Councillors reject 584-dwelling development due to flooding and koala fears
Port Stephens councillors have unanimously rejected a rezoning proposal for a 584-home development at Anna Bay.
The proposal faced significant community backlash, with residents pointing out the 125-hectare site at 283 Gan Gan Road had been identified as a floodplain and core koala habitat.
On Tuesday night, councillors were united in their condemnation of the proposal and supported staff's recommendation to reject the application.
Deputy mayor Jason Wells said the site had been identified in multiple strategic documents as unsuitable for development.
"Those documents aren't just red tape, they're not to gather dust on a bookshelf, they exist for a reason," Cr Wells said.
"They reflect years of research, consultation and expert planning to guide responsible growth. We can't start ignoring those frameworks completely."
Cr Paul Le Mottee said there was a ministerial directive ordering councils not to rezone flood-prone land for residential use.
"It's black and white - it's got no definition about if it's just a little bit of flooding, a lot of flooding or you're just going to fill it," he said.
"So as far as I'm concerned, forget all the other issues about whether you can build fancy big drains or rehabilitate [the environment] to get past everything else. That ministerial directive is a complete and utter roadblock."
Developer AB Rise proposed to import one to four metres, or 1000 truckloads, of fill to raise land to lift the land above the flood level
Mecone director Chris Shannon helped prepare the proposal and spoke on behalf of the developers.
He said flooding concerns would be addressed by raising the land and reconstructing the Anna Bay main drain, while a 33-hectare offset would alleviate environmental issues
"We're willing to work with council officers to provide the additional information," Mr Shannon said.
"If there are concerns with the proposal we're willing to make amendments as needed, but we haven't been given that opportunity."
The last time the council requested more information from AB Rise during the assessment of stage one - the adjacent 34-lot development on Gan Gan Road - the company took the matter to the NSW Land and Environment Court.
Community futures director Stephen Peart indicated further information would not change the council's opinion.
"Council has undertaken flood studies around Anna Bay catchment for many, many years, we understand the site is a significant flood risk and the flooding characteristics on that site haven't changed," Mr Peart said.
"We're not in the business of asking applicants to provide additional technical studies and spend more money on consultants when we don't believe there is strong strategic merit for an application."
Cr Peter Francis said the proposed in-filling - estimated to be the equivalent of 428 Olympic-sized swimming pools - would displace a significant amount of water.
Michael Atkinson neighbours the proposal and raised concerns about the impact of flooding, which was already threatening surrounding properties, some of which were just 60 centimetres above sea level.
"A resident in my street had their flood insurance go up to $16,000 a year, and my neighbour just stopped paying the flood portion of his insurance because it's too expensive," he told the councillors.
Cr Roz Armstrong labelled the development "highly opportunistic".
"They thought because of the current need for housing in the area they could run roughshod over established processes," she said.
Port Stephens councillors have unanimously rejected a rezoning proposal for a 584-home development at Anna Bay.
The proposal faced significant community backlash, with residents pointing out the 125-hectare site at 283 Gan Gan Road had been identified as a floodplain and core koala habitat.
On Tuesday night, councillors were united in their condemnation of the proposal and supported staff's recommendation to reject the application.
Deputy mayor Jason Wells said the site had been identified in multiple strategic documents as unsuitable for development.
"Those documents aren't just red tape, they're not to gather dust on a bookshelf, they exist for a reason," Cr Wells said.
"They reflect years of research, consultation and expert planning to guide responsible growth. We can't start ignoring those frameworks completely."
Cr Paul Le Mottee said there was a ministerial directive ordering councils not to rezone flood-prone land for residential use.
"It's black and white - it's got no definition about if it's just a little bit of flooding, a lot of flooding or you're just going to fill it," he said.
"So as far as I'm concerned, forget all the other issues about whether you can build fancy big drains or rehabilitate [the environment] to get past everything else. That ministerial directive is a complete and utter roadblock."
Developer AB Rise proposed to import one to four metres, or 1000 truckloads, of fill to raise land to lift the land above the flood level
Mecone director Chris Shannon helped prepare the proposal and spoke on behalf of the developers.
He said flooding concerns would be addressed by raising the land and reconstructing the Anna Bay main drain, while a 33-hectare offset would alleviate environmental issues
"We're willing to work with council officers to provide the additional information," Mr Shannon said.
"If there are concerns with the proposal we're willing to make amendments as needed, but we haven't been given that opportunity."
The last time the council requested more information from AB Rise during the assessment of stage one - the adjacent 34-lot development on Gan Gan Road - the company took the matter to the NSW Land and Environment Court.
Community futures director Stephen Peart indicated further information would not change the council's opinion.
"Council has undertaken flood studies around Anna Bay catchment for many, many years, we understand the site is a significant flood risk and the flooding characteristics on that site haven't changed," Mr Peart said.
"We're not in the business of asking applicants to provide additional technical studies and spend more money on consultants when we don't believe there is strong strategic merit for an application."
Cr Peter Francis said the proposed in-filling - estimated to be the equivalent of 428 Olympic-sized swimming pools - would displace a significant amount of water.
Michael Atkinson neighbours the proposal and raised concerns about the impact of flooding, which was already threatening surrounding properties, some of which were just 60 centimetres above sea level.
"A resident in my street had their flood insurance go up to $16,000 a year, and my neighbour just stopped paying the flood portion of his insurance because it's too expensive," he told the councillors.
Cr Roz Armstrong labelled the development "highly opportunistic".
"They thought because of the current need for housing in the area they could run roughshod over established processes," she said.
Port Stephens councillors have unanimously rejected a rezoning proposal for a 584-home development at Anna Bay.
The proposal faced significant community backlash, with residents pointing out the 125-hectare site at 283 Gan Gan Road had been identified as a floodplain and core koala habitat.
On Tuesday night, councillors were united in their condemnation of the proposal and supported staff's recommendation to reject the application.
Deputy mayor Jason Wells said the site had been identified in multiple strategic documents as unsuitable for development.
"Those documents aren't just red tape, they're not to gather dust on a bookshelf, they exist for a reason," Cr Wells said.
"They reflect years of research, consultation and expert planning to guide responsible growth. We can't start ignoring those frameworks completely."
Cr Paul Le Mottee said there was a ministerial directive ordering councils not to rezone flood-prone land for residential use.
"It's black and white - it's got no definition about if it's just a little bit of flooding, a lot of flooding or you're just going to fill it," he said.
"So as far as I'm concerned, forget all the other issues about whether you can build fancy big drains or rehabilitate [the environment] to get past everything else. That ministerial directive is a complete and utter roadblock."
Developer AB Rise proposed to import one to four metres, or 1000 truckloads, of fill to raise land to lift the land above the flood level
Mecone director Chris Shannon helped prepare the proposal and spoke on behalf of the developers.
He said flooding concerns would be addressed by raising the land and reconstructing the Anna Bay main drain, while a 33-hectare offset would alleviate environmental issues
"We're willing to work with council officers to provide the additional information," Mr Shannon said.
"If there are concerns with the proposal we're willing to make amendments as needed, but we haven't been given that opportunity."
The last time the council requested more information from AB Rise during the assessment of stage one - the adjacent 34-lot development on Gan Gan Road - the company took the matter to the NSW Land and Environment Court.
Community futures director Stephen Peart indicated further information would not change the council's opinion.
"Council has undertaken flood studies around Anna Bay catchment for many, many years, we understand the site is a significant flood risk and the flooding characteristics on that site haven't changed," Mr Peart said.
"We're not in the business of asking applicants to provide additional technical studies and spend more money on consultants when we don't believe there is strong strategic merit for an application."
Cr Peter Francis said the proposed in-filling - estimated to be the equivalent of 428 Olympic-sized swimming pools - would displace a significant amount of water.
Michael Atkinson neighbours the proposal and raised concerns about the impact of flooding, which was already threatening surrounding properties, some of which were just 60 centimetres above sea level.
"A resident in my street had their flood insurance go up to $16,000 a year, and my neighbour just stopped paying the flood portion of his insurance because it's too expensive," he told the councillors.
Cr Roz Armstrong labelled the development "highly opportunistic".
"They thought because of the current need for housing in the area they could run roughshod over established processes," she said.
Port Stephens councillors have unanimously rejected a rezoning proposal for a 584-home development at Anna Bay.
The proposal faced significant community backlash, with residents pointing out the 125-hectare site at 283 Gan Gan Road had been identified as a floodplain and core koala habitat.
On Tuesday night, councillors were united in their condemnation of the proposal and supported staff's recommendation to reject the application.
Deputy mayor Jason Wells said the site had been identified in multiple strategic documents as unsuitable for development.
"Those documents aren't just red tape, they're not to gather dust on a bookshelf, they exist for a reason," Cr Wells said.
"They reflect years of research, consultation and expert planning to guide responsible growth. We can't start ignoring those frameworks completely."
Cr Paul Le Mottee said there was a ministerial directive ordering councils not to rezone flood-prone land for residential use.
"It's black and white - it's got no definition about if it's just a little bit of flooding, a lot of flooding or you're just going to fill it," he said.
"So as far as I'm concerned, forget all the other issues about whether you can build fancy big drains or rehabilitate [the environment] to get past everything else. That ministerial directive is a complete and utter roadblock."
Developer AB Rise proposed to import one to four metres, or 1000 truckloads, of fill to raise land to lift the land above the flood level
Mecone director Chris Shannon helped prepare the proposal and spoke on behalf of the developers.
He said flooding concerns would be addressed by raising the land and reconstructing the Anna Bay main drain, while a 33-hectare offset would alleviate environmental issues
"We're willing to work with council officers to provide the additional information," Mr Shannon said.
"If there are concerns with the proposal we're willing to make amendments as needed, but we haven't been given that opportunity."
The last time the council requested more information from AB Rise during the assessment of stage one - the adjacent 34-lot development on Gan Gan Road - the company took the matter to the NSW Land and Environment Court.
Community futures director Stephen Peart indicated further information would not change the council's opinion.
"Council has undertaken flood studies around Anna Bay catchment for many, many years, we understand the site is a significant flood risk and the flooding characteristics on that site haven't changed," Mr Peart said.
"We're not in the business of asking applicants to provide additional technical studies and spend more money on consultants when we don't believe there is strong strategic merit for an application."
Cr Peter Francis said the proposed in-filling - estimated to be the equivalent of 428 Olympic-sized swimming pools - would displace a significant amount of water.
Michael Atkinson neighbours the proposal and raised concerns about the impact of flooding, which was already threatening surrounding properties, some of which were just 60 centimetres above sea level.
"A resident in my street had their flood insurance go up to $16,000 a year, and my neighbour just stopped paying the flood portion of his insurance because it's too expensive," he told the councillors.
Cr Roz Armstrong labelled the development "highly opportunistic".
"They thought because of the current need for housing in the area they could run roughshod over established processes," she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
a day ago
- Sky News AU
'Long term health' of construction sector under threat as risky practice continues, Arcadis' Matthew Mackey warns
Builders across the nation continue to take on risks as limited potential work forces them to take action that could hurt the long-term health of the sector, new research has revealed. The latest report from consultancy Arcadis showed construction costs continue to soar in Australia as severe labour shortages and high insolvency rates plague the nation. Arcadis' executive director of cost and commercial management Matthew Mackey said contractors in some states where work opportunities had slowed down were taking more risks. Fixed-price contracts contributed to the rise of building insolvencies during and after the pandemic when costs ballooned. 'I would like to say that fixed price contracts are not as prevalent as they were. That would be lying though,' Mr Mackey said on Sky News' Business Now. 'We are seeing a change in attitudes in some states. 'Where workload has been picking up, clients have been more willing to look at collaborative-based-type contracts and look at rise and fall mechanisms to cover cost increases for certain materials. 'In other states, where there's been a bit of a contraction in terms of potential work opportunities, they're certainly moving back to more risk-based and more fixed price type contracts, which is not necessarily good for the long-term health of the sector.' The pipeline of work in New South Wales and Victoria has fallen compared to the states' respective booms over the past 10-15 years. Arcadis' report says persistent capacity constraints will plague Sydney's housing market, while a subdued private sector in Melbourne will limit future growth in Victoria. Mr Mackey said the rise in housing development was shifting to the nation's smaller cities amid Sydney and Melbourne's drop. 'We are seeing that shift now over towards Western Australia and Queensland, and Brisbane and Perth in particular,' he said. 'Perth has been extremely busy over the last couple of years. 'Costs in 2024 alone in Perth went up by about 11 per cent which shows the buoyancy of that market and how busy that market is.' Mr Mackey also noted the soaring materials costs from the pandemic had 'largely abated' throughout 2024 and the start of 2025, however, Aussies can still expect price hikes down the track. Melbourne prices are forecast to rise by 25.5 per cent between 2025-29, while Sydney prices are expected to jump 27.9 per cent over 2024-29. Costs in Brisbane are also expected to soar as the Queensland government begins its Olympic infrastructure program. Arcadis' report also warned Labor's $10 billion housing fund and expanded help-to-buy scheme could inject fresh demand that outpaces supply. "The ability to deliver on their agenda rests on the sector's capacity to overcome supply constraints, adapt to regulatory changes, and innovate in project delivery," Arcadis said.
AU Financial Review
3 days ago
- AU Financial Review
Citi's new top equity banker shows how memories fade
Hats off to Citi's PR machine with the announcement last week that John McLean would be returning from Singapore as head of equity capital markets for Australia and New Zealand. Most (if not all) of the coverage in the finance press reprinted its media release. Or, naturally, focused on McLean replacing Rob Jahrling, the three-time Olympic rower who presided over the bank's mishandling of a Goodman block trade last year. Citi's misjudgment around the price of $1.9 billion of Goodman shares led to a $70 million loss for the firm. Few recover from such a big, single loss. Jahrling was always going to be on borrowed time.
Mercury
3 days ago
- Mercury
Mystery buyer of Sydney's skinniest waterfront revealed
Olympic gold-medalist swimmer Mark Kerry and his wife, interior designer Lynda are whispered to be the mystery buyers of Sydney's skinniest harbourfront property in Darling Point. The property was listed with $20m hopes in January, which by its February exchange had been adjusted to $17.5m. The four-level, four-bedroom, three-bathroom Carthona Avenue home occupies 207 sqm with a 6 meter sandy beach. MORE: Sydney's skinniest waterfront has eyewatering price It was a right-of-way slipway for nearby flat owners when the house was built in the early 1980s by the developer Bill Shipton, who died last September, aged 85. Melbourne accessory designer Gregory Ladner and his partner, Mark Grenville were the vendors, having purchased it for $15.5m in 2022 from the Dicker Data co-founder Fiona Brown. The bijou sur mer that sits between historic Carthona and Neidpath has been popular with Melburnians, with past owners including the late socialite Lady Susan Renouf. It was Renouf's last Sydney house, which she sold when moving back to Melbourne to be with her daughters in the mid-1990s. Renouf sold to the Melbourne socialite Dianne Allen for $2.9m with its next owner, the acclaimed Melbourne-based landscaper Jack Merlo paying $6.15m in 2009. For many years it was dormant during absentee investor Carl Spies' ownership – other than its use by skylarking rich squatters for raves in the 1980s. The waterfront was then lavishly restored by interior stylist Barry Byrne under the generous patronage of landlady Dorothy Spry, who had paid $2.4m in 1989. MORE: Ugly showdown: Hugh, Deb split $36m asset MORE: 'Don't give f**': Billionaire MrBeast needs cash The Kerry's recently sold a four-bedroom penthouse in Double Bay to Goodman Group chief executive Greg Goodman for $20m. It had been a $15.25m off-the-plan purchase in the SJD development on Cross Street. The couple had previously owned in Darling Point which they sold for $29.25m in mid-2023.
