South Africa: Buffalo City wants to recover $874,296 in Covid housing funds
There is an ongoing court case to recoup the funds from the implicated officials and contractors, although the municipality is still investigating.
A confidential report tabled before the council on Wednesday, 30 April, describes how four senior officials in the municipality's housing directorate unlawfully authorised R16m in transactions to two contractors for emergency housing during the Covid lockdown.
This is based on the findings of a Special Investigations Unit (SIU) investigation. The SIU delivered its reports to the municipality in August 2022, but the municipality only referred the matter to its attorneys in March 2023. The municipality did not respond to questions about why it took so long.
The funds were initially authorised in 2020 as part of a deviation from normal tendering processes due to the 'emergency' caused by Covid. The funds were supposed to be used to build temporary housing structures for more than 300 people who had been evicted from Buffalo Flats in 2019, and others who had lost their homes in fires during the Covid lockdown.
But the SIU's investigation found that hours before the municipality published a request for quotations, the municipality's general manager of supply chain management, Andile Xoseka, sent an email to nine companies with the details of the request. This unlawfully favoured these companies, the SIU found.
Three of these companies — SQT Construction and Civils CC, Vitsha PM Consultants CC and Coalition Trading 1203 CC — were eventually awarded the contracts to build the housing. Coalition Trading 1203 CC was not paid for any work delivered, but SQT and Vitsha were paid R6.5m and R9.7m respectively.
The payments to SQT and Vitsha were authorised and completion certificates issued before the housing structures were complete. For this the SIU held head of the housing directorate Luyanda Mbula and inspector for low-cost housing Siphokazi Dlongwana, responsible. One invoice of R1.2m paid to SQT was a duplicate of a previous transaction.
The houses are made of prefab materials, as originally planned for. Many of the people living there were evicted from Buffalo Flats in 2019, so it appears that at least some of the houses were used for what they were originally intended.
But according to the leaked report, the SIU found that not all the houses were delivered as planned and the structures were only finished in 2021 and 2022, after the Covid lockdown had ended.
The SIU found that the budget deviation used to pay the suppliers was invalid because the 'emergency' provisions of Covid were no longer relevant and the deviation had expired by the time the payments were made.
All the work done by the companies 'did not fall within the scope' of the tenders, the report says, and as a result the companies were 'unjustifiably enriched'.
The SIU also found that two officials who assessed companies that had bid for the contract, were not authorised to evaluate bids higher than R200,000.
Next steps
The municipality's lawyers have advised that the officials are guilty of financial misconduct for violating the Municipal Finance Management Act. Disciplinary matters of this nature need to be referred to to the Disciplinary Board by the city council. This referral was approved by the council last week.
The municipality has also requested the SIU to refer the investigation to the National Prosecuting Authority to consider whether to criminally prosecute the officials.
The municipality has been advised that the funds should be recovered through court action, both from the officials who authorised the expenditure and the contractors who 'appropriated the irregular expenditure'.
The municipality issued court summons to the implicated officials and the contractors on Wednesday, 10 January 2024. Xoseka filed his plea, denying that he sent the request for comment to the nine companies before it was published. The other defendants have not yet filed their pleas.
The municipality intends to continue investigating the matter, including conducting a survey of the houses that were built, before taking the legal action further. The SIU has refused to provide the municipality with a quantity surveyor report from the SIU's investigation.
The SIU has been requested by the municipality to proceed with civil action against the contractors.
Council has also resolved to refer the matter to the Municipal Public Accounts Committee to consider further legal action to recoup the money from the contractors.
SQT's founder Siviwe Mpengesi was contacted with questions. Asked to respond to the findings, he said 'Don't be fishing. Bring facts to the table. I don't know what you telling me … I don't have communication from the SIU or the municipality.'
When we sent him excerpts from the report which mentions the company, Mpengesi said 'Sir I will not comment on this top secret municipality report as it is not official. I don't see mention of my name and my company. I will therefore block you.'
Vitsha did not respond to questions by the time of publication.
The implicated officials did not respond to our questions.
Published originally on GroundUp.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Zawya
2 hours ago
- Zawya
‘Co-create Solutions' to Give Africa Stronger Role in Global Political, Financial Institutions, Debt Relief, Secretary-General Urges at Tokyo Conference
Following are UN Secretary-General António Guterres' remarks to the ninth Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD), in Yokohama today: I thank the Government and people of Japan for your hospitality and generosity — and all co-organizers for your commitment to Africa. For more than three decades, TICAD has embodied the spirit of multilateralism — grounded in mutual respect, shared responsibility and a deep belief in Africa's potential. With the world's youngest population, abundant natural resources and a vibrant entrepreneurial spirit, Africa is poised for progress. And this year's theme — 'Co-Create Innovative Solutions with Africa' — reminds us that these same strengths can help shape a more peaceful, prosperous, and sustainable world inside and beyond Africa's borders. Especially as we accelerate progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) through investment, reform and partnerships. We meet at a time of interconnected crises and deep inequalities. Tackling these crises requires a clear focus not only on development for Africa, but development with Africa. And I salute Japan for making this the focus of its cooperation with the continent. Let me highlight five priorities for our shared journey forward. First, we must reform the institutions of global governance — both political and financial — to reflect today's realities. Africa must have a stronger voice in shaping the decisions that affect its future. That includes long-overdue reform of the Security Council, where incredibly Africa has no permanent member, and other regions remain underrepresented. And it includes an overhaul of today's unjust and unfair international financial architecture, that must enhance African representation and endorse a strong African voice in the decisions being made. Meanwhile, we need bold action on debt relief. Today, 34 countries spend more on debt service than on health and education. The Sevilla Commitment points to solutions. By increasing the capacity of governments to mobilize domestic resources, including through tax reform. And by establishing a more effective framework for debt relief and tripling the lending capacity of multilateral development banks and their engagement in derisking private investment in the African Continent. Second, we must invest in sustainable global value chains and regional integration. Africa's path for prosperity must focus on adding value to its raw materials, creating decent jobs and building resilience, taking profit of the African Continental Free Trade Area. And we must also address Africa's energy paradox. Africa has enormous renewables potential, but receives just 2 per cent of global investment into renewables and 600 million Africans live without electricity. And Africa is also home to the critical minerals required to power renewable technologies. But, the countries hosting them must be the ones to benefit first and most, while adding value to local and global value chains. Third, we must harness digital innovation — including artificial intelligence (AI) — for development. But, the African people are still suffering from a wide digital divide. Japan's technological leadership can help close this divide and ensure that technology helps African countries catch up with adequate digital public infrastructure, rather than being left behind. This includes ensuring that all countries can harness the incredible potential of artificial intelligence to power progress for all, as defined in the Pact for the Future. We have just shared a report outlining innovative financing options to build AI capacity in developing countries. AI must stand for Africa Included. Fourth, we need people-centred development. Young people are the builders of Africa's future. Let us invest in their skills and education, particularly STEM [science, technology, engineering and mathematics], and ensure decent jobs, social protection, and a seat at the decision-making table. Let us invest in women's full participation across economies, societies and political systems. Fifth, we must recognize that peace and prosperity go hand in hand. Sustainable development requires sustainable peace. By silencing the guns as the African Union clearly points out. And by ending violence in all its forms and strengthening the social cohesion and stability that can attract investment and business to Africa. We have the roadmap: the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals, and the African Union's Agenda 2063. Let's co-create solutions that can build a future of dignity, opportunity and peace for all. Distributed by APO Group on behalf of United Nations (UN).
Zawya
6 hours ago
- Zawya
Japan-Malawi Foreign Ministers' Meeting
AFRICA On August 20, commencing at 5:58 p.m. for approximately 20 minutes, Mr. IWAYA Takeshi, Minister for Foreign Affairs, held a meeting with Hon. Ms. Nancy Tembo, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Malawi, who is visiting Japan to participate in the in the Ninth Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD 9). The overview of the meeting is as follows: At the outset, Minister IWAYA referred that the cumulative number of Japan Overseas Cooperation Volunteers dispatched to Malawi has exceeded 1,800, which is the biggest number in the world, and expressed his hope that young people will continue to play an active role as a bridge between the two countries. In response, Minister Tembo expressed hir appreciation for the contribution extended by Japan Overseas Cooperation Volunteers as well as her intention to further develop the good bilateral relations that have been built up over many years. Following that, Minister IWAYA announced the launch of a new comprehensive cooperation initiative covering the Nacala Corridor region, which connects Zambia, Malawi, and Mozambique to the Indian Ocean, and stated that Japan will support the development of transportation infrastructure and industrial promotion in the surrounding areas. Minister IWAYA also stated that, in light of the serious food insecurity caused by recent floods and droughts, Japan has decided to provide food assistance to Malawi. In response, Minister Tembo expressed her gratitude for Japan's support to date, while also touching on the One Village, One Product Movement. In addition, Minister Tembo expressed her desire to further strengthen bilateral relations, including strengthening economic ties through increased investment from Japan, while also expressing her hopes for cooperation in areas such as regional integration, infrastructure, minerals, and agriculture. The two ministers also concurred to further strengthening cooperation in responding to various regional and international challenges, such as policies towards North Korea including the nuclear and missile issues as well as the abductions issue, and the United Nations Security Council reform. Distributed by APO Group on behalf of Portal do Governo de Moçambique. Disclaimer: The contents of this press release was provided from an external third party provider. This website is not responsible for, and does not control, such external content. This content is provided on an 'as is' and 'as available' basis and has not been edited in any way. Neither this website nor our affiliates guarantee the accuracy of or endorse the views or opinions expressed in this press release. The press release is provided for informational purposes only. The content does not provide tax, legal or investment advice or opinion regarding the suitability, value or profitability of any particular security, portfolio or investment strategy. Neither this website nor our affiliates shall be liable for any errors or inaccuracies in the content, or for any actions taken by you in reliance thereon. You expressly agree that your use of the information within this article is at your sole risk. To the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, this website, its parent company, its subsidiaries, its affiliates and the respective shareholders, directors, officers, employees, agents, advertisers, content providers and licensors will not be liable (jointly or severally) to you for any direct, indirect, consequential, special, incidental, punitive or exemplary damages, including without limitation, lost profits, lost savings and lost revenues, whether in negligence, tort, contract or any other theory of liability, even if the parties have been advised of the possibility or could have foreseen any such damages.
Zawya
6 hours ago
- Zawya
‘Africa is poised for progress' Guterres tells development conference in Japan
'With the world's youngest population, abundant natural resources, and a vibrant entrepreneurial spirit, Africa is poised for progress,' he told the 9th Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD) in Yokohama. He said the meeting's theme – Co-Create Innovative Solutions with Africa – was a reminder that these same strengths can help shape a more peaceful, prosperous, and sustainable world in Africa and beyond. Progress and reform In this regard, he emphasised the need to accelerate progress to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) through investment, reform and partnerships. Mr. Guterres highlighted five areas for cooperation, starting with his longstanding push to reform institutions of global governance so that they reflect today's realities. 'Africa must have a stronger voice in shaping the decisions that affect its future,' he said. 'That includes long-overdue reform of the Security Council, where incredibly, Africa has no permanent member, and other regions remain underrepresented.' He also called for overhauling the international financial architecture, describing the current system as 'unjust and unfair', as well as bold action on debt relief. Value chains and renewable energy The Secretary-General next put the spotlight on investment in sustainable global value chains and regional integration. 'Africa's path for prosperity must focus on adding value to its raw materials, creating decent jobs, and building resilience, taking profit of the African Continental Free Trade Area,' he said. He also stressed the need to address 'Africa's energy paradox', noting that although the continent has enormous potential to produce renewable energy, it receives just two per cent of global investment in the sector. Meanwhile, some 600 million African lack access to electricity. 'Africa is also home to the critical minerals required to power renewable technologies,' he continued. 'But the countries hosting them must be the ones to benefit first and most, while adding value to local and global value chains.' Invest in technology, youth and peace Turning next to technology, Mr. Guterres called for harnessing digital innovation, including artificial intelligence (AI), for development. He said Japan's technological leadership can help close the digital divide, 'and ensure that technology helps African countries catch up, with adequate digital public infrastructure, rather than being left behind.' As 'young people are the builders of Africa's future', the Secretary-General's fourth point underscored the need to invest in their skills and education, particularly in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Maths). 'Let us invest in women's full participation across economies, societies and political systems,' he added. Mr. Guterres concluded by acknowledging the link between peace and prosperity. 'Sustainable development requires sustainable peace,' he said. 'By silencing the guns as the African Union clearly points out. And by ending violence in all its forms and strengthening the social cohesion and stability that can attract investment and business to Africa.' Distributed by APO Group on behalf of UN News.
