US appeal court signals scepticism over Trump's tariff authority
All 11 active judges on the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington – eight appointed by Democratic presidents and three by Republican administrations – heard the high-stakes arguments, in a case that has the potential to throw a wrench into Trump's trade policy.
The hearing came just one day before Trump's reciprocal tariffs were set to take effect on Friday. The administration warned that a ruling against the government could undermine Washington's leverage in trade negotiations with China and other key partners.
In the coming days, the judges can either declare the tariffs illegal or side with the government in deference to the president's authority. They can also send the case back to the lower court for further scrutiny.
The lawsuit, VOS Selections vs Trump, challenges Trump's claim he can unilaterally impose tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, arguing he overstepped his authority by bypassing Congress.
IEEPA gives the president power to regulate economic activity during a national emergency. No president before Trump has used the statute to justify tariffs.
Two judges in the hearing, both appointed by Democratic former US presidents, quickly signalled scepticism about Trump's use of emergency powers to impose a broad set of tariffs, pressing Assistant Attorney General Brett Shumate, who represented the US government.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
29 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
US and Chinese trade teams to meet again in 2 to 3 months, Trump's Treasury chief says
US trade officials will meet again with their Chinese counterparts within the next two or three months to discuss the future of the economic relationship between the two countries, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Tuesday. The comments come a day after the trading partners extended a tariff truce for another 90 days, staving off triple-digit duties on each other's goods. In an interview on Fox Business Network's Kudlow, Bessent also said Chinese President Xi Jinping had invited Trump to a meeting, but one had not been scheduled. 'There's no date,' Bessent said. 'The president hasn't accepted yet.' Trump told CNBC earlier this month that the US and China were getting very close to a trade agreement and he would meet Xi before the end of the year if a deal was struck. Bessent also said on Fox Business that the US will need to see 'months, if not quarters, if not a year' of progress on fentanyl flows before it considers reducing tariffs on China.
South China Morning Post
3 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
US-China trade truce a test of both countries' stamina
After two weeks of mixed signals from Washington, US President Donald Trump has finally confirmed an agreement with China to extend the tariff war truce for another 90 days. The new pause, approved hours before the ceasefire was due to end, headed off the risk of escalation. It sets the stage for a test of stamina and resilience between the world's two biggest economies as they try to reach a reciprocal tariffs deal. The extension, agreed between top officials in talks in Stockholm last month but subject to Trump's approval, reflects the reality that neither possessed enough leverage to push the other to make a big compromise. Moreover, political and policy expectations are different, particularly in Washington. Among Trump supporters, there remain those who still insist on playing hardball with China. The question is what will happen now. Both sides are trying to buy time, but from different perspectives. Voices in the US talk up the possibility of the Chinese economy coming under pressure, though it performed better than expected in the first six months of the year. Doubters hope this was partly driven by US importers placing early orders for Chinese goods ahead of higher tariffs. In the next six months, China's economy faces a deteriorating external environment and some structural issues. While this would put the US in a stronger position, there are now many people talking up risks on the US side – national debt, lower-than-expected job creation, and inflation, for example. That said, there is an element of wishful thinking on both sides about the erosion of the other's position. Far from foreshadowing a mutually acceptable deal on tariffs, the truce is a test of each economy's stamina during political and economic negotiations. Trump meets Russian President Vladimir Putin on Friday. There are hopes that Trump and President Xi Jinping will meet later this year. A positive outcome all round could build the impetus for meaningful reductions in proposed tariffs. Trump's attempts to talk up increased US soybean exports to China says as much about his need to shore up rural electoral support as it does about China's need for them, given diversified sources.
South China Morning Post
5 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
US and Chinese trade teams to meet in 2 to 3 months, Trump's Treasury chief says
US trade officials will meet again with their Chinese counterparts within the next two or three months to discuss the future of the economic relationship between the two countries, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Tuesday, a day after the Trump administration extended a pause on sharply higher US tariffs on Chinese imports for another 90 days. In an interview on Fox Business Network's Kudlow, Bessent said the US will need to see 'months, if not quarters, if not a year' of progress on fentanyl flows before it considers reducing tariffs on China. The Treasury chief also said that increasing revenues flowing into US government coffers from tariffs would make it difficult for the Supreme Court to rule against the Trump administration on the issue if a lower court case makes its way to country's top court. 'The more money coming in, it gets harder and harder for SCOTUS to rule against us,' Bessent said in response to a question about a case currently in front of the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington that challenges the legality of what Trump calls 'reciprocal' tariffs as well as a separate set of tariffs imposed in February against China, Canada and Mexico. Play He added that several large trade agreements were still waiting to be completed, including with Switzerland and India, but the South Asian country had been 'a bit recalcitrant' in talks with the United States.
