Chch soldier guilty of taking intimate images of a woman without consent
Corporal Manu Smith during the hearing. Photo: Pool / Stuff / Kai Schwoerer
A soldier has been found guilty of taking intimate images of a woman without consent.
Corporal Manu Smith was facing a court martial on one count of making intimate visual recordings.
The three-person military panel found Corporal Smith guilty of taking images of the woman without her knowledge or consent.
Corporal Smith was facing three counts under the Armed Forces Discipline Act, but on Tuesday morning Justice Tom Gilbert advised the military panel he had granted the defence's request to drop two of the charges.
The two charges were dismissed for legal reasons, because in light of the evidence he ruled that a properly directed panel could not reasonably convict on those charges.
Corporal Smith earlier said the pair had talked about boundaries and they had discussed filming sexual encounters - and said if she had asked him to stop, he would have.
The hearing, at Burnham Military Camp, was earlier told Corporal Smith laughed about the accusations when he was confronted.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
5 hours ago
- 1News
Two charges against soldier accused of filming sex without consent dropped
Two of the charges against a soldier accused of taking sexual videos without consent have been dropped. Corporal Manu Smith was facing a Court Martial on three counts of making intimate visual recordings under the Armed Forces Discipline Act. In a Court Martial, a military panel made a decision on the accused's guilt or innocence. This morning, Justice Tom Gilbert, who was presiding over the court, advised the military panel that he had granted the defence's request to drop two of the charges. The judge said the two charges were dismissed for legal reasons because, in light of the evidence, he ruled that a properly directed panel could not reasonably convict on those charges. ADVERTISEMENT That afternoon, the accused Corporal Manu Smith gave evidence for the defence. Defence lawyer Timothy Leighton asked Corporal Smith why he had taken out his phone and started recording during sex with the complainant, and if the woman had known he was filming. Corporal Smith said he saw it as a way of expressing their intimacy and that she had seen that he was filming on his phone, and did nothing to indicate she wanted him to stop filming. He said the pair's relationship had been sexual from the start, and they both shared intimate sexual images with each other. Corporal Smith said the pair had talked about boundaries. "Yes, I expected the same respect from her that she did with me, in terms of sharing content with a third party or anybody outside. "...It was a circle of trust, it should have been. I don't want images of me shared with her girlfriends, nor would she want me to share intimate images of her." ADVERTISEMENT Where to get help for sexual violence. (Source: 1News) He said the pair had discussed filming sexual encounters, while discussing their sexual likes and dislikes, and he believed she was open to it. Corporal Smith said he believed he did have consent to record the sexual encounter which was the subject of the complaint, and he said if she had asked him to stop he would have. The prosecution's captain John Whitcombe asked Corporal Smith about the nature of his relationship with the complainant and whether she had reason to assume it was a exclusive relationship. Corporal Smith said the nature of their relationship was not discussed, but he saw it as non-exclusive and he believed she did too. Captain John Whitcombe challenged Corporal Smith's assertion that the woman had consented to the sex being filmed, asking if there was ever an express discussion about him filming on the day in question. Corporal Smith said they had talked about it in a light-hearted, jovial way. ADVERTISEMENT "There was no black and white, no written agreement," he told the court. The defence and prosecution will give their closing addresses this afternoon.
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
Corporal Manu Anthony Smith sentenced over intimate recording of woman without consent
Corporal Manu Smith. Photo: Pool / Stuff / Kai Schwoerer A soldier has been sentenced to two months detention in a military jail for making an intimate visual recording of a woman without her consent. Corporal Manu Anthony Smith made the recording while having sex with his now-former girlfriend in 2020. The sentencing followed a three-day court martial at Burnham Military Camp. The 41-year-old has also been ordered to pay $2000 in compensation to the woman. Smith will remain in the army, but will be on a formal written warning for the next year. On Wednesday, a three-person military panel found Smith guilty of taking the images of the woman during sexual activity between August and December 2020. Two other charges against Smith were dropped on the second day of the hearing. Before the verdict was reached, the woman who was filmed by Smith told the court martial she felt ashamed and embarrassed about the recording. Smith's commanding officer told the court he was a diligent and enthusiastic soldier and had been decorated for his service in Afghanistan's Bamiyan province. His sisters spoke of his mana and dedication to the armed forces. During his summing up on Wednesday morning, Judge Gilbert said the case was one of law not of morals. He said the panel must not let beliefs about the way Smith or the complainants were living their lives colour deliberations. In a court martial, all three members of a military panel must agree unanimously on a verdict. The panel deliberated for less than two hours before returning the guilty verdict. Judge Gilbert said neither party disputed Smith made the video. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
1News
a day ago
- 1News
Soldier accused of filming sex with women acted like it was a joke — court martial
A soldier accused of filming women during sex without their permission laughed about the accusations when confronted about them, a court martial has heard. Corporal Manu Smith is facing three counts of making intimate visual recordings. He has pleaded not guilty. A hearing at the Burnham Military Camp began this morning and is expected to take three days. Smith has been accused of making the recordings of two civilian women, without their knowledge or consent. ADVERTISEMENT He has contended he thought he had permission. Prosecutor Flight Lieutenant Hannah O'Byrne told the court both women would say Smith recorded them without asking, and then sent the recordings via Snapchat. Where to get help for sexual violence. (Source: 1News) Smith treated it as a joke when confronted about the recordings, O'Byrne said. One woman complained she asked him if he had shared the images with others, which he also laughed off, O'Byrne said. One of the women – who had name suppression – gave evidence this morning via audio-visual link. Smith's lawyer Matthew Hague asked her about a chat group involving the woman and others who had dated Smith. ADVERTISEMENT The woman joined the group after she and the solider had broken up. She agreed the group's members did not like Smith. Hague asked if it was true the group discussed ways to cause trouble for Smith. The woman accepted the group had discussed it and she raised the sexual images as a way to get Smith in trouble. She wanted him to hurt as much as he had hurt her over the course of their relationship, she said. The woman consented to having sex with Smith, but not to him filming it, she said. Under questioning by Hague, she accepted she had worked with others in chat group on her complaint about Smith. But she said that was only because she was not very good with words. She denied making up the claims and said she thought if there were multiple complaints they were more likely to be believed.
