
Madbouly's media red line
This quote from Ibrahim Al-Yaziji (1847-1906), founder of Cairo's Al-Diyaa magazine, came to mind when I saw Prime Minister Mostafa Madbouly discuss acceptable and forbidden criticism in the media.
The Prime Minister affirmed at a press conference the people's right to criticize, but set conditions: it shouldn't 'offend the image of the state.' That's how we understood his message.
He alluded, without naming them, to countries that don't allow any negativity to be published about them, and even punish those who do. We certainly know which countries he's referring to, a subtle jab at ongoing skirmishes in the media and social sphere within the Arab world.
However, Madbouly often misses the mark!
He consistently confuses the state with the government, a grave error if you knew its significance, because the government is not the state; it is merely a government. The state is a far grander and loftier entity than any executive government. Therefore, discussions about 'the image of the state' should be left by the Prime Minister to other institutions.
He should stop conflating them, something we've warned against in previous writings!
Public service is a challenge, and constantly rehashing 'fourth and fifth-generation warfare,' even if true, shouldn't distract the government from its duties. It needs to look in the mirror, see itself, and discover its reality by standing before the mirror of its citizens.
His remarks championed authoritarianism in media, where the government deems itself solely entitled to determine the facts and information reaching the public, all to preserve what it perceives as 'the image of the state.'
This is despite the fact that times have moved on, and the circumstances have now become far more complex.
According to this government-centric view, media institutions should adhere only to what is issued by the government and its entities. They should publish only the statements they receive, which often contain 'silent rhetoric' about their activities, and ignore any developments in how news and information are received.
Currently, over 50 million Egyptians are active daily on social media!
I honestly don't know the degree of freedom Madbouly desires for the media to be 'disciplined' (from his perspective) while simultaneously maintaining what he considers 'acceptable criticism' without veering into the 'evils of forbidden criticism.'
Is acceptable criticism, then, merely adhering to the centralization of information and accepting the government's monopoly on news, interacting only with its uncommunicative messages and unrevealing reports?
Because a fundamental, public expression of the government and its achievements is missing. The first lesson is to differentiate between the government and the state.
I believe that, from Madbouly's perspective, 'acceptable criticism' means we should simply listen to his weekly pronouncements and report them verbatim, without any analysis or discussion.
He seems to think this governmental disclosure is sufficient, despite every such announcement generating a mountain of questions, starting with its timing, duration, and topics, and extending to the government's communication skills with the public itself.
Some might view the Prime Minister's remarks as a public reprimand directed at the media. However, I see it from another angle: it is, unfortunately, a tremendous opportunity for the very thing the Prime Minister fears most to proliferate—the flood of misinformation on social media.
Because when professional institutional media is absent due to restrictions, the caves of disinformation on social media grow larger, seizing opportunities to prey on people's understanding and corrupt their minds.
Any civilized nation must respect the press and view its vitality as being in the nation's highest interest, enabling it to learn and benefit from it in evaluating and improving public performance for the betterment of its people.
As for drawing lines around 'acceptable criticism,' this would return to a practice the world abandoned long ago.
Europe overcame the trials of its dark ages during the Renaissance through a true belief that transcended injustice in all aspects of society, and it all began with the word—the very same word that still seems to bother the Prime Minister.
Author's bio:
Alaa Al-Ghadrify has been the Editor-in-Chief of Al Masry Al Youm newspaper since October 2023, and the Executive Editor-in-Chief at ONA Media Group since 2016.
He is also an opinion writer in Al-Watan newspaper and Masrawy website, and an advisor at the Egypt Media Forum.
He further serves as a lecturer in television journalism and in-depth journalism for postgraduate studies at the Faculty of Mass Communication at Cairo University.
He worked as Editor-in-Chief of CBC Extra channel, which he founded, as former Managing-Editor of Al Watan newspaper, and former Executive Editor-in-Chief of its website.
He also co-founded the Al Masry Al Youm newspaper, the Al Watan newspaper, and the Al Ashera Masaan program on Dream TV channel, and was the Head of Program Editing at Alhurra channel.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Egypt Independent
2 hours ago
- Egypt Independent
Limited aid enters Gaza: A fight for survival as starvation deepens
One hundred sixty-one aid trucks entered the Gaza Strip from Thursday until dawn Friday, utilizing the Zikim crossing in the north and the Kerem Shalom crossing. An Egyptian source informed Al-Qahera News Channel that the aid shipments primarily consisted of flour, baby formula, and other food supplies, with aid continuing to flow for the third consecutive day. The source also clarified that the Israeli delegation departed after receiving Hamas's response, with negotiations expected to resume next week following a review of Hamas's proposal. The population of Gaza has been suffering from a severe and rapidly worsening humanitarian crisis, with starvation and malnutrition reaching catastrophic levels. This dire situation is primarily a consequence of the ongoing conflict, the extensive blockade, and severe restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid. Even before the recent escalation of conflict in October 2023, Gaza's population, numbering around 2.3 million Palestinians, was already highly vulnerable due to a prolonged blockade and economic deterioration spanning over 15 years. This had led to high rates of poverty and reliance on external aid. Impact of recent conflict The current crisis deepened dramatically following the start of large-scale military operations in October 2023. This conflict has: Destroyed local food production: What little local food production existed has been largely wiped out due to military operations. Decimated infrastructure: Critical infrastructure, including homes, hospitals, schools, shelters, bakeries, and water systems, has been extensively damaged or destroyed, hindering the ability to provide basic necessities. Mass displacement: A significant portion of Gaza's population, estimated at 1.9 million people (90%), has been displaced, often multiple times, leading to overcrowded and unsanitary conditions in shelters. Aid restrictions and access challenges Despite international calls, the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza has been severely restricted. While some aid is allowed to enter, it is widely considered insufficient to meet the overwhelming needs of the population. Key challenges include: Limited crossings: Access points for aid are limited and subject to strict controls. Security inspections: Aid trucks face prolonged and complex security inspections. Internal distribution issues: Even once aid enters Gaza, ongoing fighting, a breakdown of law and order, and Israeli military restrictions make safe and efficient distribution within the enclave extremely difficult. Aid convoys have reportedly come under fire, and distribution points have become dangerous. Fuel shortages: Severe fuel shortages further complicate the delivery of aid and the functioning of essential services like hospitals and water pumps. Escalating hunger and disease The culmination of these factors has led to an unprecedented level of food insecurity: Catastrophic hunger: According to the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), the leading international authority on food crises, the entire population of Gaza is facing crisis-level or worse food insecurity, with hundreds of thousands at risk of famine. Malnutrition surge: Organizations like the UN World Food Program (WFP) and UNICEF report alarming rates of acute malnutrition, particularly among children and pregnant/breastfeeding women. As of July 2025, nearly 100,000 women and children were suffering from severe acute malnutrition. Starvation deaths: The Gaza Health Ministry and UN agencies have reported a surge in deaths due to starvation and malnutrition-related complications, including dozens of children. Some reports suggest hundreds, predominantly children, have died due to hunger. Disease outbreaks: The lack of food, clean water, adequate sanitation, and functioning healthcare facilities has created conditions ripe for widespread disease outbreaks, further weakening a population already on the brink. International response and accusations Human rights organizations and UN agencies have described the situation as a 'man-made disaster' and a 'slow-motion genocide,' accusing Israel of using starvation as a weapon of war through its blockade and military operations. They have repeatedly called for an immediate and lasting ceasefire, unrestricted humanitarian access, and protection of while denying these accusations, maintains that it allows aid in and blames Hamas for diversion and UN agencies for distribution failures The ongoing crisis in Gaza represents one of the most severe humanitarian emergencies globally, with experts warning that famine is not just a risk, but silently unfolding.


Al-Ahram Weekly
17 hours ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
Arab Universities to host international recruitment forum in Amman - Society
The Association of Arab Universities (AArU), in collaboration with Belgravia Advisers, is preparing to launch the Arab Universities and International Student Recruitment Agents Forum. The event is scheduled to take place on Monday and Tuesday in Amman. The forum aims to strengthen international cooperation between Arab higher education institutions and certified student recruitment agents from around the world. It will feature bilateral meetings, the signing of strategic partnership agreements, and discussions on mechanisms to increase enrollment and student engagement in Arab universities. This initiative aligns with the AArU's mission to enhance the global standing of Arab higher education and to develop tools that keep pace with international changes and challenges in student recruitment. Ezzat Salama, the association's secretary-general said: 'This forum represents a strategic platform to strengthen the presence of Arab universities on the international educational map.' It, he added, opens new horizons for collaboration with specialized partners in student recruitment. 'At the Association, we firmly believe that expanding international student enrollment not only enriches cultural diversity on campuses but also contributes to enhancing educational quality and boosting the global competitiveness of our institutions." The Association of Arab Universities, headquartered in Amman, was established in 1964 following an initiative by the League of Arab States. Its foundation was preceded by key conferences in Benghazi and Beirut, which addressed challenges in Arab higher education and proposed frameworks for inter-university cooperation. The first General Conference in 1969 saw the participation of 23 founding universities, at which point the General Secretariat became permanent and Morsi Ahmed, Egypt's former higher education minister, was elected as the first Secretary-General. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:


Al-Ahram Weekly
19 hours ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
Egypt denounces ‘malicious propaganda' against its supportive stance on Palestine - Foreign Affairs
Egypt strongly condemned what it described as a "malicious propaganda campaign" launched by certain groups and organizations seeking to distort Egypt's supportive stance toward the Palestinian cause. Egypt also rejected the "baseless accusations" alleging its involvement in the blockade of Gaza or obstructing humanitarian aid deliveries, according to a statement issued on Thursday by the Egyptian foreign ministry. The statement emphasized 'the superficiality and lack of logic in these baseless accusations, which contradict not only Egypt's official position but also its national interests.' The claims ignore the significant role Egypt has played—and continues to play—since the beginning of the Israeli aggression on Gaza, the statement said. This includes Egypt's tireless efforts to broker a ceasefire, lead humanitarian relief operations, and facilitate the entry of aid through the Rafah crossing. Egypt has also spearheaded efforts to draft and promote a Gaza reconstruction plan that was adopted by Arab states and supported by several international parties. This plan focuses on rescuing innocent Palestinians in Gaza, delivering humanitarian aid, and initiating early recovery and reconstruction phases. These efforts 'are in line with Egypt's unwavering stance aimed at ensuring the Palestinian people's resilience and ability to remain on their land, while resisting forced displacement, land seizure, and attempts to liquidate the Palestinian cause,' read the statement. Egypt accused "malicious organizations and entities" of orchestrating propaganda campaigns aimed at fostering distrust among Arab populations and diverting international attention from the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Cairo reiterated that the Rafah crossing, a key gateway for aid, has never been closed on the Egyptian side and that the crossing on the Palestinian side is "occupied by the Israeli occupation authorities, which prevents access through it." Egypt urged caution regarding the 'deliberate lies' exploiting the suffering of Palestinians under occupation to serve 'malicious narratives." 'These narratives are nothing more than part of psychological warfare designed to frustrate Arab peoples, create division and discord among them, and serve well-known intentions to liquidate the Palestinian cause," the statement underscored. Additionally, the statement affirmed Egypt's ongoing commitment to alleviating suffering in the Gaza Strip, securing a ceasefire, facilitating humanitarian aid delivery, and initiating reconstruction efforts. It also pledged to continue working towards unifying the West Bank and Gaza Strip, ensuring Palestinian territorial contiguity, and launching a political process for a two-state solution with East Jerusalem as the capital, based on international law and the June 4, 1967 lines. As many as 166 aid trucks entered Gaza on Wednesday through dawn Thursday through the Zikim crossing in the northern strip of Gaza and Karm Abu Salem in the southern strip, according to the Egyptian news channel Al-Qahera News. The aid shipments are the largest since Israel imposed an all-out blockade on the strip on 1 March, which pushed most of the 2.3 million Palestinians into a famine. They come amid widespread condemnation by dozens of international aid organisations and Western, Arab, and muslim nations of the Israeli policies of starving Gazans. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link: