Comparing Putin's military aggressions with Hitler's
Does Russian President Vladimir Putin understandably feel threatened by the growing number of former USSR countries that have become democracies and are trying to align with the West and its values? Or is he a dictator with a Hitleresque dream of expanding his power, influence and territory no matter how much money or how many Russian lives it costs?
Your answer could indicate what you think about the recent push for a peace agreement.
President Trump and Vice President Vance seem to embrace the first scenario, while Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukrainians, most of Europe, many traditional U.S. conservatives and even most liberals hold the second.
So, it's a good time to compare Hitler's military aggressions and broken treaties and promises with Putin's to see how similar they are.
Hitler longed for the land, influence and power Germany once possessed. Similarly, Putin has been quoted saying, 'The breakup of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century.' He may not want to recreate the USSR per se, but it's clear he wants most of the nearby countries directly or indirectly under his thumb — just as Belarus is.
Hitler continued and expanded a major military buildup far exceeding what the country needed to defend itself. That raised alarms in the West. The same is true for Russia — and China. Russian military spending increased significantly before invading Crimea in 2014, reaching 5.4 percent of GDP by 2016. It dropped when Trump was first elected president but exploded again in 2021, just before Russia invaded Ukraine.
Hitler worked to sway public opinion and political leaders in neighboring countries to create sympathy to the Nazi cause. That's how he was able to absorb Austria into Germany in March 1938. Putin appears to be doing the same thing. Several countries have complained that Russia is covertly backing pro-Russia propaganda and candidates.
Hitler began his land grab by demanding the Sudetenland, which was part of Czechoslovakia, claiming he was just uniting historically German peoples. Germany, Italy, France and Great Britain met in Munich in September 1938 to resolve the issue. In an effort to avoid war, Britain and France pressured Czechoslovakia, which was excluded from the negotiations — sound familiar? — to hand over the Sudetenland. Likewise, Putin has claimed that Ukraine was always part of the true Russia, and he is just reclaiming that territory.
Before leaving Munich, British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain and Hitler agreed to work for peace. Chamberlain returned to Great Britain claiming, 'I believe it is peace for our time.'
But Hitler wasn't satisfied with the Sudetenland. He wanted all of Czechoslovakia and took it. Britain and France didn't respond. So, Hitler invaded Poland, which drew Great Britian and France into war.
Winston Churchill had warned Chamberlain, 'You were given the choice between war and dishonour. You chose dishonour, and you will have war.' Churchill was right.
Even as Hitler was moving his military closer to the other countries' borders, he denied he planned to attack, then he did exactly that.
Again, like Hitler, Putin alleged his soldiers were participating in 'military exercises' in Belarus, just north of Kyiv. It looked suspiciously like he planned to attack. Putin denied it repeatedly and then attacked on Feb. 24.
Having lived through several broken Putin promises, Zelensky, Ukrainians and Europeans believe Putin cannot be trusted — as Zelensky tried to explain to Trump and Vance. They didn't want to hear it.
But even if a deal is reached, Putin is playing the long game. He knows Trump will be out in four years while Putin will be president for as long as he lives. He can wait till Trump leaves.
In fact, since his initial Ukrainian offensive failed — a Hitler-inspired 'blitzkrieg' intended to capture the capitol in a few days — Putin could use the intervening four Trump years to rebuild his military, resupply his weapons and replenish his finances from the sale of Russian oil and natural gas. And he will be a wiser and better prepared aggressor next time.
Europeans lived through Hitler's aggressions, broken promises and land grabs. They can see the pattern and learned the lessons that led to World War II. When a dictator who longs for the land and power of his country's past begins growing his military and creating international turmoil, trouble is coming. No matter how many peace deals may be signed, they aren't worth the paper they're printed on if the dictator really wants land instead of peace and his opponents aren't willing to say no — and back it up. Just ask Churchill.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
39 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
US teacher seized by Russia is located in prison
Hubbard, 73, was accused of manning a checkpoint and fighting for Ukraine, and then convicted by Russia of being a mercenary in October and sentenced to almost seven years in a penal colony. After that, Hubbard's family was not able to find him in Russia's prison system. In a highly unusual move, the Russian judge removed his case file, including even basic information like his lawyer's name, from public view. Advertisement Documents reviewed by The New York Times show that Hubbard is being held in the IK-12 penal colony in Mordovia, the southwestern Russian region commonly referred to as 'prison land.' In addition, sentencing documents reviewed by the Times, which have not been previously reported, outline the Russian case against Hubbard and its contention that he was fighting for Ukraine. Recent interviews with one of Hubbard's sons and others, as well as text messages he exchanged with that son, contradict the Russian narrative. Advertisement Martin De Luca, a lawyer for Hubbard, said his team had talked to him three times since April. On May 28, Hubbard was allowed to call another son, who lives in Cyprus, according to De Luca and Hubbard's sister. 'He's had a rough 3½ years,' De Luca said. Ukrainian prisoners of war who were held with Hubbard told the Times that he had been repeatedly tortured because he was an American — beaten, forced to stand all day, given little food and poor medical care. In interviews after being released, the Ukrainians said they feared for his life. He is the only American known to have been taken from Ukraine and then jailed in Russia. Russia's Foreign Ministry did not respond to a request for comment. So far, the Russian government has made no official statement on Hubbard. US officials have raised Hubbard's imprisonment with Russian officials and asked that he be immediately released, a US official recently said. The US Embassy in Moscow has not been granted access to Hubbard, the official said, despite Russia's obligation under international law to do so. The official spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the negotiations. In a May 19 phone call, President Trump and President Vladimir Putin of Russia discussed a new potential prisoner exchange, according to Russian news agencies citing Yuri Ushakov, a Kremlin aide. Ushakov told reporters that the two leaders had agreed to prepare a humanitarian prisoner exchange of nine people from each side, calling it 'an important humanitarian action.' The United States has accused Russia of inflating and inventing criminal charges against Americans so they can be traded for Russians held elsewhere or used as international bargaining chips. Advertisement Hubbard grew up in Michigan, served in the Air Force in California, married young, and later divorced. He then married a Japanese woman he met in Washington state and moved to Japan, where he taught English. Eventually, the couple divorced. In 2012, Hubbard retired to Cyprus, the home of Joseph Coleman, a son from his first marriage. That is where Hubbard met a Ukrainian woman named Inna, following her to the eastern city of Izium. He earned money by teaching English to a few Japanese students online. Hubbard was alone at home when the Russians launched their Feb. 24, 2022, full-scale invasion. 'He was, in hindsight, too optimistic, I suppose,' said Hisashi Tanaka, 36, Hubbard's son from his second marriage, in a recent interview. 'He was going to wait it out. He thought he wouldn't get into too much trouble considering his age and being a civilian.' The day the war started, Hubbard didn't seem to be initially aware of what was happening, his son said. 'Don't get caught in the crossfires!' Tanaka, who lives in Japan, wrote him on Skype. 'I suppose that I should read the news,' responded Hubbard, who had just celebrated his 70th birthday. 'It is peaceful here, so far.' The Russians say Hubbard signed up the next day for the regional territorial defense unit at a recruitment center at a kindergarten in Izium to earn at least $1,000 a month, according to the sentencing documents reviewed by the Times. The documents claim Hubbard told recruiters he felt healthier than many younger people. 'In fact, Hubbard looked sporty and very fit for his age,' the documents say. Advertisement The Russians said Hubbard was then trained in combat and how to handle weapons and explosive devices. The documents say he was given the call signs — nicknames — 'Samurai' and 'Ninja,' and that he manned a checkpoint on a bridge over a river. The Russians also contend that Hubbard stopped working for the territorial defense unit after a few weeks because he feared for his life and that they arrested him inside the home of an acquaintance in April 2022. But messages between Hubbard and Tanaka in Japan, first on Skype and then through texts on the phones of acquaintances of Hubbard, show no evidence of Hubbard signing up for the military. He repeatedly told his son that all was well.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Ukraine war latest: Russia carries out one of largest attacks against Kyiv; second group of Ukrainian POWs comes back home under Istanbul deal
Key developments on June 10: In one of largest attacks on Ukraine's capital, Russian barrage hits Kyiv, Odesa, kills 3, injures 12 Ukraine, Russia conduct second prisoner swap under Istanbul deal Russia significantly improved North Korea's shoddy KN-23 ballistic missiles, Ukraine's Budanov says EU unveils 18th package of sanctions against Russia, targeting energy, banking, oil Over 40% of Ukrainians willing to compromise on 'de facto' recognition of Russian occupation for peace, poll shows Kyiv and Odesa came under another mass Russian attack in the early hours of June 10, involving ballistic missiles and drones. Russia launched 315 Shahed-type attack drones and decoys against Ukraine overnight, as well as two North Korean KN-23 ballistic missiles and five Iskander-K cruise missiles, primarily targeting Kyiv, the Air Force reported. Ukrainian air defenses shot down all seven missiles and 213 attack drones. According to the statement, 64 drones disappeared from radars or were intercepted by electronic warfare systems. A woman was killed and four other people were injured in Kyiv, according to local authorities. Meanwhile, in the southern city of Odesa, two men were killed and at least eight civilians were wounded in the attack. One more person suffered shock during the attack on Odesa, authorities reported. According to President Volodymyr Zelensky, the attack was one of the largest on Kyiv during the full-scale war. "Russian missile and Shahed strikes drown out the efforts of the United States and others around the world to force Russia into peace," he wrote on X. "For yet another night, instead of a ceasefire, there were massive strikes with Shahed drones, cruise and ballistic missiles." Read also: 'We love our country' — As Russia steps up its attacks, Kyiv residents choose to stay According to Culture Minister Mykola Tochytskyi, the strike also damaged St. Sophia Cathedral in Kyiv. The UNESCO World Heritage site, dating back to the 11th century, is one of Ukraine's most significant religious and cultural landmarks. The management of St. Sophia Cathedral has informed UNESCO about the damage caused to the historic site by a recent Russian airstrike, according to the reserve's general director, Nelia Kukovalska. Speaking to Suspilne, she said that the blast wave damaged the cornice of the cathedral's central apse. In Odesa, a film studio and medical facilities, including a maternity hospital, were damaged. A Russian attack caused damage to a maternity hospital in Odesa. At the time of the attack, 85 adults and 22 children were inside, but no staff or patients were injured as everyone was in the shelter, facility director Iryna Golovatyuk-Yuzefpolskaya told Suspilne. Join our community Support independent journalism in Ukraine. Join us in this fight. Support Us Ukraine and Russia carried out another prisoner exchange on June 10, concluding the second phase of an agreement reached during the most recent round of peace talks in Istanbul, President Volodymyr Zelensky announced. "We continue the return of our people, as agreed in Istanbul," Zelensky wrote on X, confirming the exchange without immediately disclosing the number of returnees. "Today marks the first stage of the return of our injured and severely wounded warriors from Russian captivity. All of them require immediate medical attention. This is an important humanitarian act," he added. The Coordination Headquarters for the Treatment of Prisoners of War said the second group of released prisoners includes personnel from Ukraine's Navy, Ground Forces, National Guard, Unmanned Systems Forces, Air Assault Forces, Border Guard Service, Territorial Defense, and State Special Transport Service. Ukraine managed to release officers, soldiers, and non-commissioned officers. Among the freed Ukrainian soldiers are those who are seriously ill, as well as those who defended the city of Mariupol in Donetsk Oblast and spent more than three years in captivity. "All of the defenders released today have severe injuries and serious illnesses: amputated limbs, vision problems, abscesses, infections, trauma, shrapnel wounds, and chronic diseases. Some of the liberated have been diagnosed with hepatitis and tuberculosis," the headquarters' statement read. The Russian Defense Ministry also said that it had received a second group of Russian prisoners of war who are now in Belarus. Moscow did not disclose the exchange details or the number of returnees. The swap marks the second stage of the deal negotiated during the June 2 negotiations in Turkey — the second direct peace dialogue between Kyiv and Moscow since 2022. Russia helped significantly improve North Korea's KN-23 ballistic missiles, also known as Hwasong-11, after receiving the first inaccurate batch from Pyongyang, Kyrylo Budanov, Ukraine's military intelligence (HUR) chief, said in an interview with The War Zone published on June 9. North Korea has supplied Russia with ammunition, ballistic missiles, and soldiers since the beginning of the full-scale invasion. KN-23 ballistic missiles initially flew with a deviation of a few kilometers and around half fired at Ukraine by Russia malfunctioned and exploded in mid-air, Reuters reported in May 2024, citing Ukraine's Prosecutor General's Office. But now they are hitting their targets, Budanov said, without specifying what exactly was changed in the North Korean missiles. "The KN-23 missiles that were delivered in the very beginning, now it's an absolutely different missile in (terms) of their technical characteristics. The accuracy has increased many times," Budanov said. "This is the result of the common work of Russian and North Korean specialists. Also, there is the modernization of long-range air-to-air missiles, particular technologies on submarines, and unfortunately, ballistic missiles, which can carry nuclear payloads," he added. According to Budanov, Russia has also agreed to help North Korea begin domestic production of Shahed-type kamikaze drones. Pyongyang has ratcheted up its support for Russia following Russian President Vladimir Putin's signing of a mutual defense pact with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in June 2024. Read also: As Russia inches closer to Dnipropetrovsk Oblast, new Ukrainian region might soon be at war The 18th package of European Union sanctions against Russia will include additional restrictions on energy, banking, oil, and other areas, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen announced on June 10. After the 17th package of sanctions against Russia came into effect on May 20, Ukraine's allies announced that the next package of restrictions was already in the works, after Moscow repeatedly refused to accept a ceasefire. Russian troops also continue to advance slowly along the front line, approaching Ukraine's Dnipropetrovsk Oblast and moving deeper into Sumy Oblast. "Russia's goal is not peace," von der Leyen said. "Strength is the only language that Russia will understand." The EU has proposed for the first time a ban on transactions involving the Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 pipelines, as well as a reduction in the oil price cap from $60 to $45 per barrel, as one-third of Russia's government revenue still comes from oil exports, according to von der Leyen. Von der Leyen added that the amendments to the oil price cap are a Group of Seven (G7) coalition measure, so it will be discussed at the G7 summit to be held on June 15-17 in Kananaskis County, located in the western province of Alberta, Canada. The EU will also add 77 more shadow fleet vessels to comply with the cap to prevent Russia from circumventing sanctions and propose imposing a ban on imports of petroleum products made from Russian oil. Another part of the sanctions will be aimed at the Russian banking sector, with the EU wanting to add 22 more Russian banks to the list of those who can no longer use the SWIFT international system. The EU also proposes to extend the ban on transactions to financial operators in third countries that finance trade with Russia, bypassing sanctions, and to impose limitations on the Russian Direct Investment Fund, its subsidiaries, and investment projects. Further EU restrictive measures will include a ban on exports worth more than 2.5 billion euros ($2.8 billion), which must deprive the Russian economy of critical technologies and industrial goods, von der Leyen said. Machinery, metals, plastics, and chemicals used as raw materials for industry, as well as dual-use goods involved in the production of weapons and drones, will be affected, according to von der Leyen. The European Commission President also emphasized that the EU wants its sanctions to be more effective. Thus, the EU would list another 22 Russian and foreign companies, including those from China and Belarus, providing direct or indirect support to Russia's military and industrial complex. These additions will bring the total number of sanctioned companies to over 800. EU countries will start debating the proposal this week. Read also: Key to Russia's defeat lies in its economy Some 48% of Ukrainians "categorically" oppose even a de facto recognition of Russian control of the occupied Ukrainian territories to achieve peace, according to a poll by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KIIS) published on June 10. In turn, 43% of respondents said they would be willing to make the concession to reach a peace deal with Moscow, provided it does not include a formal, or de jure, recognition of the Russian control. The news comes as Russia continues to push for territorial concessions from Ukraine as part of the ongoing peace talks. The survey suggests that Ukrainians are even less ready to accept a de jure recognition of the Russian occupation – 68% of respondents said they are categorically against such a step, while 24% were open to it if it leads to peace. The strongest opposition – 78% – was against handing over control of Ukrainian territories that Russia does not currently occupy. Only 15% of respondents were willing to make that compromise. Russia currently occupies roughly 20% of Ukraine's territory. This includes the whole of Crimea occupied in 2014 and large parts of the Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson oblasts. Moscow illegally declared the annexation of the latter four regions in 2022 and insists on Ukraine's full withdrawal from them as part of a peace deal, even though it does not control them completely. The Kremlin is also pushing for a formal recognition of its hold over Ukrainian territories. While U.S. President Donald Trump has reportedly signalled a willingness to U.S. recognition of the Russian occupation of Crimea, Ukraine has rejected the step, as well as its withdrawal from the territory it currently holds. The poll revealed that public opinion on territorial concessions has remained relatively stable over the past months. When asked whether Ukraine should give up territories to achieve peace — without specifying a de facto or de jure recognition of the Russian occupation — 52% said Ukraine should not take the step under "any circumstances." In comparison, 38% of respondents backed the compromise. These are almost the same figures as in December 2024, when 51% were opposed to the concession, while 38% were open to it. "Our survey shows that the issue of territorial losses is extremely sensitive for Ukrainians and, in particular, how exactly 'territorial losses' are interpreted plays a significant role," said Anton Hrushetskyi, executive director of KIIS, in a statement. "At the same time, this means that (un)readiness for territorial losses can become the subject of manipulation and information campaigns against Ukraine." The poll was conducted between May 15 and June 3. It involved 2,004 adult residents of the Ukrainian-controlled territories who were interviewed by telephone. Only about 500 of them answered all four questions. Ukraine War Latest is put together by the Kyiv Independent news desk team, who keep you informed 24 hours a day, seven days a week. If you value our work and want to ensure we have the resources to continue, join the Kyiv Independent community. We've been working hard to bring you independent, locally-sourced news from Ukraine. Consider supporting the Kyiv Independent.
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Lawmakers expelled from Greece's parliament over ties to jailed far-right politician
ATHENS, Greece (AP) — Three far-right lawmakers in Greece were expelled Tuesday from parliament due to ties with a jailed politician convicted of leading a criminal organization. A court found that Vasilis Stigas, the leader of the far-right Spartans party, and two other party lawmakers had misled voters in the 2023 parliamentary election. The decision comes as concerns grow among traditionally dominant political parties over the rise of far-right parties across Europe and their willingness to disrespect democratic rules. The court determined the three had effectively served as proxies for a former member of Golden Dawn, a neo-Nazi inspired party, who was sentenced in 2020 to 13 years in prison for orchestrating violent attacks against migrants and political opponents. The decision, welcomed by Greece's conservative government, will reduce the number of seats in parliament from 300 to 297 for the remainder of the legislative term through 2027. It also lowers the threshold required to pass legislation from 151 votes to 149. The Spartans party, which won 4.7% of the popular vote in 2023, has denied any affiliation with Golden Dawn and did not immediately respond to the ruling. Two remaining Spartans lawmakers will continue to serve as independents. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
