'Scuttlebutt': information black-out after power outage
Far-west NSW communities could not get accurate details about their electricity supply or where to get help due to telecommunications failures after the storm in October 2024.
That created an atmosphere of mistrust as unpredictable electricity black-outs hit Broken Hill and surrounding remote communities, including Menindee, Tibooburra and White Cliffs, for 19 days.
Residents were frustrated by a lack of reliable information, while rumours circulated about the actions of energy companies, local MP Roy Butler told an inquiry into the outages on Monday.
"There's always scuttlebutt, there's always rumours, there's Chinese whispers and you end up with misunderstandings," Mr Butler told the inquiry at NSW parliament house in Sydney.
"That just raises anxiety and it also undermines people's confidence in the next piece of information they receive.
"For my team ... it was really important that anything that we said to the community was solid."
One of the region's two back-up generators was found to be offline after the electricity lines were knocked down on October 17, while a gas turbine could not provide enough power for the vast area.
People could not call triple zero after mains power to 32 mobile and exchange sites was lost, while mines and businesses shut down and residents' food and medications were spoiled.
NSW Police Aboriginal liaison officers drove hours to remote Indigenous communities to let residents know what was happening, Assistant Commissioner Andrew Holland said.
But there was not enough warning from energy companies about periods of load shedding that caused temporary black-outs as electricity was being restored, he said.
Aboriginal Affairs NSW's deputy secretary Shane Hamilton said Indigenous community members were less likely to seek help at local clubs offering food and water.
"People would be generally reluctant to go to those places," he said.
"If they had experienced in the past any negative behaviour or racism, they'd be less likely to go to those evacuation centres."
Communities have suggested solar-powered information screens be installed in remote towns during emergencies.
Essential Energy was acting quickly to install micro grids - a localised back-up system relying on diesel, batteries and renewables - in small communities, Mr Butler said.
"That's a real win for everyone if we can make it work that way."
The inquiry is due to report to parliament in May.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hamilton Spectator
3 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Cape Breton shorelines not just changing, but disappearing
Bridges, structures and land masses that graced the shores of Cape Breton's waterfronts within living memory now lie underwater or partially submerged. A flood mapping project now underway can help make sure infrastructure and development planning can handle the future. Coastal and waterway erosion and flooding are issues affecting all of Cape Breton. Researchers working on a flood mapping project have been visiting First Nation communities in the Bras d'Or Lake area collecting information, stories and memories from the descendants of the island's first peoples about water and weather events to prepare a report. The report, expected to be finished in March 2026, will not only help scientists, climatologists and community leaders know what the erosion and flooding situation is now, but can aid in preparation for future weather-event trends and emergencies. This past week, staff from engineering company CBCL Limited and Indigenous advisory and education company Balsam – both from Halifax – held community engagement sessions in the First Nation communities of Whycocomagh and Potlotek. Studies are also being done in Nova Scotia through the Confederacy of Mainland Mi'kmaq. The provincial government is working with the Cape Breton Regional Municipality to address flooding and engage with the community in that part of Unama'ki (Cape Breton). The effects of severe weather events are real and increasing, based on factual and anecdotal historical data. Who better to detail weather-event stories but the Mi'kmaq peoples who have lived close to the land for thousands of years? 'First Nations people have been here the longest. They not only have recent memory history, but legacy history in terms of the stories they have in the places they used to visit and the places that may not be available anymore,' says Houston Barnaby, a Mi'kmaw Indigenous Rights lawyer originally from Listuguj, QC, and founding partner of Balsam. CONCERNS AND RECOMMENDATIONS In Potlotek on Wednesday, people gathered at a table where a map of the area lay in front of them. They were encouraged to help write notations on the map about where structures still were; where land or structures used to be; what was now underwater; and areas they knew were in trouble when heavy rains came. Researchers listened and took notes. They heard concerns and took recommendations from the locals about flooding or land erosion in the community. Potlotek's Charles Doucette, the community's Manager of Fisheries, said he has seen a lot of changes along the shoreline in his lifetime. He is an artist who makes jewelry from stone and so walks the shore often. He points to the map of the Potlotek area on a table in front of him. 'We've seen islands we used to go to that became sandbars and then shoals and now they're completely underwater,' he says. His finger lands on an area indicating land on the map. 'Even in the last year, there is a sandbar here on the map – it's now gone – I'd say in the last two months and the area is all open. You can canoe right through here.' He points to another area. 'Places where people used to have cabins – they're gone. The waves are coming into them and they will be gone soon.' 'One year you'll see a big rock on the hill, and the next year it's gone. It's down on the shore.' FLOODING INTENSITY CBCL's Manager of Coastal Science and Engineering, Amaury Camarena, told people they should expect the sea levels to rise and play a role in the flooding intensity and potential damage of those floods. Camarena says he was told about a wharf in the community built 30 years ago and people said it was too high back then. But now it's underwater frequently! A new wharf had to be rebuilt at a higher level in recent years. 'With climate change, we expect things like that to become accelerated,' he says. He is hoping to help Cape Breton prepare for the possible negative results of future weather events. Floods over the past decade in Nova Scotia that led to loss of life, homes and livelihoods have brought the issue of climate change to the forefront for many people. The tragic stories of flooding in Texas this past week that killed and injured hundreds have been shocking and highlighted the worst-case scenario of such weather events. The project CBCL Limited and Balsam are partnering in – Unama'ki Watershed Data Collection and Mi'kmaq Engagement' – will culminate in a report. It will include data about local maps, water levels, flow measurements and inventories of area water structures. A second component of the report will highlight some of the key findings and general methodology that was used for engagement with the communities. Camarena says they have heard about significant issues in some communities related to stormwater infrastructures or undersize culverts that don't allow for all the water to flow out of the community efficiently. 'We have heard in some communities that during extreme rainfall events or storms, parts of the communities can become disconnected because the roads are not accessible. So that is a really critical component of how floods impact a lot of people,' he said. 'A lot of businesses have to close because of the flooding and limited access they have during these events and the recovery efforts that have to be done afterwards.' PROVIDING A BRIDGE With his knowledge as part of the Mi'kmaq community in Eastern Canada, Houston has been providing a bridge between climate researchers and First Nations communities on Cape Breton. 'It's the two-eyed seeing concept – using indigenous knowledge systems but also technical modern systems to get a clearer picture,' he said. 'We have tech analyses through instruments in the water, so we're getting concrete data and also getting quality data from the community members given their experience and methods of adaptation to the ever-changing and sometimes volatile environment.' 'One method is not better than the other. Both need each other to get as accurate a picture as possible. Working together and piecing these data points and insights we get from community members who have lived here all their lives is good. They got their stories from grandparents and great-grandparents and it can only help shed light on what has happened and what the trends are and what's happening today.' Camarena said the research project and its data will be a very useful tool. 'It will lead to a lot more discussion and ideas for development from everyone in the communities, in government, and for the people selecting how future funding is going to be used.' He said the project will help provide the tools people will need to both grant the funding and apply for the funding. While the companies have only been invited to work in two of the five First Nation communities on Cape Breton, they say they are open to discussions with others if invited. ABOUT FLOOD MAPPING Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
The Hill
5 days ago
- The Hill
Monsoon floods sweep away 18 people and the main bridge linking Nepal to China
KATHMANDU, Nepal (AP) — A mountain river flooded by monsoon rains swept away the main bridge connecting Nepal with China on Tuesday, leaving 18 people missing, Nepali authorities said. Rescue efforts were underway and an army helicopter was able to lift people stranded by the flooding. Police said 95 rescuers were already at the area and more are expected to join in rescue efforts. The flooding on the Bhotekoshi River destroyed the Friendship Bridge at Rasuwagadi, which is 120 kilometers (75 miles) north of the capital, Kathmandu. Several houses and trucks that were parked at the border for customs inspections also were swept away. Hundreds of electric vehicles imported from China had been parked at the border point. The 18 missing are 12 Nepali citizens and six Chinese nationals, according to the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Authority. The Chinese along with eight Nepalis were workers at a Chinese-assisted construction project on the Nepali side of the border, according to the Chinese Embassy in Nepal, quoted by state media. The destruction of the bridge has halted all trade from China to Nepal through this route. The longer alternative is for goods to be shipped from China to India and then brought overland to Nepal. Monsoon rains that begin in June and end in September often cause severe flooding in Nepal, disrupting infrastructure and endangering lives. ___ This version has corrected that the flooding occurred Tuesday, not Monday.
5 days ago
Monsoon floods sweep away 18 people and the main bridge linking Nepal to China
KATHMANDU, Nepal -- A mountain river flooded by monsoon rains swept away the main bridge connecting Nepal with China and 18 people were also swept away by the flooding Tuesday, Nepali authorities said. Rescue efforts were underway as officials assess the damage and search for the missing people. An army helicopter was able to lift people stranded by the flooding. Police said 95 rescuers were already at the area and more are expected to join in rescue efforts. The flooding on the Bhotekoshi River destroyed the Friendship Bridge at Rasuwagadi, which is 120 kilometers (75 miles) north of the capital, Kathmandu, in the early hours of Tuesday. The flooding also swept away several houses and trucks that were parked at the border for customs inspections. Hundreds of electric vehicles imported from China were also parked at the border point. The 18 missing are 12 Nepali citizens and six Chinese nationals, according to the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Authority. The destruction of the bridge has halted all trade from China to Nepal through this route. The longer alternative is for goods to be shipped from China to India and then brought overland to Nepal. Monsoon rains that begin in June and end in September often cause severe flooding in Nepal, disrupting infrastructure and endangering lives.
