logo
Workers may not get ‘day one' protection against unfair dismissal despite government pledge

Workers may not get ‘day one' protection against unfair dismissal despite government pledge

Independent7 days ago
Proposals to give new workers 'day one' protection against unfair dismissal has suffered a heavy defeat in the House of Lords on Wednesday.
The defeat is a new blow for the government as the proposals were a Labour manifesto commitment.
The House of Lords backed by 304 votes to 160, majority 144, a Conservative -led measure which would instead reduce the existing qualifying period for the workplace safeguard from two years to six months.
It was the latest setback suffered by the Labour frontbench to its Employment Rights Bill in the upper chamber and puts peers on a collision course with the administration, given it was an explicit election pledge.
The change will be considered by MPs when the draft law returns to the Commons during so-called 'ping-pong', when legislation is batted between the two Houses until agreement is reached.
The proposed reforms also give workers other 'day one' rights, such as sick pay, paternity leave and the right to request flexible working.
In addition, the Bill would introduce new restrictions on 'fire-and-rehire' processes when employees are let go and then re-employed on new contracts with worse pay or conditions.
Business minister Baroness Jones of Whitchurch told peers: 'This Government was elected on a manifesto to provide unfair dismissal protections from day one of employment.
'Not two years, not six months, but day one.
'To deliver this commitment we will remove the qualifying period for these rights.'
She added: 'These amendments would not deliver on the Government's manifesto commitment to introduce a day one right against unfair dismissal, leaving many newly hired employees without robust employment protections.'
However, Tory shadow business minister Lord Sharpe of Epsom said: 'We are debating a change that will fundamentally alter the balance of risk in hiring, and at a time when unemployment has risen in every month this government has been in power.'
He added: 'This clause will do nothing to promote fairness in the workplace.
'It will erode flexibility, it will choke opportunity, and it will harden the barriers that those on the margins already face.'
He pointed out the Government's own impact assessment which said that introducing the day one right to claim unfair dismissal 'could damage the employment prospects of people who are trying to re-enter the labour market, especially if they are observed to be riskier to hire', including younger workers with less experience and ex-offenders.
Lord Sharpe went on: 'The Government already knows and thinks this so why are they doing this?
'So I don't believe this clause is ready. I don't believe that it's safe, I don't believe that it's wise.'
Independent crossbencher Lord Vaux of Harrowden said: 'With this Bill, the Government is knowingly and deliberately damaging the life chances of the most vulnerable, in particular young people trying to get their first step on the employment ladder, and for no apparent tangible benefit.
'I urge them to think again.'
The Government was subsequently dealt a further blow as peers backed by 248 votes to 150, majority 98, a change to the legislation, proposed by the Liberal Democrats, which would force ministers to strengthen whistleblower protections.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Minister wants to get more tourists to Cornwall
Minister wants to get more tourists to Cornwall

BBC News

time12 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Minister wants to get more tourists to Cornwall

The tourism minister says he wants to get more British people going on holiday in places like Cornwall rather than Chris Bryant visited Falmouth and Mylor to meet people who work in tourism locally and discuss the state of the leaders said the 2024 budget had been a "hammer blow" for the industry with changes to employer national insurance rates and many businesses were struggling even if their sites were minister said he knew things were still "really tough" for people working in the sector and more needed to be done to highlight what areas like Cornwall could offer domestic tourists. The Labour MP said Covid had impacted the industry greatly but he remained confident visitor numbers could return to pre-pandemic levels."I want many more British people to say 'what's the point of Spain - we've got this'," he said. Allen Simpson, chief executive of UK Hospitality, said the reality for businesses in the sector was "really stark" and had not been helped by the said: "A third of businesses in the sector are losing money even if it looks like they're doing very well on the door."Bryant said the total number of jobs in the industry was rising and the government wanted to help traders "build resilience".Speaking in Mylor on Wednesday, he added: "We need to get more British people coming to resorts like this and experiencing the variety of tourism that we have in the UK."I [also] want to get more international visitors coming into the UK and we've set a target of getting 50 million by 2030."

Live next to Lake Windermere! Rare plot of land in popular beauty spot goes on sale for the first time in 300 years for £1.2million
Live next to Lake Windermere! Rare plot of land in popular beauty spot goes on sale for the first time in 300 years for £1.2million

Daily Mail​

time12 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Live next to Lake Windermere! Rare plot of land in popular beauty spot goes on sale for the first time in 300 years for £1.2million

A rare plot of land next to Lake Windermere has come on the market for the first time in 300 years with a £1.2m guide price. The 32 acres of mixed ancient and semi-natural woodland fronts on to the the lake and estate agents have described the sale as a 'once in a lifetime opportunity'. The land, which provides direct access to the eastern shore of the lake, is being offered for sale by informal tender, final offers to be sent to estate agents by Thursday, September 18. The land is described as perfect for nature conservation, quiet enjoyment, and 'long-term stewardship'. Mark Barrow, director of H&H Land & Estates, said: 'It is impossible to overstate just how remarkable and a one off this opportunity is. 'Windermere for me is without a doubt the Lake District's most iconic lake and along with what can only be described as an unspoilt woodland paradise, this parcel gives the new owners direct access to their own private stretch of waterfront on one of the world's most admired and famous lakes. 'The potential this property offers is genuinely unique and it will appeal to the widest range of buyers, from local property owners and investors to lifestyle purchasers, conservationists, and those looking to secure their own secluded foothold in the heart of the Lake District National Park.' The woodland, which is free from environmental stewardship or woodland schemes, is crossed by a network of 'well-maintained' hardcore tracks and benefits from natural water supplies. The land will be sold as a whole, with a guide price of £1 million to £1.2 million, or in three lots, with guide prices ranging from £150,000 to £550,000. The first lot, with a guide price of £300,000 to £360,000, is made up of 7.92 acres of woodland with 184 metres of lake frontage and includes a site with lapsed planning permission for a proposed forestry building. The second lot, with a guide prices of £530,000 to £550,000, is made up of 12.12 acres of woodland with 350 metres of lake frontage. The third lot, which has a guide price of £150,000 to £210,000, is made up of 12.48 acres of woodland with around 80 metres of lake frontage.

Judge says law doesn't allow her to release grand jury records in Jeffrey Epstein's long-ago Florida case
Judge says law doesn't allow her to release grand jury records in Jeffrey Epstein's long-ago Florida case

The Independent

time13 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Judge says law doesn't allow her to release grand jury records in Jeffrey Epstein's long-ago Florida case

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging. At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story. The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it. Your support makes all the difference.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store