Luigi Mangione's lawyers claim DA used fake court date, bogus subpoena to get his medical records
In a new court filing, the defense accuses prosecutors of violating HIPAA, the federal law that protects medical privacy. They say the DA's office pressured Mangione's health insurer, Aetna, into handing over documents without a court order or consent from any party involved.
According to the filing, prosecutors faked a court date and used a "false and fraudulent" subpoena, warning Aetna it would be held in contempt of court if it didn't comply.
Mangione's lawyers are now asking the judge to sanction the DA's office, including the possibility of throwing out the charges entirely. They are requesting a formal evidentiary hearing on the matter.LUIGI MANGIONE'S TEAM ASKS COURT TO REMOVE 'SHACKLES,' BULLETPROOF VEST ON UNITEDHEALTHCARE CEO MURDER SUSPECT
The Manhattan District Attorney's Office told Fox News it will respond in court papers. It said very limited information was requested from Aetna and Aetna sent additional materials in error.
"We deleted the materials as soon as we became aware of them and brought it to defense and the court's attention," the office said.
Mangione is charged with murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside the Hilton Hotel in Midtown Manhattan on Dec. 4, 2024, just before the company's annual investor conference. Prosecutors say Mangione used a homemade ghost gun equipped with a silencer and shot Thompson twice at close range before fleeing the scene.LUIGI MANGIONE ARGUES DOUBLE JEOPARDY IN BID TO DROP MURDER CASE, SUPPRESS EVIDENCE
The DA's office argues the killing was ideologically motivated, calling it an act intended to "violently broadcast a social and political message to the public at large." According to court filings, Mangione allegedly marked ammunition with the words "deny," "delay," and "depose," and described himself as a "revolutionary anarchist."
Prosecutors also cite journal entries and a note to the FBI in which Mangione allegedly expressed grievances against the U.S. healthcare system, writing that "these parasites simply had it coming."
Mangione has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
Defense attorneys have separately moved to suppress Mangione's statements to law enforcement and evidence from his backpack, arguing both were obtained unlawfully. They've also asked the court to dismiss terrorism-related charges, citing constitutional concerns over double jeopardy and concurrent state and federal prosecutions.
The DA's office calls it "an open and shut case" and argues that the evidence is "overwhelming."CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
A judge will now decide whether to grant the defense's request for a hearing on the alleged HIPAA violation. The broader motion to dismiss and suppress remains pending.
The state case is proceeding ahead of a separate federal prosecution, where the government is seeking the death penalty.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Cryptocrash king' Do Kwon pleads guilty to fraud
A South Korean former tech executive accused of a helping to spark a cryptocurrency crisis that cost investors more than $40bn (£31.8bn) has pleaded guilty to two criminal counts of fraud. Do Kwon was the boss of Singapore-based Terraform Labs, which operated two cryptocurrencies - TerraUSD and Luna - both of which collapsed in 2022, triggering a wider sell-off in the crypto market. The US says he was responsible for the failure of the two digital currencies, accusing him of "orchestrating a multi-billion dollar crypto asset securities fraud". As part of the plea deal, prosecutors have agreed to refrain from seeking a sentence longer than 12 years. Kwon is due to be sentenced on 11 December. Kwon's guilty plea in a New York court comes after a lengthy legal battle. He initially fled South Korea after a warrant for his arrest was issued in 2023, eventually ending up in Montenegro where he was arrested and jailed before being extradited to the US. US prosecutors said Kwon misrepresented features that were supposed to keep the so-called stablecoin at $1 without outside intervention. They alleged that in 2021, Kwon arranged for a trading firm to surreptitiously purchase millions of dollars worth of the token to restore TerraUSD's value, even as he told investors that a computer algorithm called Terra Protocol was responsible. Prosecutors say the alleged misrepresentation prompted a wide array of investors to buy Terraform's offerings, which helped prop up the value of the company's Luna token, which was closely linked to TerraUSD. The following year, Kwon's TerraUSD and the Luna cryptocurrency crashed. "In 2021, I made false and misleading statements about why [TerraUSD] regained its peg," he said in court on Tuesday. "What I did was wrong and I want to apologise for my conduct," he added. Kwon had originally pleaded not guilty to nine counts stemming from the crash, including securities and wire fraud, and money laundering conspiracy. He had faced up to 135 years in prison if convicted of the charges in the original indictment. As part of his plea deal, Kwon agreed to refrain from challenging the allegations in the indictment. He must also forfeit up to $19.3m plus interest and several properties and pay restitution. While prosecutors have agreed to limit their requested sentence to 12 years, Judge Paul Engelmayer maintained that he was entitled to prescribe a longer sentence. That sentence could be up to 25 years in prison. He still faces charges in South Korea, according to his attorney. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data
CBS News
2 minutes ago
- CBS News
Nursing mother in ICE custody in Minnesota to be released from detention, judge rules
A nursing mother who has spent more than three weeks in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody will soon be reunited with her children following a federal judge's ruling on Tuesday. Antonia Aguilar Maldonado, 26, was arrested by federal agents on July 17. She came to the United States from El Salvador as a teenager and has no criminal history. She is now seeking asylum and lives in Lake Elmo, Minnesota. Her attorneys filed a writ of habeas corpus challenging her detention because an immigration judge authorized her release on bond on July 31. Soon after the U.S. Department of Homeland Security then filed an automatic stay to keep her in custody at the Kandiyohi County Jail despite that order. They sought injunctive relief to block that from taking effect and require her release while her case moves forward. Hannah Brown, one of her attorneys, told the court Tuesday that her client is experiencing emotional and mental distress while separated from her two U.S. citizen children, including her youngest whom she is breastfeeding. She also said she faces physical harm because she cannot pump on a set schedule or in sanitary conditions. U.S. District Judge Susan Richard Nelson delivered a ruling from the bench in St. Paul after each side made their arguments, ultimately granting the request for a temporary restraining order which will force her release. She rejected the government's argument that Aguilar Maldonado's detention was allowable by law and said ICE violated its own policies for pregnant and nursing mothers. Nelson said ICE contends that a January executive order from President Donald Trump revoked that rule, but "nowhere in that policy is there a mention of nursing mothers." "In the court's view, the irreparable harm to separating a nursing mother and her child is self-evident," she said. She added that her case is a civil matter yet Aguilar Maldonado is being held in conditions "indiscriminable" to criminal detention and that agents made a "mistake" when they arrested her. A written ruling will follow later this week. Aguilar Maldonado's attorneys said she will be released as soon as she posts bond, likely early Wednesday morning. The court room was packed with friends, congregants at Aguilar Maldonado's local church and other community members who observed the hearing. They erupted into applause once it was over, celebrating her release. Her church helped raise money to pay her bond. "A lot of people can relate to Ms. Aguilar Maldonado's situation and to her story. And there are folks here who know her and folks here who don't know her," Brown said. "And I think it was really beautiful to see so many people, so many Minnesotans, showing their support for a young mother who does not need to be detained." Aguilar Maldonado came to the U.S. in 2017 as a minor, granting her special protections, and had a removal order in 2019 for failing to attend a hearing. But an immigration judge reopened her case last year after finding she wasn't given notice of that court appearance, Gloria Contreras Edin, another one of her attorneys told WCCO in an interview. Since then, she has been doing "everything right," she added, and filed for asylum and obtained work authorization. Her arrest on July 17 came as a surprise. When asked about Aguilar Maldonado's case, a spokesperson for ICE provided the following statement to WCCO: "By statute, we have no information on this person." "[Her son] is allergic to other forms of milk, and so unfortunately, this baby has been without his mother's milk now for 26 days, and she wants to get to him right away and start nursing," Contreras Edin told reporters Tuesday. Contreras Edin and Brown said she will remain free as her writ of habeas corpus petition proceeds. The government is also appealing the immigration judge's earlier ruling late last month. The judge said she does not have a removal order at this time. Telma Vides, a friend of Aguilar Maldonado, spoke with her friend soon after the hearing and said she was excited and crying nonstop when she learned that should be released. "It's just amazing what God can do to get her out," Vides said. "It just kept going up and down and up—it's been a roller coaster all these three weeks."
Fox News
4 minutes ago
- Fox News
National Guard troops seen in DC amid Trump crackdown on crime in capital
The Trump administration has cited the city's crime rate for the surge in law enforcement.
