Beef Wellington and death cap mushrooms: Tragic accident or recipe for murder in case gripping Australia
While many Australian families gather for family lunches on weekends across the country, few would expect that the delicious dish they're eating might be poisoned by a loved one.
But that's what authorities say happened to three people in a small town about an hour's drive east from Melbourne in July 2023. Erin Patterson -- a 50-year-old mother of two -- is on trial for allegedly serving death cap mushrooms in a home-cooked meal of beef Wellington.
In a courtroom saga captivating audiences in Australia and beyond, Patterson faces three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder relating to what authorities say was a toxic lunch she is accused of preparing for the relatives of her estranged husband, Simon Patterson -- who himself backed out of the ill-fated lunch in what was likely a life-saving decision.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty as she stands accused of murdering Simon's parents and aunt, with all three victims suffering multiple organ failure that led to their deaths a few days after the lunch. Simon's uncle Ian Wilkinson survived, having spent weeks in the hospital.
Wilkinson later told prosecutors that he and his wife were grateful for the lunch invitation, although they did not understand its purpose.
Patterson's lawyers said the poisoning was a tragic and terrible accident, maintaining Erin's innocence.
In one of the many twists to this fascinating tale of death and cookery, one of the victims said shortly before passing away that the lunch was actually "delicious."
During the trial, now in its fifth week, the prosecution played a video of Patterson's police interview recorded in August 2023, according to court reports.
A homicide detective said Patterson 'expressed surprise' when she found out that some of her guests had died as police searched her property in the wake of the poisonings.
Looking at her computer's search history, investigators found that Patterson looked up a website listing sightings of the poisonous mushroom.
Meanwhile, Australians remain glued to their screens as some obsess over the slowly unfolding proceedings.
The trial is expected to conclude in June and is sure to be well documented, with several podcasts and documentaries capturing every little detail -- and they have no shortage of material.
One juror has already been removed for possible misconduct while a protest interrupted court proceedings on Monday, as accusations that the murder cases had been "rigged" echoed through the court.
Editor's Note: This article has been updated for clarity.
Beef Wellington and death cap mushrooms: Tragic accident or recipe for murder in case gripping Australia originally appeared on abcnews.go.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
12 minutes ago
- CNBC
Australia's economic growth stays flat at 1.3% in the first quarter from a year earlier, missing estimates
Australia's economy grew less than expected in the first quarter this year, as growth stalled amid the simmering global trade tensions. The country's economy grew 1.3% year-on-year in the first quarter, lower than the estimated 1.5% growth among economists polled by Reuters. That was unchanged from the 1.3% year-on-year growth in the prior quarter. The GDP figure comes as the Reserve Bank of Australia slashed rates to its lowest level in two years at its last meeting in May as inflation figures concerns receded, offering some room for the RBA to ease monetary policy. The central bank said in its statement after the meeting that it expects domestic GDP growth to pick up in 2025, driven by a recovery in consumption and continued strength in public demand. "However, the pick-up is expected to be more gradual than previously forecast due to weaker global demand, global and domestic uncertainty and weaker momentum in consumption," it added. Inflation in the country has eased to a four-year low of 2.4% in the first quarter of 2025, within the RBA's target range of 2% to 3%. The RBA said in its May meeting that its baseline assumptions for the country's economy going forward would reflect "somewhat weaker" demand for Australian exports. It said that "some weight was placed on the possibility that heightened policy uncertainty might dampen domestic investment and household spending; and near-term momentum in consumption was a little weaker."
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Qantas passenger hits out over hidden travel frustration for thousands of Aussies: 'So common'
An Australian disability advocate is calling for better, disability-led policies and systemic reforms to ensure disabled travellers are respected, and their mobility aids are properly handled, after her wheelchair was damaged for a third time by Qantas. Melbourne woman Zoe Simmons, who lives with fibromyalgia, said she recently embarked on a round-trip to Tokyo from Melbourne with the national carrier, and when she was given back her wheelchair in Australia, it had sustained substantial damages. She said it was handed back with warped metal, broken parts, and scratches that impacted its safety and usability. Zoe said that in 2021, a similar, though more severe incident occurred with Qantas, and again last year, though she didn't report the latter issue — the steering controller had broken off — over fears of being "laughed off". Following her recent trip to Japan, Qantas did arrange for Zoe to get her wheelchair repaired through one of its partnered repair services, but she feels it's unfair that disabled passengers have to accept this as the norm — that they're expected to handle repairs themselves whenever their mobility aids are damaged during travel. Zoe said she, and hundreds of thousands around the country, remain deeply frustrated at the energy it takes disabled passengers to continually advocate for repairs and recognition, often met with indifference or excuses from airline staff. "I just hate that it's so common, like what are they doing to our wheelchairs that causes metal to warp and break," Zoe told Yahoo News Australia. "There are chunks out of the arm rests, the arm rests are very warped and are weirdly sitting now, they're also loose, the foot guard has chunks out of it, my wheel cover and my cup holder are also damaged, not to mention the scratches, and so on. "Last time I flew with them, they broke my wheelchair controller off. And it was just laughed off! I didn't have the energy to fight for such a small thing then." Zoe said that after discovering damage to her wheelchair, she had to explain her story to several airport staff who mostly responded with dismissive sympathy. When a manager eventually spoke with her, Zoe raised the issue of how the burden always falls on disabled people to advocate for themselves—something the manager denied, citing policies and procedures, without acknowledging how exhausting that constant advocacy is. She criticised the way airlines treat wheelchairs like baggage instead of essential mobility aids, and called for stronger policies, better staff training, and public reporting on wheelchair damage. "Imagine if non-disabled people expected their legs to be broken every time they flew, if chunks came off," she said. "What if your bones were warped? They need to stop treating wheelchairs like baggage and start respecting them for what they are." Zoe highlighted that in the US, some 30 wheelchairs are damaged daily during flights, according to the US Department of Transportation, which began requiring airlines to report wheelchair and scooter damage in December, 2018. Since then, monthly reports have consistently shown that an average of around 25–30 mobility devices are damaged each day across US domestic flights. But Australia lacks transparent recording or reporting of such incidents. "It's just frustrating to have sat in the Disability Royal Commission several years ago, and we're talking about this. While things are improving, they aren't improving fast enough," she said. "We need disability-led policy and procedural reforms, and to ensure everyone has access to repairs, not just people who can be the squeaky wheel." In a letter given to Zoe by Qantas, seen by Yahoo, a representative asked her to take her "damaged bag" to an authorised repairer. "If this is not convenient, please forward a quote for the repair with this letter to your nearest Qantas office for review," it said. Speaking to Yahoo on Wednesday, a Qantas spokesperson "sincerely apologised" for the ordeal. "We sincerely apologise to Ms Simmons for the damage caused to her wheelchair. We know how critically important mobility aids are, and we are investigating how this damage occurred," they said. "We are working closely with Ms Simmons to ensure the repairs are facilitated as soon as possible." Woman slams shocking treatment at Aussie music festival: 'Not good enough' Hidden danger affecting vulnerable Aussies outside supermarkets 'Horrible' reality millions of Aussies face every time they board a flight After Yahoo's enquiries, Zoe said Qantas reached out to her again. She said their designated repairer doesn't service her type of wheelchair. "I then gave them the details of a repairer I know will work, but see all the hoops and onus and exhaustion here, when this stuff happens every day," she said "I'm not mad for myself — I am mad for every disabled person who experiences this, in whatever way that might look like," she said. "I am not that angry about my chair. What I'm angry about is that this is what we are expected to put up with — and much, much worse — every time we fly." Do you have a story tip? Email: newsroomau@ You can also follow us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Twitter and YouTube.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Toxic beef wellington cook gives evidence at triple-murder trial
Australian woman Erin Patterson is giving evidence in her triple-murder trial The court has heard Ms Patterson, 50, cooked and served a beef wellington meal containing toxic death cap mushrooms at her home in regional Victoria in July 2023, which killed three relatives and seriously injured another The prosecution says Ms Patterson included the poisonous mushrooms deliberately - she denies this and her defence team says it was a "terrible accident" Her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, both died as well as Gail Patterson's sister, Heather Wilkinson. Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, became ill but survived Her testimony so far has canvassed the breakdown of her marriage, moments of tension with her in-laws, her health anxieties, and her love of mushrooms She will spend a third day in the witness box on Wednesday Toxic beef wellington cook gives evidence at triple-murder trial
