'South Africans tired of commissions of inquiry': parties on Ramaphosa's response to Mkhwanazi allegations
Addressing the nation on Sunday evening, Ramaphosa announced he was placing minister of police Senzo Mchunu on special leave, and said and that Prof Firoz Cachalia would act as police minister.
Ramaphosa also announced he has established a judicial commission of inquiry chaired by acting deputy chief justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga to investigate allegations relating to the infiltration of law enforcement, intelligence and associated institutions within the criminal justice system by criminal syndicates.
This comes after explosive allegations levelled against Mchunu by Mkhwanazi last Sunday.
Mkhwanazi accused Mchunu of interfering with police investigations and of overstepping his role when he ordered the disbandment of the political killings task team.
ActionSA said it sees no logic in yet another commission of inquiry carrying out work that law enforcement and agencies like Ipid should be doing, especially while the R1bn Zondo commission report into state capture gathers dust as those who committed treason continue to evade justice.
DA leader John Steenhuisen welcomed the new appointment made by Ramaphosa, but also expressed concern over the decision to establish a commission of inquiry.
In an interview with Newzroom Afrika, Steenhuisen said m any South Africans are sceptical about commissions of inquiry after the Zondo inquiry produced no convictions, even after people were named.
He added that the public's trust might deteriorate if there is another inquiry that yields no consequences.
GOOD party secretary-general Brett Herron said the appointment of a commission, while well-intentioned, is too slow, too cumbersome and too costly.
'We have walked this road before, most notably with the Zondo commission, and we have seen that a commission of inquiry cannot replace a criminal investigation. The Zondo commission produced volumes of prima facie evidence, which the investigating authorities were then required to investigate before any decision to prosecute could be made,' he said.
Herron said allegations made by Mkhwanazi demand an urgent and credible criminal investigation, not another year-long process the outcomes of which might never be acted on.
RISE Mzansi welcomed the establishment of a commission of inquiry.
The party feels that a judicial commission of inquiry is important because the SAPS and the minister cannot investigate themselves.
'The establishment of this inquiry insulates the process from political contamination,' said Makashule Gana, RISE Mzansi National Assembly caucus whip and member of the portfolio committee on police.
Meanwhile Mchunu has welcomed Ramaphosa's decision to place him on special leave, saying he fully supports the process.
'I welcome and respect the president's decision and pledge my commitment to the process. Honour and integrity are the virtues I personally subscribe to and which we all need to make efforts to uphold. I stand ready to respond to the accusations against me and account to the citizens of the republic, fully and honestly so,' Mchunu said in a statement.
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
25 minutes ago
- Mail & Guardian
Madlanga inquiry into police corruption to hear first witness in August
Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga The inquiry established by President Cyril Ramaphosa to investigate allegations of criminality, corruption and political interference in the criminal justice system will begin hearing public testimony in August, its chairperson, Acting Deputy Chief Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga, said on Monday. Ramaphosa set up the inquiry in response to Madlanga said the commission has begun its preparatory work, including the appointment of senior personnel and the scheduling of the first witness consultation. 'Our first consultation with a witness is imminent. We are mindful that South Africa is eager to see the first witness in the stand. We too are keen to see that happen,' he told a media briefing. While Madlanga would not name the first witness, he confirmed that the commission would consult Mkhwanazi 'imminently'. Mkhwanazi alleged in a media briefing earlier this month that Mkhwanazi said 121 case dockets were removed from Mchunu, On Monday, Madlanga said the commission is treating the matter with urgency but must follow procedures, including consulting witnesses, assessing information and determining the need for follow-ups before public hearings can begin. 'The fact that General Mkhwanazi made the allegations does not make us ready to start hearing evidence immediately,' he said. He added that public hearings will take place in Gauteng, with a procurement process under way to secure a building. Madlanga assured the public that this would not delay preparations. 'We are proceeding full steam ahead. The lack of infrastructure does not affect progress on the commission's preparatory work,' he said. The commission will also establish facilities for members of the public to lodge relevant information, both in person and online. 'We consider it important that the public be afforded an opportunity to contribute,' Madlanga said. The commission has appointed a high-level team of professionals, with advocates Sesi Baloyi and Sandile Khumalo serving as co-commissioners. Advocate Terry Motau is the chief evidence leader, with Lolita Vukuza appointed as the commission secretary. Peter Gous is the chief investigator and Jeremy Michaels the commission's spokesperson. 'We believe this team is up to the task and will deliver on the mandate,' Madlanga said. The commission is expected to submit an interim report within three months and conclude its work in six months. Madlanga reiterated that the commission is bound by a timeline and said the interim report by the end of its first three-month period may include recommendations for immediate action. Madlanga also outlined the terms of reference, which include investigating the South African Police Service, metro police departments in Gauteng, the National Prosecuting Authority, the State Security Agency, the judiciary, correctional services and any executive members responsible for the criminal justice system. The inquiry will look into whether these entities have been infiltrated by criminal syndicates, including attempts to shield politically connected individuals and obstruct justice. Asked about witness safety, Madlanga said each case would be assessed to determine whether protection was required. Given that some implicated parties are still in the system, this is 'receiving serious consideration'. He said the commission is also empowered to conduct search-and-seizure operations when necessary, but would do so in a way that 'does not alert the intended persons'. When pressed on whether arrests could follow, Madlanga said: 'I cannot give a categorical answer at this stage.' He added that litigation challenging the commission's legitimacy is pending before the constitutional court, and the commission would abide by the court's ruling on whether it would be interdicted or continue. Mkhwanazi's disclosures include allegations that the police service is compromised at senior levels and that attempts were made to destabilise it, including efforts to frame national commissioner Fannie Masemola and remove senior officials. Mkhwanazi said Mchunu had tried to 'smooth the waters' between him and Sibiya, whom he referred to as 'a criminal'. He also alleged that Mchunu misled parliament about links to Brown Mogotsi, a man with alleged ties to organised crime, and Vusumuzi 'Cat' Matlala, a business person who allegedly benefited from police tenders despite criminal allegations against him. Ian Cameron, the chairperson of parliament's police portfolio committee, said Mkhwanazi had effectively 'He was fully aware of the risks — physical or career-related — and acknowledged this publicly,' Cameron said. Parliament is establishing an ad hoc committee to Madlanga declined to provide a budget estimate, which he said would be determined by the justice department. He said it was too early to estimate how many witnesses would testify. He confirmed that the commission's rules — including procedures for public access and media attendance — will be published.
Mail & Guardian
an hour ago
- Mail & Guardian
MK party to square off in court against Ramaphosa and Mchunu
In the dog box: Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, who comes from KwaZulu-Natal, has been put on 'special leave' by President Cyril Ramaphosa. Photo: Delwyn Verasamy The At the centre of the case are questions about the limits of presidential power, the legality of acting appointments and whether Ramaphosa acted rationally when he established a judicial commission of inquiry into serious allegations of criminal infiltration of law enforcement agencies. Ramaphosa suspended Mchunu after serious allegations by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi that he colluded with a criminal syndicate, accepted illicit payments, interfered in investigations and disbanded a specialised task force into political killings. Through its deputy president, John Hlophe, the MK party argues in court papers that Ramaphosa acted outside the bounds of the Constitution when he suspended Mchunu and installed Cachalia, who is not a cabinet minister, to act in his place. 'The president has no constitutional authority to place a minister on leave,' Hlophe argued, describing the measure as 'a fancy phrase for suspension with pay'. He insisted that ministers are political appointees, not employees, and therefore not subject to labour law. In a supporting affidavit, Zuma accused Ramaphosa of 'inventing new powers' not grounded in law, calling the president's interpretation of the Constitution 'indecipherable gobbledygook'. Ramaphosa, in his response, argued that his power to appoint and dismiss ministers include the discretion to place them on special leave, especially under circumstances that require an impartial investigation. 'This is not a punitive measure,' the president said. 'It is an interim step to preserve the integrity of the inquiry.' He said the Constitution vests in him the discretion to manage the cabinet and to act in the public interest when questions of credibility arise. Addressing concerns about Cachalia's appointment, Ramaphosa said he had followed a formal process. He said Cachalia was first to be appointed as a minister and then assigned the police portfolio on an acting basis. Hlophe dismissed this as a legal 'contrivance' and accused the president of manipulating constitutional provisions to serve political ends. He said the inquiry chaired by the acting deputy chief justice, Ramaphosa said the allegations made by Mkhwanazi were serious and required a process that would not be clouded by political interference or public suspicion. According to Mkhwanazi, the disbandment of the police's political killings task team was linked to efforts by criminal syndicates to capture the state's security architecture, a claim Mchunu has strongly denied. In his affidavit, Mchunu said Mkhwanazi's allegations were both 'unsubstantiated' and misinformed. He said he had instructed national police commissioner Fannie Masemola to disband the unit based on operational assessments, not political motives. Mchunu also criticised the timing of Mkhwanazi's public statements, arguing that the KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner did not inform him of his intentions to make allegations. 'He did not afford me any right to comment on the nature and basis of his intended 'revelations' before he made them. I was taken by complete surprise on 6 July 2025, when I learnt that Lieutenant General Mkhwanazi had called a press conference at short notice in order to level serious allegations against me,' Mchunu said. 'What is even more unfortunate is that the allegations he made against me relate to events which on his own version occurred several months ago, in particular, my decision in relation to the disbandment of the political killings task team. 'General Mkhwanazi had ample time to liaise with me and afford me a right to respond to any concerns that he may have had before he went into the public domain and made his extravagant and misinformed allegations.' Mchunu further stated that he had informed Ramaphosa of his willingness to cooperate with the inquiry, and denied that the ANC's The Madlanga commission has been tasked with investigating the infiltration of law enforcement and intelligence agencies by criminal syndicates. Its terms of reference include the South African Police Service, metropolitan police departments, the State Security Agency, the NPA and parts of the judiciary. The commission has the power to summon witnesses, compel documents and, in limited cases, conduct search-and-seizure operations. According to a government gazette last week, the commission may also recommend prosecutions, internal disciplinary steps and systemic reforms. Interim reports are expected within three and six months, with a final report to be submitted to the speaker of the National Assembly, Thoko Didiza, and Chief Justice Mandisa Maya.
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
How Russia's historical ties are fading in southern Africa
The Valdai Discussion Club in partnership with the South African Institute of International Affairs hosts the 3rd Russian-African Conference in Pretoria titled: 'Realpolitik in a Divided World: Rethinking Russia-South Africa Ties in a Global and African Context'. Image: Oupa Mokoena / Independent Newspapers Russia's influence in southern Africa is facing a significant challenge as the region's historical memory of the Soviet Union's role in liberation movements begins to fade. Lwazi Somya, manager of research and development at the Southern African Liaison Office, made this observation during the Russia-Africa conference co-hosted by the Valdai Discussion Club and the South African Institute of International Affairs in Pretoria. He warned that the decline in electoral support for former liberation movements in southern Africa could signal a loss of historical memory in Russia's relations with African countries, potentially eroding the soft power gained during the Soviet Union era. "Russia has to engage with the decline of support to former liberation movements within southern Africa in terms of electoral support," he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Somya cited the recent meeting of southern African liberation movements, where Russia was mentioned only once in the declaration, as evidence of the diminishing influence. He also pointed out that Russia's trade relations with South Africa are relatively low, ranking 46th as an export partner and 39th as a source of imports. "The ideological dilution of governance within southern Africa" and the emergence of a new generation without attachment to the liberation history are further challenges for Russia, Somya said. "Young people are forgetting the historical role Russia played, and therefore those historic memory connections Russia has predicated on and relied on in terms of soft power are declining," he added. Godwin Gonde, a lecturer at the Dr Salim Ahmed Salim Centre for Foreign Regions in Tanzania, noted that Russian-African relations have evolved, spanning pre-colonial, liberation Struggle, Cold War, and post-Cold War eras. However, he emphasised that the current generation often lacks knowledge of this history, and that Russia's re-engagement with Africa is taking place in a vastly different context. "The future generation will no longer have the same historical context and good notion of relations," Gonde said, highlighting the importance of learning from past experiences to move forward as global partners. He added that Russia's renewed engagement with Africa comes at a time when the continent is struggling to find its footing in a rapidly changing world. Munyaradzi Nyakudya, chairperson of the Department of Peace, Security and Society at the University of Zimbabwe, praised the Russians for their trade cooperation investments made in his country. "I think they are doing a lot in terms of trying to get into mining and energy. We have seen some cultural exchanges. We have seen quite a number in terms of the scholarships and education exchanges," he said. However, Nyakudya noted that despite significant developments on the ground, the visibility of Russia's presence in Zimbabwe is lacking, and the relationship between the two countries has faced criticism for being elitist. He bemoaned the fact that the benefits of the partnership are not trickling down to the grassroots level, where the country's resources are being exported as raw materials.
