logo
Workers may not get ‘day one' protection against unfair dismissal despite government pledge

Workers may not get ‘day one' protection against unfair dismissal despite government pledge

Independent16-07-2025
Proposals to give new workers 'day one' protection against unfair dismissal has suffered a heavy defeat in the House of Lords on Wednesday.
The defeat is a new blow for the government as the proposals were a Labour manifesto commitment.
The House of Lords backed by 304 votes to 160, majority 144, a Conservative -led measure which would instead reduce the existing qualifying period for the workplace safeguard from two years to six months.
It was the latest setback suffered by the Labour frontbench to its Employment Rights Bill in the upper chamber and puts peers on a collision course with the administration, given it was an explicit election pledge.
The change will be considered by MPs when the draft law returns to the Commons during so-called 'ping-pong', when legislation is batted between the two Houses until agreement is reached.
The proposed reforms also give workers other 'day one' rights, such as sick pay, paternity leave and the right to request flexible working.
In addition, the Bill would introduce new restrictions on 'fire-and-rehire' processes when employees are let go and then re-employed on new contracts with worse pay or conditions.
Business minister Baroness Jones of Whitchurch told peers: 'This Government was elected on a manifesto to provide unfair dismissal protections from day one of employment.
'Not two years, not six months, but day one.
'To deliver this commitment we will remove the qualifying period for these rights.'
She added: 'These amendments would not deliver on the Government's manifesto commitment to introduce a day one right against unfair dismissal, leaving many newly hired employees without robust employment protections.'
However, Tory shadow business minister Lord Sharpe of Epsom said: 'We are debating a change that will fundamentally alter the balance of risk in hiring, and at a time when unemployment has risen in every month this government has been in power.'
He added: 'This clause will do nothing to promote fairness in the workplace.
'It will erode flexibility, it will choke opportunity, and it will harden the barriers that those on the margins already face.'
He pointed out the Government's own impact assessment which said that introducing the day one right to claim unfair dismissal 'could damage the employment prospects of people who are trying to re-enter the labour market, especially if they are observed to be riskier to hire', including younger workers with less experience and ex-offenders.
Lord Sharpe went on: 'The Government already knows and thinks this so why are they doing this?
'So I don't believe this clause is ready. I don't believe that it's safe, I don't believe that it's wise.'
Independent crossbencher Lord Vaux of Harrowden said: 'With this Bill, the Government is knowingly and deliberately damaging the life chances of the most vulnerable, in particular young people trying to get their first step on the employment ladder, and for no apparent tangible benefit.
'I urge them to think again.'
The Government was subsequently dealt a further blow as peers backed by 248 votes to 150, majority 98, a change to the legislation, proposed by the Liberal Democrats, which would force ministers to strengthen whistleblower protections.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump's Secret Service probes major security breach on Scotland visit after attempt to smuggle person onto plane
Donald Trump's Secret Service probes major security breach on Scotland visit after attempt to smuggle person onto plane

The Sun

timea minute ago

  • The Sun

Donald Trump's Secret Service probes major security breach on Scotland visit after attempt to smuggle person onto plane

A SECURITY breach on Donald Trump's Scotland visit sparked a major Secret Service probe. An investigation has been launched after an agent attempted to smuggle his wife onto a support plane accompanying the US President. 3 3 3 The agent, based in Dallas, flew his wife to Maryland, and she received the official Secret Service briefing at the hotel. She then got on the bus to the visitor lounge at US military base Joint Base Andrews. The woman was later discovered and told to leave, The Herald reports. Secret Service spokesperson Anthony Guglielmi said: "The U.S. Secret Service is conducting a personnel investigation after an employee attempted to invite his spouse – a member of the United States Air Force – aboard a mission support flight. "The aircraft, operated by the U.S. Air Force, was being used by the Secret Service to transport personnel and equipment. "Prior to the overseas departure, the employee was advised by supervisors that such action was prohibited, and the spouse was subsequently prevented from taking the flight. "No Secret Service protectees were aboard and there was no impact to our overseas protective operation." Meanwhile, visitors were told to vacate Balmedie Beach in Aberdeenshire ahead of the President's trip to his neighbouring Menie Estate. Police warned roads and the park would be shut in advance as a massive security operation got underway ahead of Mr Trump's arrival. We told how a protester was arrested and given a recorded police warning on Friday for "abusive behaviour and refusing to stop" at Prestwick Airport in Ayrshire where the American leader's Air Force One jet landed. Trump's security entourage deployed a highly modified golf buggy to protect the prez from fairway assassins while he played his favourite sport. The vehicle, which can sit six people, is believed to have state-of-the-art security protection - including smoke screens, electrified door handles and armoured plates.

Plan for major logistics centre near Banbury dismissed
Plan for major logistics centre near Banbury dismissed

BBC News

timea minute ago

  • BBC News

Plan for major logistics centre near Banbury dismissed

A plan for a major logistics centre that developers said would have brought about 1,900 full-time jobs has been rejected by a planning CB saw the application dismissed by Cherwell District Council in March 2024 for about 65 acres (26.3 hectares) of land south of Huscote Farm, in Daventry Road, appeal for outline planning permission, to develop up to 140,000 sq m of agricultural land with 10 new buildings, east of junction 11 of the M40, was dismissed by inspector Patrick 260 people had opposed the plan going ahead when the council rejected it last year. Mr Hanna found the economic impact would have been "substantial" but dismissed the application last week following a planning inquiry in February. The developers said the centre would have been served by a three-arm roundabout junction off the District Council had wanted to use the land as an employment site 10 years ago but that decision was reversed because of concerns about its landscape and road networks. You can follow BBC Oxfordshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.

Britain may recognise Palestinian state 'within months'
Britain may recognise Palestinian state 'within months'

Daily Mail​

timea minute ago

  • Daily Mail​

Britain may recognise Palestinian state 'within months'

Britain could recognise a Palestinian State as early as September if a new ceasefire plan helps to end the violence and humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Sir Keir Starmer will host an urgent Cabinet meeting this afternoon as he seeks to set out a pathway to peace after a helpful intervention yesterday by Donald Trump. The president criticised Israel, saying that reports and images of starvation in the battered enclave were 'real' despite Benjamin Netanyahu's insistence that there was none. Sir Keir shared plans he is working on with France and Germany to 'bring about a lasting peace' with Trump when they met in Scotland yesterday, Downing Street said. 'We've always said that this needs to be part of a process. It needs to be meaningful. And I think that we also see the crisis in front of us that is so unprecedented and it is so horrific, it's reached terrible levels of deprivation in Gaza,' he added. The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: 'This week, the Prime Minister is focused on a pathway to peace to ensure immediate relief for those on the ground, and a sustainable route to a two-state solution. We are clear that the recognition of the Palestinian state is a matter of when, not if, but it must be one of the steps on the path to a two-state solution as part of a wider plan that delivers lasting security for both Palestinians and Israelis.' Amid international alarm over starvation in Gaza, Israel announced at the weekend that it would suspend fighting in three areas for 10 hours a day and open secure routes for aid delivery. The UK confirmed it was taking part in airdrops of aid into the territory. Aid agencies have welcomed the new measures but said they were not enough to counter the rising hunger in the Palestinian territory. Sir Keir said that the British public is 'revolted' at the scenes of desperation in Gaza as he appeared alongside Mr Trump at his Turnberry golf course on Monday. 'It's a humanitarian crisis, it's an absolute catastrophe. 'Nobody wants to see that. I think people in Britain are revolted at seeing what they're seeing on their screens, so we've got to get to that ceasefire.' The US president hinted at sticking points in US-led negotiations over a peace deal, saying Palestinian militant group Hamas had become 'very difficult to deal with' in recent weeks. He suggested this was because they only held a small remaining number of Israeli hostages.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store