GOP rivals Barberio, Musella tackle development, tax breaks in Parsippany mayoral debate

Yahoo

16-05-2025

Bitter rivals since they took office together almost four years ago, Parsippany Mayor James Barberio and Councilman Justin Musella rarely see eye to eye on the issues.
But facing each other on May 15 in a much-anticipated online debate — just weeks before Republican voters decide which one to nominate for mayor in the general election — the candidates found common ground on several points during the hourlong event.
Parsippany's building boom and tax deals for developers continued to divide Musella, 33, and Barberio, 64, who is seeking a fourth term leading Morris County's largest community.
But topics of agreement included the state of disrepair at the Lake Hiawatha Branch of the Parsippany Library. With a current estimate of more than $9 million to renovate the building, neither candidate predicted an affordable solution to save it. Barberio said the town was looking into a lease to occupy the Lake Hiawatha Rite Aid store, which closed last year. Musella suggested they look into shared services with neighboring Montville.
The forum was hosted by the League of Women Voters Morris Area, the Daily Record and the Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Morristown Alumnae Chapter.
Both men agreed the town had to do a better job at granting building permits in a timely manner, a common complaint in town from both contractors and residents. Barberio defended the existing staff but pointed to a problem recruiting construction code officials to come on board.
"We're involved with a lot of new construction," Barberio said.
Musella said building permits were "a top priority" for him, including adding staff and digitizing the process.
Both also admitted that towns have little control over the affordable housing mandate that has fueled a wave of construction throughout the state, particularly in Parsippany, where more than 2,300 residential units are currently under construction.
Barberio blamed the "Trenton Democrats" in control of state policy. Musella said it was essential for New Jersey to elect a Republican governor in November "to shut down the mandate." Both of them also insisted they would negotiate development deals for the town, not the developers.
More: Parsippany demolished 2 million square feet of office space. Here's what will replace it
One thing they did not agree on was the omnipresence of former township municipal attorney John Inglesino in many of those Parsippany development deals, including several that included the sometimes controversial practice of awarding tax discounts known as PILOTs, or "payment in lieu of taxes." Inglesino is now a private attorney who has represented several developers in negotiations with the township.
PILOT supporters include Barberio — "they are absolutely necessary" he said during the debate. Backers say the tax deals give builders incentives to knock down vacant office buildings in town and replace them with revenue-generating properties.
Musella said PILOTs can be a useful tool in certain negotiations, but he blasted the flurry of agreements granted by the Barberio administration as "corporate welfare for the mayor's top fundraiser and our former town attorney, John Inglesino."
Barberio defended Inglesino and his administration's PILOTs. "We had certain projects that if they didn't get PILOTs, they were going to leave," Barberio said. "They would have left, they would have demolished the buildings, and who would subsidize the taxes? The taxpayer. We can't allow that to happen."
"We have to end the culture of cronyism in town hall," Musella said later. "It is a serious problem that [Inglesino] does the majority of the development in town and receives all the PILOT contracts."
"You got to let John Inglesino stop living rent-free in your head," Barberio shot back, adding that Musella voted in favor of the Inglesino development proposals, if not the PILOTs that followed.
"If the guy was that evil, I wouldn't have invited him to my wedding," Barbero added. "But that's beside the point. John does not push development forward here in Parsippany."
"In Parsippany, having good relations with John Inglesino is essential to getting anything done," Musella countered. "Developers know that. Residents know that. Anybody on the outside looking in knows that. I want things being done fairly, equitably, and transparently, where one person in particular doesn't just cut the line to get whatever they want."
Musella questioned why, in addition to housing construction, that PILOTs had been granted to two warehouse projects and a new Lifetime Fitness gym along Sylvan Way.
"The mayor is incentivizing the very things that are in extreme demand right now," he said. "Everybody is knocking down our door to build an apartment building or a warehouse. And to put us into business with a gym for 30 years I thought was completely the wrong thing. Because it's Parsippay taxpayers that assume the risk."
The debate ended on a more civil note as each candidate was asked to say something nice about the other. Musella said Barberio was "a nice person" who cared about the town."
"Our issues are not personal," he added.
"Justin's absolutely correct, I don't take it personal, and I hope he doesn't take it personal after I read my closing statement," the mayor joked. "What I do really like about Justin, like myself, he cares about the town, he cares about the residents. One thing that touches my heart, when he had his baby. I had no problem congratulating him and his wife, Courtney, There's no greater gift in the world."
Finally, both agreed to support the primary winner in the general election.
Barberio and Musella ran together four years ago but have clashed in public practically since they took office. Now, they'll vie in the June 10 GOP primary for the right to lead the town of 56,000 people, which has Morris County's only full-time mayor's office.
Barberio is seeking a fourth term after being elected in 2009 and 2013, losing in 2017 and then reclaiming the post in 2021. He is running on a ticket with two town council candidates: current Council Vice President Frank Neglia and Jigar Shah, who the mayor appointed during his first term as his liaison to the large Indian American community in town.
Musella was elected with Barberio and Neglia, but has broken with his fellow Republicans, becoming a vocal critics of the town's deals with developers. He has also criticized the township's adoption of project labor agreements that favor larger unions for big municipal projects.
Musella is running with former Planning Board Chairman Casey Parikh and John Bielen, a business development professional.
The GOP council candidates will not debate. Parikh and Bielen agreed to take part in a League of Women Voters forum but Neglia and Shah declined.
Democrats have endorsed Pulkit Desai, president of the Lake Parsippany Property Owner's Association, for mayor and Matt Kavanagh and Diya Patel for council. Unopposed in the primary, they will meet the winners of the Republican race in the November general election.
A second mayoral debate proposed by the Puddingstone Community Club that would have included Desai was postponed last week after conflicting reports about the event posted on local websites created public confusion.
This article originally appeared on Morristown Daily Record: In Parsippany, GOP rivals Barberio, Musella clash in mayoral debate