 million to progress it in 2025". The Route Selection phase was completed last year. The project is now in the Design and Environmental Phase. This phase, which is expected to conclude late next year or in early 2027, includes detailed road design, necessary surveys, geotechnical investigations, and preparations related to the submission of a planning application. Upon the conclusion of this phase, a preliminary business case will be submitted to the Department of Transport ahead of a Government decision on approval-in-principle, as is required under the Infrastructure Guidelines. The Minister for Transport, Darragh O'Brien, told RTÉ News that it is anticipated the project could go to construction around the end of this decade, subject to the necessary approvals and completion of the planning process. Minister O'Brien said he is fully aware of the importance of the project in supporting "a vital regional link," which connects Sligo to Ireland West Airport Knock. N17 being examined as part of NDP review The department spokesperson told RTÉ News that elements of the overall project would provide bypasses of Charlestown and Tubbercurry and are "of particular importance, given the need to reduce congestion and improve safety in both towns". The spokesperson said that while minister's allocations letter of 2024 focused on the progression of these [Charlestown and Tubbercurry] bypasses, it was important to point out that as part of the ongoing review of the National Development Plan, a wide range of projects are being examined, including Knock to Collooney. Minister O'Brien said the Programme for Government commitment to increased funding for new roads as part of the NDP review should "greatly assist in the delivery of projects such as the N17 Knock to Collooney Project."
