Misapplied compliance: e-invoicing and charitable organisations
From Andrew Ewe
With the full implementation of Malaysia's e-invoicing regime underway, many charities and non-profit organisations are facing pressure – often from tax advisers and even Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) officers – to issue e-invoices for donations, especially when requested by corporate donors.
The logic appears straightforward: companies want e-invoices to support their tax deduction claims. And so, many have concluded that charitable organisations must comply.
This view is flawed, both legally and practically.
The law is clear: e-invoices are only required for business activities
The statutory requirement to issue e-invoices arises not from guideline language or professional commentary, but from Section 82(c) of the Income Tax Act 1967, which states: 'A person shall, for each year of assessment, issue an electronic invoice in respect of each transaction relating to goods sold or services performed by that person which constitutes the carrying on of a business.'
This provision unambiguously limits the e-invoicing obligation to transactions that are business in nature. Receiving a donation – an unrequited, voluntary transfer – does not constitute the sale of goods or provision of services. It is not a business transaction.
Therefore, there is no legal basis to compel a tax-exempt charitable organisation to issue e-invoices for such donations.
IRB guidelines misinterpreted
The IRB's e-invoicing guidelines refer broadly to 'companies, bodies of persons, associations, etc' as being within the scope. However, they do not emphasise clearly enough that this only applies where those entities are carrying on business.
As a result, many readers have mistakenly assumed that all such entities, including tax-exempt NGOs, are automatically included. This is a misreading.
In law, it is the activity, not the entity form, that triggers e-invoicing.
A flawed practical justification
Some advisers have gone further to suggest that NGOs should secure e-invoices for all expenditures – 'just to be prudent'. This view, too, does not withstand scrutiny. Why would a charitable organisation with tax exemption under Section 44(6) need to compile e-invoices to support tax deductions? If the organisation is not taxed on its income, and if it is not engaged in a business, there is no necessity to compile deductible expense records for tax reporting. Unless an NGO undertakes separate business activities, there is no tax reporting reason to issue and collect e-invoices.
Where a charity does undertake business (for example, a social enterprise), only those business-related transactions would fall within the e-invoice requirement. The rest – donations, grants, sponsorships – remain outside its scope.
The receipt is still the legally recognised document for donations
Donors, both corporate and individual, must provide valid proof to claim tax deductions. This has always been, and remains, the donation receipt in the prescribed format, issued under IRB guidelines. There is currently no legal requirement for e-invoices to support a Section 44(6) deduction.
Until and unless the IRB explicitly states otherwise – with reference to the law, not mere administrative convenience – it is inappropriate to insist that charitable organisations issue e-invoices for donations.
A call for legal clarity
We respectfully urge the IRB to clarify its guidelines, and affirm that non-business charitable organisations are not legally obligated to issue e-invoices. Without such clarity, the sector is at risk of expending limited resources on systems and processes that are neither required by law nor meaningful for compliance.
In our effort to modernise tax infrastructure, let us not abandon the foundational principles of our legal system. E-invoicing has its place – but it must stay within its lawful boundaries.
Andrew Ewe is a Fellow of the Chartered Tax Institute of Malaysia and a former chairman of its Northern Branch.
The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of FMT.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Don't forget the workers in trade war talk, says scholar
Vilashini Somiah speaking at BBC's World Questions programme in Petaling Jaya. PETALING JAYA : A feminist scholar has called out the absence of labour, particularly that of women and migrant workers, in discussions around the US tariffs. Universiti Malaya's Vilashini Somiah, an anthropologist specialising in migration, gender and labour, said the current debate often focuses on geopolitics and corporate interests instead of the factory and construction workers who will feel the impact. 'We are so consumed with the conversation of companies. We're so consumed about the way America is looking at China and how China is looking at America and where all of us are in between in the Indo-Pacific,' she said during tonight's recording of BBC World Questions debate at Petaling Jaya Performing Arts Centre. 'But the fact of the matter is, you can't move any of these things… if the cost of labour on invisible bodies, particularly, is not acknowledged.' Vilashini said the gendered and migrant dimensions of labour often go unmentioned in trade policies, as these perspectives were not seen as 'sexy' or powerful compared to hard diplomacy and economic strategy. 'These are people (holding up economies). These are your mothers, your sisters,' she added. US president Donald Trump introduced the tariff measures on April 3, imposing a 10% baseline levy on most trading partners and steeper duties on dozens of countries and blocs, including the EU, UK, Canada, Mexico, and China. Malaysia initially received a 24% tariff rate, excluding electronics, while regional neighbour Cambodia was slapped with a 49% tariff, the heaviest among all Southeast Asian countries. It was followed by Laos (48%), Vietnam (46%), and Singapore (10%). Malaysia's exports in manufacturing and palm oil, sectors heavily reliant on migrant labour, were expected to feel the impact. However, the tariffs shook global markets, leading the White House to delay or soften some of the measures. Beyond trade diplomacy, deputy domestic trade and cost of living minister Fuziah Salleh said the government was studying how the US tariff package could affect Malaysian households. 'I have also asked for a study to be done on how it will affect the cost of living because that's basically within our purview,' she said.
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Petronas job cuts in line with industry norms, says Shahril
Petronas president and group CEO Tengku Muhammad Taufik Aziz said last week the company would cut about 10% of its workforce in a company-wide restructuring exercise. (Reuters pic) PETALING JAYA : Petronas' decision to lay off 5,000 workers is in line with the challenging global situation in the oil and gas industry, says a former economic director in the Prime Minister's Office (PMO). In the latest episode of the Keluar Sekejap podcast, Shahril Hamdan also said Petronas's move was apt considering the national oil company's revenue per employee (RPE), which he said stood at RM6 million in 2015. 'The RPE of Petrobras is US$2 million to US$3 million… and Pertamina's is around US$1.5 million to US$2 million,' he said, referring to the state-owned oil companies of Brazil and Indonesia respectively. 'So there is a need for Petronas to be more optimal.' Shahril also said the public had to accept the fact that the oil and gas landscape had changed over the years. He said it was clear that Petronas – or any other oil and gas company – would have to evolve from the 1990s, when exploration costs were much lower. Shahril also said other large oil and gas companies had taken steps to reduce their workforce although their production levels might not have dipped. He said this was especially evident in the United States, which has seen a drop in oil and gas industry workers despite production still at a high level. 'However, the number of workers required has indeed decreased,' he said. 'So there is 'productivity gain', which is indeed normal in this industry.' A former Umno information chief, Shahril was an economic director in the PMO under former prime minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob. Last Thursday, Petronas president and group CEO Tengku Muhammad Taufik Aziz said the company would cut about 10% of its workforce in a company-wide restructuring exercise that was aimed at reducing costs due to falling crude prices. He said Petronas expects to reduce its headcount by more than 5,000 people and freeze hiring until December 2026. Deputy prime minister Fadillah Yusof later said Petronas's restructuring exercise was due to global challenges and was not linked to its dispute with Sarawak's state-owned gas aggregator, Petroleum Sarawak Bhd. Petronas has promised to support employees affected by the exercise, including by offering competitive separation packages.
Malaysia Sun
4 hours ago
- Malaysia Sun
Malaysia, Poland seek strengthened economic, trade ties
KUALA LUMPUR, June 10 (Xinhua) -- Malaysia is seeking strengthened economic and trade ties with Poland while reaffirming the importance of free and open trade, Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and Polish President Andrzej Duda said here on Tuesday. They reaffirmed the importance of adhering to internationally accepted trade norms and multilateral engagement and cooperation, as this would be mutually beneficial, the leaders said in a joint statement during Duda's official visit to Malaysia from June 9 to 11. "The leaders reiterated their unwavering commitment to open and inclusive trade and a fair, rules-based international trading system. They strongly reaffirmed their support for the swift advancement of the Malaysia-EU Free Trade Agreement (MEUFTA) negotiations and stressed the importance of concluding the agreement at the earliest opportunity," they said. "Both sides agreed to promote balanced trade by reducing economic barriers, enhancing consultation mechanisms between relevant ministries, and fostering collaboration amongst business communities," they said, adding that friendly bilateral cooperation will facilitate cooperation in a number of new and emerging fields such as the digitalization of public services, green transition, particularly the hydrogen economy and renewable energy and the maritime economy. Anwar and Duda also agreed to cooperate on security matters, including enhancing the exchange of experiences and coordination in combating crime, including organized and international crime. Poland is Malaysia's important trading partner among EU member states. Malaysia's main exports to Poland include electrical and electronic products, rubber products and machinery, while main imports from Poland consist of machinery, equipment and spare parts, electrical and electronic products, and transport equipment.
