Alabama Senate bill requiring display of Ten Commandments draws support, opposition
Rabbi Steve Silverman speaks to members of the Senate Education Policy Committee in opposition of a bill mandating the display of the Ten Commandments in public schools at the Alabama State House on March 5, 2025. Silverman said he opposed the legislation because it does not accurately represent the Hebrew-derived text. (Anna Barrett/Alabama Reflector)
A bill that would require Alabama's public schools — including colleges and universities — to display the Ten Commandments drew supporters and opponents to the Senate Education Policy Committee on Wednesday.
SB 166, sponsored by Sen. Keith Kelley, R-Anniston, would require a text of the Ten Commandments to be displayed in a common area of the school. The legislation does not list any sanctions for schools that do not comply.
The senator said the bill was 'not promoting any religion.'
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
'I understand those that are opposed are trying to make it a religious issue,' Kelley said in an interview. 'It's not. It's a historical issue. It's affected our civilization.'
Critics said the version of the Ten Commandments in the bill combines multiple versions of the text and is not historical. Rev. Julie Conrady, a minister with the Unitarian Universalist Church of Birmingham, said there are three distinct versions of the Ten Commandments and combining them degrades the value and misrepresents the history of the Hebrew words.
'This bill is a violation of the First Amendment and imposes a certain religious understanding of a certain text that has been hodged-podged together and linguistically abused and has no place in our public schools,' Conrady said.
Kelley also said he did not know who would not want their children to learn 'thou shall not murder.'
'It's just some of the comments that were made were basically saying these principles are not really applicable in the school,' Kelley said. 'But especially in the day and time we have school shootings and everything that we have, it's applicable.'
Supporters of Kelley's bill said the text is the foundation of Western civilization and the framework of the United States' laws.
'The commandments are the cornerstone of Western civilization and American law,' said Becky Gerritson, executive director of Eagle Forum, a conservative organization. 'These fundamental principles benefit society by reminding us of basic moral values such as respecting life property and truthfulness, which are essential for a well functioning community and regardless of your religious affiliation.'
Jim Lowe, a Baptist minister from Birmingham, said the Ten Commandments would serve as a 'timeless' moral compass in classrooms.
'Let's be clear, display and Ten Commandments in public schools is not about promoting a specific religion, but about reinforcing the fundamental universal values that were a part of our nation's greatness,' Lowe said.
Steve Silverman, a rabbi from Mobile, said teachers are not equipped to answer questions students may have about the Hebrew-derived text.
'Displaying the 10 Jewish words unfairly sidelines Alabamians who may have diverse views of religious traditions,' he said. 'Members of county boards of education, local principals and teachers across our state are not necessarily well trained to explain this program.
Louisiana passed similar legislation in 2024, but a Louisiana federal district court ruled it unconstitutional in November, citing the separation of church and state. Louisiana's law, unlike Kelley's proposal, required the Ten Commandments to be displayed in every classroom.
The committee did not vote on the legislation on Wednesday.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Russia plans multi-pronged attack on Ukraine following drone strikes, US officials say
Russia launched a massive drone and missile attack on the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv Saturday, as US officials warned that Moscow plans a multi-pronged assault on Ukraine. Russia has escalated strikes on Ukrainian urban centers in recent weeks as peace talks between the two sides have stalled; the fresh onslaught on Kharkiv was 'the most powerful attack' since 2022, its mayor said. Despite the bombardment, Washington believes the Kremlin's retaliation for Ukraine's drone strike on Russian bombers last weekend hasn't yet happened in earnest, Reuters reported. 'It will be huge, vicious and unrelenting,' one Western diplomat said, with analysts predicting Russia will target Ukrainian government buildings.
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Hancock & Kelley: Rams settlement money for tornado relief, Trump-Musk squabble on social media
ST. LOUIS – It was another Sunday morning of sometimes heated but always civil political debate on Hancock and Kelley for Sunday, June 8, 2025. Republican consultant John Hancock and Democratic consultant Michael Kelley discussed the following topics: St. Louis Mayor Cara Spencer, has an idea for using at least part of the Rams-NFL settlement jackpot – tornado relief. Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker for president in 2028? A U.S. Senator calls it a 'no-brainer.' Missouri Governor Mike Kehoe cuts deals to win the special session of the state legislature. And our Quote of the Week: 'Such ingratitude.' President Donald Trump meets his match on social media: it's Elon Musk. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Boston Globe
8 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Helping save Kyiv from drones: Volunteers, caffeine, and vintage guns
Advertisement The chase was on. Mykhailo and the other two members of his crew jumped into a gray pickup parked at the foot of the terrace and sped off, racing through narrow roads into the countryside. They pulled up beside an open field a few minutes later and jumped out. Moving quickly, they set up three tripods — two for machine guns, the third for night-vision binoculars and a laser. Then, Mykhailo — who, like other crew members in this article, asked to be identified by only his first name for security reasons, according to military protocol — glanced at a tablet set on the pickup's hood. Its screen lit up with a swarm of red triangles sweeping across a live map of Ukraine; they showed Russian attack drones, several dozen miles away. Advertisement 'Three heading our way,' said Mykhailo, who is a trade union representative by day. 'Let's wait.' While Russia intensifies its drone assaults on Ukraine, volunteer crews such as the one in Pereiaslav are spending sleepless nights trying to repel them. As the crew deployed last Saturday, Russia launched a record-breaking 472 drones and decoys at Ukraine. This Friday, Russia sent off another swarm of more than than 400 drones and decoys, in addition to nearly 40 cruise missiles and six ballistic missiles at towns and cities across the country, according to the Ukrainian air force, in one of the largest barrages of the war. Military analysts say Russia uses drone swarms to wear down Ukraine's air defenses before unleashing missiles that are far harder to intercept. Russia has also improved its tactics. Its drones now often fly high, out of reach of machine guns, before swooping on their targets at full speed. The drones constantly change route and include many decoys to confuse Ukrainian forces. To shoot down drones and missiles, Ukraine relies on a vast network of units armed with everything from antiquated machine guns to cutting-edge Western air-defense systems. It also uses electronic jamming to scramble navigation systems. Kyiv, a frequent target of Russian air attacks, has held strong thanks in part to crews manning powerful US-made Patriot air-defense systems that can intercept guided missiles. But the city's reliance on unpaid, lightly equipped volunteer crews to shoot down drones shows just how stretched its air defenses are. The unit in Pereiaslav, a quiet town of 20,000 on the Dnieper River, was formed in summer 2023. Sofia, a former journalist now working full time with the air-defense crew, said locals noticed Russian drones skimming low along the river to evade radar. Advertisement 'We saw them, heard them, and understood we needed to do something,' Sofia said. 'All we needed was guns and ammo.' They pulled together a team of civilian volunteers, including women, and contacted the Ukrainian army. The military sent them some old guns and provided basic training. Everything else — uniforms, bulletproof vests, first-aid kits, fuel, food — is at the volunteers' expense. For the past two years, they have juggled day jobs with grueling 12-hour night shifts chasing drones. Caffeine, they say, has become their most reliable ally. Oleh Voroshylovskyi, the commander of the unit, explained that Kyiv's air defense was structured in three concentric rings. His unit covers about 20 miles of the outermost layer, tasked with taking down incoming drones early and warning the rings closer to the capital what's heading their way. For nearly two years, the unit has relied on World War II-era Maxim machine guns and several Uk vz. 59 machine guns, developed by Czechoslovakia in the 1950s, to bring down drones. 'They may be old, but they're effective,' said Voroshylovskyi, showing off the weapons at their base, a large building where downed Russian drones were displayed only a few feet from a relic of Ukraine's Soviet past — a large white bust of Vladimir Lenin, now turned to face the corner. After mounting the guns on tripods during last week's attack, the team waited in the silence of a pitch-black night, lit only by a crescent moon and a scatter of stars. The stillness was occasionally broken by the croak of toads and the hoot of owls. Advertisement Then, suddenly, the tak-tak-tak of machine guns echoed from the north. 'Look! It's getting busy over there,' Mykhailo said, pointing to red tracers cutting through the night, accompanied by spotlights sweeping the sky. Later, the whir of rotor blades hummed overhead — Ukrainian helicopters were chasing the drones. 'They're not leaving us anything,' Mykhailo joked. After about an hour of waiting, a familiar sound from the north made the crew freeze. It was a grinding buzz like a lawn mower, signifying a Russian attack drone. Their radar did not show it, but the sound left no doubt. 'It's coming!' shouted Yaroslav, one of the crew members. They scrambled into position behind the mounted guns. Yaroslav rotated the night binoculars, which fed a grainy black-and-white image of the sky onto a small connected screen. The buzz grew louder, then curved west, circling around them. Unable to spot the drone, the crew held its fire, unwilling to waste precious rounds. By the time dawn broke shortly before 5 a.m., crew members had not fired a shot. But the damage from dozens of drones that had slipped through was already clear on the social media feeds they had been scanning — explosions in Kyiv, buildings ablaze across the country, wounded civilians rushed to hospitals. 'A classic night,' said Yaroslav, his eyes red with sleeplessness. This article originally appeared in
