Cyprus attorney general appeals after five Israeli men cleared of gang raping British tourist in Ayia Napa
The attorney general of Cyprus attorney has appealed against the acquittal of five Israeli men accused of gang raping a British tourist on the island.
The woman, then 20, said one of them forcibly took her to his hotel room before the others joined the attack during a pool party in the popular holiday resort of Ayia Napa on 3 September 2023.
All five of the men, then aged 19 and 20, denied charges, including rape, sexual assault and abduction and have returned home after they were cleared by three judges after a trial which finished at the end of last month.
The court decision cited contradictions in the woman's testimony concerning the identification of the alleged attackers.
But the country's attorney general George Savvides has confirmed to Sky News he has filed an appeal against the court's decision.
The woman's lawyer Michael Polak said the intervention means the acquittals could eventually be reversed and the men found guilty in the court of appeal.
"Obviously she was very disappointed with the acquittals of the men after bravely travelling back to Cyprus to give evidence," he told Sky News.
"The decision of the attorney general to appeal their acquittals is welcome.
"The appeal process in Cyprus is long and slow but she still hopes to achieve justice at the end of the process."
The acquittals came just weeks after a European Court of Human Rights criticised the Cypriot authorities over their handling of the allegations of another British woman who alleged she had been gang raped by up to 12 Israeli tourists.
The case caused international outrage when the then 19-year-old was convicted of "public mischief" after she retracted the allegations.
She said she was forced into withdrawing the claims and her conviction was eventually quashed at the Cypriot Supreme Court which found she did not receive a fair trial.
The judge who had overseen the initial trial was one of the judges who acquitted the five Israeli men in the latest case.
Mr Polak, who also represented that woman said: "There were many promises after what happened in the first case, including from Cypriot parliamentarians, but none of them seem to have had any impact."
In the latest case, the woman, who is openly gay, told police one of the men grabbed her by the hand as she was partying with friends and took her to his room before the others entered.
Mr Polak, who is director of the Justice Abroad organisation, said her family was "shocked" by suggestions she had consented to have sex with the men, who didn't even speak the same language as her.
He said the now 21-year-old woman, who is from Scotland and retuned to Cyprus to give evidence over four days in a closed court in Paralimni, was "really shocked, sad and distraught" after the verdicts.
The judges said the woman's initial statement to investigators contained "weaknesses," which weren't "out of the ordinary" under the circumstances, according to reports of the announcement of the acquittals.
The court said the woman was under the influence of a "significant" amount of alcohol and the drugs MDA and MDMA.
But it found the quantities in her system weren't enough to "remove her ability for consent" since she testified that she only felt "a little dizzy" after consuming the alcohol and drugs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
7 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Chagossians want sovereignty deal to go ahead, says Mauritius legal adviser
Philippe Sands KC, who has represented Mauritius in its legal battle with the UK since 2010, told a House of Lords committee he wanted to 'knock on the head this idea that all of the Chagossians were not involved' in negotiations over the deal. His comments came a day after a panel of UN experts urged Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer to abandon the agreement reached with Mauritius last month and negotiate a new one. The panel, appointed by the UN Human Rights Council, said it was 'gravely concerned about the lack of meaningful participation of Chagossians in the processes that have led to the agreement'. The experts also criticised the continuing bar on Chagossians returning to Diego Garcia, the largest of the islands, because of the ongoing presence of a joint UK-US military base. On Wednesday, Mr Sands told the Lords International Relations and Defence Committee: 'To be clear, it is not the case that Chagossians had no role in the negotiations. 'I can tell you that Chagossians in Mauritius and Seychelles were deeply involved in consulting with successive prime ministers of Mauritius and they attended the hearings at the International Court of Justice.' He added: 'I want to really knock on the head this idea that all of the Chagossians were not involved in the various processes. That is simply not true. 'It is true, however, that the Chagossian community is divided and I respect that division.' Earlier, he had told the committee that, while some UK-based Chagossians wanted the islands to remain British territory, 'most in Mauritius and Seychelles have made very clear…that they wish this deal to go ahead'. The Chagossians were expelled from the islands between 1965 and 1973 to make way for the Diego Garcia base and have not been allowed to Mr Sands told peers the 'quid pro quo' for the military base remaining on Diego Garcia was Chagossians would be allowed to settle on the outer islands of the archipelago. The deal follows a 2019 advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice saying the islands should be handed over to Mauritius. As well as establishing a £40 million fund for Chagossians, the UK has agreed to pay Mauritius at least £120 million a year for 99 years in order to lease back the Diego Garcia base – a total cost of at least £13 billion in cash terms. The deal also includes provisions preventing development on the rest of the archipelago without the UK's consent, which the Government has said will prevent countries such as China setting up their own facilities. The agreement has also been backed by the United States, the UN secretary general and the African Union, but heavily criticised by the Conservative Party as a 'surrender'. Mr Sands disagreed with that on Wednesday, saying the deal 'will enhance Britain's position in the world'. He said: 'I can tell you from personal experience, direct comments from countries, ambassadors, prime ministers, presidents around the world, this is seen as Britain back on the world (stage), acting honourably and decently, protecting its interests and safeguarding…the rule of law.'
South Wales Guardian
9 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Chagossians want sovereignty deal to go ahead, says Mauritius legal adviser
Philippe Sands KC, who has represented Mauritius in its legal battle with the UK since 2010, told a House of Lords committee he wanted to 'knock on the head this idea that all of the Chagossians were not involved' in negotiations over the deal. His comments came a day after a panel of UN experts urged Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer to abandon the agreement reached with Mauritius last month and negotiate a new one. The panel, appointed by the UN Human Rights Council, said it was 'gravely concerned about the lack of meaningful participation of Chagossians in the processes that have led to the agreement'. The experts also criticised the continuing bar on Chagossians returning to Diego Garcia, the largest of the islands, because of the ongoing presence of a joint UK-US military base. On Wednesday, Mr Sands told the Lords International Relations and Defence Committee: 'To be clear, it is not the case that Chagossians had no role in the negotiations. 'I can tell you that Chagossians in Mauritius and Seychelles were deeply involved in consulting with successive prime ministers of Mauritius and they attended the hearings at the International Court of Justice.' He added: 'I want to really knock on the head this idea that all of the Chagossians were not involved in the various processes. That is simply not true. 'It is true, however, that the Chagossian community is divided and I respect that division.' Earlier, he had told the committee that, while some UK-based Chagossians wanted the islands to remain British territory, 'most in Mauritius and Seychelles have made very clear…that they wish this deal to go ahead'. The Chagossians were expelled from the islands between 1965 and 1973 to make way for the Diego Garcia base and have not been allowed to Mr Sands told peers the 'quid pro quo' for the military base remaining on Diego Garcia was Chagossians would be allowed to settle on the outer islands of the archipelago. The deal follows a 2019 advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice saying the islands should be handed over to Mauritius. As well as establishing a £40 million fund for Chagossians, the UK has agreed to pay Mauritius at least £120 million a year for 99 years in order to lease back the Diego Garcia base – a total cost of at least £13 billion in cash terms. The deal also includes provisions preventing development on the rest of the archipelago without the UK's consent, which the Government has said will prevent countries such as China setting up their own facilities. The agreement has also been backed by the United States, the UN secretary general and the African Union, but heavily criticised by the Conservative Party as a 'surrender'. Mr Sands disagreed with that on Wednesday, saying the deal 'will enhance Britain's position in the world'. He said: 'I can tell you from personal experience, direct comments from countries, ambassadors, prime ministers, presidents around the world, this is seen as Britain back on the world (stage), acting honourably and decently, protecting its interests and safeguarding…the rule of law.'
The Independent
10 minutes ago
- The Independent
New Reform chair David Bull calls for return of death penalty
The new chairman of Reform UK has said there is a 'very strong case' for the death penalty - 24 hours after Nigel Farage said he would not support its reintroduction. Dr David Bull, a former medical doctor, has said he would support the return of capital punishment for criminals such as Axel Rudakabana, who murdered three girls in a mass stabbing at a children's dance class in Southport. 'For those people, I think there is a very strong case that I would support the death penalty,' Dr Bull, who succeeded Zia Yusuf as Reform's chairman on Tuesday. He also added to a row in Reform's ranks over burqas, calling for the religious covering to be banned, saying 'I don't like seeing people in them'. He added: 'I don't like seeing people in burqas. I feel particularly in East London, where I live, it certainly has divided the community. We've got a whole swathes of people not even speaking English, which I just think is not acceptable.' Dr Bull was unveiled as Reform's chairman at a press conference at which Mr Farage sought to put the chaotic saga of Mr Yusuf's sudden and unexpected departure - and swift return just days later - behind him. Asked for his thoughts on the death penalty, Mr Farage has said it is an 'issue of conscience', likening it to the debate over assisted dying. He said: 'Personally, given there have been 500 quite serious miscarriages of justice in this country since the 1970s, I don't think I could ever support it. But I understand why others take a different view. 'I think it is quite interesting that the younger generation seem to increasingly support the death penalty… it will be back in the next decade as an issue of major national debate.' The death penalty was fully abolished in the UK in 1998. Asked about his view on the Reform row about banning burqas, he said he had wider concerns about face coverings. He added: 'Do I think in cultural terms the burqa fits in with the British way of life? Not really, no.' Former television presenter Dr Bull was announced as the party's chairman at a press conference in Westminster, as Mr Farage told reporters that his job would be to "give leadership" and "not to get involved with the admin". The appointment of Dr Bull, who previously presented Watchdog, Tomorrow's World and Most Haunted Live! comes after businessman Mr Yusuf resigned from the position last week following an internal row over the party's position on the burqa. Mr Yusuf said he was "hugely excited" that former MEP Dr Bull was taking the role. "This party is no longer a start-up," Mr Yusuf told reporters. "I think it's gone to a scale-up phase ... the reality is what we need now in a chairman is someone who is an incredible communicator, someone who's loved universally across the party ... someone who's going to I think do a better job than me at energising volunteers on the front line." "I wholeheartedly congratulate him and I know he's going to do an incredible job for us," he added. Mr Farage said Dr Bull would come to the chairman's role with "terrific verve, energy, enthusiasm". He described Dr Bull as a "terrific communicator" and that his "job is not to get involved with the admin, is not to get involved in the tech" but rather is to "give leadership to that volunteer army out there of people". Mr Farage also said it is "very good" that the new chairman has television experience, telling reporters that "message delivery and simplicity of message in politics is very important". Mr Yusuf returned to Reform over the weekend, just 48 hours after he quit, saying he had made an "error". His departure followed a row, in which he said the party's newest MP, Sarah Pochin's question to the prime minister about banning the burqa was "dumb".
