N.S. opposition call government out over withholding environmental racism report
Their comments came after Becky Druhan, minister responsible for the Office of Equity and Anti-Racism Initiatives, told reporters Thursday that government has requested a meeting with the environmental racism panel that created the report to 'discuss with them before sharing any additional information.'
The report was completed by an eight-member panel appointed in June 2023 to look at how racism affects a community's natural environment in Nova Scotia. Environmental racism is a form of systemic racism where environmentally hazardous activities like landfills, trash incinerators, coal plants and toxic waste facilities are set up near Black and racialized communities or Indigenous territories.
The report was delivered to the province about a year ago.
'In this instance, the (panel's) mandate didn't include a public report. The mandate was advice to government. So we want to respect the parameters of that,' Druhan said after a cabinet meeting when asked if she will release the report.
The panel members included community leaders with expertise in subjects such as Mi'kmaw and African Nova Scotian history, law, health and environmental sciences.
'We do know that Nova Scotians want to hear more, and we want to respect the panel and have a conversation with them before we do that,' Druhan said.
Nova Scotia NDP Leader Claudia Chender and Liberal member Derek Mombourquette both said Thursday it's puzzling the province is choosing to withhold this critical information about environmental racism.
'I think they probably don't like what it (the report) says,' Chender said of the provincial government.
'We're talking about a legacy of wrongdoing and harm that this government is now complicit in, because they will not address what it was that came forward' from this panel's work, she added.
The idea for the panel came from the NDP, who proposed it in an amendment to climate change legislation that was passed in the fall of 2023. Chender said it 'was no one's understanding' that this panel's work would be kept from the public.
'That report came from an amendment that was put forward by our caucus that specifically called for the establishment of a panel that would provide recommendations to the province for redress,' Chender said. 'It didn't say that it would privately provide some things that the government might consider, and then not tell anyone about it. That doesn't make any sense.'
Mombourquette agreed, saying it's 'really shameful' that the report has not yet been made public to Nova Scotians, adding that he represents a constituency that has faced environmental racism in the form of the Sydney tar ponds and coke oven sites in Cape Breton.
'I think that the government should release it immediately. I don't buy this argument that there needs to be a meeting with the panel beforehand. Release the report, let Nova Scotians see what's in it,' he said.
When asked if he thinks the report ought to be made public, Premier Tim Houston did not directly answer.
'We're using that to formulate public policy. It's having a positive impact. There is a meeting being organized with a number of ministers and the panellists to talk about… the ways forward,' he said after Thursday's cabinet meeting.
When pressed on if he is of the opinion that it should be public, he said 'we'll have a discussion with the panels. I think the most important thing is that the work is actually used.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 11, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
2 hours ago
Poilievre's byelection win sets the table for his return to Parliament this fall
After a summer of rodeos, dinosaurs and door-knocking, Pierre Poilievre is now officially heading back to Ottawa as a Conservative member of Parliament for Alberta. The Tory leader will represent the sprawling rural riding of Battle River–Crowfoot, in the province's eastern region, after winning a byelection on Monday. Getting to know the people in this region has been the privilege of my life, Poilievre told a crowd at a victory party in Camrose, Alta., on Monday night. In fact, I've had a hell of a lot of fun. Poilievre spent weeks this summer meeting constituents, attending events and stopping by local businesses in his new riding. It was precisely the kind of boots-on-the-ground campaign he ran in 2004 when he became an MP for the first time in the Ontario riding of Carleton. It's also exactly the kind of local campaign he could not run in Carleton in the spring, when his leader's tour criss-crossed the country for 36 days, before holding a final rally in his home riding the night before the April 28 election. Poilievre lost to Liberal MP Bruce Fanjoy, who had spent more than two years campaigning against him in the Ottawa-area riding. Poilievre's return to the House of Commons in one of the safest Conservative seats in Canada was all but guaranteed, observers said. Now Poilievre's attention will turn to two things: the fall sitting of Parliament and his upcoming leadership review. WATCH | Poilievre projected to win byelection, return as MP: Top priorities When Parliament resumes on Sept. 15, Poilievre will square off with Prime Minister Mark Carney in the House of Commons for the first time. The [Conservative] Party and the country have moved past the election campaign. We're now in a new government. He's going to have to show that he's really good at holding their feet to the fire, said Amanda Galbraith, a Conservative strategist and partner at Oyster Group. Poilievre has already signalled some of what he plans to focus on. At a news conference on Aug. 7, he said he will introduce a bill in the House of Commons called the Canadian Sovereignty Act (new window) to speed up the development of major projects. He also said Conservatives were calling on Carney to begin construction of at least two pipeline projects, a new natural gas liquefaction project and a road to the Ring of Fire in Ontario by March 14. WATCH | Conservative leader celebrates byelection result in Battle River–Crowfoot: With Poilievre once again leading the party in Parliament, Andrew Scheer will return to his Opposition House leader duties. There will be changes to the party's front bench, too. The Conservative leader pledged in the spring to shuffle his shadow cabinet — a group of 74 MPs appointed to critic or leadership roles in the House of Commons — this fall. We've seen which ministers are performing, which ministers are not, where the weaknesses lie in that government. So they'll realign, said Galbraith. Poilievre's former campaign manager, Jenni Byrne, said in a recent podcast interview that the fall House sitting is when the real next chapter starts for the party. The Conservatives will focus on issues like immigration and crime, said Byrne, who noted in the interview that she's still involved as an adviser to Poilievre and takes calls on a daily basis. The cost of living will likely remain a top priority for the Opposition, particularly as trade and U.S. tariffs command the government's attention. Leadership review to start 2026 Ginny Roth, a partner at Crestview Strategy and a Conservative commentator, said Poilievre has been successful as Opposition leader in pointing out the places where Canadians are struggling and where the government is failing. The Conservative Party will hold a national convention in Calgary in late January. The party's constitution stipulates that any leader who has just lost an election will face a vote on their future. Running a byelection campaign all summer has meant Poilievre has not been travelling the country. Enlarge image (new window) Poilievre meets a supporter during a break at a Battle River-Crowfoot byelection candidate forum in Camrose, Alta., on July 29. Photo: The Canadian Press / Jason Franson The rallies that were a fixture of his leadership since 2022 have been scrapped in favour of door-knocking. And while that's likely given him a good window into the mindset of Conservative voters during the Carney government's post-election honeymoon, it's also meant he has not been in the national spotlight. While that might feel frustrating when you come off this high-energy election, I think it was the right approach. Lie low, get back to basics, Roth said. The Tory caucus has been firm in its support for Poilievre, and it is widely expected that he will win the leadership review — not least because no one has so far publicly challenged his leadership. There's a lot to be excited about and I think Conservative members will recognize that in the leadership review, Roth said. Galbraith said things can shift quickly, and Poilievre can't take the leadership review for granted. For example, he was going to be prime minister until he wasn't going to be prime minister, right? she said. With files from CBC News
Vancouver Sun
3 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
Separatism and internal dissent fizzle as Poilievre coasts to victory in rural Alberta
OTTAWA — Embattled Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre bought himself some breathing room with a resounding byelection win in rural Alberta on Monday. Poilievre had just over 80 per cent of the vote, with 99 per cent of ballots counted in Battle River —Crowfoot , holding a 70 point edge over independent challenger Bonnie Critchley . Conservative Damien Kurek won 83 per cent of the vote in April's federal election, a mark Poilievre will just miss. Poilievre, who lost his long-held Ottawa area seat in April, said in an emotional victory speech that he drew inspiration from the rural Alberta community's true grit. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. 'Getting to know the people in this region has been the privilege of my life. In fact, I've had a hell of a lot of fun,' Poilievre told supporters in Camrose, Alta. 'You don't give up, so I don't give up,' said Poilievre, reflecting on the myriad hardscrabble stories he heard from members of the community on the campaign trail. He added that the experience of running in a byelection so soon after losing in the general forced him to re-learn 'humility and hard work.' Battle River —Crowfoot resident Lance Neilson told the National Post he was taken aback by the throng of voters who showed up to support Poilievre on election day. 'That was the longest line I've ever been in to vote here,' said Neilson. 'I don't think other parts of Canada understand what this represents to us. No one is leaving this to chance.' Turnout was a robust 59 per cent, with 50,434 of 85,736 registered voters showing up at the polls. Poilievre spent much of the campaign taking aim at the Liberal government's controversial electric vehicle mandate , calling the planned phase out of gas-powered vehicles akin to 'banning rural life.' The Liberal vote was down by more than half versus April, with Liberal candidate Darcy Spady at just 4.3 per cent as of Tuesday morning. NDP candidate Katherine Swampy also had a rough night, barely breaking the 2 per cent mark. In the end, the much ballyhooed Longest Ballot Committee failed to make much of a dent in the proceedings, with none of the 201 candidates sponsored by the protest group winning more than a handful of votes. Elections Canada announced last month that write-in ballots would be used in the byelection, as a result of the historically large number of candidates entered into the race. Just to be on the safe side, the Conservative campaign set up signs instructing voters on how to fill in 'Pierre Poilievre' on their ballots outside of voting stations. There's also little evidence that the rising tide of Alberta separatism had much of an impact in the race. The United Party's Grant Abraham, who called ahead of the byelection for a referendum on Alberta's independence , finished with just 1.5 per cent of the vote. Libertarian Michael Harris, who also supports a referendum, won a paltry 0.2 per cent. Poilievre called himself a 'Canadian patriot' in a July interview with the CBC and said Alberta should stay in Canada even if the Liberals continue to hold onto power in Ottawa. He's now set to resume his role as Leader of the Official Opposition in the House of Commons, facing off directly against Prime Minister Mark Carney when the House meets again next month. Yet even with his strong showing in the byelection, Poilievre has a long road back to relevance after losing the April election to Carney's Liberals. Polls show him losing ground to Carney on a number of key issues since the election. Poilievre will face his next major test at his Conservative leadership review, set for late January in Calgary. National Post rmohamed@ Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .
National Observer
3 hours ago
- National Observer
Poilievre still wants to run against Trudeau
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre once again has a seat in the House of Commons after losing his long-held Ottawa riding in April's federal election. Little surprise there. But the four-month hiatus should have been plenty of time for him to chart a new offensive against Prime Minister Mark Carney's Liberal minority government. That would require imagination Poilievre has never exhibited. Instead, just days before the byelection, Poilievre announced plans to mount a campaign against the last vestiges of the Trudeau government's climate policy — the zero-emission vehicle mandate. Yawn. It's a predictable course for Poilievre, who crafted his unsuccessful election campaign against the consumer carbon tax and shamelessly shills for the oil and gas industry. Polls suggest attacking the vehicle mandate will be a huge hit with his supporters, 85 per cent of whom believe the goal is unrealistic. The poll indicates it will appeal to non-Conservatives as well — 68 per cent of Canadians overall think the goal is unrealistic. They might be right. The mandate, set to take effect next year, will require 20 per cent of all light-duty vehicles sold in Canada to be ZEVs. The percentage will rise yearly until it reaches 100 per cent by 2035. Even reaching the first-year target would take some doing; the adoption rate of ZEVs in 2024 was only 15.4 per cent. Given that federal incentives to help consumers offset the price of EVs are on pause and many oil-producing provinces like Alberta and Saskatchewan wouldn't dream of offering any help, the uptake has slowed. Carney is under pressure from automakers to repeal the mandate and while he hasn't yet expressly said so, there are signs he may cave to their demands. The auto industry is already struggling under US tariffs and Carney may well decide the mandate would unreasonably add to their woes. Despite his climate background, which earned him support from the Liberals' climate wing, Carney has so far not hesitated to throw climate policy under the bus to keep his party ahead in the polls. Before the election, he kneecapped Poilievre's campaign by promising to kill the consumer carbon tax and made good on that pledge the day he took office. Poilievre claims credit for the move, but most Canadians credit the man who pulled the lever, not the one who started the fight. Since then he's indicated a willingness to backtrack on plans to impose an industrial emissions cap, another Trudeau initiative that was unpopular with business. Poilievre is back and plans to mount a campaign against the EV mandate, one of the last vestiges of the Trudeau government's climate policy. Shows once again, he's stuck in the past along with fossil fuel companies whose days are numbered. Carney's pragmatic approach has disappointed many of those who voted for him hoping he would expedite Canada's efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. But his popularity remains strong with the latest Leger poll finding 54 per cent of Canadians approve of the Carney-led government. With the NDP in the wilderness and the Green Party down to only one seat, voters who care about climate change appear to have little choice but to back Carney, who at least gives lip service to climate policy. That's exactly why Poilievre's most recent gambit to fight the EV mandate is weak from a tactical point of view. If Carney believes the vehicle mandate is politically unpalatable, there is every indication he will kill it, or at least push implementation so far into the future that the grumbling will stop. At the same time, he can offer carrots, instead of a stick, to increase ZEV purchases by reupping the federal incentive program. In June, Federal Environment Minister Julie Dabrusin said Ottawa is working to bring back the rebate program. If all those chips fall into place, Poilievre's anti-EV campaign will be over before it has a chance to begin. Poilievre's political persona is centred on his considerable attack-dog abilities — which served him well against former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who had worn out his welcome with the electorate. The approach isn't working so well now. With our economy under attack in a bitter trade war with the US, Canadians continue to yearn for leadership from someone with a steady hand, fresh ideas and foresight. That type of leader would look to Norway where the share of electric car sales is getting close to 100 per cent and China, a more populous country which is at the half-way mark. Closer to home, a forward-looking leader would pay attention to Ford, which just built a giant US factory to produce lithium iron phosphate (LFP) battery cells to power lower-cost EVs. We don't yet know how hard Carney will go to bat for EV adoption in Canada. Regardless, in the minds of the majority of Canadians, the leader for our immediate future is Carney, not Poilievre. Poilievre is a wrecker who is good at tearing ideas down. But he'll never be a builder, because he's stuck in the past along with fossil fuel companies whose days are numbered. When it comes to motor vehicles, ZEVs are the future, whether that future comes in the next 10 years or takes a little longer. Carney is still enjoying a honeymoon period and he's reaping credit for creating sound policies of his own and killing unpopular policies from his predecessor. The transition to ZEVs presents an opportunity for him to do both. Poilievre, who lost his mojo the day Trudeau left office, will keep attacking no matter what. Back in the House of Commons, he can resume swinging his fists at any target in sight — but with Trudeau gone the punches just aren't landing.
