Judge criticises delay in assessing Mary Ward murder accused
A Central Criminal Court judge has criticised the delay in preparing a psychiatric assessment on a Somalian national accused of the murder of his former partner Mary Ward in Belfast last year.
"I understand the Central Mental Hospital has a resources issue, but this impasse has to be broken by somebody. This can't go on,' said Mr Justice Paul McDermott, asking both the prosecution and defence teams to establish a timeframe in the case of Ahmed Abdirahman (31).
Mr Abdirahman, originally from Somalia and with a last address at Kinlay house, Lord Edward Street, Dublin, is accused of murdering the young mother on September 25, 2024, at her house on Melrose Street in south Belfast.
At the Central Criminal Court today, counsel for the State, Antonia Boyle BL said that the book of evidence had not yet been served on the accused due to mental health concerns.
The court heard from the defence team that the accused is waiting to be admitted to the Central Mental Hospital, and he has failed to engage with a psychiatrist who attempted to see him.
Defence counsel also told the court that there is a jurisdictional issue in the case, as the alleged offence occurred in Northern Ireland, meaning the accused must be given the option to be tried there.
Mr Justice McDermott noted that there was still no diagnosis of the accused, so there was no understanding if he was fit to plead or not. He said that he wanted both the defence and the prosecution to contact the Central Mental Hospital to establish a timeframe as to when the issues will be resolved.
"There has to be some response. I understand the Central Mental Hospital has a resources issue, but this impasse has to be broken by somebody. This can't go on,' said Mr Justice McDermott.
The matter was put back to July 30 next.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
6 hours ago
- The Journal
'Sound': Man accused over garda stabbing speaks via video-link as court awaits DPP decision
A 23-YEAR-OLD man charged over the stabbing of a Garda on a Dublin street last week has agreed to stay in prison for another four weeks pending directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Abdullah Khan replied 'sound' in Cloverhill District Court today when told that his next hearing was set for 3 September and that he was going to have a further consultation with his legal team. Mr Khan, with an address in north Dublin that cannot be reported by court order, was arrested at the scene following an incident at around 6pm on Capel Street in the city's north side on 29 July. He appeared before Judge Patricia Cronin today for his second court appearance, having been held in custody with no bail application on 31 July. Appearing via video link, seated and wearing a grey sweatshirt, he confirmed to his solicitor Katie Dowling that he consented to being further remanded in custody pending the DPP's decision on the case. He initially said, 'That's all right,' 'Yeah, yeah,' and 'Thank you' when his case was called early and put to second calling. When it resumed, he spoke up to give his surname and confirmed to his solicitor, Katie Dowling, 'I can hear you'. It was explained to him that the matter was listed for mention, and he answered, 'Yeah'. Judge Cronin noted the DPP's directions were not yet available. Detective Sergeant Liam McLaughlin, of the Bridewell Station, informed the court that he was applying for a four-week remand if there was consent. Advertisement During later exchanges with Ms Dowling, Mr Khan was informed that the directions were not available and he was entitled to apply for bail at any stage. The defence solicitor also explained that the State was asking for another four weeks for those directions, and he could consent to a two-week adjournment, but it was unlikely that they would be available. Or, she added that he could agree to a four-week adjournment. 'On consent to the four weeks,' he replied. Judge Cronin remanded him in continuing custody, noting that a video link appearance was acceptable on the next date. At the end of the hearing, his solicitor advised him that he had a video link consultation arranged for that night, adding, 'we will be able to discuss the matter in more detail at that stage', to which Mr Khan replied, 'Sound'. Ms Dowling also advised him that if he wished to apply for bail, he could do so at any time once gardaí have been notified in advance. The injured garda, a young probationary member of the force who was on high-visibility patrol with a colleague, received hospital treatment for non-life-threatening injuries. The accused man is charged with assault causing harm to the officer and the production of a Tactix knife capable of causing serious injury. He has yet to indicate a plea to the charges, which are under section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act and section 11 of the Firearms and Offensive Weapons Act. At the first court appearance on Thursday, the defence secured reporting restrictions on the publication of Mr Khan's address, due to 'concerns around safety', which was confirmed by Detective Sergeant McLaughlin. Medical attention in custody was also ordered, and legal aid was granted.
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man charged over Capel Street garda stabbing further remanded in custody
A 23-year-old man charged over the stabbing of a garda on a Dublin street last week has agreed to stay in prison for another four weeks pending directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Abdullah Khan replied "sound" in Cloverhill District Court on Wednesday when told his next hearing was set for September 3, and he was going to have a further consultation with his legal team. Mr Khan, with an address in north Dublin that cannot be reported by court order, was arrested at the scene following an incident at about 6pm on Capel Street on the city's northside on July 29. He appeared before Judge Patricia Cronin on Wednesday for his second court appearance, having been held in custody with no bail application on July 31. Appearing via video link, seated and wearing a grey sweatshirt, he confirmed to his solicitor Katie Dowling that he consented to being further remanded in custody pending the DPP's decision on the case. He initially said, "That's all right," "Yeah, yeah," and "Thank you" when his case was called early and put to second calling. When it resumed, he spoke up to give his surname and confirmed to his solicitor, Katie Dowling: "I can hear you". It was explained to him the matter was listed for mention, and he answered, "Yeah". Judge Cronin noted the DPP's directions were not yet available. Detective Sergeant Liam McLaughlin, of Bridewell Garda Station, informed the court he was applying for a four-week remand if there was consent. During later exchanges with Ms Dowling, Mr Khan was informed the directions were not available and he was entitled to apply for bail at any stage. The defence solicitor also explained the State was asking for another four weeks for those directions, and he could consent to a two-week adjournment, but it was unlikely they would be available. Or, she added, he could agree to a four-week adjournment. "On consent to the four weeks," he replied. Judge Cronin remanded Mr Khan in continuing custody, noting a video link appearance was acceptable on the next date. At the end of the hearing, his solicitor advised him he had a video link consultation arranged for that night, adding: "We will be able to discuss the matter in more detail at that stage," to which Mr Khan replied: "Sound". Ms Dowling also advised him if he wished to apply for bail, he could do so at any time once gardaí had been notified in advance. The injured garda, a young probationary member of the force who was on high-visibility patrol with a colleague, received hospital treatment for non-life-threatening injuries. The accused man is charged with assault causing harm to the officer and the production of a Tactix knife capable of causing serious injury. He has yet to indicate a plea to the charges, which are under section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act and section 11 of the Firearms and Offensive Weapons Act. At the first court appearance on Thursday, the defence secured reporting restrictions on the publication of Mr Khan's address, due to "concerns around safety", which was confirmed by Det Sgt McLaughlin. Medical attention in custody was also ordered, and legal aid was granted.
Irish Daily Mirror
3 days ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Jonathan Dowdall's plush torture house finally sold as prison release looms
Prison bosses are braced for the imminent release of disgraced State witness Jonathan Dowdall - as his plush Dublin home is finally sold. The former Sinn Fein councillor's home, where he once waterboarded a man, has sold after over a year on the market - and within weeks of his scheduled release from prison, having served his time for his role in the Regency Hotel shooting of Kinahan cartel associate David Byrne. The massive four bedroom home - number 270 Navan Road, was on the market for an eye watering €795,000 - and is believed to have sold for far more than that. Dowdall is set to net that money, along with his soon to be new life abroad - courtesy of the Irish State. Now we have learned that despite having a release date in early October, prison bosses are prepared to have Dowdall be released earlier than that - with his release being facilitated by An Garda Siochana. Sources say he could be released any day now - and it will likely happen under the cover of night and at a moments notice. It is believed Dowdall has been admitted into the State's witness protection programme - despite being a disastrous witness for the prosecution in the case against Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch. He has been housed on a quiet landing of Limerick Prison, where he spends 23 hours a day in his cell - and does not ever mix with the rest of the prison population. Since his incarceration in 2022 to a four year sentence for helping a criminal organisation carry out the murder of David Byrne, Dowdall has been the most high profile prisoner in the system - and security around him has been tight. The home of Jonathan Dowdall has been sold ( Gardai will have the power to take Dowdall out of prison early - with his 'temporary' release then being signed off on by the Irish Prison Service, allowing for him to get out ahead of his scheduled release, and to ensure his safety. It is likely he will then be wizzed off to another country where he will be given new accomodation and a new identity. It will also become illegal overnight to reveal his new identity or location. There remains serious concerns for his safety and that of his family - as gardai believe he has not only made enemies of the Hutch and Kinahan mobs - but dissident republican groups as well. Dowdall, a married father of four, pleaded guilty to facilitating the murder of David Byrne in September of 2022. He ultimately accepted that he made a room available at the Regency Hotel to the Hutch gang which was used later that night by one of the gunmen - 'Flat Cap' Kevin Murray during the now infamous shooting on February 5, 2016. He had originally been charged with the murder of David Byrne - but that charge was dramatically dropped and he was able to plead to the lesser charge. That became the subject of controversy during the trial of Gerry Hutch, in which Dowdall turned State witness and gave evidence to the court over the course of a week. The witness was repeatedly challenged by Defence Counsel Brendan Grehan about the exact circumstances of how that charge was dropped, and whether he was only willing to give evidence against the accused if that occurred. Dowdall's involvement in the operation also came under intense scrutiny - from the secretly recorded conversation he had with Hutch in which he implied a significant amount of criminality - to his allegation that the accused had confessed to the murder of David Byrne to him in a park in Whitehall - days after the shooting. His evidence was ultimately thrown out by the three judges of the Special Criminal Court - who ruled that Gerry Hutch was not guilty of the murder of David Byrne. Hutch sensationally walked free from the court on April 17 2023 after Ms Justice Tara Burns said that Dowdall's evidence in particular must be treated with 'scepticism and extreme care.' Dowdall had claimed to gardai that Hutch personally confessed to him to the murder of Byrne two or three days after the shooting in Ellenfield Park in Whitehall - but Ms Justice Burns said the court could not corroborate his claims. Justice Burns said then when Dowdall took the witness stand it would have been expected he would tell the full truth 'warts and all,' but she said 'that was not the case.' Dowdall also served a lengthy sentence for the horrific torture of a man named Alexander Hurley in the garage of his home on the Navan Road. Alexander Hurley was subjected to horrific torture at the hands of the former Sinn Fein councillor and his father, who waterboarded him in the garage of his home on the Navan Road in Dublin on January 15, 2015. In a previous interview with this paper, Mr Hurley, who said his life has been hell ever since he was tortured by Dowdall in that very home, said in his mind, the disgraced liar and criminal should never have been allowed to sell it. 'I think it's going to be very, very hard to sell it. Regardless of who buys it will always have that stigma attached to it, that it was the scene of a very violent crime. 'The only way that would ever be properly dispersed is if you raised it to the ground,' Alexander told us. 'I think he shouldn't be allowed to sell it. It should be seized and a portion of the value of the property should go to the courts for his wasting of everyone's time as a State witness. Secondly it should go towards compensating his victims, whether it's me or whoever else he's done an injustice to,' he added. Asked if he was saying he felt the State should gift him some of the proceeds of Dowdall's home Alexander said: 'Absolutely. But of course I know that's not going to happen.' High quality pictures and video of the interior of Dowdall's home, including of the garage he tortured Alexander in were available for potential buyers to view online - but for the victim himself, those images only brought the horror of what he went through back. Dowdall and his father Patrick invited Alexander to their home for dinner in January 2015 after trying to sell him a motorbike on DoneDeal - but then claimed they believed he was trying to defraud them - something Alexander vehemently denies to this day. The pair, who later found themselves caught up in the Regency shooting incident, lured Alexander into the garage, backed him into a swivel chair and subjected him to waterboarding - and threatened to take his life. For more of the latest breaking news from the Irish Mirror check out our homepage by clicking here
