Second homes policy shows impact but fears grow 'vital' visitors will shun Wales
In parts of Gwynedd, holiday homes have made up half of all properties, prompting stark warnings about threats to the Welsh language and culture. Measures have been brought in to reverse the trend and free up housing for locals – though critics say the real focus should be on building more homes.
The changes include steep council tax premiums on second homes and stricter criteria for properties to qualify as council tax–exempt holiday lets. Cyngor Gwynedd has also introduced a new Article 4 directive requiring planning permission to change a home's use. Other regions are considering similar rules.
While many welcome the crackdown, the tourism industry warns of a potential hit to their trade, and the Conservatives argue that more housing construction should take priority.
New Land Transaction Tax figures – Wales' version of stamp duty – suggest the policies are reducing sales to second home and holiday let buyers. Properties bought as second homes, holiday homes, or for buy-to-let face higher transaction rates, and such sales are now falling.
Adam Al-Nuaimi, Head of Data Analysis at the WRA, said: "Comparing the year to June with the previous year, many areas of Wales saw decreases in their percentage of residential transactions which were higher rates, in particular the Isle of Anglesey and Gwynedd."
Commenter Ofcourseitis says: 'There are some excellent bargains to be snapped up for anyone who wants to retire to North Wales and work from home, it's a great lifestyle change.'
SCATHINGPEN writes: 'So, if the measures imposed by Gwynedd Council with the premium on second home Council tax and the 182 rule for holiday lets is working, how exactly, has the housing demographic changed? Who's buying the properties now? They're still way beyond the price point of locals due to locals not earning the right salaries to buy them.
'I guess they are being bought by those wishing to retire here, those already in the holiday letting business or other, richer second home owners who really don't care how high the council tax is because they're rich. From what I see, there is only one set of winners here, the councils who are always in search of a new source of revenue. The housing crisis hasn't changed. Locals still don't own the keys to their doors.'
Steamnut agrees: 'They are making it up as they go along to justify the actions they have taken. Where are the new builds of low cost housing that were supposed to be built using this extra money? The money should have been ring fenced from the start.'
Lucy1967 points out: 'The people that are buying second homes are those who obviously have plenty of money - having more affordable housing is fine, but you still have to be working and earning over a certain amount. It's not as easy as people may think, we need more social housing for people who cannot afford to buy, renting is as high if not in a lot of cases more expensive than a mortgage. As long as this continues then things will never change, gradually there will be less and less Welsh people living in their own birth place, which is very very sad."
Jnrm replies: 'But some second home owners inherited the properties from parents and wish to maintain a presence in their homeland. The other owners are not 'lucky' they are hard working people who saved their earnings to afford a second home rather than going on expensive holidays every year.'
Statistix says: 'I take issue with the 'I deserve to live in the village where I was brought up' argument. Most children brought up in a nice big house in a popular village have benefitted from their parents' struggle to climb the property ladder. How many of us starting out could or can expect to afford what our parents strived for years for?'
Sparklytiger states: 'You're all blaming incomers for buying homes in Wales. Just remember, it's the Welsh that sold those houses for top prices. Not ONE of the sellers had the morals to think 'I know I can get thousands more but I'll take a really low offer instead so my Welsh compatriots can have a home where they live'. Start by looking at who REALLY is at fault here.'
Tjr42 adds: 'Tourism is vital to Wales.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
27 minutes ago
- ITV News
Welsh tourism sector 'nervous' about performance as cost of living impacts visitor spending
It has been a "very mixed picture" for tourism businesses this year, with self-catering accommodation said to be the hardest hit by declining visitors and rising costs, Wales' leading tourism alliance has told ITV Wales. Almost half of self-catering accommodation businesses say they have had fewer customers so far this year than last year. That's according to the Welsh Government' s recent Tourism Barometer, which provides a regular snapshot of industry performance and gathered businesses' views in June this year. 60% of businesses reporting lower visitor numbers say a lack of disposable income or global economic uncertainty have been contributing factors. There is also a strong trend emerging towards last-minute bookings. It means only one in six operators said they feel 'very confident' to operate profitably this year. The Welsh Government says it is working closely with the industry to help address the challenges they face. "We're seeing a very mixed picture," Bethan Davies of Wales Tourism Alliance told ITV Wales. "What we're seeing across Wales is a change in the patterns of visitors. "There are a number of tourism organisations that are nervous about their performance this year. Numbers are down. People who are staying overnight are down, so we've got far more day visitors than we used to have. "And people are finding the cost of living really impacting on their spend at the moment." Bethan Davies also hit out at the tourism tax proposed by the Welsh Government, saying she finds it "very difficult to believe it is going to work in most of Wales." "I think adding £40 a week for a family of four staying in self-catering accommodation is going to make a massive difference. "Would you come here to a beach in Trearddur Bay, or would you go to a beach in Morecambe and save £40 and have an extra night out with the family?" The Visitor Levy Bill, which was approved in the Senedd in July. If plans go ahead, councils would have the power to charge up to £1.30 per person, per night, depending on the type of accommodation. The Welsh Government says the levy could raise around £33 million a year to help fund infrastructure and local services in tourist hotspots, including the upkeep of footpaths, public toilets and waste collections. 'These reports lays bare the economic damage being inflicted on Welsh tourism,' said Nicky Williamson, Professional Association of Self-Caterers (PASC) UK's Lead Policy Advisor in Wales. 'What we are witnessing is the avoidable erosion of a vital sector, one that sustains jobs, communities, and Welsh culture. The figures are shocking, but not surprising to those of us on the ground.' Ms Williamson said that the 182-day rule, which requires properties to be let for at least 182 days to qualify as a holiday let, as especially damaging. 'This is not a policy designed to support genuine businesses, it's a punitive approach that makes it harder for responsible operators to stay afloat,' Williamson added. It is a measure the Welsh Government says is designed to tackle the impact of second homes on an area. Suzy Farr, bookings manager for Trearddur Bay Holiday Homes on Anglesey, says she is optimistic for the future, but the business has had to adapt to survive – with people having less money and making more last-minute plans. "We are busy right across the board. Things have changed in the last eighteen months," she told ITV Wales. "There's a lot of bookings last-minute, but we've adapted by changing things to a 3-day travel away Friday to Monday, Monday to Friday getaways and long-term getaways. It has changed considerably in the last eighteen months though.""Things have become a lot more expensive, and so that people can come away, we've adapted." Phil Brown, owner of the Sea Shanty Cafe in Trearddur Bay, said that hospitality is facing difficult challenges, so tourists visiting the area play a crucial role in staying afloat. "We are doing our best to bring people here, and I think we've succeeded. And other businesses have opened up since we started," he said. "Trearddur Bay has become a destination, and why not?"He added: "People say there are less people here this year than there were last year... I don't know. "But I think if you come here, you haven't got to go to an airport, there's so much going for Wales but they don't seem good at marketing themselves, which is a shame."A Welsh Government spokesperson said, 'Tourism makes an important contribution to the Welsh economy and to Welsh life. "Wales has so much to offer, and we want to ensure that we realise that potential in a way that achieves a balance between our communities, businesses, landscapes and visitors.'We work closely with the industry to help address the challenges they face. Sector-specific support is available to businesses through Visit Wales via capital investment funding, marketing campaigns to promote the whole of Wales, year-round and other support for activities to boost the contribution of tourism and hospitality to the Welsh economy."
Leader Live
2 hours ago
- Leader Live
Mynydd Isa FC seeks permission for new 50-seater stand
After securing promotion to the Lock Stock Ardal North West League – the third tier of Welsh football – the club was required to apply for a tier three license from the Football Association of Wales. It was successful in its application, on the condition that it met the licensing requirement for providing covered fan seating by December. 'We are delighted to have been awarded a FAW Men's Tier 3 Licence for the 2025/26 season,' said the club in a statement. 'Thank you to our volunteers for their hard work behind the scenes.' It plans to install the 50-seat stand – which will also have space for fans who use wheelchairs to take shelter – to the right-hand corner of the ground as you look out from the dugout. The seating will sit inside a 40ft shipping container modified by Ruthin-based I.T Williams and Co, who specialise in small capacity sports stands – with the base provided by SCR Landscaping Services. Argoed Sports Association will contribute 10% of the cost, with the remaining 90% coming from the FAW and Cymru Football Foundation's Welsh Ground Improvements Fund. The FAW said: 'The club licensing system aims to assist the continual improvement and development of football clubs within Wales. 'Licensing is a transparent process that enables clubs to demonstrate to their stakeholders that they meet quality standards.'
North Wales Live
2 hours ago
- North Wales Live
I keep booking this budget seaside hotel right on a huge sandy beach that still has dates free this summer
We're now in the full swing of the long summer holidays, and the kids are already bored with the local park and the iPad. You want to squeeze a cheeky summer trip in, but everywhere is booked or expensive. Luckily, I've found a budget hotel right on a sandy beach. It costs £32 per person, for a family of four, for a wallet-friendly stay on the gorgeous Welsh coastline. Picture a vast sandy beach extending as far as the eye can see, with crashing waves and a stylish promenade with an ice cream shop in the middle of the seafront. You're not in a pricey European resort; this is Pendine, a charming seaside village in Wales with a seven-mile beach and seaside hotel, Caban. Caban Pendine is an excellent choice if you're looking for a budget-friendly seaside getaway. Its spacious rooms start from £32 per person in the peak season (based on a family of four sharing a £130 room), and prices drop the rest of the year, too. It's modern, comfortable, and ideally situated for exploring the glorious Carmarthenshire coast without spending a fortune. There are 14 rooms at Caban, including spacious family bedrooms (some with bunkbeds), mobility accessible bedrooms, and dog-friendly bedrooms. You can book the room that best suits your needs, though I definitely recommend a sea view room if you can get one. I love this hotel for its location alone. It's ideally situated right next to Pendine Sands, making it perfect for long sunset strolls or even a bracing dip in the sea if you're an outdoor swimmer like me. Plus, with the ocean practically lapping at your doorstep, you'll drift off to sleep to the soothing sound of the waves. You can see our list of the best Welsh beaches here. I have stayed here several times, as it's my go-to when we have a warm spell of weather and the beach is calling. On my most recent spontaneous stay, the weather had tipped over 23 degrees, so I went into immediate 'mini break' mode. I bundled a bag and my obling husband into the car, and off we set. We had booked a sea view room that was fuss-free, bright and airy with splashes of coastal chic in the decor colour palette. There was a cosy double bed, an ensuite bathroom, a TV, and those all-important tea and coffee facilities. I don't know about you, but I generally need a coffee within minutes of waking up, or I'm completely irrational. Another bonus is that after a day of exploring Pendine, it was nice to grab a drink at the hotel bar and sink into deep slumber, knowing this seaside stay wouldn't tip me into my overdraft. To be fair, this isn't a luxury stay; it's frankly an elevated Premier Inn in a prime location that's comfortable, clean, and won't break the bank. If you want a five-star stay with a concierge and a swim-up bar, this is not the hotel you're looking for (said in Obi-Wan Kenobi voice). One of the main highlights is the fully licensed restaurant and bar overlooking the Carmarthen Bay seafront. The relaxed restaurant serves authentic Welsh cuisine using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The reasonable prices are a bonus, and you also don't need to book. The menu has a decent selection of mains, including the Chef's homemade chicken curry, smoked salmon salad, vegetable lasagne, and homemade smoky beef chilli. Prices range from £12.50 to £13, which is a total bargain. Their full-cooked breakfast costs less than £7 for adults and £4 for the kids. If you love sweet treats, the pancakes drizzled with maple syrup are a steal at just £4.00. To be honest, I was tempted to order two plates at that price. After filling up on a budget breakfast, we explored Pendine Beach and the surrounding area. While visiting Pendine Sands, it's worthwhile delving into its racing heritage. Pendine Sands has been associated with land speed records for over a century. Its unique landscape, a natural runway of compacted sand, provided an ideal testing ground for early 20th-century speed trailblazers. By the 1920s, Pendine had become the preferred location for land speed record attempts, where racing limits were stretched to thrilling new levels. In 1924, Sir Malcolm Campbell, a racing icon, brought his Sunbeam 350HP car, Blue Bird, to Pendine. Using the beach as his racetrack, Campbell made history by setting a new world land speed record at 146.16 mph. His insatiable need for speed brought him back the following year, where he shattered his record with an impressive 150.76 mph. These achievements solidified Pendine's status as the ultimate platform for automotive triumph. Not to be outshone, Welsh engineer and driver J. G. Parry-Thomas stepped up to the plate. In 1926, he steered his bespoke car, 'Babs', to a new record of 169.30 mph, demonstrating cutting-edge engineering and fearless driving. Sadly, Parry-Thomas's quest for speed came to a tragic end in 1927 when he was fatally wounded trying to regain the title. His car, buried in the sands after the accident, was later unearthed and restored. Pendine Sands' legacy fell silent for much of the 20th century until contemporary speed enthusiasts brought it back into the limelight. In 2015, actor Idris Elba paid tribute to the sands' rich history by setting a new 'Flying Mile' record, hitting 180.361 mph in a Bentley Continental GT Speed. His accomplishment was a touching homage to the audacious pioneers who had paved the way nearly a hundred years earlier. Today, Pendine Sands is hailed as a historic centre for motorsport and engineering excellence, and its racing heritage is now preserved in the splendid Museum of Land Speed. We visited the Museum of Land Speed to learn more about Pendine's history. I know shockingly little about motorsports and wanted to get up to speed. Is Jenson Button still a thing? I have no idea. The modern museum celebrates the area's illustrious history of land speed record attempts on the renowned sands of Pendine Beach, situated exactly where these historic events took place. Overlooking the beach, the museum is brimming with artefacts, memorabilia, and tales of the incredible speed achievements made along this iconic stretch of coast. A standout feature of the museum is its collection of vehicles that have shattered land speed records on Pendine Beach throughout the years. We wandered around engineering wonders such as Sir Malcolm Campbell's iconic "Blue Bird" and John Godfrey Parry-Thomas's "Babs," gaining insight into the technological advancements that drove these machines to break speed barriers. Interactive displays also offered a deep dive into the lives and legacies of these trailblazing speedsters, and I came away a little more educated and appreciative of this thrilling sport. Pendine also offers more than its sandy shores. It's also the starting point for the Wales Coast Path, an 870-mile trek skirting the nation's coastline. The path near Pendine features epic clifftop vistas and wildlife. Heading west, you'll reach the scenic cove of Amroth, while the eastward path offers expansive views of the Gower Peninsula and Carmarthen Bay. With its firm sand and dog-friendly policy during the off-season, the expansive Pendine Sands is a perfect spot for a lengthy beach stroll in Wales. The Wales Coast Path website suggests a route starting at the Augmented Reality panel in front of the 'Tea by the Sea' cafe. Take the steep steps up to Gillman Point following the Wales Coast Path. The breathtaking views over Morfa Bychan are worth every bit of the climb! You can choose to return the same way. Fancy going further? Continue to the small beach at Morfa Bychan and turn right onto a signposted track that leads uphill. At the fork in the track, turn right and head towards the B4314 road back to Pendine village. During our visit, we plodded along the seven miles of firm golden sands, tracing the shoreline with its lapping waves and then popping to Cambrian Ice Cream for a lush ice cream with a sea view. Perfection. In recent years, the Pendine resort has seen a multi-million-pound regeneration. Completed projects include a 500m traffic-free promenade providing easy access to the beach and a beach-facing commercial centre (Parry Thomas Centre) housing businesses ranging from kayak hire and coffee shops to an Asian fusion restaurant. I really love this part of Wales, and I think it's hugely underrated. Most people head for the popular tourist hotspots of Rhossili Bay or Tenby, but Pendine is absolutely worth a stop, especially if you're looking for a budget minibreak this summer. Travel tips for Pendine and Carmarthenshire Planning a trip to Pendine and Carmarthenshire? Here are some top tips to ensure your journey goes off without a hitch: Hotel: Book your stay at Caban Pendine here. You can also check out a range of Carmarthenshire hotels, B&Bs and camping on and Airbnb. Parking: A large car park conveniently located next to Pendine Sands provides easy access to the hotel, beach and the village. Parking tends to be more readily available during the off-peak season, but it can get busy during the height of summer. Beach access for dogs: Dogs are allowed on most parts of Pendine Sands during the autumn and winter. However, restrictions are in place between the slipways from May to the end of September, so check the signage if you're visiting in the summer. Wales Coast Path: The coastal trail around Pendine features breathtaking clifftop vistas and is well-marked. Wear robust footwear, particularly after rainfall, as some parts can become muddy. Nearby facilities: Public lavatories are near the beach, and the village boasts several cafes and small shops within a short stroll. These are ideal for warming up after a brisk day outdoors. Military firing range: Portions of Pendine Sands are occasionally utilised as a Ministry of Defence firing range, which may restrict access. Always check for any notices or limitations before setting off.
