Aristophanes in Tel Aviv
These scenes are typical. Whatever your political leanings, you would likely view them as legitimate expressions of political positions. But on the other hand, not even the greatest satirists in history could have imagined the absurd scene I witnessed in Tel Aviv: protesters in the heart of the Israeli capital demonstrating in front of the Egyptian embassy—in support of the Palestinian people!
The demonstrators took souvenir photos with Israeli soldiers, the same soldiers killing Palestinians and depriving Gaza of the necessities of life, all while attacking Egypt, as if the dust rising from Gaza's rubble could somehow conceal such blatant hypocrisy.
This protest, which drew widespread mockery across Egyptian and Arab social media, ignored Israel's responsibility for besieging, starving, and massacring Palestinians, instead placing the blame squarely on Egypt. This, despite the fact thatEgypt has provided the largest share of aid to Gaza since the start of the war—70% of all assistance—and has never closed the Rafah crossing from its side. Israel, meanwhile, occupies the Palestinian side of the crossing and maintains full control over all other entry points to Gaza, effectively besieging the Strip by land, sea, and air. It is, without question, the primary culprit behind Gaza's humanitarian catastrophe.
Logically, such a protest demanding the lifting of the Gaza blockade should have marched toward the Israeli Ministry of Defence or Prime Minister Netanyahu's residence. Instead, it revealed its brazen support for Israel—at a time when some are inciting against Egyptian embassies abroad.
I will not blame those who fall for Israeli propaganda about 'self-defence,' as the propaganda machine is powerful. But for matters to escalate into a protest against Egypt in the very heart of Israel? That is a scene worthy of an Aristophanes play—or perhaps a George Orwell novel—depicting a parallel universe where the truth is turned upside down.
The ongoing attempts to distort Egypt's historic role in supporting the Palestinian cause serve only Israel's interests by diverting international public opinion away from the real culprit. The reality is that Egypt is determined to deliver humanitarian aid to Palestine—not just as a moral obligation, but to ensure the Palestinian people remain steadfast on their land and to prevent Israel's plans for forced displacement into Sinai, which it seeks to achieve through starvation.
A full reading of the situation shows that since the war began, Egypt has consistently pushed to end it in order to protect Gaza's residents. It has hosted the Cairo Peace Summit and the Extraordinary Arab Summit, succeeded in brokering a ceasefire in January—only for Israel to renege—and put forward a reconstruction plan for Gaza to counter displacement schemes. Egypt has also organised visits for numerous international officials to Rafah, allowing them to see the reality on the ground and helping to create international pressure to end the war.
Egypt's efforts to support Palestine are unmatched regionally or internationally. That is why I believe the Tel Aviv protest against Egypt—and the incitement against Egyptian embassies abroad—should not be read with sober political analysis. Whether seen as an attempt to ease pressure on Israel, a campaign to pin Gaza's tragedy on Egypt, cooperation between the Muslim Brotherhood and Zionism, or part of a larger plan for forced displacement, I strongly urge filmmakers and satirists to immortalise this absurd spectacle in their work. Some events are simply too absurd to address seriously; they deserve to be met with nothing but satire.
Ragy Amer is a writer, academic, and radio presenter at Egyptian Radio.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mada
an hour ago
- Mada
Israeli military to displace Gaza City's population to new ‘humanitarian zone' in strip's south
Ahead of a military advance to fully occupy Gaza City, Israeli officials said they were finalising steps on Sunday to evacuate the city's residents to areas in the south of the Gaza Strip. Israel officials have previously said they intend to construct a 'humanitarian city' to confine displaced Palestinians in Rafah, on the border with Egypt, where the government has held concerns since the outset of Israel's genocidal war that such a plan could push tens of thousands of Palestinians toward Egypt's eastern border to seek refuge in Sinai. 'Starting from Sunday,' Israeli military spokesperson Avichay Adraee said in a post on X on Saturday evening, 'Gaza residents will be provided with tents and other shelter equipment.' He said the step came ahead of the relocation of the city's population, 'from combat zones to the south of the enclave to ensure their safety.' The Israeli military is accelerating plans recently approved at the political level to invade and establish complete security control over Gaza City — Gaza's largest urban center, currently home to around 1 million people. Intense ground and aerial bombardment has already killed dozens, and forced residents of east Gaza City to evacuate, especially residents of the southeastern Zeitoun neighborhood. The Israeli Army Radio reported on Sunday that the chief of staff had convened an expanded meeting with the Southern Command to finalize plans for the city's 'capture.' It would be impossible to accommodate all the expelled residents of Gaza City in the 'humanitarian zones in central Gaza and Mawasi camps that exist today,' its correspondent said. The camps of Bureij, Maghazi and Nuseirat in central Gaza, as well as the tented coastal area of Mawasi, are already packed with residents displaced from across the strip by nearly two years of war. Instead, 'the IDF will be required to withdraw from a certain area that it currently controls in the southern Gaza Strip, in order to turn it into a humanitarian zone for hundreds of thousands of evacuees from Gaza City,' according to the army radio. The schedule of operations has been advanced, pushing planned maneuvers forward in schedule to the coming weeks, with the target of evacuating the city's population as well as establishing full operational control inside the city by October 7, the military broadcaster stated. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had also said on August 10 that civilians would be evacuated before the offensive to what he called 'safe zones' outside Gaza City, describing the area as Hamas's last stronghold. He claimed that Hamas is also active in the central camps and Mawasi, articulating plans for Israel to assume full security control over the entirety of Gaza. Plans for a so-called 'humanitarian city' to be established in Rafah to house hundreds of thousands of displaced Palestinians were floated in July by Defense Minister Israel Katz, who also said that Palestinians would not be allowed to leave the zone. Israeli academics and former officials decried the plan as a blueprint for crimes against humanity, saying it would be a 'concentration camp.' Palestinian and UN officials have said that no area in the enclave is safe — including the southern zones to which residents are being directed. A spokesperson for the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs warned that Israel's displacement plan would only deepen civilian suffering, though the body welcomed Israel's decision to permit the entry of tents and other shelter supplies. 'The UN and its partners will seize the opportunity this opens,' the spokesperson said. A Mada Masr correspondent in Gaza noted, however, that residents were yet to report the provision of further tents or supplies to support living conditions for those fleeing the Israeli forces advancing into Gaza City. Egypt's foreign Ministry issued a statement Sunday addressing reports of Israeli talks with several countries on hosting Palestinians displaced from Gaza, in which it reiterated its categorical rejection of any Israeli attempt to displace Palestinians, whether within Gaza or abroad, stressing that it will not accept or participate in any measures that undermines the Palestinian cause.
Daily News Egypt
an hour ago
- Daily News Egypt
Egypt reaffirms rejection of Gaza displacement plans as war, protests intensify
Egypt has reiterated its categorical rejection of any Israeli plans to forcibly displace Palestinians from the Gaza Strip, describing such proposals as 'a crime that is politically, morally, and legally unacceptable.' In a statement, the foreign ministry stressed that Cairo would not allow itself 'under any circumstances to be a party to this crime,' warning that displacement would be 'an unforgivable historic crime' with severe regional and international repercussions. It urged the international community to shoulder its legal and moral responsibilities, labelling the proposals as war crimes and violations of international humanitarian law. Meanwhile, Haaretz reported that Egypt and Qatar—key mediators in ceasefire talks—may soon present a new framework for an agreement, amid signals of flexibility from Hamas. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office, however, insisted that any deal must involve the release of all hostages in a single phase, Hamas' disarmament, continued Israeli security control over Gaza, and the establishment of a new governing authority. On the ground, Gaza's health ministry said hospitals recorded 47 deaths and 226 injuries in the past 24 hours, bringing the death toll since 7 October 2023 to 61,944, with 155,886 wounded. Seven more people, including two children, died of starvation over the same period, raising the total deaths from hunger and malnutrition to 258, among them 110 children. Israel's army radio reported that Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi has approved an operational plan to occupy Gaza City and refugee camps in central Gaza, with the stated aim of displacing civilians by 7 October this year. Hamas condemned the move as a 'major war crime' and 'an announcement of mass extermination and forced expulsion.' In Cairo, Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa arrived Sunday for talks with Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouly and Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty. He is also expected to travel to El-Arish to oversee aid deliveries. Inside Israel, protests escalated as families of hostages launched a general strike, blocking major highways and demanding a prisoner swap deal. Demonstrators carried signs reading: 'We won't let the government sacrifice the hostages.' The strike gained support from private companies, municipalities, and civic organisations. Netanyahu criticised the protests, warning that calls to end the war without dismantling Hamas could 'lead to a repeat of October 7.' On the humanitarian front, Israel reopened the Kerem Shalom crossing Sunday to allow aid into Gaza, while Egypt continued to send convoys via Rafah. The Egyptian Red Crescent said 50 aid trucks were dispatched as part of its 16th convoy. Gaza's government media office accused Israel of 'deliberately starving more than 100,000 children and patients' by blocking the entry of baby formula, nutritional supplements, frozen meats, and vegetables. Tensions also rose diplomatically, with Israel Hayom reporting that Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar advised Netanyahu to close the French consulate in Jerusalem in retaliation for Paris' recognition of a Palestinian state. At the United Nations, special rapporteur Francesca Albanese cautioned against demonising Hamas, describing it as a political movement that came to power through what she called the most democratic Palestinian elections. Meanwhile, UNRWA warned that replacing its aid distribution system in Gaza with a U.S.-Israeli-backed mechanism would 'bring chaos and death,' urging instead a return to a unified UN-led humanitarian framework under international law.
Daily News Egypt
an hour ago
- Daily News Egypt
Egypt joins Geneva negotiations on Global Plastics Treaty, calls for urgent agreement
Egypt's Ministry of Local Development and Environment announced on Sunday that a national delegation, led by Ali Abou Sennah, head of the Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency, participated in the second round of the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee (INC-5.2) in Geneva, which is working to draft a legally binding international treaty on plastic pollution, including marine waste. Acting Environment Minister Manal Awad said the negotiations, held from 5 to 15 August, brought together more than 2,600 representatives from 183 member states and 400 observer organisations, including NGOs, waste pickers, and youth groups. She warned that plastic pollution poses an escalating global threat to public health and ecosystems, requiring urgent and collective international action. Awad noted that the Egyptian delegation—which also included representatives from the ministries of foreign affairs and petroleum, along with the Federation of Egyptian Industries—actively supported Egypt's positions across working groups. These discussions covered key issues such as sustainable plastic production, raw materials, and financing mechanisms for the treaty. The session ended with countries agreeing to continue negotiations in a further round, with the ultimate goal of adopting a comprehensive global treaty to end plastic pollution. On the sidelines, Egypt held bilateral talks with officials from Germany, Norway, the United States, Bangladesh, and the United Kingdom. It also participated in regional coordination groups, including the African and Arab blocs, as well as the 'like-minded' coalition, and contributed to the ministerial segment on 12–13 August. Awad underscored the importance of reaching a consensus text to effectively tackle plastic pollution, reaffirming Egypt's commitment to advancing international cooperation for environmental protection and sustainable development.
