Parents who advised daughter against chemotherapy warned over inquest behaviour
Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani, a prominent online conspiracy theorist and her father, Dr Faramarz Shemirani, who is 'sympathetic' to his ex-wife's views, believe medical professionals are to blame for their daughter's death.
Coroner Catherine Wood, presiding over the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroner's Court in Maidstone, left the court due to the behaviour of Miss Shemirani's parents on Tuesday afternoon.
The inquest, which was originally scheduled to conclude on Wednesday, had been extended as the evidence and questioning of witnesses had taken longer than anticipated.
On Tuesday, Mrs Shemirani, who was struck off as a nurse in 2021 after spreading harmful misinformation about Covid-19, was cross-examined by Dr Shemirani.
Questioning broke down when Dr Shemirani, who is understood to have a PhD in computational fluid dynamics, tried to ask his ex-wife's opinion of medical evidence which she would then try to answer, despite warnings from the coroner.
'Mrs Shemirani, I've told you not to speak, I'll find you in contempt if you keep on speaking now,' the coroner said.
'Confine (yourself) to asking questions of this witness as a witness of fact,' she told Dr Shemirani.
As Dr Shemirani argued back through his video-link, the coroner said: 'Dr Shemirani, challenge me by judicial review later' before trying to move on.
'Of course I will, of course I will,' he replied.
Later, Dr Shemirani once again tried to ask questions which had already been ruled irrelevant by the coroner.
'I'm going to rise for a few minutes because I'm finding it incredibly difficult to keep you on track,' said Ms Wood.
Dr Shemirani continued to speak until the coroner shouted 'Dr Shemirani, listen'.
'Your behaviour has been bordering on contemptuous to the court – when I make a ruling on something you cannot come back,' she added.
Mrs Shemirani also accused osteopath Nick Gosset of lying under oath earlier in the inquest.
Mr Gosset treated Miss Shemirani the day she collapsed and said she had appeared to be in the 'last stages of a very difficult disease'.
He told the court that when he inspected her, he could feel lumps in her right shoulder going all the way up into her neck, which he identified as lymphoid mass and that he 'had never seen anything like it' in 43 years of practice.
Mr Gosset told the court: 'It was obvious to me that I was not the right person to be helping her, normally you see a patient like that, you would refer her (to a GP).
'Any referral was refused – when I suggested that the proper avenue of approach was through a normal, medical channel she dismissed it.
On Tuesday, Paloma's mother said 'his statement under oath is completely opposed with the truth' and has argued her daughter was healthy the day she collapsed.
The inquest continues on Wednesday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
3 minutes ago
- BBC News
Mum 'kept interrupting paramedics saving daughter', inquest told
The mother of a woman who died after refusing chemotherapy for cancer "presented a challenge" to paramedics trying to save her daughter's life after she suffered a heart attack, an inquest has Shemirani, 23, from Uckfield, East Sussex, was diagnosed at Maidstone Hospital with non-Hodgkin lymphoma in December 2023. She died seven months later after seeking only "alternative" treatment. Her mother Kate Shemirani, a former nurse who rose to prominence on social media sharing Covid conspiracy theories, calls chemotherapy toxic and dangerous, the inquest was told. 'We had to be quite firm' When Paloma collapsed at her mother's home in July 2024, paramedic Robin Bass said Kate "presented a challenge as she kept interrupting while the crews were carrying out care".He told the coroner that Kate mentioned a mass on her daughter's chest. When Mr Bass told colleagues it could be cancer, he said Kate denied it was. Paloma's mother, who was struck off as a nurse for promoting misinformation about the pandemic, instead said she was choking on food. Paloma, a Cambridge graduate, died at the Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton after suffering a heart attack caused by her tumour. Dr Peter Anderson, who saw her when paramedics brought her in, previously told the inquest a large mass in her chest and neck, which was compressing her airways and affecting major blood vessels, could have caused the cardiac arrest. A safeguarding report was later requested over concerns about Paloma's refusal of cancer treatment and the "possible influence" of her mother. Paloma's twin brother Gabriel, who blames her death on his mother's conspiratorial beliefs, asked if she had made the paramedics' job more difficult that night. Mr Bass said: "I believe we had to be quite firm at some points… had to ask for quiet while administering care to your sister."The coroner previously heard that Ms Shemirani had called a friend when Paloma collapsed, only dialling 999 after her friend arrived at the house. Paloma's brother Gabriel asked another paramedic who treated Paloma at the inquest if his mum's delay in calling an ambulance affected her chance of survival."It's difficult to say," said Karen Clarke, Secamb critical care paramedic. "You always recommend someone calling 999 straight away."Gabriel asked Ms Clarke if she would have called a friend first, she replied she would have called an ambulance first. Dr Arundoya Mohan, a consultant haematologist at Maidstone Hospital, told Paloma in December 2023 she had an 80% chance of recovery if she had chemotherapy. Ms Shemirani blames doctors for her daughter's death.
Daily Record
4 hours ago
- Daily Record
First day at school for Lanarkshire youngster who was Scotland's youngest Covid patient
Peyton Maguire was just three weeks old when she was diagnosed with Covid in the early days of the pandemic - but has bounced back and is now heading for Primary One A Lanarkshire youngster who was thought to be Scotland's youngest Covid patient when she was just three weeks old is all set to start school. Five-year-old Peyton Maguire is among the thousands of new starts who will be heading to classrooms across North and South Lanarkshire for the first time on Thursday when she starts in Primary One at Aitkenhead Primary in her home town of Uddingston. She weighed less than four pounds when she was born two months prematurely by section at University Hospital Wishaw in the first week of the Covid lockdown in March 2020, and the tiny newborn then had to spend time in isolation until finally testing negative and being able to go home for the first time the following month. Mum Tracy, now 32, and dad AJ, 34 were shocked when NHS Lanarkshire staff first diagnosed their three-week-old baby with the virus in April 2020 – and her story made headlines around the world in the earliest days of the pandemic, with Tracy now saying: 'The head teacher has joked that they're about to have a celebrity join the school.' Peyton had been delivered early after Tracy was diagnosed with pre-eclampsia, and was being cared for in an incubator in Wishaw's neonatal unit when her parents were told the alarming news that she'd tested positive for Covid-19. Her mum recalled: 'We were told we'd have to stay away from Peyton for 14 days and isolate at home but I pleaded not to be apart from my baby for that long. The staff kindly agreed I could to isolate with her in the hospital while AJ stayed at home. 'Watching the staff at work was incredible. They put their lives at risk to make sure my baby was getting fed and cuddled. Even wearing their PPE, they were determined to hold her. 'I found the same compassion when I had my second daughter, Harley, who's nearly two now. She was also premature and needed extra care. Peyton was able to visit me and Harley in the maternity unit and the staff were very happy to see her again.' Boxing coaches Tracy and AJ are grateful that Peyton's expert care during the traumatic period ensured she has had no long-term health problems, with Tracy adding: 'She's great except for a touch of asthma – it's a real tribute to the staff who looked after her. I was so moved when I found out some of them had to live away from their own children during the pandemic but were caring for my baby.' Peyton bounced back after her weeks of treatment at Wishaw General. The five-year-old loves fashion, gymnastics and drawing and can't wait to begin classes at Aitkenhead Primary, where she is all set with a schoolbag in her favourite colour of pink. Tracy said: 'We've been in so many papers, magazines and TV shows, but the most worthwhile thing her story has led us to do was taking part in a conference for neonatal nurses, where I shared my experience. 'I was also amazed when a woman tapped me on the shoulder in the street and told me she'd read my story and it was the only reason she'd felt confident to go to hospital to have her baby during the pandemic.' 'It's great to hear how she's doing and hard to believe that tiny, vulnerable baby is now a lively five-year-old who's about to go to school.'
Scottish Sun
6 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Tennis legend Monica Seles, 51, diagnosed with rare muscle-weakening condition as she bravely opens up
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) TENNIS great Monica Seles revealed she has been diagnosed with a rare muscle-weakening condition. Seles, 51, started experiencing double vision and extremely depleted strength in her arms and legs in 2019. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Monica Seles was diagnosed with a rare neuromuscular autoimmune disease Credit: Getty 2 The tennis star won nine Grand Slams and was the dominant player before her tragic stabbing Credit: AP A long string of tests and scans - delayed by the Covid pandemic - ruled out brain tumours and motor neurone disease. The nine-time Grand Slam champion was eventually diagnosed with myasthenia gravis (MG) in 2022. Now Seles has gone public on neuromuscular autoimmune disease - which currently has no cure - and will raise awareness for the condition with an event around this month's US Open. MG affects most of the body but particularly the muscles that control the eyes - although symptoms can vary from day to day. Approximately 15-20 people per 100,000 - or 0.015 per cent of the population - are affected by MG, which sees the immune system attack the neuromuscular junction where nerves and muscles communicate. Seles told AP: "I would be playing [tennis] with some kids or family members, and I would miss a ball. "I was like, 'Yeah, I see two balls.' "These are obviously symptoms that you can't ignore. "It took me quite some time to really absorb it, speak openly about it, because it's a difficult one. "It affects my day-to-day life quite a lot." BBC presenter taken to hospital after 'real wake up call' working at Wimbledon and putting off medical care Seles won seven of her nine Grand Slams by the age of 18. That included reaching eight Major finals in a row - winning seven - before she was tragically stabbed in April 1993 on court during a match in Hamburg by a fixated fan of Steffi Graf. The Yugoslavia-born star - who switched nationality to USA - returned in 1995 after a two-year absence. She reached the US Open final in her first Major since the stabbing then won the 1996 Australian Open, her ninth and final Grand Slam title. The lefty, who played with a double-handed forehand and backhand, officialy retired in 2008 five years after her final competitive match. Now living in Florida, she told The Athletic about her MG diagnosis: 'I thought, 'OK, just push through it.' "But a couple of instances happened when — on court and in daily life — I realised there was something going on. What is myasthenia gravis? MYASTHENIA GRAVIS is a rare long-term condition that causes muscle weakness. It typically has phases when it improves and phases when it gets worse. MG usually affects most of the body, spreading from the eyes and face to other areas over weeks, months or years. But for some people with myasthenia gravis, only the eyes are affected. It is common for people to have "flare-ups", where symptoms are very troublesome, followed by periods of remission, where symptoms improve. It's an autoimmune condition, which means it's the result of the immune system (the body's natural defence against infection) mistakenly attacking a healthy part of the body. In myasthenia gravis, the immune system damages the communication system between the nerves and muscles, making the muscles weak and easily tired. It can affect people of any age, typically starting in women under 40 and men over 60. Common symptoms of myasthenia gravis include: droopy eyelids double vision difficulty making facial expressions problems chewing and difficulty swallowing slurred speech weak arms, legs or neck shortness of breath and occasionally serious breathing difficulties The symptoms tend to get worse when you're tired. Many people find they're worse towards the end of the day, and better the next morning after getting some sleep. Source: NHS "After coming out of my former country to the IMG Academy, I had to totally reset. "When I became No1, it was a huge reset because everybody treats you differently. "Then obviously when I got stabbed, that was a huge reset. And then when I was diagnosed, it was a huge reset. "The day-to-day part of managing it, depending on my symptoms, is really adjusting, you know. I think anybody else who has Myasthenia Gravis knows it's a continuous adjustment. "After my stabbing, I had to deal with that internally for quite a few years to process it and my MG diagnosis was kind of very similar. "I had to understand my new normal of day-to-day life, what I can do work-wise and different things."
