Court hears 13-year-old girl with history of drug use and sexual exploitation needs to switch care unit
A 13-year-old girl who has had more than 200 incidents involving gardaí along with a history of drug use, sexual exploitation and severe neglect is to be moved from her secure-care unit for her own safety.
On Thursday, against the recommendations of her advocate, the High Court ordered the girl be moved due to 'very significant issues' with another child in her current unit.
Mr Justice John Jordan, acknowledging concerns of her guardian ad litem – an independent person appointed by the court to act as the child's voice – said
Tusla, the Child and Family Agency
, was 'between a rock and hard place in terms of resolving a situation which has to be resolved'.
The deteriorating situation of the girl, who was detained in secure care, also known as special care, earlier this year, has been reported to the court regularly since the admission of another child to the same unit.
READ MORE
The two children, who are from the same locality, have a 'fractious' relationship.
The girl has said she 'should not have to live' with the other child.
William O'Rourke, assistant national director of alternative care in Tusla, said on Thursday the issues between the children were 'becoming more toxic, more fractious', and 'a move should occur as soon as possible'.
Margaret Fennell, the girl's guardian ad litem, described her as 'a very vulnerable... young girl who wants to be part of something. She is lost.' Until recently she had not engaged 'in any form of therapeutic service, nor wanted to'.
'She has over 200 incidents with
An Garda Síochána
... [there was] quite a significant incident [that] has gone to the DPP [
Director of Public Prosecutions
] in relation to a serious assault.'
Since coming into special care earlier this year she had built positive therapeutic relationships in her current placement.
This was 'amazing' and 'should be nurtured', said Ms Fennell. 'I still do believe it should not be [the girl in her charge] that is moving.'
Mr Justice Jordan noted that the girl came from 'an extraordinarily dysfunctional background'. When she first spent time in special care, at age 11, she had already experienced 'drug-taking problems, suicide attempts... serious sexual exploitation, despite her young age'. At the time, both her parents were in prison.
'[The girl] has had very few breaks in life and it is the position she was making improvements in [her unit which] appear to have come to a halt or to have slowed.' .
There was 'no doubt' it was necessary to separate the two children.
Each of the three special care centres was 'too small', he noted, to effectively keep children who had a negative impact upon each other apart.
The complexity of separating them lay in the fact that all 16 available special care beds are occupied, meaning a child currently staying in the unit to which the girl will move must also be moved to make space for her.
Tusla told the court it had identified a child in the second unit who would benefit from swapping places with the girl, due to 'escalating tensions and difficulties' they were involved in.
That child's parents agreed 'absolutely' with the move if the child was 'in danger'.
Making orders to arrange both moves, the judge said there were 'no guarantees' they would be without problems. He listed the three children's cases for review in coming weeks.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Michael Gaine murder: Ex-partner of suspect Michael Kelley says he became ‘very unstable' after 9/11 attacks
A former partner of the American man questioned about the murder of Kerry farmer Michael Gaine expressed serious concern about his mental wellbeing and increasing paranoia after the 9/11 attacks in the US. American woman Alicia Snow was involved in a relationship with Michael Kelley in the late 1990s and early 2000s and has two children with him. Ms Snow told The Irish Times that Mr Kelley (53) suddenly became 'very unstable' and increasingly paranoid after the September 11th, 2001 al-Qaeda attacks and began stockpiling supplies during their time together in Maine. She described the change in him as 'a total reversal to me'. Within three months, Ms Snow and her children moved out of the home they shared near the town of Swanville. They later separated and became estranged. READ MORE Mr Kelley, who moved to Kerry from the north-eastern US state of Maine about seven years ago, was arrested on May 18th last by gardaí investigating the murder of Mr Gaine (56) before being released without charge. Kerry farmer Michael Gaine who went missing in March and whose partial remains were discovered on his farmland last month. Mr Gaine's dismembered body was found the previous day in slurry spread on fields and in a slurry tank at his isolated farmyard 6km from Kenmare. He was last seen alive in a local shop in the town on March 20th. Mr Kelley lived and worked on Mr Gaine's farm. He has denied any role in his murder, claiming he is being framed by organised criminals. Gardaí investigating the murder of Mr Gaine travelled to Maine last weekend to interview Ms Snow and to search for any clues to explain what might have happened to the farmer. Ms Snow described her former partner as 'hardworking' and 'responsible' during their time living together on his mother's farm in Swanville. Mr Kelley worked as a farmhand on a nearby farm among a variety of other jobs, including as a cook and a butcher in a local shop. She said her then partner's increasing paranoia after the 2001 attacks 'surprised the hell out of me'. Alicia Snow, a nurse based in Maine in the United States and the former partner of Michael Kelley. Photograph via Ms Snow's website. Ms Snow, who is a qualified nurse, said Mr Kelley could be very sweet and was notably loyal but that he went through 'bouts of intense paranoia'. Others who knew him in Waldo County, where he lived in Maine, recalled his interest in conspiracy theories, including his fears about the Ku Klux Klan, the white supremacist group, and other groups of interest to conspiracy theorists. Mr Kelley previously claimed to The Irish Times that he fled to and applied for asylum in Ireland as he feared he was being targeted by the KKK. Ms Snow last spoke to Mr Kelley about 10 years ago when he came to her door saying a group called the Heaven and Earth Society were pursuing him. The Irish Times put her concerns about Mr Kelley to him in an interview this week in Tralee, where he is now living. Asked about his former partner's belief that he may struggle with mental illness, Mr Kelley said he would leave people to make up their own minds. 'People need to judge for themselves; they need to judge from their own observations,' he said. Michael Kelley photographed in Tralee this week. Photo: Domnick Walsh © Eye Focus Ltd Asked about what those in Waldo County had said about his beliefs in conspiracy theories, Mr Kelley said people should decide for themselves. 'People need to judge for themselves – that's the blanket answer for all these things people are saying about me,' he said. Following the couple's separation, Mr Kelley and Ms Snow were involved in a legal dispute over rights of access to their children. A US judge concluded that Mr Kelley made 'false accusations' claiming Ms Snow was 'a witch' and 'practises witchcraft on their children'. The judge also found that Mr Kelley's ability to determine fact from fiction was 'questionable'. In his interview with this newspaper, Mr Kelley gave more detail about how he came to work on Mr Gaine's farm. He declined to answer any questions about the Garda investigation into the murder or his relationship with Mr Gaine as he said it might affect the investigation. He said Mr Gaine offered him board and lodging at the old Gaine family farmhouse in return for doing farm work. Members of the Garda forensic team carrying out a search at the farm of Michael Gaine (56) near Kenmare last month. Photo: Domnick Walsh © Eye Focus Ltd The American said he began working for Mr Gaine after he approached a number of farmers in the Kenmare area on New Year's Day 2022 looking for farm work, having spent more than a year living in a camp at Scully's Wood near Dromquinna outside Kenmare. He said he moved to Kerry after he applied for asylum in Dublin and was transferred to Killarney where he lived with other men in accommodation provided by the State's International Protection Accommodation Service. He later left there and camped in Killarney National Park before he was ordered to leave by National Parks and Wildlife Service rangers. Mr Kelley did a variety of casual jobs in Co Kerry, harvesting seaweed in Kenmare Bay for a man from Glenbeigh and cutting grass at an adventure centre at Blackwater. Before moving to Mr Gaine's old farmhouse, Mr Kelley set up a camp at Scully's Wood and bought a solar panel and battery to charge his headlamp and mobile phone. He spent much of the Covid pandemic living in the wood before deciding on New Year's Day 2022 to look for farm work. He said he convinced Mr Gaine to give him a job after he repaired Mr Gaine's quad bike and he moved into the old farmhouse. Michael Kelley photographed in Tralee Town Park this week. Photo: Domnick Walsh © Eye Focus Ltd Mr Gaine paid him €100 a week to help with the farm work, including repairing machinery, bringing fodder to cattle and fetching sheep from the mountain. He brought him into Kenmare once a week to buy supplies. Mr Kelley said the money was 'more than enough for me to live on and I was actually able to save money'. The old farmhouse had no electricity but it had a stove. He described it as 'a serious upgrade on living in the woods'.
Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
GAA spygate: looking for that 5% on the opposition to get you over the line
Business as usual. When it was put to Jim McGuinness that a spy had been infamously outed at Kerry's training before the 2014 All-Ireland final, his response was matter-of-fact: It happens to everyone. Everywhere. 'Listen, the bottom line with that is that, espionage is a very strong word to use, but it's going on all the time,' he said at the time, while denying that Patrick Roarty was associated with their camp after the Donegal man was spotted in a Killarney tree observing training. 'We put people out of our own training on Wednesday night and maybe three or four times in the lead in.' Inter-county management has always been steeped in a cloak-and-dagger tradition. The art of preparation is an exercise in sourcing information. In the endless search for an edge, who you know is as important as what you know. A long list of contacts has its currency in this peculiar trade. 'You'd consult a lot of different people depending on who knows a county or the players,' says former Tyrone footballer Ryan McMenamin, who previously managed Fermanagh and coached Cavan. 'How are things going or what are you hearing? I know my time with Cavan and Fermanagh, we had a lot of knowledge on the players with videos and everything. All the video is available in a shared Drive. You'd have that anyway. You are just looking for a sense. 'Ireland is small enough. Everyone has a contact. The phone might buzz after a challenge, any chance we can see that? Who played well? 'You would have a network of former players, friends and coaches you can give a shout.' Most of this is well within the lines. A former team-mate involved in a rival club championship, a casual chat with a GAA-obsessed cousin, a call, a text and a MP4. With the challenge game circuit the way that it is, video exchanging is a routine practice. That has only accelerated in recent years. 'There is a general acceptance of it since Covid,' says McMenamin. 'Andy McEntee created a WhatsApp group for managers to get their hands around it all. There is a behind-the-scenes scene that supporters wouldn't see." 'There is a bit of 'don't give out any of your own secrets but if you want to get along…', so we played challenges and both teams requested no video. 'We're not recording that.' It stops anything from getting out. 'There are conversations among managers all the time. Sometimes you have an agreement around a challenge. No video and no information shared.' In the aftermath of a devastating Ulster final defeat, Armagh boss Kieran McGeeney made it clear they had already started to plan for the group stage. 'Derry are playing well by all accounts in the challenge games,' he said. Did they get access to the footage from those matches? Who knows. Would it have been in their interest? Absolutely. Earlier this month, McGeeney was less willing to discuss how they utilised a free weekend having secured a quarter-final spot before their final group game. When asked if they elected to travel outside the county for a training camp, he was guarded. 'You try do as much as you can each weekend. Some days you travel, it depends if fellas are working. Any time we have had a chance, it depends if the Athletic Grounds is available, all of those things. You try make the most of every weekend you are off. It wouldn't just be the last one.' Each leader has a trusted circle. Before the All-Ireland final last year, Pádraic Joyce revealed the two managers he was closest to were former International Rules team-mate McGeeney and former Sigerson Cup team-mate Jim McGuinness. Kerry boss Jack O'Connor has previously charted his network. Ger Loughnane was a confidant after they struck up a relationship at a coaching course. Fr Gerard McAleer was his coach in Maynooth and a key influence. The Tyrone priest was part of the management team that led the county to an All-Ireland title in 2003. Writing in his autobiography, O'Connor recalled how he looked to Tyrone for solutions in 2006. 'I go and speak to people about tackling. I phone contacts in Ulster. What do Armagh do? What do Tyrone do? This is almost a betrayal of my Kerry blood, to be asking how they do things up North. 'One day I travel to the Crowne Plaza Hotel in Dublin and meet with a very prominent northern football man who knows exactly what they do. (He has to remain nameless.) We sit for a few hours as he shows me drills, gives me ideas, opens up a new world of work to me.' Take word in. Keep the watchers out. In 2013, Éamonn Fitzmaurice's decision to lock the gates for Kerry training proved unpopular locally. The voice of Kerry football, Weeshie Fogarty, stepped forward to vocalise those frustrations. What he discovered convinced him the decision was justified. Management told him their 'proof' that scouts had attended and studied their sessions They also showed him how it makes a difference. Páidí Ó Sé was adamant they had been monitored in the lead-up to the 2003 decider. All-time great Declan O'Sullivan spelled out the difference it made in his mind. 'Training behind closed doors was definitely the reason why we beat Donegal in the final,' he told Fogarty for the Heart and Soul of Kerry Football. 'The game is gone so professional now, people are always looking for that little extra percentage.' Such is the power of information. Truth is optional; perception alone can tilt the scales. Sides source strength from the belief they know what is going on with the opposition. 'A general chitchat might give you a sense of what is going on,' says McMenamin. 'It depends what you glean from it. A lot of it will come from your analysts. They might have 90% of what you need to know. You are just looking for that extra five or ten percent to get you over the line.' Half the battle is convincing yourself you're already ahead.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Court hears 13-year-old girl with history of drug use and sexual exploitation needs to switch care unit
A 13-year-old girl who has had more than 200 incidents involving gardaí along with a history of drug use, sexual exploitation and severe neglect is to be moved from her secure-care unit for her own safety. On Thursday, against the recommendations of her advocate, the High Court ordered the girl be moved due to 'very significant issues' with another child in her current unit. Mr Justice John Jordan, acknowledging concerns of her guardian ad litem – an independent person appointed by the court to act as the child's voice – said Tusla, the Child and Family Agency , was 'between a rock and hard place in terms of resolving a situation which has to be resolved'. The deteriorating situation of the girl, who was detained in secure care, also known as special care, earlier this year, has been reported to the court regularly since the admission of another child to the same unit. READ MORE The two children, who are from the same locality, have a 'fractious' relationship. The girl has said she 'should not have to live' with the other child. William O'Rourke, assistant national director of alternative care in Tusla, said on Thursday the issues between the children were 'becoming more toxic, more fractious', and 'a move should occur as soon as possible'. Margaret Fennell, the girl's guardian ad litem, described her as 'a very vulnerable... young girl who wants to be part of something. She is lost.' Until recently she had not engaged 'in any form of therapeutic service, nor wanted to'. 'She has over 200 incidents with An Garda Síochána ... [there was] quite a significant incident [that] has gone to the DPP [ Director of Public Prosecutions ] in relation to a serious assault.' Since coming into special care earlier this year she had built positive therapeutic relationships in her current placement. This was 'amazing' and 'should be nurtured', said Ms Fennell. 'I still do believe it should not be [the girl in her charge] that is moving.' Mr Justice Jordan noted that the girl came from 'an extraordinarily dysfunctional background'. When she first spent time in special care, at age 11, she had already experienced 'drug-taking problems, suicide attempts... serious sexual exploitation, despite her young age'. At the time, both her parents were in prison. '[The girl] has had very few breaks in life and it is the position she was making improvements in [her unit which] appear to have come to a halt or to have slowed.' . There was 'no doubt' it was necessary to separate the two children. Each of the three special care centres was 'too small', he noted, to effectively keep children who had a negative impact upon each other apart. The complexity of separating them lay in the fact that all 16 available special care beds are occupied, meaning a child currently staying in the unit to which the girl will move must also be moved to make space for her. Tusla told the court it had identified a child in the second unit who would benefit from swapping places with the girl, due to 'escalating tensions and difficulties' they were involved in. That child's parents agreed 'absolutely' with the move if the child was 'in danger'. Making orders to arrange both moves, the judge said there were 'no guarantees' they would be without problems. He listed the three children's cases for review in coming weeks.
