DCC may thwart plan to demolish lecture theatres
The Dunedin City Council has included the Archway Lecture Theatre building on a draft list of 146 buildings to be protected under changes to the district plan.
The council's heritage assessment says the building is unique, special and "without comparison" in Dunedin. However, the University of Otago says the building represents the "poorest quality" lecture theatres on campus and demolition had been on the cards for at least 15 years.
The proposed heritage changes will be considered at a hearing beginning on May 19.
In his written evidence, vice-chancellor Grant Robertson asked for the building not to be included on the list, saying the university was considering demolishing the theatres and the neighbouring Gregory Building — possibly replacing them with a formal garden space.
The university wanted to "maximise the value" of neo-gothic buildings on campus by developing the Union St entranceway, he said.
In March, Mr Robertson confirmed he was planning to move a significant proportion of the staff in the Clocktower building — including himself — into the consumer and applied science building.
"A formal garden space connecting the [consumer and applied sciences] building with Union St and the gothic heritage buildings of the Clocktower precinct, for example, offers a substantial enhancement to the university's heritage campus," he said.
"The Archway Lecture Theatres are a barrier to this entranceway."
The 2010 Campus Master Plan suggested removing the building in favour of a new teaching centre. However, following the Covid pandemic and "the changing nature of teaching and learning", the centre was not required.
Rather, the university had an "abundance of building space".
The Archway Lecture Theatre building was built in 1974, designed by notable Dunedin architect Ted McCoy, and won a New Zealand Institute of Architects Southern Architecture Award for Enduring Architecture in 2020.
The council's heritage assessment report proposed the entire external envelope and internal corridor be protected.
"When considered alongside other buildings on the district plan heritage schedule, the Archway Lecture Theatre is without comparison," the report said.
"This building is both unique and special to Dunedin. It also contributes to a nationwide body of Brutalist architecture."
University property and campus development director Tanya Syddall said while opposition did not come lightly, the building represented "the poorest quality" of tiered lecture theatres on campus.
"They are cold and austere, the seating uncomfortable and acoustics poor."
The building would likely be unused in about three years as demand for teaching spaces changed, making maintenance costs "impossible to justify" and demolition inevitable, she said.
Mrs Syddall said in 2010, Mr McCoy was asked about the proposal to demolish the theatres and told Master Plan lead consultant Chris Alcock "words to the effect of 'I'm fine if you want to get rid of them"'.
She said there was no timeline for any proposed demolition and the formal garden was as yet unapproved and subject to change.
The university had supported the inclusion of three of its other buildings — the former Dunedin Hospital Nurses' Home, former Queen Mary Maternity Hospital and the Hercus Building — on the heritage schedule, with some requested amendments.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Hipkins Needs Ideas That Don't Make Kiwis Poorer
ACT Leader David Seymour is urging Chris Hipkins to bring serious ideas to today's Labour retreat – because so far, Labour's only policies would make New Zealanders worse off. 'Chris Hipkins, the recidivist country-destroyer, has retreated to his lair, presumably to stockpile fresh petrol for the economic fire he was stoking just 18 months ago,' says Seymour. 'He moans about the people leaving New Zealand, even while proposing to tax the ones who stay harder – and ban the industries that could bring Kiwis back – just as the economy is turning the corner. 'Yesterday, Treasury confirmed what ACT said at the time: Labour ignored clear advice not to 'stimulate' the post-COVID economy with reckless spending. Grant Robertson did it anyway, ramping up the spending machine, flooding the economy with cheap money that pushed up debt, then inflation, then interest rates, and now unemployment. 'It was economic vandalism on an historic scale. Now, as we hose down the smouldering ashes of Labour's inferno, Hipkins cries 'austerity' – like an arsonist returning to the scene of the crime, asking for the matches back. 'Labour is a party out of ideas – and the vacuum will be filled by the Greens and Te Pāti Māori. That circus would plunge us into third world conditions: higher debt, crippling taxes, more division, and fewer reasons to build a life in New Zealand.'
Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Hipkins labels Covid spending criticism 'Treasury spin'
By Craig McCulloch of RNZ Labour leader Chris Hipkins is dismissing what he calls "Treasury spin" after its analysts said the last government overspent during the Covid-19 pandemic against official advice. Treasury's 2025 Long Term Insights Briefing, released this week, calculated the total cost of the pandemic at about $66 billion, or roughly 20.4 percent of GDP. Previous govt spent too much during Covid: Treasury The report said Treasury advocated for more targeted support in late 2020 into 2021 and explicitly warned "against any further stimulus" by Budget 2022. But responding to questions from RNZ on Friday, Hipkins was unapologetic about his party's economic response to Covid-19. "We prioritised keeping people alive and keeping people in jobs," he said. "I'm never going to claim that we got everything perfect... but prioritising jobs and prioritising lives was the right thing to do." Hipkins claimed other countries also spent up large with the same objectives, but Treasury said New Zealand was near the top of the chart when considering spending as a percentage of GDP. "If you listen to the Treasury spin, then you're going to get one view," Hipkins told RNZ. "If you speak to other economists, you'll get a different view. "Our job was to support New Zealanders through the global pandemic, making sure that we saved lives and kept people's jobs, and we were very successful in doing that: one of the lowest death rates in the world, one of the lowest rates of unemployment in the world, and one of the fastest rates of economic growth in the world." About half of the total Covid-19 response cost was directly tied to the pandemic, such as the wage subsidy scheme, or health initiatives like vaccination, contact tracing and quarantine. The remainder went to a wide range of initiatives like: "tax changes, training schemes, housing construction, shovel-ready infrastructure projects, increases to welfare benefits, the Small Business Cashflow Scheme, Jobs for Nature, additional public housing places and school lunches". Treasury said that had "a lagged impact on the economy and proved difficult to unwind in later years". But Hipkins said Treasury had mischaracterised some of that spending, such as the provision of distance-learning for school students. "Making sure that kids could keep learning while they were at home during lockdown was an essential Covid-19 expense," Hipkins said. The report comes during a prolonged economic downturn, with both the government and opposition parties trading blame over its cause. Finance Minister Nicola Willis was quick on Thursday to wield Treasury's findings as evidence that Labour had been undisciplined in its spending, driving up inflation, and fuelling a cost-of-living crisis. "Treasury's language is spare and polite, but its conclusions are damning," she said. "New Zealanders are still paying the price of the previous government extending a big-spending approach initially intended for a pandemic response. "The lesson from Labour's mishandling of the Covid response is that while there are times when governments have to increase spending in response to major events the fiscal guardrails should be restored as soon as possible." To that, Hipkins scoffed: "By comparison to this government's track record, I'll take our one any day". Hipkins said Willis should stop blaming others and instead accept the consequences of her government's spending cuts. "The wreckage that she is leaving in her wake at the moment is obvious for all New Zealanders to see. Unemployment is going up," he said. "Economic growth has collapsed. Essential services that the public rely on a daily basis are falling into disarray, and this is all on Nicola Willis' watch."
NZ Herald
8 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Intrepid Travel fully acquires NZ's Haka Tours and ANZ Nature Tours
As part of the acquisition, Haka Tours will now operate as Intrepid DMC New Zealand Limited. Haka House Hostels chief executive Ryan Sanders said Haka Tours is in very capable hands with the Intrepid leadership team. As Sanders explained, the deal to take over the whole business was always part of the original deal, and something he had a lot of time to prepare for. 'In terms of the size of the business now and what we have achieved, I feel really proud,' Sanders said. 'What started as a dream when on my OE in the UK to launching the business, having never worked in tourism before, to where it is now with a global pandemic and the Christchurch earthquakes thrown in (our head office was in Christchurch) is something I will always look back on with a huge sense of achievement.' Sanders confirmed he is 100% out of the business, but said it's in very capable hands with the Intrepid leadership team. Reflecting on the wider tourism industry, Sanders believes it is still yet to normalise post-Covid, but feels the recent changes to Tourism New Zealand's strategy were the right move. 'Specific to group tours, I feel like we were ahead of the curve, focusing on small group tours as increasingly travellers are looking for more tailored and bespoke options.' 'I feel there will always be a place for small group touring, especially for those travellers who are time poor, travelling solo and want to prioritise safety.' Sanders also announced the news on his LinkedIn, sharing in a post: 'I had never worked in tourism before starting a nationwide tour company, so it really was a baptism by fire. Nor did I have any ambition to be a tour guide – to be honest, I never ran a single tour for Haka Tours in those nearly 20 years. 'But I knew I was representative of our target customer and developing the business from the standpoint of what would excite me was the best north star I could have had and is something I still do today with my other businesses.' His focus moving forward will be his position as chief executive of Haka House Hostels, Australasia's second-largest hostel network, which has 14 properties across New Zealand. As for the funds he's received from selling Haka Tours, it has gone into a new project – the purchase and restoration of Earnscleugh Castle in Central Otago, which is set to be featured in a major TV show. Intrepid's Australia and New Zealand managing director Brett Mitchell said that Haka Tours shares their DNA. Photo / Supplied Important for the strategy Intrepid Travel's Australia and New Zealand managing director Brett Mitchell said that New Zealand has always been an important part of strengthening their operational presence. 'From the outset we always intended to acquire 100% of the business, as we saw strong alignment, culturally, strategically and commercially,' Mitchell said. 'New Zealand continues to be a core market and focus for us. It aligns with our long-term ambition to grow Intrepid's presence in Aotearoa and invest deeper in one of our core markets.' Mitchell explained New Zealand was Intrepid's highest-performing market per capita, and one of the most aspirational destinations globally. He wouldn't confirm how much Intrepid acquired the business for, but said it was a long-term investment and that any changes would be mostly operational. 'Haka also shares our DNA. Both businesses started as homegrown startups, and both are built on a passion for adventure, connection and doing tourism responsibly.' 'While some products may still reference Haka during the transition, all branding will shift to Intrepid by the end of the year. What won't change is the great small group experience, with local guides and local insights, and support from our global reach and operational strength.' To help reflect the next phase of the business, Simon Mckearney has been appointed Intrepid's first New Zealand country manager to bring both inbound and outbound operations together for the first time under a single leadership position. 'Simon is a Kiwi with more than two decades of experience in the New Zealand travel industry. He understands the market and our customers and is well respected across the sector. 'Based in Auckland, he'll lead our operations with a focus on growing inbound and outbound travel and engaging local travellers. We're confident he'll grow the Intrepid brand in New Zealand and take the business to the next level.' Tom Raynel is a multimedia business journalist for the Herald, covering small business, retail and tourism.
