logo
Warner Bros. Moves to Throw Out ‘Superman' Suit Over Foreign Copyrights

Warner Bros. Moves to Throw Out ‘Superman' Suit Over Foreign Copyrights

Yahoo06-03-2025

Warner Bros. Discovery and DC Comics have moved to throw out a lawsuit over the copyrights to 'Superman' in foreign territories, arguing the issue has already been exhaustively litigated.
Mark Peary, the nephew of the late Superman co-creator Joe Shuster, filed the suit in January, seeking to invalidate the studio's copyrights under the laws of the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and Ireland. If successful, the lawsuit could interfere with the release in July of 'Superman,' starring David Corenswet and directed by James Gunn.
More from Variety
Patrick Schwarzenegger Says He Auditioned for 'Superman' but Was Told It 'Wasn't for You': 'I Don't Think I Got Any Feedback'
Rachel Brosnahan on Seeing David Corenswet in the 'Superman' Suit for the First Time: 'In That Moment, I Knew It Would Be David'
Superman Creator's Estate Sues DC and Warner Bros. Over Foreign Copyrights Ahead of James Gunn Reboot
In a motion to dismiss filed Wednesday, Warner Bros. noted that courts have repeatedly rejected Peary's claims, finding that his mother, Jean Peavy, signed away all rights to the Superman character after Shuster's death in 1992.
'Peary's complaint fails on every ground,' argued Daniel Petrocelli, the studio's attorney.
The estate's lawyer, Marc Toberoff, argued that in the overseas territories, copyright assignments automatically terminate 25 years after the author's death. He filed the suit in federal court in New York, arguing that U.S. courts have jurisdiction over the dispute because the U.S. is a signatory to the Berne Convention.
In response, Petrocelli argued that the Berne Convention is not enforceable in U.S. courts, and that the case should be dismissed because the court lacks jurisdiction.
The studio also argued that the Shuster estate's claims have already been denied by a federal judge in Los Angeles, and those findings were upheld by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeal in 2013.
The studio also offered a summary of the many legal disputes that have arisen since Shuster and Jerome Siegel first signed away the rights to Superman for $130 in 1938. Since then, the studio argued, the creators and their heirs have received millions of dollars, adjusted for inflation, in royalties and other payments.
After Shuster died, his sister — and sole heir — asked DC Comics to cover his debts and increase the survivor payments to her. DC Comics agreed to those terms, raising her annual payments from $5,000 to $25,000 per year for the remainder of her life. The agreement states that it 'fully settles all claims' regarding Shuster's copyrights and trademarks.
In 2013, the 9th Circuit found that agreement precluded the estate's subsequent attempt to cancel the copyright.
Toberoff argues that the 9th Circuit opinions pertains only to U.S. copyright law, and says nothing about Peary's rights in other countries. The suit seeks to assert the 'Dickens provision' of U.K. copyright law, which it argues also applies in Canada, Australia, Ireland, Israel, Singapore, Hong Kong, India, New Zealand and South Africa.
In response, Petrocelli argued that the 1992 agreement covers 'all rights' — including foreign rights.
'There are no carve-outs in the controlling 1992 agreement for any foreign copyrights, much less for the copyrights in the 10 countries Peary now alleges in the Complaint,' Petrocelli wrote.
Warner Bros. was required to respond to the suit by March 24, but filed the motion to dismiss nearly three weeks early. The studio asked that if the judge does not dismiss the case, that it should be transferred to the Los Angeles judge who handled it previously.
Superman is due to enter the public domain in 2034.
Best of Variety
New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week
Oscars 2026: First Blind Predictions Including Timothée Chalamet, Emma Stone, 'Wicked: For Good' and More
What's Coming to Disney+ in March 2025

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

DCU's James Gunn Says 'Wonder Woman' Is ‘Being Written Right Now'
DCU's James Gunn Says 'Wonder Woman' Is ‘Being Written Right Now'

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

DCU's James Gunn Says 'Wonder Woman' Is ‘Being Written Right Now'

Almost exactly one month ahead of the release of the highly anticipated Superman movie, DCU is continuing to make moves. DC Universe's co-CEO, James Gunn, revealed that a new Wonder Woman movie is on the horizon, something fans have been calling for often in recent months. While the news left the bulk of fans overjoyed and only added more intrigue behind Superman's release, Gunn also provided some additional information on the Wonder Woman news. From the sound of it, DCU and Gunn have been in the process of prepping for a new Wonder Woman film for some time, as the ball is already rolling, which Screen Rant revealed. According to Gunn, the script-writing process for Wonder Woman is already underway. "We're working on Wonder Woman. Wonder Woman's being written right now," Gunn stated. The big news on DCU's next high-profile release comes at a good time as Superman continues to build hype before its July 11 release. The last time fans saw Wonder Woman was over a three-movie stretch with Gal Gadot in the starring role. Her debut as the superhero came in the 2016 film Batman vs. Superman: Dawn of Justice, roughly one year before Gadot's Wonder Woman movie hit theaters in June 2017. Gadot reprised the role once more, appearing in Justice League, which was released in November 2017. Fans will now anxiously await news on casting for the future film and a potential timeline for Wonder Woman's James Gunn Says 'Wonder Woman' Is 'Being Written Right Now' first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 10, 2025

When Is ‘A Minecraft Movie' Coming To Streaming On Max?
When Is ‘A Minecraft Movie' Coming To Streaming On Max?

Forbes

time2 hours ago

  • Forbes

When Is ‘A Minecraft Movie' Coming To Streaming On Max?

Warner Bros. Discovery announced in May that Jack Black and Jason Momoa's A Minecraft Movie would begin streaming on Max in June. However, we're a week and a half into June and A Minecraft Movie still has no release date on the Max streaming service, which will renamed HBO Max this summer. News broke on May 21 that A Minecraft Movie was part Max's new lineup of programming in June. The move was surprising given the expediency of the release coming to the streaming service, considering the film opened in theaters on April 4 and made its debut on digital streaming via premium video on demand on May 13. In Warner Bros. Discovery's May announcement of A Minecraft Movie's debut on the service, the press release only said the movie was 'coming soon.' A Minecraft Movie is still playing in 346 North American theaters. To date, the film has earned $423.6 million domestically and nearly $527.6 million internationally for a worldwide box office tally of $951.2 million against a $150 million budget, according to The Numbers. A Minecraft Movie attracted unique attention early in the film's run thanks to the film's "Chicken Jockey" scene and the havoc that erupted during screenings. Piglin characters in "A Minecraft Movie." Warner Bros. Pictures With no new news from Warner Bros. Discovery about A Minecraft Movie about the release of the film on Max, the streaming tracker When to Stream is projecting a potential landing date for the film on the platform. When to Stream, which is typically accurate with its PVOD and streaming service reports, previously forecasted June 20 arrival for A Minecraft Movie on Max since that is the only available date that the service doesn't have a big title scheduled for release. In recent reports, When to Stream is sticking with its projection. The most recent mention of A Minecraft Movie's pending release on Max from Warner Bros. Discovery came in a Tuesday press release, where the title was mentioned among others that will be available to 12 new countries when the platform expands its global footprint in July. Rated PG, A Minecraft Movie follows four misfits (Jason Momoa, Sebastian Hansen, Danielle Brooks and Emma Meyers) who are sucked into a portal in a mine that brings them to the Overworld, where anything the mind imagines can be built with blocks. It's in the Overworld where the group encounters a smattering of block-shaped creatures and the human, Steve (Jack Black), who is being held by a nefarious, pig-like group known as the Piglins. Directed by Jared Hess, A Minecraft Movie also stars Jennifer Coolidge and the voices of Hess, Rachel House, Jemaine Clement, Bret McKenzie and Matt Berry. A Minecraft Movie, of course, is based on the blockbuster Mojang Studios video game Minecraft.

Robert Eggers Is Making a ‘Christmas Carol' Movie, and Willem Dafoe May Be Scrooge
Robert Eggers Is Making a ‘Christmas Carol' Movie, and Willem Dafoe May Be Scrooge

Gizmodo

time3 hours ago

  • Gizmodo

Robert Eggers Is Making a ‘Christmas Carol' Movie, and Willem Dafoe May Be Scrooge

Over the decades, few stories have been as malleable as Charles Dickens' A Christmas Story. It's been a Bill Murray comedy, it's been a Robert Zemeckis CGI fest, and it's even been a Muppet movie, just to name a few. Next up for the iconic tale, though, is what we can only assume is a much darker, scarier twist from none other than Robert Eggers. Deadline reports that the man behind The Witch, The Lighthouse, The Northman, and last year's surprise hit Nosferatu, is in talks to write and direct an adaptation of the story for Warner Bros. And, though no cast is attached yet, Eggers is reportedly eyeing frequent collaborator Willem Dafoe to play the lead character of Ebenezer Scrooge. If you're like us, your mind is currently trying to figure out what an Eggers version of this story looks like, and it's not a pretty picture, in the best possible way. Eggers has largely avoided adaptations, instead preferring deep, personal research to inform his own original stories, though that slightly changed with Nosferatu. Next up, he's co-written and will direct Werwulf, another period horror piece which will focus on—you guessed—werewolves. When you think about A Christmas Story, though, it's just so in Eggers' wheelhouse. There's the original, period setting, of course. The mix of pathos with fantasy and horror. Lots of opportunities for evocative and beautiful sets, creatures, and costumes. Plus, for Hollywood, it's a name brand. It's kind of the perfect bullseye in every single way. And that's before you even put Dafoe in the role of Scrooge. It's basically the role he was born to play. Eggers is also attached to a reboot of Labyrinth, so there's no word about which film would go after Werwulf, which is currently looking at a Christmas 2026 release. But, if Christmas Carol is next, there seems to be a very good chance that Christmas 2028 might just scare the Dickens out of us.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store