Fact checking Fox News about crime rates and migration in Ireland
In the TV piece, Fox alleged that Dublin has gone from being one of the safest cities in Europe in 2003, to one of the most dangerous in 2024.
To support this claim, Fox showed a screenshot of an article published in 2024 by the Irish newspaper Sunday World titled "Dublin ranks among the top ten most dangerous major cities in Europe, survey claims."
However, when investigating the claim, EuroVerify found that the article uses data sourced from a survey carried out by online betting platform the OLBG (Online Betting Guide).
"The main reason why this research was conducted was to reveal the best cities in Europe for nightlife, and as part of the study, safety scores for each city were analysed", a spokesperson for the OLBG told EuroVerify.
The reliability of the survey is questionable given that OLBG sourced its data from Numbeo, a platform which relies on crowd-sourced data and warns there is no "assurance that any statement on the website is correct or precise."
Meanwhile, the Global Peace Index, which is produced by the Australian-based NGO, the Institute for Economics & Peace, has consistently ranked Ireland as one of the safest countries in the world, placing it in second position in 2025.
Rising crime in Ireland
During the piece, the channel aired two graphs side by side on screen — on the left one showing rising immigration in Ireland, while the one on the right displayed figures for rising crime — in turn implying that there is a causal link between migration and crime.
Contacted by EuroVerify, Ireland's Department of Justice said that it was not "aware of any credible evidence that would suggest a causal link between immigration and crime in Ireland."
"Over the past 10 years there has been a large increase in the numbers of non-Irish people employed in Ireland. They bring essential skills and experience that are much needed in the current labour market. There has been no corresponding change in crime levels over this period," the spokesperson added.
Ireland experienced unprecedented levels of immigration in the year leading up to April 2024, with a population increase of 98,700, which amounts to positive net migration of 79,300, meaning that more people have been arriving in Ireland, than those leaving.
Fox News also stated that robberies had increased by 18% and violent crime by 10%. However, these selected crime and robbery statistics are misleading because the country's statistics office does not classify crimes under the broad labels of "robbery" and "violent crime."
More specifically, the 18% figure cited by Fox appears to refer to an increase in "robbery, Extortion & Hijacking" from the first quarter of 2023 to the first quarter of 2024, while the 10% figures refer to an increase in crime incidents involving "weapons and explosives offences."
What the segment fails to mention is that other crimes decreased between the first quarter of 2023 and the same period of 2024, with homicide and sexual offences dropping by 8% and 12% respectively.
How disinformation is fuelling hate crimes in Ireland
Over the course of the summer, a spate of brutal attacks predominantly targeting South Asian migrants occurred in Ireland.
"A series of highly publicised, very violent attacks targeting members of Ireland's Indian community have spread fear. A lot of the attacks were initiated by misinformation and disinformation, for instance through lies spread about crime", Teresa Buczkowsa, the CEO of Immigrant Council of Ireland told Euronews.
On 19 July, an Indian man was attacked by a group of men in southwest Dublin, who beat him and accused the man of inappropriate behaviour with children.
While Irish authorities stated that the allegations against him were unfounded, footage of the aftermath of the attack spread online according to Irish broadcast RTE, leading the footage to gain traction as anti-immigration accounts reshared it.
This led the country's Indian embassy to issue a safety warning to its citizens following what it qualified as "an increase in the instances of physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland recently."
"Everything changed after the Dublin riot in 2023, when we saw a huge level of violence erupting in Dublin city centre against migrants and that really kind of was the starting point for the physical violence we are seeing today", said Buczkowsa.
"The shifting narrative we are hearing in politics and false allegations that migrants are raising crime rates are leaking into everyday conversations and opinions, which is a worrying trend", added Buczkowsa.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
5 hours ago
- LeMonde
Gaza: Over 100 humanitarian organizations denounce Israeli rules for aid groups
More than 100 nonprofit groups warned, on Thursday, August 14, that Israel's rules for aid groups working in the Gaza Strip and occupied West Bank will block much-needed relief and replace independent organizations with those that serve Israel's political and military agenda – charges that Israel has denied. A letter signed by organizations including Oxfam, Doctors Without Borders and CARE accused Israel of "weaponizing aid" as people starve in war-torn Gaza and using it as a tool to entrench control. The groups were responding to registration rules announced by Israel in March, which require organizations to hand over full lists of their donors and Palestinian staff for vetting. The groups contend that doing so could endanger their staff and give Israel broad grounds to block aid if groups are deemed to be "delegitimizing" the country or supporting boycotts or divestment. The registration measures were "designed to control independent organizations, silence advocacy, and censor humanitarian reporting," they said. The letter added that the rules violate European data privacy regulations, noting that, in some cases, aid groups have been given only seven days to comply. Israel claims aid groups are being used by Hamas COGAT, the Israeli military body in charge of humanitarian aid to Gaza, denied the letter's claims. It alleged the groups were being used as cover by Hamas to "exploit the aid to strengthen its military capabilities and consolidate its control" in Gaza. "The refusal of some international organizations to provide the information and cooperate with the registration process raises serious concerns about their true intention," it said in a statement on Thursday. "The alleged delay in aid entry (…) occurs only when organizations choose not to meet the basic security requirements intended to prevent Hamas's involvement." Israel has long claimed that aid groups and United Nations agencies issue biased assessments. The majority of aid is unable to enter Gaza The aid groups stressed on Thursday that most of them haven't been able to deliver "a single truck" of life-saving assistance since Israel implemented a blockade in March. A vast majority of aid isn't reaching civilians in Gaza, where tens of thousands have been killed, most of the population has been displaced and famine looms. UN agencies and a small number of aid groups have resumed delivering assistance, but say the number of trucks allowed in remains far from sufficient. Meanwhile, tensions have flared over Israel and the United States backing the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation to serve as the main distributor of aid in the besieged territory. The American contractor, meant to replace the traditional UN-led aid distribution system in Gaza, has faced international condemnation after hundreds of Palestinians were killed while trying to get food near its distribution sites. Life-saving supplies stuck at border crossings Israel has pressed UN agencies to accept military escorts to deliver goods into Gaza, a demand the agencies have largely rejected, citing their commitment to neutrality. The standoff has been the source of competing claims: Israel maintains it allows aid into Gaza that adheres to its rules, while aid groups that have long operated in Gaza decry the amount of life-saving supplies stuck at border crossings. "Oxfam has over $2.5 million worth of goods that have been rejected from entering Gaza by Israel, especially WASH (water, sanitation and hygiene) items as well as food," said Bushra Khalidi, an aid official with Oxfam in Gaza. Aid groups' "ability to operate may come at the cost of their independence and ability to speak out," she added.
Euronews
11 hours ago
- Euronews
Brazil announces $5.5B in credits for exporters hit by US tariffs
Brazil on Wednesday unveiled a plan to support local companies affected by a 50% tariff imposed by US President Donald Trump on several of the country's exports. Dubbed 'Sovereign Brazil,' the plan launched during a signing ceremony at the Planalto presidential palace in Brasilia provides for a credit lifeline of 30 billion reais ($5.5 billion), among other measures. Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva described the plan, which includes a bill to be sent to Congress, as a first step to help local exporters. 'We cannot be scared, nervous, and anxious when there is a crisis. A crisis is for us to create new things,' Lula said. 'In this case, what is unpleasant is that the reasons given to impose sanctions against Brazil do not exist.' Hours later, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced new sanctions against at least two Brazilian officials, in a move the South American nation's health minister rebuked. Top congressional leaders attended Wednesday's ceremony at the presidential palace in Brasilia, a first in months, in a sign of growing political support for Lula in response to Trump. What does the plan entail? According to local media, Brazil's measures include postponing tax charges for companies affected by US tariffs and providing 5 billion reais ($930,000) in tax credits to small- and medium-sized companies until the end of 2026. It also includes expanding access to insurance against cancelled orders. While public purchases of items that could not be exported to the US are also included, Lula's government is also granting a one-year extension of tax credits for companies that import items so they can produce goods for exportation, a mechanism called 'drawback.' Trump has tied the 50% tariff on many imported Brazilian goods to the judicial situation of his embattled ally, former President Jair Bolsonaro, who is currently under house arrest. Trump claims Bolsonaro is a victim of a political witch hunt, allegations Brazil denies. The Trump administration's accusations and trade tariffs against Brasilia have riled up the country's political climate and led to an increase in support and poll numbers for President Lula da Silva. On Wednesday, Lula once again said he and Trump have never spoken and claimed the American president does not want to negotiate.
LeMonde
20 hours ago
- LeMonde
Historian Françoise Thom: 'Faced with Putin, Europeans are in a position of strength without realizing it'
Recently, the "fog of war" has morphed into the "fog of diplomacy." There is no point trying to untangle the confused impulses of the Trump administration. We must stand on the only solid ground available: Russia's objectives – especially since it is always on that side that the American president ends up. Here, the situation is clear. The Russian economy has been plunging at an accelerated pace. Militarily, Russia is making progress, but not quickly enough to win the race against economic collapse. The Kremlin's men have a long memory. They remember that most of the Russian Empire's territorial expansions were achieved with the complicity and help of one or more foreign powers: in the wake of Prussia and Austria for the partition of Poland in 1772; by coming to an agreement with Turkey to reconquer the Caucasian states in 1920-1921; by relying on Germany for the reconquest of the Baltic States and the annexation of Galicia (the Ribbentrop-Molotov Pact, signed in 1939). So why not turn to Donald Trump to bring Ukraine to heel? Military force is always a last resort in the eyes of those in the Kremlin. They prefer manipulation and subversion. And this is where they excel, thanks to Western ignorance of Russian methods of projecting power, which remain unchanged. In addition to co-opting a foreign accomplice, the second hallmark of Russian expansion is the salami tactic. Russia slices up its victim (as we saw with Ukraine: First Crimea, then the Donbas). Once the first slice is taken, it moves on to the second, then the third. The Russian proposals made to Steve Witkoff [special envoy of the US president, who visited Russia on August 6] illustrate this approach. Vladimir Putin demanded that the United States, as a prerequisite for hypothetical negotiations toward a ceasefire, force the Ukrainians to evacuate the parts of the Donetsk region they still control, which are the strongest fortified lines on the Ukrainian front, in exchange for a symbolic piece of territory in the Sumy region.
