Judge upholds obstruction conviction for B.C. Mountie in Dale Culver case
Dale Culver, 35, went into medical distress after being tackled to the ground and pepper-sprayed by RCMP officers on July 18, 2017.
A provincial court judge has ruled that the guilty verdict stands for an RCMP officer convicted of obstruction of justice in the case of an Indigenous man who died in police custody in 2017, clearing the way for sentencing.
A statement from the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association says Judge Adrian Brooks dismissed the attempt by RCMP Const. Arthur Dalman to have the proceedings stayed, rejecting Dalman's claim that his Charter rights were breached.
The B.C. Prosecution Service has confirmed the ruling, which communications counsel Damienne Darby says was released on May 29.
Dalman was found guilty last July of obstruction of justice for ordering witnesses to delete video footage taken at the time Dale Culver was arrested in Prince George.
The civil liberties association says officers used pepper spray during the 'violent' arrest and Culver died about 30 minutes later after complaining of breathing difficulties.
The Independent Investigations Office of B.C. recommended charges in 2020 after finding reasonable grounds to believe two officers may have committed offences related to the use of force and three others may have obstructed justice.
But the civil liberties association says manslaughter charges against two officers were stayed last year, one obstruction charge was stayed and another officer was acquitted of obstruction, leaving Dalman as the only officer convicted in the case.
The reasons for Brooks' judgment have not been released, and Darby said in a statement on Monday that Dalman's next appearance is on June 19 to set a date for a sentencing hearing.
Culver was from the Gitxsan and Wet'suwet'en Nations. He was 35 years old at the time of his death.
An RCMP release from the time said police had received a report about a man casing vehicles and found a suspect who tried to flee on a bicycle.
The civil liberties association, meanwhile, said after Culver's death that it was aware of reports from eyewitnesses that he 'was taken forcibly to the ground by RCMP members immediately after exiting a liquor store, apparently unprovoked.'
The group shared a statement from Culver's daughter, Lily Speed-Namox, following the judge's decision to uphold Dalman's conviction this week.
The family has waited 'eight long years' for accountability, Speed-Namox says.
'I have somehow managed to remain positive about my feelings that eventually someone would be held accountable.
'Even if it's because Dalman lied under oath to 'protect' his fellow officers. How many people have to die before people realize that the justice system is broken?'
In the earlier decision finding Dalman guilty of obstruction of justice, the same provincial court judge, Adrian Brooks, found the officer deliberately lied and his evidence was 'so fraught with illogical missteps … and so contradictory when compared with reliable evidence, that it (was) not worthy of any belief.'
Culver's cousin, Debbie Pierre, says in a statement that Brooks' latest decision upholding Dalman's conviction marks a step toward accountability.
'But true justice goes beyond one decision. My vision is for a system where Indigenous lives are protected — not silenced — and where police are trained to de-escalate, not destroy.
'This is not just about Dale; it's about transforming a justice system that continues to fail our people. We will not stop until that change is real.'
This report by Brenna Owen, The Canadian Press, was first published June 9, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
21 minutes ago
- CBC
Thompson woman missing since last week found safe: RCMP
A 31-year-old Thompson woman who was reported missing last week has been found, Manitoba RCMP said Monday. The woman had last been seen in the city, about 770 kilometres north of Winnipeg, on June 3 and was reported missing at 10 p.m. that day, RCMP had said in a news release Monday afternoon. Several hours later, RCMP issued an update saying the woman "has been safely located." Police thanked the public for their help in finding her.
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
A lost RCMP USB device with key information was offered for sale by criminals, privacy watchdog says
The RCMP lost a memory key containing personal information about victims, witnesses and informants, and later learned it was being offered for sale by criminals, the federal privacy watchdog says. A detailed report from the office of privacy commissioner Philippe Dufresne reveals the RCMP told the watchdog about the breach in March 2022, prompting a lengthy investigation. The RCMP determined that the unencrypted USB storage device contained the personal information of 1,741 people, including witnesses, complainants, subjects of interest, informants, police officers and civilian employees. 'The RCMP's investigation also established that only some of the documents on the device were password protected and that the device itself was not encrypted nor password protected,' the privacy watchdog's report says. The Mounties learned from a confidential source three weeks after the loss that the data on the device was being offered for sale by members of the criminal community. 'Given the nature and sensitivity of the information that the RCMP handles on a daily basis, (our office) would have expected the RCMP to have strict security measures in place to safeguard its information holdings,' the privacy commissioner's report says. 'We also would have expected for those measures to be stringently monitored and that the RCMP would take prompt action where non-compliance, whether accidental or not, is discovered.' Dufresne's office found the RCMP violated the Privacy Act, given that the personal information of individuals was disclosed without their consent. The privacy watchdog also concluded that RCMP personnel failed to report the loss of the USB storage device to the force's authorities in a timely manner. However, once aware of the breach, the RCMP's notification to affected individuals and the steps taken to manage the risk of further harm to them were 'generally appropriate in the circumstance,' the report says. Finally, Dufresne's office found the RCMP failed to take appropriate measures to safeguard the personal information. The privacy watchdog recommended the RCMP adopt strict security measures for the use of USB storage devices. This included measures not only to ensure that approved USB devices are used, but also audits to confirm that devices are returned when no longer needed, as well as additional training, the report says. The commissioner reports that the Mounties agreed in principle to the recommendations but did not commit to implementing them within a specific timeline. RCMP spokeswoman Robin Percival said Monday the force initiated a review of its security and privacy policies, as well as its awareness program, to ensure employees were reminded and sensitized of their continual responsibilities to protect sensitive information. 'The program also addresses the immediate actions to be taken in case of a security breach,' Percival said in a written response. The RCMP remains committed to preventing the use of unauthorized devices of unencrypted USB storage devices and to implementing appropriate measures and solutions across the country, she added.
CBC
29 minutes ago
- CBC
Town of Fort Smith issues fines, seizes dirt bikes over concerns of unsafe riding
The Town of Fort Smith, N.W.T., is cracking down on reckless dirt bike and ATV riding in the community. Bylaw officers have been issuing fines and confiscating bikes in an effort to address what they describe as a rise in unsafe and unlawful use. They said it's about safety, not punishment. But some parents say it's gone too far, and the new enforcement effort has sparked pushback from some community members. Bev Chepelsky, a Fort Smith parent, agrees kids shouldn't drive recklessly. But she says the town's approach is too harsh and was implemented without notice or community consultation. "This crackdown seems like we're criminalizing children," she said. "There are kids who had their bikes confiscated while they were in class at school, which just really seems alarming to me." The Town of Fort Smith recently posted on social media to remind residents of the laws regarding off-road vehicles. Those rules require helmets, valid registration, current insurance, and a driver's licence to operate within town limits. Riders who don't meet those conditions are expected to take their machines out of town. The town also encourages residents to report unsafe riding and provide video or photos if possible. Chepelsky says the town's approach fails to consider the value of riding for youth in Fort Smith, which she says is a way of life for her family and many others in the community. She said it's a lifestyle that teaches mechanical skills, independence, and mental resilience. It's also a way for youth to connect. She said older kids teach the new riders the ropes and help them fix their machines. "They share a lifestyle and an interest," she said. "I think that the people that get it, like, really get it that there's medicine in riding." Chepelsky said her kids, who began riding as young as three years old, have learned responsibility, teamwork, and how to help each other through machine riding. She wants to see the town work with parents and young riders to find a better solution. She's proposing things like a youth safety course or a designated area where riding can be monitored and encouraged. Fort Smith's director of protective services, Adam McNab, said the town is open to working with families and the riding community. "The Town of Fort Smith would love to see a proactive group like a club or association take on a mentoring role and maybe help to create some safe trail networks out of town to a designated area," he said. However, McNab says it's illegal for children to operate unregistered, unlicensed, and uninsured motorized vehicles on public roads and that the priority is keeping all road users, especially children, safe. McNab said the town has had many direct complaints about youth reckless driving in the community. "Some youth have almost been hit by motorcycles, both on roads, sidewalks and the batch of trail systems," he said. "So that's really alarming to us." He says that in some cases, youth have run from bylaw officers. "When children are speeding on public roadways, stunting and doing wheelies, are underage, often don't have the right safety equipment, and aren't being monitored by an adult, that puts everybody in the community at risk." McNab said he understands the appeal of riding because it's also part of his family's lifestyle, and he values the freedom that comes with riding in the North. However, the town's priority is making sure no one gets hurt.
